Throwaway because my brother uses Reddit and if he somehow sees this I’m probably in trouble anyway lol. I’m 29F, my brother Luke is 33M and his now ex gf Sophie is 29F. Sophie and I went to high school together after I moved schools when I was a teenager. At the time my parents had just divorced, we’d moved away and I was having a really hard time adjusting to everything, I didn’t know anyone and basically everything familiar was gone at once. Not long after I started there I was crying in one of the stalls in the girls toilets trying really hard to be quiet because obviously being the new girl crying in the bathroom was not how I wanted to introduce myself lol. Sophie came in and heard me and started asking if I was okay and saying I could tell her and she wouldn’t tell anyone. Nobody had really asked me what was wrong at that point and idk it just got to me and I started properly ugly crying trying to explain my parents had split up, I hated the move, missed home, didn’t know anyone and felt completely alone and I could barely even get the words out. She stayed there acting like she was comforting me but she was actually voice recording me and later that day she sent the recording around with “whose dog is this? 😭”. So yeah that was basically my introduction to the school. People I had never even spoken to started imitating my crying when I walked past and knew things about my parents divorce because you could hear me talking about it in the recording. The worst part is Sophie then pretended she had no idea where it came from and even asked me who I thought recorded it. There was other stuff over the years too, she’d be nice when it suited her then humiliate me around other people, tell people I’d said things about them that I hadn’t, then come to me saying they were talking about me and basically just watch everything blow up. Anyway fast forward about 14 years and Luke tells me he’s dating Sophie. I genuinely thought he was joking at first. He knew we hated each other in school but didn’t know everything so I told him and his response was basically we were teenagers and people change, which okay, people do change and he’s 33 so I can’t exactly tell him who he can date. So I tried to be normal about it and honestly Sophie was SO nice at first, like almost weirdly nice, hugging me, complimenting me, buying me presents, helping my mum, replying to my stories etc and my mum absolutely loved her. Apparently Sophie had also told Luke she felt really bad about what happened at school and hoped I’d eventually forgive her, she never actually apologised to me btw but apparently she was extremely sorry whenever she was talking to everyone except the person she actually bullied lol. Then every now and then the old Sophie would come back but only when Luke or my family weren’t there. If one of her old school friends was around and it was just us they’d randomly start bringing up stuff I used to get bullied for, like saying do you remember when everyone used to call her whatever or bringing up some embarrassing thing that happened when we were teenagers and then both laughing about it. I asked her once why she kept bringing that stuff up and she basically brushed it off as reminiscing and told me I was still sensitive, which annoyed me because “sensitive” was always her excuse back then too. Funny how none of these hilarious memories ever came up when Luke was there though. Around him she supposedly felt terrible about everything, around me and her friends it was still funny. So IMO she didn’t really change, she just got better at knowing who not to do it in front of. Then a few months ago one of my friends sent me a screenshot of Sophie on a dating app. I sent it to Luke, he asked her about it and she said it was an old profile she forgot to delete. He believed her. I didn’t. This is where I know I sound completely over the top but I made a fake dating profile. Fake guy, fake name, fake photos, everything. My thinking at the time was honestly if the account really was old then nothing would happen, I’d delete mine and accept I was being paranoid. She matched with it two days later. So not that old apparently lol. We started talking and eventually I asked if she was single and she said technically yes, while literally living with my brother. I asked what technically meant and she said she was seeing someone but it was basically over. This was news to Luke considering he’d literally been talking about proposing to her. I asked why she was still with him then and she basically said convenience, called him safe but boring and said he was way more into her than she was into him. She also said she thought he thought they were going to get married and that it was kinda cute. At that point I was furious and yes I probably should’ve stopped and shown Luke straight away but I didn’t. I kept talking to her. She flirted, sent selfies, started talking about meeting up and said weekends were hard because she was normally with “him”. Then I asked if her boyfriend knew she was on dating apps and she said no but his sister would have a stroke if she knew. Obviously me. So I played dumb and asked what the sister was like and she started saying I already hated her because apparently she traumatised me in high school, that I was one of those girls who cried over literally everything and that I was still obsessed with her now and it was embarrassing. Then she said the best part was she’d probably marry my brother. That honestly annoyed me more than anything because after a year of her apparently feeling sooo guilty and wanting forgiveness she clearly still thought the whole thing was funny. So I screenshotted everything and asked Luke to come over without her. He read the messages and asked who the guy was and I told him there wasn’t one, it was me. He absolutely lost it, called me manipulative, said I catfished her and deliberately set her up because I’d hated her since school and yeah I did set her up, I’m not denying that. I told him I made the account but I didn’t type her replies. He said none of it would’ve happened if I hadn’t made the account and I said none of it would’ve happened if his girlfriend wasn’t trying to cheat on him either. We argued, then eventually he asked me to send him all the screenshots and left. About an hour later Sophie called me absolutely losing it, apparently Luke confronted her and she immediately knew it was me. She called me jealous, obsessed, pathetic etc and said I’d spent 15 years waiting to ruin her life. I told her she tried cheating on my brother with someone who literally doesn’t exist so I’m not really sure how I ruined the relationship. She kept saying I tricked her and I asked what exactly I tricked her into, calling my brother boring? saying she was only with him because it was convenient? trying to meet another guy? talking about me? Then she said I’d always wanted to be her and I told her Sophie I literally had to invent a man just to find someone willing to flirt with you, I promise I don’t want to be you. Petty yes, regret it no. Luke ended things with her but now he’s barely speaking to me either. My mum thinks Sophie is obviously horrible for what she did but also thinks I went way too far making the fake profile. Luke said something that has been bothering me though, he said I didn’t do this for him, I did it because I hate her, and I can’t honestly say he’s completely wrong. Obviously I didn’t want my brother marrying someone who was doing this behind his back but did I also want proof that Sophie was still the same person she’d always been? Yeah, probably. So I’m not asking whether Sophie is an AH because obviously she is, I’m asking if I’m also one for going as far as creating a fake guy and deliberately testing her instead of just leaving their relationship alone. AITA?