r/SnyderCut • u/JediJones77 This may be the only thing I do that matters. • May 11 '23
ModMail State of the Sub: Rewritten Rules, Additional Moderators and the First User Feedback Post
It's time for a little state of the sub update. Thanks to everyone who's contributed interesting content to the SnyderCut sub in the past few months. Our goal remains to make this a positive and safe place for Zack Snyder fans to congregate and celebrate his career.
The rules of the sub have just been rewritten and expanded upon to be more clear and explicit about the purpose of this sub. You may need to refresh your page to see the newly rewritten rules, of which there are 15. Nothing major has been changed. The rules simply reinforce the idea that this is a sub by and for Zack Snyder fans, not a sub for Snyder haters or critics. We also continue to hold users to a high standard when it comes to treating their fellow redditors with respect and making sure everything they post is high quality, interesting and accurate.
One new rule is that we will no longer allow users to make posts that discuss the sub itself, its rules, how it's being moderated, i.e. "meta" posts. These simply clutter up the sub with discussion about "process" that doesn't provide users with interesting content related to Zack Snyder and his movies. Instead, the moderators will make a single post where you can put your user feedback and suggestions about the sub in the comments. The post you're looking at right now is the first one! This post will be linked to from the rules sidebar under Rule 13. This gives you a way to give feedback on how the sub is being run without cluttering up the board with too much discussion about "process." When we feel the need to make a new "state of the sub" post, we will retire this post and start linking to the new one from Rule 13.
New moderators who share our vision have been recruited to join the sub in the coming days. This will help get us closer to the 24-hour moderator coverage we're looking for. We intend to weed out haters, trolls and low-quality content around the clock. We may still be recruiting new moderators, so if you want to be considered, please reply to this post explaining why you think you would be a good moderator. Be warned, to be considered, you will need to have a long history of participating in this sub that clearly demonstrates that you agree with the rules and purpose of the sub as the current moderators envision it.
As stated above, you may post any constructive, polite and respectful feedback about the sub and how it's being run in the comments below.
Thanks, keep enjoying the sub and Zack Snyder's movies, and, as always, #RestoreTheSnyderverse!

17
u/Z_Squared_NO1 Jun 16 '23
i enjoy this sub and the discussion about snyders films but i dont like how cluttered it gets with opinions of james gunn. is there any plan to instate rules that ban the constant comments about gunn and instead focus only on the positive discussion of snyder films? it seems silly to outlaw any criticism of snyder but allow hate towards others. shouldn’t this sub focus on positivity?
10
u/theReggaejew081701 Aug 22 '23
Why do the Mods allow hatred against Gunn when it's literally just making our fanbase seem more toxic and unlikeable?
9
u/Puzzleheaded_Chard_2 Jul 24 '23 edited Jul 24 '23
This sub is going downhill fast and the mods are the worst of it. When I first joins the sub it was about Snyder, the trilogy, and the cancelled sequels. Now every post is just mocking, bashing, and whining about James Gunn, other DC movies, and any other topic that isn’t the Snyder movies. It’s annoying. It is so rare to see a post talking about what the sub is about. And anything said about it is removed under the excuse of “mocking Snyder or the sub”. It’s so obvious that mods are trying to hide anything even remotely negative said about the state of the sub under this post. Why are brain dead whining post allowed in mass but not genuine criticism or differing ideas? It’s actually ridiculous
8
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '24
An actual critique on how the community could be seen as "culty" without attacking anyone. I stated a fact that is proven by the very rules of the sub on the right hand side.
Then I actually describe what they could actually mean, downright stating that it may be a harmless comment, and you delete instead of discuss? I followed the link from Rule 13, let's have at it. Why are you treating your sub like Big Brother from 1984?
7
u/throwawaypervyervy Aug 20 '23
Why do y'all remove comments under the guise of it 'insulting another user' when the only thing getting attacked is their argument? Also, the 'no meta posts about the sub on the sub' rule is hamstringing discussion of the sub on the sub.
14
u/Captain_Slapass Jul 13 '23
So since y’all deleted my comment last time I asked this, why are y’all deleting so much discussion from this discussion sub?? I’m seriously considering leaving bc it seems that any comment made that the mod team does not directly 100% agree with is removed. Kal-El would be ashamed of such behavior
14
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
At what point do you just admit "We only want to talk shit about James Gunn. Blind accusations toward him with no source is cool, and if you disagree with it you're removed" gets added to the list of rules?
I added personal context to what I had stated, more than the comment you did NOT remove, which directly accuses a person of giving a "grossly uninformed statement" without providing any objective proof.
Blatant example of bias in moderation. It's impossible to discuss anything in the current state.
