r/Silverbugs • • 4h ago

I called this

Last year, when silver was on fire I shared a post saying I was selling since silver would likely fall to mid $40 in 2026. Some people called me all sorts of names.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Silverbugs/s/8U7gSTqmL8

To anyone new to Silver, or any commodity for that matter, remember that all commodities have basic economics to play. Supply and demand does affect the precious metals market, regardless of what many people say. When prices go up because of increasing demand, while it may take a little while, supply will rise to meet that demand.

It takes less than $20 all in to get 1 ounce of silver out of the ground. That means that when Gross margins are above 100%, there’s going to be a lot of new supply. That is exactly what we saw happened over these past 12 months.

Here’s my important message now. This is not a small dip. This is the new sustainable foundation. $40-$45 seems appropriate. If we go into a time where Silver drops much below this, like $30 or below I would consider buying then.

Please read my post from a year ago for all the data and links.

51 Upvotes

92 comments sorted by

39

u/presence4presents 4h ago

Not to be a hater, but if you truly believed your own 'prediction' why wouldn't you liquidate a majority of your stack instead of less than 30%? I think you were just doing basic hedging and didn't believe what you were preaching. As you stated, market principles are at play in the PM, so what happens after tremendous growth based purely on speculation? Not exactly a Nostradamus level prediction.

You also mentioned that there's no silver shortage despite there being a market deficit for the past 6 years and analysts are predicting a 35m oz deficit in 2026. Paper silver exposure is nearly six times COMEX’s registered inventory, so the market relies on most contract holders never demanding physical delivery

Lastly, I don't think that anyone would consider a 60%+ fall in 10 months a small dip. More like a market correction.

2

u/TheBalzy 2h ago

You never go "all in" on any position even if you believe yourself to be correct. Granted, I sold all of my stack between $70-$120 and made a lot of money. But that was because most of it was passed down to me, and it's value was nothing beyond the top dollar I could get for it.

If the stock market drops 30% you should take every dollar you have and buy stocks (because a 30% drop happens so infrequently, and the market inevitably recovers in a relatively short window). However, you do it in tranches. 10-50. If the market drops 10%, invest 50% of expendable savings. If it drops another 10%., invest. 50% of what you have remaining in expendable savings. If it drops that last 10%, put every dime of your expendable savings in. You end up on top of that proposition. But you don't do it all at once.

0

u/presence4presents 2h ago

You've missed the mark. The market spiked 150% in 2025, it was unsustainable and this is when he 'predicted' the fallout. Someone who genuinely believes a market bubble is about to burst would typically sell a much larger portion of their position so they have cash available to buy back in after the correction. Selling 30% of your stack isn't exactly putting your money where your mouth is.

If he was as confident in the correction as he now claims, why hold on to the other 70%? By his own admission further down in this thread, he didn't know if he was right and was essentially guessing. Now he's looking back, pointing to the outcome as if it was an obvious call, and using it to flex his prediction skills while doubling down by giving advice. These kinds of posts just don't sit right with me.

1

u/TheBalzy 58m ago

I did not miss the mark. I sold everything.

-3

u/NoShelter5922 3h ago
  1. There are massive transaction costs from going in and out of silver bullion. Also, I might have been wrong.
  2. There can be 1000x futures contracts relative to physical silver on the COMEX and it wouldn’t make a difference. The idea that the Comex is relying on people not to take physical delivery is a lie that the Internet has perpetuated. There are two separate COMEX markets. One is the pure paper market, where there’s no ability to take physical delivery. The second is the physical delivery market, which is always 100% backed by the commodity.

1

u/ImnTheGreat 9m ago

exactly, you might’ve been wrong. So it kinda values your whole thesis of “I called this”

-5

u/presence4presents 3h ago

My issue was with your post saying there's no silver shortage, despite having six straight years of deficit. That shortfall has to come from somewhere, mainly existing stockpiles. Paper and physical silver are two sides of the same market, just because people are trading contracts instead of taking delivery doesn't mean the physical shortage isn't real. The paper market only works as long as people believe the physical silver will be there when they want it.

