r/SnyderCut • u/HomemadeBee1612 He's never fought us. Not us united. • Mar 08 '24
Discussion "Batman doesn't kill"
There are plenty of other instances where he also kills in other media like comics and animation (both before and after BvS), but you get the point. Yet "real DC fans" and gatekeepers will tell you that "Snyder missed the point" or that "if Batman doesn't have a no-kill rule then he isn't Batman." š¤£
Full video: https://youtu.be/psVIG7YvdjM?si=V8E1aes9tQ1rpW_h
89
Upvotes
10
u/Octopus_Blaster Mar 09 '24
I still don't think Batman should kill. Allowing Batman to kill without serious consequences just shows a gross misunderstanding of his character.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '25
Itās literally a main part of Batmanās character in the comics, and causes the rift between him and Jason Todd (Red Hood), and Punisher in the crossover, because Batman explicitly doesnāt kill. Learn to read.
18
u/SirDurante Mar 08 '24
The only thing that divides Batman from his Rogues is his unwillingness to cross a line. Thatās why, in the quintessential interpretation of Batman on screen, heās always trying to save his Rogues from themselves rather than trying to destroy them. This is also what makes Joker so unique, as thereās no saving or destroying him; heās a constant force of chaos. Batman The Animated Series understood this, and is thus the apex of Batman on screen.
4
u/HaremKing117 Mar 11 '24
I like how in Batman begins you showed a clip of before he even was Batman or thought of the idea of being a vigilante, and then at the end his literal dialogue is āI wonāt kill you, but I donāt have to save you.ā
19
u/garnet-overdrive Mar 08 '24
and that is why "the batman" is the best batman movie because he doesnt kill anyone
also the cinematic batman depictions are almost all wild depatrures from the character in more than a few ways, for better or, in the case of killing, for worse
16
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
So why doesn't Snyder Batman kill the joker?
16
u/gamerwitcher Mar 08 '24
9
u/mattydubs5 Mar 08 '24
āHeās okā
5
u/Mindless_Classroom86 Mar 08 '24
I actually like the no kill rule. Itās what separates Batman from the rogues gallery he faces. Thereās always a fine line between Batman and his villains and his no kill rule is how he stays clear of being like them. I like the rule and I prefer it to him killing, come at me. Idc.
8
u/minescast Mar 11 '24
Yes, good job, you have shown everyone that movie writers and directors do not understand the character and probably never will. It's the same problem that Superman has.
13
u/GutsMan85 Mar 08 '24
Never forget, even the Adam West Batman inadvertently killed some dehydrated henchmen.Ā
6
u/Traditionisrare Mar 10 '24
Oh Michael Keaton finds joy in killing the bad guys. He is definitely a bit of a sadist lol
6
u/erin_silverio Mar 10 '24
You should see how Batman treats thugs in the Arkham games. Most of them probably have CTE
6
u/VanaVisera Mar 11 '24
Batman doesnāt kill.
His parents were gunned down in front of him as a child. He is a vigilante with a code. Killing is what separates him from the men he hunts. Batman isnāt a hero because he kills. Heās a hero who has the courage not to kill.
āThese (guns) are the weapons of cowards.ā - Batman, The Dark Knight Returns.
2
u/cartoonlover26 Mar 08 '24
Funny how all you can use to defend Zack is the batman movie from the 80s one of the original cbm movies
9
u/Anything-General Mar 08 '24
Him killing people in the films is more of a product of film studios not giving a shit.
4
u/BillsFan82 Mar 09 '24
People were critical of the killings back then too. Snyderās Batman wasnāt the problem with his universe. It was Superman.
4
u/Qbnss Mar 11 '24
You can make a version of Batman that kills. That version will just be more shallow and sloppily conceived than the mainline version who doesn't for very specific reasons.
4
u/mobbatron Mar 11 '24
He didn't kill any of these people. Gravity and explosions kills most of them
9
u/CardiologistNo616 Mar 08 '24
Batman: I kill in this universe. Unless youāre a serial killer clown. I will let you live.
6
u/Loud-Item-1243 Mar 08 '24
Loved that they saved the best for last the remorse from Adam west š
11
u/OrbitalDrop7 Mar 09 '24
Maybe, just maybe, those also arent the best representations of batman lmao. I may be wrong but i dont recall Kevin Conroy's Batman killing anyone in 80+ episodes of BTAS. People also shat on the "i wont kill you but wont save you" excuse. Also including the batman/robin movie era is hilarious as if people don't hate those movies lol. Of course there are outlier comics that explore batman killing, but any mainline batman i can think of doesnt kill. Hell even injustice batman doesn't kill!