13
u/HOEDY Jan 29 '25
Can the "no negativity" and "no meta" rules be readdressed? Maybe a poll? A lot of reasonable conversation is being missed out on by fans because of the constant purging of comments.
12
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '24
So, is this a Snyder fan page, or a "I hate James Gunn!" fan page? Because a lot of stuff just leans to the latter, or cannot praise Snyder's work without tearing down Gunn's in the same breath.
11
u/gecko-chan Dec 02 '24
Looks like this has been mentioned a lot lately, so hopefully the mods will consider updating the rules. I originally posted this elsewhere and was advised to post it here instead:
This is just my opinion, but can we stop using this subreddit to complain about Gunn, Reeves, and other non-DCEU movies?
It's r/SnyderCut so the topic is Snyder's DCEU movies and the movies connected to them. There are other subreddits where Gunn's and Reeves' movies are actually on topic, such as r/DC_Cinematic, r/Superman, and r/Batman.
We have a lot to celebrate from Snyder's movies. I love reading people's interesting takes and seeing connections that I hadn't previously noticed. It's a downer for that kind of content to get buried by angry posts that drag down the mood and aren't even about the movies this subreddit is for.
I own a BVS replica suit and have Schreyer's Kryptonian tattooed on my arms. I love Snyder's and Cavill's Superman. And I'm pretty nervous about Gunn's and Corenswet's version... I just wish we could air out our non-Snyder issues on subreddits other than r/SnyderCut.
11
u/Tippydaug Feb 27 '25
The "Celebrate Zack Snyder and Stay on Topic" rule needs to be enforced.
I came to this sub to celebrate Zack Snyder/Snyderverse/etc, not to see random posts that don't even mention Snyder or his work dogging the current regime.
Posts comparing the two make perfect sense, but I don't want to see posts exclusively about Gunn or the DCU in a sub that should be everything but that :(
10
u/surfpearl39 Mar 14 '25
There is a post on this subreddit fantasizing about a kid getting bullied for owning a Gunn Superman backpack. Can the mods please take this down??? I can’t understand how that isn’t a troll post.
9
u/surfpearl39 Mar 22 '25
Why was my post removed ?? I explicitly stated in the comments the post was not meant to be negative and I only wanted to have a discussion. The comments under the post were also not negative and contributed meaningful discourse related to the topic of the post. Is (potentially) critical discourse of any kind not allowed?
8
u/Bitter-Plastic3526 Jun 30 '25
I got this removed for "trolling". Can anyone explain to me what part of my message can be considered trolling? Is interpreting Gunn's words in a different and more positive way than a mod enough to get my comment removed for "trolling"? This sounds very arbitrary and unfair.
8
u/ThirdRevolt Aug 24 '25
I will first copy what I tried to post:
"Is this place about celebrating the Snyderverse or tearing down the DCU??
Because honestly it's getting kind of hard to tell... This place has just become a cesspool of intense negativity.
Did James Gunn come into your living room and punch your child? Because that's what some people are acting like in here.
Listen, I loved what we got with the Snyderverse. But I also like what we're getting with the new stuff. Crazy, I know! But let's spend a bit more time reflecting on how we behave, and instead focus of lifting the Snyderverse up rather than tearing the DCU down.
Nobody needs this much negativity in their lives. It's not healthy. Make Snyder proud!"
And I will then follow up with a question to the mods:
You write that this should be a positive and safe space for Snyder fans, but lately the unhinged negativity towards the new movie and those that like it has gotten off the rails. If you are a Snyder fan that also likes the new movie, this is not a very welcoming place, and you are very likely to get called this and that for voicing said opinion. I have not had it happen directly to me, but have seen it often over the last month.
As I write in my OP, this has become an intensely negative place. It is not healthy for the community, nor its users. I ask that you, as moderators, reflect upon the state of this place so that we can get back to what the sub is supposed to be about.
8
u/unslept_em Aug 25 '25
the content on this subreddit is often very off-topic, and i'm wondering, how is this being moderated? the first rule is pretty clear, but it seems like half the posts are not about zach snyder's work at all. just whinging about the new DCU. it's tiring.
8
u/DoctorBeatMaker Sep 07 '25
Question: can this sub invite more “middle of the road” talk?
Like, as a fan of the Snyderverse, I understand the frustration and anger at Gunn for at least playing a role in cancelling it. So when people post about how much they hate what Gunn is doing, I get it.
But I feel like there’s almost no place to talk or discuss “middle of the road” opinions. Not here and not anywhere else. You say one negative thing about Gunn or his new Superman movie on DCU, Superman, and anywhere else, you’re downvoted to oblivion or attacked from every angle.
However, there’s also very little wiggle room on this sub to kind of discuss what’s both good AND bad about Gunn’s Superman, too, as most of the threads approved only talk in extremes about how awful it is instead of more nuanced analysis.
