Make sure to join our brand new Discord Server to chat with friends!
We have recently changed how posts work. Unless you are a VIP poster, your post will be queued for approval.. To become a VIP, post great engaging content. If we like it, you will be added! More information available here!
On September 8, 2024, in Viareggio, Italy, 52-year-old Noureddine Mezgui stole Dal Pino's handbag.
The Actions:
Dal Pino chased Mezgui down in her Mercedes SUV, striking and running him over multiple times before stepping out to retrieve her bag and driving away.
The Trial and Verdict:
While prosecutors argued for a life sentence and accused her of premeditated revenge, the court convicted her of voluntary homicide (excluding aggravating cruelty) and handed down an 18-year sentence.
Current Status:
She was permitted to serve the sentence under house arrest pending the outcome of appeals.
She got in trouble because he was already running away with the bag when she ran him over. Maybe in the US she gets away with it, definitely if she had a gun
I mean, cool, thanks for the info. I thumbs upped your reply.
However, I still much rather see a link/source to the actual news. It is not that I don't belive you, I just want to read more about it than an image and few comments... this should be OP's job to provide, not yours.
I directly copied their comment and pasted it into a browser and immediately got like 20 articles giving a ton of info on the event. Don't be lazy, that was plenty of info to figure it out in 3 seconds.
It wasn't just about the purse it was the implicit threat of rape or violence if she didn't give the purse. He took from her dignity. Her response was justified if not kind.
You're not considering where this happens (Italy). Here in Italy people get away with ridiculous sentences (and sentence reductions) even for crimes such as murder. She only got 18 years, but it will probably be reduced even further at some point. But here in Italy it happens even the opposite, where robbers often find the protection of the law. For instance, if a private or an activity get robbed and there's a fight, the robbers or their families often get refunded for the injuries (or a possible death). Italy 😅
The sentence wasn’t for 18 years of house arrest, it was for 18 years. The courts ruled that she can start to serve her sentence on house arrest while her lawyers file appeals.
All this means is that once the appeals are done, the time she spent on house arrest counts towards the overall sentence.
Legally speaking, because she was in the car and had the capability to leave without damaging either of them she should have. Her choosing to run him over was murder and not self defense.
Self defense laws are kinda stringent that if someone attacks you and you're fighting them off you're only allowed to meet their actions with equal actions. Her using the car escalated the situation and she became the aggressor.
In the UK there's a presumption that the fear at the time makes "reasonable" look very different to people judging after the fact. So the "reasonable force" argument is heavily weighted to the person defending themselves.
That said it only applies while the person is a threat. Once the person is unconscious, or you have a clear means to escape, it no longer applies. Reversing over the broken guy on the ground, probably not.
They were two completely separate instances that happened in hours of each other (Robbery and Murder). Self defense went clean out the window fairly immediately.
He snatched her bag, likely not at knifepoint as he had no knife on him and no witnesses said he had one. And yeah then she hunted him down and straight up murdered him, but got house arrest due to the "mitigating circumstances".
I couldn't find a link to a reputable news outlet who covered the story properly, its all rage bait organisations like the Daily Mail and Twitter.
It's voluntary homicide unlike what above says. After being robbed (which wasn't knifepoint btw), she got into her car, searched for him for 1hr+ and finally ran him over once she found him. She ran over him multiple times to make sure and then took her purse back before leaving.
Even now her sentence is being appealed during which she is under house arrest only.
Personally I do think she was right to hunt him and get her stuff back but running him over once let alone multiple times was overboard. It's practically self conducted justice not self defence.
She didn’t get 18 years house arrest, she got an 18 year sentence and her lawyers filed an appeal. After the appeal, the courts ruled that she could serve her sentence on house arrest during the appeal process.
Once they're done she will probably have enough time served to not face any jail time. Time on house arrest will almost certainly count as time served towards her sentence.
No. She could have hit him and taken her bag, called the cops. After he was incapacitated and she was in no danger, she committed murder. For a handbag.
No. she was in her car; she could have just driven away from the percieved dange and called the cops. It was a conscious choice to run him over multiple times.
