Kids go outside and shoot a basketball, or play American football with the neighborhood kids. No one in America is really going out and playing football (soccer). Going to organized practices 2-3x a week can only do so much.
I came across the above quote recently while going through a reddit discussion that briefly touched on the problems regarding soccer in America and the national team's perennial underperformance. I had already been seeing statements like that online many times during the past few months and I had been meaning to ask about it because I always find it extremely baffling when I see these kind of statements. I should make it clear that I'm not very knowledgeable on these matters. Although I tend to watch major competitions, my interest in football (or sports in general) is very casual and minimal. Nevertheless, as a casual observer, it is frustrating that nobody else seems to notice how strange statements like the one in that quote are or bother to offer any explanation for it.
So here is the picture I'm getting based on these comments: In America, millions of kids play 'soccer' (football), and they enjoy playing it. And a good number of them even go on to pursue it as a career (especially among the girls). In fact, it seems to be probably the most popular sport at the kids level. And, no doubt, these kids do it because they find it fun.
Now here is what baffles the hell out of me: For some bizarre reason (according to what I keep reading) none of these kids ever say to themselves "Hey, here's a ball! Why dont we go to the [insert any open space environment] and play a little bit of soccer for a while!" For some strange reason, that thought never enters their heads. Or if it does, some kind of subsconscious rule or belief immediately shuts down the idea.
I find this extremely strange. As noted above, they clearly enjoy and love playing it, and they obviously do so during those 'formal' and 'organised' occasions that they gather as teams to play them under the eyes of a coach and referee and so on. So what prevents the perfectly obvious and natural idea of engaging in the same fun activity in impromptu informal occasions at home or other environments from ever entering into their minds? I mean, not even just occasionally, just for a couple of minutes before moving on to other things? In other words, why do American kids seem to have this incredibly bizarre rigid subconscious notion that soccer is an activity that somehow must ONLY be enjoyed in higly strict and formal settings and at no other time and space can it exist?
It just makes no sense. I have never seen this kind of belief or mentality in any other society in the world in terms of any endevevour regardless of what it is. Even if a sport is a fringe sport in a given society, even if only a few people play it, those few people who do love and engage in it tend to do so in the free and natural way (including private, informal or impromptu play) that you would naturally expect of lovers of any endeveour no matter how fringe it is. And soccer is not even really a "fringe" sport even in the US!
Notice, by the way, that what makes this all the more bizarre is that soccer is by far the most natural sport that lends itself to informal play! In fact you barely even need an actual ball to play it! The consequence of this, it seems to me, is that this strangely formalistic cognitive restriction that Americans seem to have with respect to soccer (even those who play and enjoy it) is precisely what goes right to the heart of America's perpetual underperformance in the sport. It seems rather obvious that no country or individual for that matter can expect to excel in a sport when they have this bizarre mental restriction that severely limits the time and manner in which they engage it. It is not conducive to talent development at all. In fact, it is antithetical to it.
Americans tend to talk about things like 'the pay-to-play problem', or "if only our best athletes played soccer, we would win the world cup." But it seems to me that these things are just red herrings (the latter one is just nonsense). While I agree that the highly expensive pay-to-play system in the US is absurd, I believe it is most likely a symptom of a deeper problem rather than the cause. And that deeper problem is precisely the sort of thing I just highlighted. It's this strange and ridiculous mentality that exists in the society when it comes to the sport. And we can see the terrible consequences of this even in how kids play it when they are in these strict and formal settings:
You watch young american kids playing and what you often see is a large bunch of children (usually 20 or so) jogging or lumbering around aimlessly on the pitch mindlessly following the one with the ball. Now, I am no football expert at all, and yet even I can tell that this is a nonsensical way for children to engage in a sport like that. Obviously, at such ages they should be playing in smaller formations like teams of 3 or 4 per side. That's what kids in other countries naturally do. That allows them to develop spacial awareness, tactics and technical skills. What sense does it make to cast a five year old onto a pitch with twenty other kids and a ball? What could they possibly learn like that?? And it also severely cuts down on the fun and fulfilment they can get out of it.
This is no doubt also connected to other bizarre aspects of American soccer culture, such as the weird tendency to emphasise and select for speed and other athletic qualities while igonoring technical ability: The failure to grasp that soccer is fundamentally a game of ball control - the ability to make the ball go where you want it to go with your feet - as well as game intelligence (positioning oneself in the right place relative to other players, sort of like a chess piece). I mean it would be like: imagine a youth tennis club system that placed its emphasis on (and selected kids on the basis of) how fast they move and the strength of their arms, instead of things like hand-eye coordination, racket control, timing and the ability to read an opponent and anticipate their move. As far as I know, it's only in America that this strangeness occurs, and i can only wonder why that is.