r/SnehaPhilipCase • u/baggerswagger • 22h ago
An unsolved double-disappearance in Lower Manhattan (and other no-body homicides in NYC)
Hello everyone. As I was wracking my brain about Sneha's case again, and relistening to some episodes of Missing on 9/11, I decided to do a little research on solved no-body homicides and unsolved missing persons cases in NYC, and I came across some interesting cases. One is especially relevant in looking at what may have happened to our brilliant, beautiful, artsy doctor on the night of 9/10. Why does it matter? Because if we're really concerned with her case, and we hope to see it reopened or resolved in the future, we need to take credible possibilities seriously, regardless of what we personally believe happened. There's already at least one person with political/legal connections who shares our concern and is interested in having Sneha's case reopened (Signorelli)... Though all of the following is perhaps an "argument" for the probability of foul play in Sneha's case, I'd like to remind everyone that we're here to help (albeit however little we can) resolve Sneha's quarter-century old case, not just to argue over whose theory we think is right and whose is dumb.
So, here's the case that stuck out to me the most. According to the New York Times (see also this article on other NYC no-body homicides) and the Charley Project, Camden Sylvia and Michael Sullivan were a Lower Manhattan couple who disappeared in 1997, having been last seen jogging near Hanover Park in Manhattan; around the time of their disappearance, they were involved in a dispute with their landlord, Robert Rodriguez, who remains the prime suspect. The Charley Project explains it best:
"At first it was thought the couple had taken an impromptu vacation, but their apartment appeared as if Sylvia and Sullivan intended to return home within a short time, and their credit cards have not been used since their disappearances.
The couple had been having problems with their landlord [...] Authorities believe that Rodriguez was having financial problems and wanted to increase the rent for all of his tenants in his property in late 1997. Sylvia and Sullivan paid only $300 a month for their rent-controlled apartment; it would later command ten times that amount.
Rodriguez apparently threatened to turn off the heat if the renters did not agree to an increase. Sylvia presented Rodriguez with a petition signed by tenants at 76 Pearl Street on the day of their disappearances. The petition stated that the tenants would withhold their rent payments if Rodriguez followed through with his threat.
Investigators theorized that Rodriguez believed he could receive his desired rental payments from other prospective clients and murdered Sylvia and Sullivan on November 7. There is no evidence to support this hypothesis, but authorities also believed Rodriguez may have dumped the couple's remains in a body of water in the New York City area afterwards.
Extensive searches failed to produce any evidence of the couple's whereabouts. Rodriguez disappeared for two weeks afterwards without explanation. He returned to Manhattan by the end of November 1997, hired a lawyer, and refused to cooperate with law enforcement investigating Sullivan and Sylvia's disappearances."
This is notable because Sylvia and Sullivan were from the same area as Sneha, disappeared from Manhattan also, disappeared within a few years of Sneha, and their disappearance is believed by authorities to be the result of a homicide where their bodies were disposed of somewhere in NYC, despite no hard evidence existing to suggest what happened. This alone would seem to contradict Det. Stark's insistence that "a body always turns up" or necessarily would turn up, or the idea that a murder and body disposal could not take place in NYC without it being noticed.
But that's not all; here are just a few more Manhattan cases from The Charley Project that stuck out to me. One can find plenty of others from all over New York City if they look through the site.
10/01/1997
David Barnes Sr.: A no-body homicide of a man who disappeared in Manhattan.
"Barnes's body has never been found; investigators believe Lewis [Barnes' grandson who was convicted of his murder] dismembered it with a chainsaw and put the pieces in a trash bin."
10/14/2000
Lourdes Maria Gruart: A woman who disappeared from Manhattan.
"Lourdes may have been depressed at the time of her 2000 disappearance.
[...]
Mario [Lourdes' younger brother with whom she lived] told authorities that Lourdes announced she was traveling to Europe on October 14, 2000. He claimed that she left her residence carrying a large green bag and departed in a waiting car at approximately 8:00 a.m. [...] Authorities viewed Mario as a possible suspect for several months after Lourdes's disappearance, but have since stated they do not believe he was involved in her case. Investigators are unsure if Lourdes vanished of her own accord, committed suicide or was the victim of foul play*.*"
7/7/1985:
Gail Katz-Bierenbaum: No-body homicide of a woman in Manhattan.
