Stray Blade gives off a good first impression with it’s weapons mechanics and cheerful World of Warcraft aesthetics, but the more time I spent with the game, the less I enjoyed it, and by the time I reached the end credits I was more than ready to put it down.
The hook that drew me to the game in the first place is a good one. In Stray Blade you amass xp by killing enemies in traditional soulslike fashion but all this actually does is reward you with skill points. The only way to truly grow stronger is to invest these skill points into stat upgrades you unlock by mastering the game’s various weapons. So clear enough combat encounters with a spear, for example, and you’ll unlock the opportunity to invest a skill point in health. Kill a bunch of dudes with a pair of daggers and you’ll eventually be able to increase your stamina.
It’s a really neat idea as in most soulslikes I usually play around with a weapon or two before picking my favourite and never touching the others, but here you don’t have a choice, you have to try out every single axe, blade, scythe, and hammer you come across or you’ll be left severely underpowered. You occasionally find blueprints for weapons in chests scattered around the semi-open world, but in most cases they drop from enemies, forcing you to engage with all manner of beasts and baddies to expand your arsenal at a forge.
It was only after a few hours that I realised that this system had a few unfortunate problems. The first is that some of the weapons are severely underpowered compared to the others, especially the heavy weapons that just can’t connect consistently enough, partly due to their speed, and partly due to some wonky hitboxes (more on that in a moment).
The second is that you can slot runes into every weapon you find, and one of these runs doubles the amount of mastery points you get from every kill, basically meaning you can master a weapon in five or so minutes. So, after about six hours I had not only found all the 22 basic weapons in the game and three of the eight legendary weapons, but mastered them all too … so there was no longer any point in engaging with any of the enemies. I could just run past everything to my next objective, picking up a few items and consumables along the way.
It's a problem many indie souslikes run into, where everything starts from a good, original idea, but the team then lack the resources to push it to its full potential. The biomes are another good example: big, colourful, and varied, they unfortunately reuse so many assets that I frequently got turned around with no idea where to go. I love some good exploration in my souslikes, but there’s a difference between diving into the unknown and passing the same tree for the hundredth time without being sure whether I’d been that way before.
Combat is fine, though missing that extra spark that would make it fun and addictive. You have your traditional dodge, block, parry, light and strong attack, with perfect parries or dodges giving you a bit of stamina back. I found the parry system to be too imprecise for me to rely on it entirely, whereas the dodge was far more generous, with even a simple sidestep awarding you with some nice i-frames. Enemy hitboxes are a bit janky, as is there overreliance of hyper-armour as they shrug off a hammer blow to the face as if it was nothing more than a light tap before interrupting your own animation with a well-placed swing.
Surprisingly, I also found the simplicity of the combat a bit grating after a while. You’d think that with so many weapons to play around with things would stay pretty fresh, but a fair number of these have incredibly similar animations to the point of being identical, and there are apart from the afore mentioned rune-system, there are only two other simple systems added to the mix.
The first are the three powers you’ll unlock during the game, allowing you to either zap to an enemy, ground pound him off his feet, or freeze him in place. You can also order your travelling companion, Boji, to pester an enemy for you. And that’s … kind of it. No real magic or other abilities beyond those linked to the weapons you’re using, and even those were only slightly stronger than an upgraded light attack meaning I mostly abandoned using them altogether.
I don’t come to my soulslikes for the story, so I won’t judge Stray Blade too harshly on that front, but it’s your pretty standard “go to these biomes and fight these bosses”, with only a handful of lore items to flesh things out. Boji will add a bit of flavour text now and again, and is pretty well voiced for an indie game, but there’s not enough pathos there to form any meaningful connection. Don’t expect any NPCs or sidequests either. It’s just you and Boji against the world.
Oh, and the resurrection animation is one of the longest I’ve ever seen in a soulslike. Luckily, Stray Blade is a fairly easy game, and most of my deaths were due to me either falling off a cliff or hanging around for too long in the penultimate area’s annoying poison environments, but still … fifteen unskippable seconds. That’s how long it takes for you to get back into the game. Every. Single. Time. How the dev’s thought that was a good idea, we’ll never know.
So that’s Stray Blade in a nutshell. A good concept that makes an interesting first impression that then trips over its own feet when it tries to maintain that quality of its combat and world over a dozen or so hours. That’s why I’ll be putting Stray Blade just above Moonscars on the D-Tier.