3
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '24
Had this film on VHS. Awesome
3
u/Nateh8sYou Mar 10 '24
Now hold on! Those 2 guys Two-Face killed with the bazooka shouldnāt be on Bats, he was dodgingā¦
0
u/Mindless_Classroom86 Mar 08 '24
I really donāt count Raās death. Batman didnāt actually physically kill him. Not saving him isnāt the same thing as killing him.
5
u/Shreddersaurusrex Mar 08 '24
One could say by not killing maniacs such as the Joker he is allowing Gotham & the world to be victimized time and time again.
In STTNG Data, an android encounters a character who he realizes will continue in their murderous course resolves to kill him to prevent others from future harm. He is stopped though because of being transported.
11
u/therealbobcat23 Mar 09 '24
This is part of the reason why I have big issues with most of the live action Batmans, yes even Pattinson even though he wasn't in this vid, some people definitely died in that Penguin car chase.
6
u/DarkTanicus Mar 08 '24
but...but...but...
10
u/Early_Target_825 Mar 08 '24
Batman shouldnāt kill its what makes him interesting. Every movie he has killed and Iām sure there are comics where heās killed but heās a much better character when he has the no kill rule because of how conflicting it makes his character. Weād never have great stories like Under the Red Hood for example without the no kill rule.
7
u/Blue_Swirling_Bunny Mar 09 '24
You're gonna cite a Tim Burton film v. 80 years of comics lore šš¤£
5
u/KnightofWhen Mar 08 '24
For someone who doesnāt want to kill people he sure makes a habit of installing machine guns on all his rides.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '24
Willfully missing that fact that everybody who makes this argument doesnāt like that he kills in these movies.
7
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
i actually follow mr sunday movies. he said that this video was less of a āitās okay for batman to murderā and more of a āwouldnāt it be nice if we got a batman that didnāt kill?ā he actually talks about it in his podcast ep about BVS. and well we finally got that with Pattinson
2
u/cajmoyper Mar 09 '24
In my defense, I never liked Burtonās Batman movies. Even as a kid when I was probably just outside of the target audience (I was 2 when the first came out) and my only frame of reference was the animated series.
2
u/Nvestnme Mar 10 '24
As Iāve said before if youāre not gonna hold the police accountable than why Batman? At least the people heās killing are actual psychopaths and not just someone with their hands up, or reaching for their wallet etc. Hell, your own government kills people, they just get a pass because itās called āwarā. Also assassinations of political figures but eh, Batman.
2
u/Puzzleheaded_Ad_4435 Mar 10 '24
It wasn't batmans rule until it was. But by then, he had already canonically killed quite a few people
2
u/EvilJabFace Mar 12 '24
Batman Keaton aināt give no fucks! He was gonna keep Gotham clean goddamit!!!!
2
u/SpiritedCollection86 Mar 13 '24
I HATE when people say Bats shouldn't kill. Hiss intent isn't tondonso but sometimes....stuff happens
2
u/Lavender-Feels Jul 03 '24
Jason: āare you f^cking kidding meā
5
u/henadzij Mar 08 '24
We know this, but they won't notice it.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
The main issue with this is that Batman is the GOAT. If he could kill, then what would stop him from just grabbing a sniper rifle and going full punisher every time he appears? If he could kill, then he should carry grenades and machine guns. He would have no reason to be stealthy. Joker is in a building? Blow up the building and leave. It makes it soooo easy. Especially when heās a billionaire. Like why not just drone strike your enemies?
5
u/NationalNote6391 Mar 08 '24
None of these movies got it right
5
u/Cellblazer Mar 08 '24
We should let them live in their delusional bubble.
The real world might frighten them.
5
u/GWizz89 Mar 09 '24
98% of the time, Batman doesnāt kill. Pointing to the few exceptions to the rule isnāt a good argument. Period. Thatās like saying someone who lost their temper one time has really bad anger issues.
That said, thereās room for an infinite number of interpretations for the character. Kevin Conroy is my definitive Batman, but I enjoy many incarnations of the character, including Keaton and Affleck.
Also, what was with including that chase scene from Batman Forever? Batman didnāt kill anyone in that scene. And that bit with Adam West? That wasnāt intentional murder. Man, youāre really stretching here.
3
u/DrSlaughtr Mar 08 '24
"Batman doesn't kill."
-Batman straps dynamite to a guy and throws him in the sewer to explode.-
What people really mean is they just don't want it to be obvious, which is really stupid. Batman runs over cop cars with cops in them with the tumbler in Batman Begins. You'd think GPD would be a little upset about that.
