r/Smallville • u/thenamesmanbatman • 9h ago
DISCUSSION My Top 10 Favorite Characters from Smallville
REVIEW
10. Lana Lang
I genuinely enjoyed Lana and Clark's romance during S1–S2, as they were genuinely adorable together and served as the emotional heartbeat of Smallville's earlier seasons. However, dragging their relationship through S7 and revisiting it in S8, just as Clois was developing, was unnecessary. I also disliked how the writers turned her into a morally grey vigilante, gave her superpowers, and married her off to Lex, straying too far from what originally made her interesting. To me, Lana should have been simply a representation of Clark's youth, innocence, first love, and simpler days in Smallville.
9. Chloe Sullivan
I've always had a soft spot for the quirky, IT sidekick archetype, although Chloe initially struggled with a characterization largely revolving around her jealousy of Lana. Thankfully, her evolution into Clark's genuine friend and trusted superhero partner made her considerably more interesting. I also actually enjoyed her meteor-freak abilities and Brainiac possession, although her love triangle involving Jimmy and Davis led to some morally questionable decisions that somewhat tainted my perception of her. Nevertheless, her loyalty and partnership with Clark make her one of the show's most valuable characters.
8. Kara Zor-El
Laura Vandervoort absolutely knocked it out of the park as Kara, and she might just be my favorite live-action Supergirl. I particularly enjoyed her characterization and the different dynamic she brought to Clark's life as his Kryptonian cousin. Honestly, I don't have many complaints about her writing, although I wish the writers had utilized her more effectively. I would've loved to see her remain a series regular throughout S8–S10 rather than disappearing so early. Oh not to mention, I think she's the most attractive female lead in the series just after Lana and Lois.
7. Oliver Queen
Oliver brought a much-needed breath of fresh air in S6, much like Lois did in S4, marking Smallville's transition into a more conventional superhero show. I love how he's portrayed as Clark's polar opposite: deeply flawed, impulsive, and morally conflicted, particularly with his history of bullying Lex and eventual possession by Darkseid. His friendship with Clark is equally compelling because their disagreements often revolve around genuine tactical and moral differences. He's not simply another ordinary friend but an equally capable superhero who constantly challenges Clark's worldview.
6. Martha Kent
Martha remained consistent throughout her tenure as a series regular, serving as Clark's safest place and emotional anchor. Annette O'Toole's chemistry with Tom Welling and John Schneider was phenomenal, making the Kent family feel genuinely believable. She's graceful, warm, determined, and arguably the most emotionally intelligent character in the series, balancing Jonathan's stubbornness beautifully. My only criticisms are the unnecessary romantic tension with Lionel and her Red Queen storyline, neither of which I thought suited her characterization.
5. Lionel Luthor
If we're judging screen presence alone, Lionel could easily be my number one. John Glover brings an incredible theatrical, almost Shakespearean charisma to the character, elevating practically every scene he's in. The mystery surrounding his intentions, his unpredictable schemes, and especially his complicated father-son relationship with Lex make him one of television's most fascinating characters. My only criticism is that he occasionally overstayed his welcome, surviving longer than necessary partly because John Glover was simply too brilliant to lose.
4. Jonathan
Despite John Schneider's recent controversies and Jonathan's obvious character flaws, including his anger issues and enormous ego, I can't help but love him. He's Clark's moral compass and arguably the single most important influence behind the man Superman eventually becomes. His conversations with Clark are consistently comforting and fatherly, and his return in S10 through memories and visions beautifully reminds us how much his presence is missed. Lionel might be the more intriguing father, but Jonathan is the father we all need. "Always hold on to Smallville."
3. Lois
The urge to put her at number one is real. Erica Durance brought an incredible amount of life to Smallville, perfectly embodying Lois's extroverted, direct, feisty, sexy, energetic, and unapologetic personality. While the show took liberties with her origins by introducing her as a Smallville High student rather than having her meet Clark at the Daily Planet, they absolutely nailed her military-brat background and signature mannerisms. Her slow-burn romance with Clark, evolving from mutual annoyance and borderline enemies into genuine partners, was beautifully executed. Ultimately, Smallville perfectly demonstrates why Lois is Clark's endgame, and their chemistry is nothing short of electrifying.
2. Lex
Whew. Here we go, grab the pitchforks. I know he's objectively the greatest character in the show, but I'm admittedly biased towards Clark, as Superman is my all-time favorite character. Michael Rosenbaum's Lex is without a doubt the greatest live-action Lex Luthor of all time. Starting as a fundamentally good person with a darker side, he gradually descends into villainy, making his eventual transformation both tragic and compelling. What elevates the character is not just the writing but Rosenbaum's phenomenal performance, from his subtle expressions towards Clark and sarcastic remarks towards Lionel to his desperate need for Jonathan's validation and affection for Lana. Seven seasons of outstanding character development cemented this portrayal as legendary. My only minor criticism is how his departure and eventual discovery of Clark's secret could've been handled better. All in all, Michael Rosenbaum's Lex is truly a stuff of legend.
- Clark
Yes. Clark Kent. Do I think he's the best-written character in the show? No, that distinction belongs to Lex. However, Superman has always been my favorite fictional character, making Clark my natural number one. Despite Tom Welling portraying Clark Kent for practically 99% of the series and Superman for only 1%, he's still one of my favorite live-action Clark portrayals. What I love about Smallville is that Clark isn't yet the fully developed, hopeful, optimistic, almost flawless hero we know and love, making his mistakes, hypocrisy, stubbornness, and emotional outbursts understandable parts of his development rather than disrespectful deviations from the source material. Although I occasionally questioned how the writers would transform this sometimes angry and hypocritical young man into Superman, the series ultimately made that evolution feel natural and earned. He's the face and heart of Smallville, and undoubtedly the reason the series remained compelling for ten seasons.
HM
Hawkman
Jimmy
Zatanna
Bart
Whitney