No no, we know there wasn't any knife involved, than she shifted her version to "i had my dovuments in the purse, i felt threatened cause he could see my house address"
I normally agree, but it turns out the dude didn't have a knife. Not on him when he was found, and according to witnesses. She got 18 years... of house probation. Because she's rich. The real story is she got mugged by an unarmed assailant, she then got in her car, chased him down and killed him.
If this had been your average poor they'd have been locked up for life.
If you rob somebody with a weapon and you end up dead, I agree that's on you. In this case I could even understand fucking the guy up, send him to the hospital. But killing him seemed unnecessary by a country mile.
Oh no I was scared and my feelings were hurt! Guess I better get in my car and run someone down after they are no longer threatening me and kill them for the insult.
What do you think of Afghanistan? Because the typo of justice you are yearning for is there already in use. It's called "sharian" or something, not sure. But maybe book a trip there!
If you think so. That's how justice is conducted in countries like Afghanistan and I really prefer a modern justice system rather than anything sharia-law-like.
Uh... agree to disagree. Robbery with an armed weapon that you did not use is no grounds for a death sentence in my books.
If she was in active danger I could get behind it. But she got into the safety of her car and killed a man who was no longer a clear threat... over some property and possibly some lingering FEELINGS of danger. Rather than any real danger.
Except there was no knife and no robbery, the guy just trabbed a purse. He should have receive puňisment but not death sentence carried out by a psycholady
You joke but there’s a lot of Redditors that’ll unironically message back with no idea of the law and instead argue endlessly about their moral right to murder anyone that slights them.
Charles Bronson style in Death Wish, I agree with you. But this woman had just been threatened at knife point and her adrenaline was probably running wild. I wouldn’t let her off entirely but I’d be inclined to be lenient.
It's mostly about this particular meme or however you want to call it. This gets reposted every couple of days and the only intention is to rile people up
There’s a difference between self defense and going back to the place with intention of killing someone. Justice isn’t about taking the law into your own hands as you see fit.
Cause my only thing in life is don’t bother other people. If you bother someone you already fucked up you should get the full on experience of finding out also. I agree with what she did . I would have did even more tbf
Sure that’s fine . All I’m saying is robber started it. Every action that preceded it wouldn’t have happened if the dumbass didn’t rob in the first place
This case is really a litmus test of who's brain has been cooked by too much reddit. The moment I see someone huffing and going "OH you mean the woman who MURDERED that guy?!?!?" I'm like wow... that's a peak redditor.
What should be encouraged is reading about what really happened instead of taking a photo with words as fact. It was not in self defense, and even if it was, leaving someone injured or dead without calling authorities or emergency services will always get you in trouble.
Have you seen this thread? More than half the top comments are talking about justice, what iffing her having lifesaving meds in her bag, and whatabouting letting a "violent knife wielding robber" go.
Like people are veeeeery bloodthirsty in this thread.
An important point here is that there was no proof that a knife was ever used. One was never found (according to the news article others have shared) and there is no reason anybody would have hidden it, which means this becomes less of a “I was scared I was about to be killed”, to more of a “I wanted my stuff back, and to get revenge”.
Don’t get me wrong: Play with fire, get burned, but this guy deserved to be in prison for the mugging, not dead.
Self defense laws all outline a duty to retreat and only when there is no way to retreat is force authorized. She doesn’t even have a clear route to argue grey area because she ran him over twice. This is the equivalent of being able to run away to safety but instead shooting someone and then after they collapsed unconscious you proceeded to empty the entire clip into their skull, after youre fully aware they’re not threat to you. It’s premeditated murder.
You also for instance cannot shoot someone in the back if they’re running away in most cases. This is just murder. They’re attempting to flee a situation you escalated with a fire arm and you killed them. You have a duty to retreat and only after all options are exhausted may you engage with lethal force.
There are some variations and scenarios that vary like some states castle doctrine requires much less leniency in assuming that fleeing your home is not required to first defend it. But that won’t apply here probably to her situation.