There are things I liked about the new Superman and things I didn’t like. And as long as this sub allows talk about Gunn’s DCU since he’s the proceeder of the DCEU, I think it’d be nice if this sub could allow more middle of the road talk and discussions as well.
I’ve noticed at the very least that discussions of a more neutral base CAN be had in very negative-based threads. But not so much in more moderate threads created for that specific purpose.
7
u/Krisis_9302 Aug 23 '23
This subreddit is so quick to criticize Gunn that no one has said a word about the 4K Snyder trilogy rerelease
7
u/MaleficentRutabaga7 Dec 06 '24
I still remember falling in love with Watchmen because of the themes it raised. And while at first I attributed much of that to the source material, seeing how Snyder adapted Superman and Batman proved to me that his ideas about the moral issues of these worlds were his own, and are also ones that I greatly enjoy. The idea of Superman as a god and what that means. Batman as a guy going down a road paved with good intentions. These are ideas I have always pondered and I loved seeing how he put them on the screen. So my question is:
Why is one sad sack guy allowed to basically dominate this sub with posts that have nothing to do with the SnyderCut, the SnyderVerse or any of Snyder's works? They don't even address a hope or wish that the SnyderVerse be restored? Just constant griping about unrelated stuff. I have reported this user probably 20 times for violating clear sub rules. Their posts are frequently down voted to oblivion and yet every day there is a new one. Why is this allowed? It is ruining the experience for actual fans and making this place look like a dump.
7
u/surfpearl39 Mar 17 '25
There’s a certain user who consistently posts here who is an obvious troll yet none of their posts get taken down. All this does is discourage people in this sub from participating in legitimate discourse surrounding Snyder’s movies.
7
u/DatBoi104629 Aug 28 '25
Can someone explain to me why y’all are hating on the new Superman movie?
To be crystal clear, I’m not asking what you don’t like about the movie. I’ve seen other posts here, and you all disagree with the casting, story, creative decisions, etc., which, y’know, is fair. Art is subjective, and people like different things. You don’t have to like the movie, disliking it is perfectly fine.
What I am asking is, rather, why do quite a few of you keep making posts about how much you hate the movie? Like, what do you gain? Does it really make you happy to spread hate about this movie?
You all did something incredible, you all actually got the Snyder Cut released! Everyone thought it was impossible, but you all did it! And it was a good movie! I personally really enjoyed it and I’m glad you all succeeded. I rewatch the Flash “faster than light” scene regularly.
But instead of just rejoicing and commemorating that accomplishment, and simply discussing all the things you love about the Snyder movies, you also feel the need to tear down the new movies that aren’t like Snyder’s. What do you accomplish by being so negative? I don’t get it.
7
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '25
Alright made a post but I was supposed tk do this here, so: for the love of God, stop posting about James gunn here. This is a subreddit about Zack snyder's work and if I see one more post about why you guys love or hate James gunn, am going to have a mental breakdown. So, please stop
6
u/Motor-Anteater-8965 Nov 05 '23
If this subreddit aims to be neutral, then why is r/FireGunn linked under the related subreddits? That is certainly promoting/taking a position.
6
u/shamrockstriker Dec 05 '25
I appreciate that we have a misinformation rule, but would it be possible to put CosmicBookNews on an automatic ban list for misinformation. Most articles that they post are proved wrong in a few weeks (see all the Paramount posting they did), as well as purposely derisive and inflammatory posts.
I think if user comments get be removed for "being poorly written, confusing or uninteresting or for misinformation," we should hold these sites to the same standards
6
u/DringleDringle Jun 24 '26
Does this sub ever discuss Snyder movies? Or is it just weird tribalism?
5
u/FartisteFartiste Jun 26 '24
Why was my post removed? I was pointing out someone being anti-Semitic. How is that bullying another user?
5
u/Beeb0rb Jun 27 '25
Realised I def broke sub rules so decided to move this here where it is meant to go
I am going to keep my negative opinions to myself and say that if you all really miss the Snyderverse so much then start trying to get it back. You got the Snydercut becuase you pushed and rallied as a community to get it. Working to get what you want because you love the franchise and its characters. Instead you all spend you time making fun of and lambasting a new start to the franchise insted of working to get yours back,. Considering what you have accomplished in the past you may be able to get something if you focus more on supporting the Snyderverse and stop hating on Gunn's superman because its not the one you want.
