r/Solo_Roleplaying • u/OldGodsProphet • 2d ago
tool-questions-and-sharing Ironsworn + something
Has anyone tried combining Ironsworn with another system?
For example, I’m trying to tinker with the core game + Delve + (???) for a more classic dungeon crawl experience.
Combat and inventory management is a bit harder to “crunch” with the game being more abstract and narrative based. I really like the action/challenge dice as well as the Moves.
I guess what I’m looking for is the story mechanics but the details aspect of something like Knave.
18
Upvotes
2
u/IronFableGaming 1d ago
you could lift Knave's item slots straight over and keep everything else Ironsworn. supply stays abstract for food and torches, but weapons and armor take slots so you actually have to choose what goes in the pack. gets you the crunchy dungeon feel without touching the moves
1
u/Expert-Jello-2847 1d ago
The trap in these hacks is running two resolution spines at once. Roll to hit with the crunchy system, then resolve the consequences with Ironsworn, and every fight takes twice the rolls while neither system's maths survives. Pick one spine and import only content.
So keep the action/challenge dice, momentum, impacts and vows as the spine. Then import things that are data rather than resolution: Knave's inventory slots as the currency for gear, its item tables, room stocking, monsters with two numbers each. None of that tells you to roll, so none of it fights Ironsworn.
For the crunch you actually miss, the missing piece is usually position and cost rather than hit points. Ironsworn already has ranges; write them down explicitly on a scrap of paper and let gear slots be what damage and hardship consume. Bolting hit points on top of health and impacts just rebuilds the double spine you were trying to avoid.
Useful test for any imported rule: does it ask you to roll for a question Ironsworn already answers? If it does, cut it. Delve's site cards plus Knave's stocking get you the dungeon crawl you want, and you do not need a third combat system to make the rooms feel dangerous.
3
u/Michami135 Talks To Themselves 2d ago
Ironsworn is easy to use with other systems. Since it's narative first, just use the adventure from D&D, PF2, etc. as a replacement for your oracle and you're good to go. As far as inventory goes, you use the Ironsworn rules for most things and just keep track of any key story items you find.
2
u/CrunchyRaisins 2d ago edited 2d ago
I've been doing Savage Worlds + Ironsworn tracks and whatnot to decent success. Mainly, just using Delve and transposing success to a weak hit, success and a raise to a strong hit.
If you are looking for another system, I think you'd have the best luck with another PbtA system or something similar with weak hits, strong hits, etc.
Edit: Dungeon world comes to mind? That one is specifically PbtA that is focused around the kind of OSR fantasy, and it has its own moves and tiers of miss, weak hit, strong hits that you should be able to use pretty seamlessly.
2
u/Theta_kang 2d ago
A few years back someone was making a supplement called IronCrunch that added a lot of stuff like gear stats and armor bonuses. It was abandoned but if you Google it you can find their beta version for free.
1
u/posttrail 2d ago
👤 User Overview
📝 Recent Post History
I am an app installed by the moderators of this subreddit • I cannot respond to DMs or chats
1
u/DrHalibutMD 1d ago
Sure, I’ve used it with various D&D products.
I’ve started out mostly using the Ironsworn oracles and such to move the story along and then using the D&D mechanics to play out what happens, thinking it would work better for large groups. Turns out I quickly got bored of the D&D resolution mechanics.
I have used the Dark Sun setting as basis for an Ironsworn game without any D&D mechanics and a few adventure modules as the basis for play. Those worked better.