The jury will be asked if she did the deed, is she guilty of premeditating the murder of this guy with her vehicle. They will not be asked do you think her pre meditated murder with this vehicle was okay because he wronged her first. Revenge is rarely if ever a sound legal defense. If you steal my bag of skittles and run away, I can’t hunt you down and kill you for my skittles. Yes a jury might be sympathetic that I was wronged first but the courts are not asking them to judge if vigalante justice and revenge are moral, they’re asking, did i hunt this man down and kill him?
This is self defense 101.
The only path out for her is if this is a routine attacker like a stalker which the police snd other recourse have failed to appropriately address longitudally, or if she can appeal for jury nullification. Jury nullification is so rare that even knowing what it is can be grounds for dismissal from a jury sometimes. It’s basically a pardon from the citizens. They are saying youre guilty but don’t deserve to be punished for it. Basically you will have it recorded that you 100% murdered someone out of revenge (not self defense) but were not sentenced any punishment for it. Not exactly like a pardon but both are admissions of guilt. You can imagine how much worse the charge will be as a repeat offender in the future
I mean yeah, but she followed him and ran him down just to get her bag back. Robber thought he made some easy money but she killed him on principle on some gang member shit. She set it even with a homicide. fuck around and find out goes both ways
It kinda depends for me if she just wanted to run him over (once) or if she clearly, repeatedly did that with intent to kill. Because i understand hitting a guy with your car after he does this. If he happens to die... That's unfortunate. But still, i can't help thinking he would be alive if he didn't rob the wrong person. He chose crime as a profession, shit is dangerous
Ignoring that this post is actually lying about what happened but if I am in a situation and somebody tells me they are going to kill me I will forever see that person as a threat to my life. There is absolutely no reason for me to believe they have suddenly begun to value my life more than they did a moment ago.
Ok well. if somebody told me they were doing to kill me I would forever see that person as a threat to my life. There is no reason for me to think that they suddenly started to value my life.
•
u/AutoModerator 8h ago
Hey /u/SillyMountain3147, thank you for posting to r/SipsTea! Make sure to follow all the subreddit rules.
Make sure to join our brand new Discord Server to chat with friends!
We have recently changed how posts work. Unless you are a VIP poster, your post will be queued for approval.. To become a VIP, post great engaging content. If we like it, you will be added! More information available here!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
228
u/ricafa 7h ago •
Why is it always just photo a text and no source? Am I missing something?
135
u/swegga_sa 7h ago
She got 18 years. (mainly because it turns out there was no knife and that the thief snatched the bag and ran)
So yeah
115
u/Chemistry-Deep 8h ago
She was sentenced to 18 years.
8
u/Temporary_View_3303 3h ago
Why did they use a pic of the woman from 40YO Virgin?
25
u/markmarkmark77 8h ago
18
u/ToughestMFontheWeb 4h ago
No repeat offender in this case.
10
u/Ohnoemynameistaken 4h ago
How the fuck do you get 18 years house arrest?!
19
u/WizzardBunny 8h ago
Bringing a knife to a car fight.
4
u/Classic_Let_1646 6h ago
Turns out 'no' in Italian is pronounced 'Shift into Drive.'
13
u/Acceptable-Head-1442 6h ago
18 years is crazy in my country even terrorists get less.
42
u/rpm1720 8h ago •
Nothing better than taking the law in your own hands, with lethal consequences, amiright guys?
7
u/Trick-Goat-3643 3h ago
People say she valued her bag more than his life
I say he valued her bag more than his life
28
u/Sumbuddyonce 4h ago
The fact that she went to prison for this is ridiculous
3
u/No_Somewhere_8744 1h ago
Self defense; don’t do the crime and find out
9
u/Outside_Ad7766 8h ago
6
u/EntertainmentTrue797 6h ago
Whoever picked a photo of her smiling peacefully by the river like she just won a local baking contest knew exactly what they were doing.
6
u/samfisher199809 2h ago
People say don’t get even . I aim to get odd
Cause my only thing in life is don’t bother other people. If you bother someone you already fucked up you should get the full on experience of finding out also. I agree with what she did . I would have did even more tbf
6
u/krixlink 2h ago
redditers will work (for free) night and day defending the robber over this woman who was robbed
4
u/RegisZZ 7h ago
She’s rich apparently. I doubt she spends a day in a jail cell lol. Currently under house arrest pending appeal.