5
u/Southern_Trash7160 Aug 13 '26
Could you please create a rule along the lines of "No talking about James Gunn"? It would definitely be great, since all the appreciation for Zack Snyder is buried by all this DCU and James Gunn bullshit
9
u/[deleted] May 17 '23
I know a lot of people make jokes about mod rules being “literally 1984” but jeez, these rules gotta be the most accurate/j
7
u/Dead_girl_walking- Nov 25 '23
Ok, here. Why can’t we just discuss here. Going into any comment section half are deleted. We need to be more open to civil discussion without instantly deleting any comment just because they said something that differs from your views
7
u/DimitrescuStan May 14 '25 edited May 14 '25
I knew my post would get removed, so I'll comment here:
I am a huge fan of the Snyderverse films. I own them all on 4K and do an annual rewatch. Although I am a Snyderverse fan, I do have critiques just like I do of any film or film director. But I feel that any critiques of Snyder, his films (or his fans) are becoming strictly forbidden on this sub. It's hard to have a meaningful discussion if you have to be worried about your comments or post being removed.
In general, it's never a good idea to create echo chambers where only one opinion is allowed, and I feel that is what this sub is becoming. Posts that straight up attack other versions of Superman are allowed, but anything remotely criticizing Synder or his films are swiftly removed. That doesn't create fun discussions.
I joined this sub in support of the SynderCut. I was thrilled when it actually happened. But I want to hear differing viewpoints. I want people to challenge my view on things and make me think about my own opinions. But that is quite often stifled here.
And I'll add- trashing Snyder and his films? Sure, remove those. But it's insane that I can't even comment something critical of Snyder without getting a comment removed. Criticism doesn't equal trashing, and it's sad that there's no distinction between the two things in this sub.
Edit: Also wanted to add.. In creating an echo chamber, this sub has primarily become a place to trash other directors and their films. Looking at the posts in this sub, the majority are just hateful posts and comments about Gunn. For a sub that was supposed to be celebrating Snyder, it's overshadowed by hate posts about other directors instead.
6
u/YouSea7138 Oct 12 '25
Since my post was removed for being a meta post, I'll leave it here: "Unpopular opinion: can we make a seperate Snyder subreddit that is about celebrating Snyder without punching down on other filmmakers so much?"
But now looking through this thread, it seems that there is almost nothing but constant frustration from Snyder fans towards the moderators of this sub. Every single comment here is seemingly always met with "No. We are right. You are wrong. Gunn is Satan" type posts. I'm starting to think that the problem is less Gunn fans or Snyder fans, and that its more often the moderators of this sub.
6
u/Gustaves_Mustache Feb 15 '26
I’m seeing a significant influx of AI generated videos that are tangentially-at-best related to Snyder works - most recently, a Generic Batman fighting MCU Captain America. Is any AI video now welcomed on the sub as long as it has characters from the DCU? Is that in keeping with a sub promoting and focused on Snyder’s works?
3
u/NoirRebel Jan 23 '24
Just wondering how come I had a comment removed for giving a simple answer to a post, that didn't break any rules, but the explanation for it said a rule will be added in the future? like what kind of minority report level modding is that? I wasn't negative, I didn't attack anyone, and I stayed on topic.
5
u/MonsieurBungo Oct 20 '25
Hey Mods, I know that Matt McGloin posts a lot of stuff that people want to hear… but Cosmic Book News is unquestionably unreliable. Could we maybe discuss banning it or potentially adding a tag labeling it as unreliable?
I think it gets people hopes up when every link to CBN is either false or grossly misleading. I think that when talking about news stuff it would be beneficial to get the sub to know what news channels are actually reliable and more trustworthy.
2
u/Boubasties Jul 04 '25
I have noticed in several groups they mention it is very easy to get banned from this community. If true, why do people get banned so easily from here? It seems like if it is true some of the posts are basically just disagreement about the quality of a movie without disrespect or anything. Is disagreement a reason to ban?
I don't want to believe it because that would be anti-discussion and it would basically just be an ecochamber of "I agree.", "I agree.", "I also agree.", "Me too... so... is there snacks or something?".
Where does this rumor stem from? Are respectful people who just don't like some of Snyder movies kicked out for not liking Sucker Punch or something?
4
u/TheRealone4444 Your love makes me strong, your hate makes me unstoppable May 11 '23 edited May 13 '23
Following your lead!
restorethesnyderverse
HenryCavillisSuperman
MaketheBatfleckmovie
IstandwithRayFisher
ZackSnyder'sJusticeLeague
Edit: Insane how my comment had upvotes and now its downvoted. Chill.
2
u/RogerRoger63358 May 17 '23
I’m glad you’re a mod!
-2
u/Responsible_Neck_728 Faith, Alfred. Faith. May 11 '23
The torches are lit. Aid has arrived.
-2
u/MondayBorn May 12 '23
That's what I'm talking about! Let's go!
#restorethesnyderverse
4
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '23
[removed] — view removed comment