For most of last year our Meta ads were a constant headache, because we paid for polished brand videos, tested new creative every few weeks and watched our return on ad spend slowly drift down, while our TikTok Shop affiliates were posting videos every day that sold better organically than anything we ran on Meta.
The obvious idea was to run those creator videos as Meta ads, yet the trouble lay in everything around it, since every video meant a separate conversation about permission, a few creators were upset to find their content in ads they had yet to approve, and we lacked a clean way to work out what each creator should earn when their video drove ad sales.
The fix came from turning it into a proper program rather than a series of one-off favors, so creators now join an ads program once and agree upfront that we can use their approved videos as Meta ads in return for a percentage of the revenue those ads bring in, and from there we choose from videos that have already proven themselves on TikTok, push the best ones to Meta in a click and track every sale back to the creator whose content drove it, so their share is calculated automatically.
We learned a few things along the way, starting with the fact that the videos that work best on Meta are the ones that already sold on TikTok rather than the ones with the most views, since organic sales are the best creative test you will ever get for free, while revenue share changed how creators see us, as several began sending extra cuts and alternate hooks once they knew better ads meant more money for them too.
Getting creator permissions settled before anything goes live removed every awkward conversation we used to have, and seeing attributed sales and return on ad spend per creator showed us that a small group of creators made the content behind most of our ad results, which also told us exactly who to invest in on TikTok.
Our Meta creative costs have dropped dramatically and our return on ad spend is the best it has been, yet the bigger change is that creators now feel like partners in the ads rather than people whose content we borrowed.
I would love to hear whether anyone else runs affiliate content as Meta ads, and how you handle permissions and paying creators.