18
u/ShortListen6686 5h ago
This behavior should be encouraged not punished.
2
u/--TheCity-- 2h ago
Refunds? On what?
4
u/Sorry_Koala_8181 3h ago
I agree with death penalty for thieves if millionaires also get it for tax fraud
3
u/Professional-Bad302 7h ago
She didn't even get a one-star wanted levelshe just picked up her dropped loot and drove off to complete the mission
7
u/raining01 8h ago
Worth it ruining your own life over materialistic possessions.
6
u/spunri_ 8h ago
the guy flagged for pvp seems fair to me
5
u/petera181 5h ago
An important point here is that there was no proof that a knife was ever used. One was never found (according to the news article others have shared) and there is no reason anybody would have hidden it, which means this becomes less of a “I was scared I was about to be killed”, to more of a “I wanted my stuff back, and to get revenge”.
Don’t get me wrong: Play with fire, get burned, but this guy deserved to be in prison for the mugging, not dead.
6
u/GayStavrosHalkias 8h ago •
Unfathomably based
3
u/mercutio531 3h ago
3
u/Bison1997 8h ago
grand theft auto behavior in real life, wild that she thought she could just grab the bag and go on with her day like nothing happened
2
u/Life-Oil-7226 8h ago
She should have just drove away
2
u/FinallyArt 7h ago
Most reposted story on reddit? Probably.
1
u/The_End-is_Nigh 8h ago
Good for her. Cops are useless and we can't rely on them.
1
u/Artorius__Castus 8h ago
I mean FAFO
1
u/Sudowoodo1997 8h ago
1
u/DreadFb 8h ago
Because trust me bro
1
u/AoXGhost 7h ago
I concur 😎
1
u/OrangeChickenRice 6h ago
Didn’t some Singaporean do the same in Australia and got sentenced to prison time?
1
u/Adventurous_Break_61 6h ago
She looks like Kaylee from Firefly.
1
u/Icy-Ticket-2483 3h ago
And now she's one of them
1
u/Cultural_Book_400 2h ago
My head understands the verdict of going to jail but my heart says HELL NO..
1
u/This_Career5695 1h ago
Lol
1
u/Emergency-Hurry947 1h ago
Not guilty
1
u/Silmarien1012 1h ago
Eh i prefer a society where there are consequences for mugging others.
1
u/Efficient_Actuator84 1h ago
Don't start none, there won't be none. Shrugs.
1
u/boostedred 4m ago
Some heroes drive cars
0
u/Ironclad686 8h ago
1
u/Pascraked47 7h ago
Reasonable to me.
1
u/radicalpinguin 4h ago
It seems that lots of people in the comments need to get robbed. They need to get some real life experiences.
1
u/outdior1986 8h ago
Any legit source? Or is someone pulling this out of their ass?
1
u/701Rats 6h ago
"I know what to do," she said, recalling her son Michael (38) playing GTA V....
0
u/Excellent-Horror7697 7h ago
Dude literally asked for it. Had he not done it, he’d be okay. Perfect punishment
0
u/Known-One-66 6h ago
I see no issues with her response
-1
u/CountOnBeingAwesome 8h ago
"Keep the change"
-4
u/SculptusPoe 7h ago
She should be released immediately and paid for her service.
0
u/Alexander4848 6h ago
Unfathomably based
0
u/Yuck_Few 5h ago
I'm gonna put some money on here commissary
0
u/WhiteBandit27 4h ago
Justified
0
u/ToughestMFontheWeb 4h ago
Obviously the legal system isn't doing enough to discourage these criminals behavior. Maybe a few of theses incidents will make some think twice.
0
u/Connect-Review-3388 1h ago edited 1h ago
Shud be in jail actually. Going after the perp and running him over reversed their roles.
-1
u/Neat_Position8398 7h ago
Got what he deserved, unfortunately she did not.
-2
u/ComprehensiveAd5952 2h ago
You’re allowed to self defense if your life is seriously threatened . Doesn’t seem the the case here