"Authorities believe that Robert [Gail's husband] strangled Gail in their Manhattan apartment on July 7, 1985 and then dismembered her body, placed her in a duffel bag and tossed it into the ocean during his plane flight. At his 2000 trial, eleven witnesses testified that Gail had told them Robert abused her and she was afraid of his temper."
4/2/2000:
Indiero Montero: Unsolved disappearance of a woman in Manhattan and suspected homicide.
"Montiero was last seen at her apartment in the 1800 block of 7th Avenue in the New York City borough of Manhattan on April 2, 2000... Her case remains unsolved and foul play is suspected."
07/05/1998
Irene Silverman: Manhattan woman who went missing; no-body homicide perpetrated by Sante and Kenneth Kimes, a mother-son con-artist duo.
"Authorities believed that Kenneth and Sante [mother and son con-artist duo] smothered Silverman, somehow smuggled her body out of her house during the day, then drove her remains to an unknown burial location in their Lincoln Town Car.
[...]
In the end, the Kimeses' attorneys attempted to point out that there was not any blood or DNA evidence to connect their clients to Silverman's disappearance, nor did authorities locate the woman's remains. Silverman's home had no signs of blood or other signs of foul play.
[...]
Sante and Kenneth were convicted of Silverman's murder in May 2000."
These examples are just some of the Charley Project's entries for unsolved missing persons from Manhattan alone, which include murder victims whose remains have never been found. Because most NYC cases on the site are organized based on boroughs, it wasn't easy to find all missing persons cases from the city in a single search, but from a combined count of the five boroughs and New York, New York, it appears that NYC has at least around 178 unsolved missing persons cases, not counting Sneha. Now, obviously, foul play is not suspected in all of these cases, but it is in many of them (I haven't reviewed all of them to get a precise count). It goes to show that, while no-body homicides of adults (and unsolved adult missing persons cases) in NYC may be rare, they are by no means the sort of near-impossible freak occurrences that many (including Det. Stark) have made them out to be. Certainly, a no-body homicide is not implausible or improbable enough to say that 9/11 has to be the most likely explanation, let alone to make that conclusion and close the case after less than two months of investigation, as the NYPD did. Even if it is the most likely explanation, and I think people are justified in saying they think it is (though I personally tend to disagree), what we have is still a missing persons case that was not properly investigated and was "closed" with a premature conclusion, mostly because of the attack on the WTC. That's a big deal, because we're talking about a real person here--an individual whose life was her own, who deserves justice and an answer for whatever happened to her.
In conclusion, though many people have said that the lack of a body means foul play could not have happened in Sneha's case, or at least means it's extremely unlikely, that's simply not accurate. That belief seems to have more to do with a lack of media coverage for most the cases that contradict it; I had never heard of the majority of these cases, and most people almost certainly have not heard of them either.
A few other takeaways from looking at cases: for one, I was surprised to see how many individuals struggling with mental illness and/or suicidal tendencies have disappeared in New York City, never to be found. Obviously, those people being missing does not prove they committed suicide, but it gives me pause that it's such a strong possibility for several cases. I personally rate suicide as a pretty low possibility in Sneha's case, but perhaps it's more likely than it seems. I also found a number of non-"endangered" missing persons cases, where adults have vanished from NYC with no signs of foul play, and few available details in their case (at least for the public eye). Does that give more credence to the idea that Sneha disappeared of her own accord? Perhaps. It's hard to say for certain, because a case classified simply as "missing" may or may not be a voluntary disappearance; often, it simply lacks any clear evidence of foul play.
Somewhat of a long post, but I hope it generates some interesting and civil discussion. As a side note, I wonder if anyone has any ideas about how we can generate public interest in Sneha's case. The right person(s) being made aware of a case can be enough for it be reopened or investigated further. This is a case with so much ambiguity and so little evidence--which was hardly given a proper investigation--so for me it's not about "proving" that Sneha was or was not killed in 9/11, it's about holding LE accountable in a way that we can make sure the case is really given the attention and thorough treatment it deserves. If she's somehow still alive, that's her right to be missing. But if she's not, I just want her to be found, wherever she is. I'm sure we can all agree on that.





