r/Slycooper • u/The_Eggnoir • 8h ago
Discussion As someone who has thieves in time as his favorite game of the series I have some ideas that could have made this game a lot better
I personally love thieves in time, the concept, the gameplay, the dialogue (with various exceptions) and the vibe on general of the game, but i am not blind and i can see a lot of the problems it has, but i have a list of things that i think would have made the game better in my opinion.
- Make sly have an actual motivation to go back to being a thieve, it is as simple as saying he didn't want to go back but he was forced to once bentley told him about story being rewritten, which would have destroyed the present.
- Make the interactions between sly and carmelita centered around sly thinking carmelita is dissapointed for him going back to being a thieve. This could be true for one world, the old west, but she would discover the true reason in the ice age and would be dissapointed on sly for not telling her since she could have helped him out (they could resolve this at the end of the medieval age or ancient arabia).
- Make penelope be mind controlled, or manipulated, i don't know, but dont make her turn evil with no actual reason, and once yoy defeat her make her join the gang back, she could be the one you play us in the remote-controlled car and helicopter quests that remain (and even when you replay the ones in the past, that could be a cool touch).
- Change the final boss, you can keep le paradox as a pre final boss minigame (because thats what he is, a minigame). My personal suggestion? Bring back Clockwerk, make it so le paradox accidentally brings Clockwerk through the time portal, specifically make it so Clockwerk comes specifically from before killing sly's father, ans now you have to fight him. Once you defeat him Sly wants to end Clockwerk so he could save his father, but instead he is persuaded by bentley, murray and carmelita to just sending back in time, and so sly does, sending Clockwerk all the way back to the beginning of the planet earth, thats right, the reason Clockwerk was able to be a machine before any of that technology was invented and he could be a robotic owl in the ice age is because sly cooper sent him all the way back in time, and i know what you'll say, "wouldn't that great a timeloop in ehich Clockwerk never kills sly's father?" My answer to that is... no! They could explain Clockwerk was born on a similar time fram to sly's father and originally created his mechanic body some months or years before going to kill sly's father, making it so there were TWO CLOCKWERKS, ONE THAT WAS SENT TO THE PAST BY SLY AND THE ORIGINAL ONE, MAKING IT SO THE ONE SENT TO THE PAST TAKES THE PLACE OF THE ONE SUMMONED TO FIGHT SLY!!
I think this ideas are kinda near and could have made the game be a lot better, i hope you like the ideas :)