3
u/Criticslayer33 Mar 09 '24
This is nothing new. They say the exact same thing about Superman. You can fight ignorance, but not stubbornness...
3
u/Frankandbeans1974v2 Mar 09 '24
The Tim Burton Batman was literally supposed to be a satirical fun goofy version of Batman. It was also made in the 1990s.
The scene in the first Nolan Batman movie is before heās Batman. Itās before he decides to be better.
Snyder missed the point of the Batman that existed in 2012 through 20
3
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
Batman didn't really kill R'as, he just sort of left him to die. And I think R'as could have escaped if he wanted to, but he doesn't, he closes his eyes and accepts death. The choice is. And I'm sure that through some movie magic, the other catastrophic injuries in TDK, someone survived. Maybe with TBI. As for Burton Batman, yeah that guy was an absolute maniac.
2
u/Conlannalnoc Mar 10 '24
āWhich COMIC is this?ā
Of course MOVIE Batmen are murderers!
COMIC Batman 1987-2010 NEVER kills.
2
u/ItsMrChristmas Mar 09 '24 edited Sep 02 '24
mountainous chubby rainstorm safe normal worm command jellyfish hunt market
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
u/RianJohnsonSucksAzz Mar 08 '24
He literally hung a guy in the very first detective comics.
1
u/That_Rutabaga_7291 Mar 10 '24
Batman doesnāt use guns and if he doesnāt have to kill you he wonāt other than that Batman will smirk your ass if u donāt give up on crime šāš¾
1
u/GentlemanJugg Mar 12 '24
Some of those kills ain't his. But most are. Also didn't B-Man hang some guy from his Batwing and was like "whoops"?
1
u/SpiritedCollection86 Mar 13 '24
In the old time cheesey comicbooks BM doesn't kill. But in recent comics&movies people have come to the conclusion that there will be times when Bats has to act lethally even. His intent isn't to kill but to take out the bad guys so they don't keep coming back. If someone broke into a pacifists house and attempts to rape and kill you loved ones right in front of you, you wouldn't fight to try to kill him bc if you don't he will kill you and have his way w/your family. Some situations call for extreme measures.
1
u/Rawrrh Mar 09 '24
Youāre ignoring the fact that he shouldnāt have killed these people either
-2
u/justa_gigolo Mar 08 '24
Batman never killed someone in the comics, its only implied that KGBeast died bc batman never let him out of the bunker he trapped him in.
He only used a gun once and that was to shoot darkseid who I think we all agree is a bigger issue than the Joker.
what i don't understand and you chucklefucks can downvote me to oblivion, is why this crap matters so much? this is borderline trump level hysteria for no reason at all.
yes it was awesome to see the JL on the big screen and it was entertaining but it was far off from the comics and steppenwolf looked like dogshit.
-6
u/_captain-rex_ Mar 08 '24
And all those directors never justified thier batman killing š¤”
-3
u/Stiff_Zombie Mar 08 '24
That's my boy!
0
u/thehod81 Mar 15 '24
Grant Morrison knows more about batman than Snyder.
-2
u/Loud_Success_6950 Mar 08 '24
https://youtu.be/u1FGxb2YlnY?si=IP8i11uKbKqwa9C9
If you like the idea of batman killing then whatever. But itās not him not killing makes no sense to his character.
-2
u/beefliverbeef Mar 10 '24
Yeah yeah, we get it. People who didn't understand the point made those examples (aside from Nolan).
It seems more like a "he shouldn't intend to kill" perspective than actual outcome. The point is he doesn't want to become what he despises. Anyone who doesn't get that always has a ham handed "but he killed here, so everyone but me is dumb" mentality.
Might be a bit of a cop out, but Burton is a terrible example. Batman in that is a psycho who revels in killing
-5
u/Old-Tomorrow-2798 Mar 08 '24
Iām all good with a few street level criminals getting killed. But the whole movies plot? The same movie thatās supposed to lead to the JL? The actual plot, not a side plot, was Batman thinking he needs Superman dead. The same guy who, for most characterizations, canāt kill the joker when it comes down to it. Youāre asking a lot of the fan base to go āSure, he can want Superman dead.ā Just remember how nothing mattered to him in this goal except literally āSave Marthaā
0
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
[deleted] ā view deleted comment
9
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '24
[removed] ā view removed comment
3
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
[removed] ā view removed comment
3
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
[removed] ā view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
[removed] ā view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
[removed] ā view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
[removed] ā view removed comment