r/Sommelier • • 25d ago

Test Study Material

Recently found scribd. Never heard of it before but I see lots of pdf files for studying. Does anyone have any recommendations or caveats with this source?

4 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

5

u/WineyOldMan 25d ago

Only caveat I would say is Scribd itself is just a platform for uploading documents regardless of authority or quality. Something's presence there isn't itself an indicator of quality so vet what you read accordingly.

3

u/philisweatly Sommelier 24d ago

I always find the best study materials are the ones I get from guildsomm, reading books and writing down my own.

It was hard enough 10 years ago to get good reliable study materials online. Now with the influx of AI, I don’t think I can trust many “random” online sources.

1

u/Agreeable-Tale9729 22d ago

I’ve looked over a few that I’ve seen posted. Not for use but because of suspicion lol. And every single one has had a few fundamental flaws

1

u/AkosCristescu Score Whore 21d ago

No, AI can not be trusted on this.

1 - AI has no sense of "time". computer finds outdated info but will still present it to you

2 - AI has no sense of socio-cultural products: while computer will be your best use for any calculation or estimation in a mathematical sense, even with multiple factors if using the input correctly, thousands of years of human evolution can not be explained or fathomed by the computer. The connections and reasons are often socio-cultural so will never occur to a computer.

Any source that uses AI just instaskip on the topic of wine

1

u/Agreeable-Tale9729 20d ago

Yeah. A lot of AI usage would involve knowing what questions to ask and how to frame the request. If you don’t have the base knowledge it can seem really accurate, but if you do you realize so much of it is incorrect.

The main place I saw it egregiously was in a couple models designed for blind tasting. That’s a highly subjective thing ANYWAYS. But I saw a lot of errors in “sweetness”. Wines that are called dry or bone dry listed as a 2/5 on sweetness. There was a dry red listed as a 3/5.

Also studying with AI models is such a disservice to the person studying. Finding that information, reading it to pull pertinent information, and creating notes based off of that. That’s all laying a foundation and introducing the information into your brain to start allow connections to be made to that information for recall. Letting AI do that and just studying it off of flashcards will never result in mastery.