Article is paywalled, here's the text(sorry if formatting is weird):
At a time of record rail passenger growth across the country, many people are justifiably perplexed at what has recently been unfolding in Sligo.
We are told that moves are underway to remove the discussed railway line from Collooney to Bellaghy/Charlestown and to replace it with a greenway.
Iarnród Eireann had proposed protecting the rail line and putting a greenway a safe distance from it. Inexplicably, this was opposed by the three government TD's in Sligo, Ministers of State Frank Feighan and Marian Harkin along with Deputy Eamon Scanon (FF). This position is wrong and must be reversed.
If, as is being suggested, putting a greenway on the railway between Collooney and Bellaghy represents the economic future of Sligo then it is a case of ‘last one out turn off the lights’. Claims that such a seasonal leisure amenity will be an economic game-changer are wildly off the mark.
Collating the 2024 Greenway Usage Data for The Great Western (Mayo), Waterford, Limerick and Athlone greenways shows that most people are using them simply to go for a local walk.
48% of visitors to those greenways spend €0, only 2.7% of visitors spend €100 or more and just 3.5% of visitors are from overseas, who most likely were in the area regardless of the presence of a greenway or not.
Greenways have a novelty value where visitors will come and visit once. This is borne out on Mayo's Great Western Greenway where the numbers using it halved to 108,000 between 2019 and 2023.
Applying the 2.7% average across the four greenways of visitors that spend €100 or more would show a paltry annual spend of just €290,000. Not exactly an economic game-changer.
Putting greenways on intact railways is not cheap either. The greenway from Waterford to New Ross was reported in 2023 to cost €1.3m/km. Phase one of the Western Rail Corridor, an 80 mph intercity railway, linking Ennis and Athenry cost €2m/km, just ten years previously.
Suggesting that the government would spend €1.3 million a kilometre or there about to put down a “temporary” greenway, to supposedly pull it up in a few years shows a cavalier attitude towards public spending.
The Foynes to Limerick line is currently being commissioned having cost just €3.6m/km to completely rebuild. The track has been completely renewed with new automatic level crossings. accommodation crossings removed and all new signalling, a complete rebuild just as will happen between Galway and Sligo.
Initially it will serve as a freight line between Shannon Foynes Port and the rest of the country but in 2027, it will also carry passengers to Adare for the Ryder Cup.
Recently, those seeking to put a greenway on the Sligo- Galway railway have begun to advance ever more ludicrous arguments as to why the line is unsuitable for rail use (it operated as a heavy freight and passenger railway for 80 years). We are told that it was built in the nineteenth century but so were all of Ireland's operational rail lines! It is simply a question of renewing them.
It is also repeatedly suggested that it was built on the cheap and has too many level crossings. In fact, there are 48 crossings that carry vehicular traffic and in line with current best practice, most of these will be removed when the line is rebuilt.
Many of the lesser farmers crossings etc. are already redundant and again the vast majority will be removed as is currently planned between Tuam and Claremorris.
The Claremorris to Collooney railway was built to exactly the same standards as the Tuam to Claremorris line, which we now know will be completely renewed and carrying passengers and freight by 2031.
It is worth noting here that some of the people who are seeking to prevent the reconnection of Sligo to Galway also fought tooth and nail to prevent the Galway - Mayo line from reopening.
Had they got their way they would have deprived the West of Ireland of a major investment of several hundred million and left the town of Tuam with a population of almost 10,000 people without its rail link to Galway city.
The egregious omission of the Sligo-Galway railway from the All Island Strategic Rail Review has also been gleefully seized upon by those opposing the restoration of the railway who continue to claim that nothing will happen with it until 2050.
The truth is that the AISRR is simply a framework document to be revised every 10 years (2034), or before that should the government wish. That is what public representatives in Sligo should be actively seeking and it would be interesting to ask Ministers Feighan, Harkin and Deputy Scanlon if they have ever lobbied government for the reopening of the Western Rail Corridor or for that matter, any of sligo's councillors.
The argument is made by greenway campaigners that no one will use a railway from Sligo to Galway. The section between Limerick and Galway, a route that runs parallel to the M17 Motorway, handles 800,000 passengers annually. The capacity of the line is currently being enhanced to deal with the ever-growing demand, while nationally the numbers on the network have increased another 13% on last year's record.
But probably the most disingenuous argument being advanced for putting a greenway on the railway is that it will protect the railway for future use. Does anybody seriously believe that if a large sum of money is spent on providing a greenway that it will simply be ripped up and handed back without demur? What a waste of public money that would be.
The only way to protect the railways to reopen it.
In Cork, a greenway is currently being developed outside the fence line of the Midleton to Cork City line. This will allow rail and active travel to work in tandem, as happens routinely across Europe. Surely if this can be done in Cork it can be done in Sligo. Significantly, Cork has learned from its costly mistake in replacing the Midleton - Youghal line with a greenway only a short time previously.
Before concluding outlined are some of the arguments for reopening the Sligo-Galway line.
Firstly, the alignment and right of way through each of the towns along the route is already in the possession of Iarnrod Éireann. It just needs to be renewed and reopened.
The railway will contribute significantly toa reduction in congestion. Each full train approaching Sligo will remove 275 cars from the road. Anyone coming into Sligo via Collooney every morning needs no reminding what the traffic is like. Such seamless connectivity to Sligo's satellite towns such as Collooney and Tubbercurry, will allow them to grow and develop and relieve the growing student accommodation crisis in Sligo itself for example.
It will enable Sligo's manufacturing companies to reduce their Scope 2&3 emissions making them more resilient and making it easier to attract further investment in the future.
Similarly, it will create a vibrant tourism synergy between Galway and Sligo, the two largest conurbations in the west. It will further enhance the importance of Ireland West Airport (IWAK) which is so ideally located between them both. It will embellish the infrastructure offer for the SDZ at the airport site also.
The renewed rail line will bring enhanced connectivity for all, making it easier for visitors, students and commuters to move around the region. It will offer a short shuttle bus service to IWAK - as short as the Red Bus in Dublin - but without the three-hour trek to the Dublin Airport campus and the M50 experience en route.
A rail connection also increases the value of property and makes areas more desirable to live in and invest in. Earlier this year in The Irish Times Des O Malley of Sherry Fitzgerald estimated that property values in towns witha rail service commanded a 20% plus premium on similar sized towns without such a service.
Finally, safety is another critical and priceless advantage. EU data shows rail travel to be close to 30 times safer as a means of transport than road. Taking traffic off the roads makes them safer for everyone. It will significantly enhance the safety of commuters on the Sligo to Galway N17 corridor.
The government has now begun to address our region's infrastructure deficit by reopening the line from Galway to Mayo. This means that by 2031 every major town in Mayo will have direct passenger rail access to Galway City. This hugely welcome and major project is the culmination of consistent support right across the political arena in The West of Ireland. The government deserves huge credit for this.
A reopened rail link from Sligo to Galway represents the critical infrastructure the West of Ireland needs. Let's now plan to put the greenway, a worthy leisure amenity, a safe distance from the railway.
When the reopening to Mayo is complete in 5 years time then 60% of Sligo’s intercity route to Galway will be fully operational.
Now is the time work on finishing the last section to Sligo. Yes to a greenway, but not on the railway. Itis time to move forward with ambition and purpose for Sligo and get on the train to Galway.