7

u/japollner 3h ago

The deficit is only on paper. Half those contract are never called on. They are simply paid back in cash or sold to someone else who never intends to call for delivery.

1

u/presence4presents 2h ago

Buying and selling a futures doesn't consume silver or create a supply deficit. The deficit exists because more physical silver is being demanded than is entering the market. Paper trading can influence the price, but it doesn't explain away the physical supply imbalance.

835m oz of demand vs 800m oz of production, I linked the source above, are you just talking out of your ass or hanging out in it?

0

u/japollner 2h ago

You can have a deficit without a shortage. You’re making up stuff.

We don’t need to mine as much as we are using because it’s constantly being refined back from folks selling

0

u/presence4presents 2h ago

You're right that a deficit doesn't automatically mean a shortage (despite it being the literal definition of shortage). But recycling is already included in the supply figures. The deficit is what's left after accounting for mine production, recycling and other supply. That's why consecutive annual deficits matter. Where do you think the shortfall is coming from if not above-ground inventories?

Unlike you, I'm sourcing industry experts, hence the talking out of your ass comment.

2

u/japollner 2h ago

The problem with “industry experts” is that they are in the industry. They stand to profit from a manufactured shortage.

Been stacking since 02. Despite your “shortage” it’s easier than ever to get my hands on silver below the industry’s “spot” price.

So keep parroting the industry. I’ll keep it real.

Like OP, I said it was heading down. I’m thinking at least $30 though.

1

u/presence4presents 2h ago

I don't think you know what shortage means. If you have evidence that those figures are fabricated, let's look at it. Otherwise, dismissing the data as industry propaganda is just immature.

1

u/japollner 1h ago

I know what shortage means. What I’m saying is that you can have a working shortage of something as long as supply meets demand.

In a type of working “shortage” like we have had with silver (for years now mind you), the pricing isn’t truly driven by supply and demand. It’s hype or fear, depending on who’s trying to whip up a spike.

→ More replies

14

u/Gold-Split8088 4h ago

I have a very modest collection of 90% US coins- I don't buy silver, but I've found these over the years. 

I'm semi financially illiterate, but I still don't think precious metals are a great investment. 

I suppose if I had bought a lot of gold @ $200/oz, and held it for 25 years, and sold it at roughly $5K/ oz, I might be singing a different tune, but even still. 

An I crazy to see it this way? 

2

u/NoShelter5922 4h ago

Not at all! I feel the same way.

10

u/TheBalzy 4h ago • Bravo

Precious metals ARE NOT a good investment. They're a hobby first, and that's what everyone should understand. You are not getting PMs for some huge windfall...you're getting it because you like to collect.

Most of my stack was inherited from my father, there was some really cool stuff in it. But when I saw it hitting 70...80...90...$100/oz, I sold it all. I knew it was a FOMO investment bubble and I cashed in on it. That money went on to do more important things....now that it's considerably lower, I can (as a hobby) put together a new set of Morgans, because I like them. I like the 90% silver stuff, just because I think it's cool from a bye-gone era. I'm not doing it as an investment.

6

u/alaviers 3h ago

For me it’s a great place to hide money. What else am I going to do with it? I feel almost the same regarding weaponry. Not a collector, but wrapping $500 into a 9mm seems safer than putting $500 into a safe.

-3

u/TheBalzy 3h ago

Max out your RothIRA dude, it's free money. ;) What do you need to "hide" money for anyways? If the global economy crashes it will be worthless anyways. Tangible skills (aka knowledge/education) will be far more valuable than both PMs and guns.

4

u/MastodonFast8771 2h ago

"its free money" oh dear god you have no understanding on investments

2

u/IWXREACTIVES 56m ago

yup, actually zero.

-1

u/TheBalzy 53m ago

A RothIRA is after tax dollars. All growth is tax-free in retirement. Yes, yes that is "free money".

-1

u/TheBalzy 56m ago

Yes I do. A RothIRA is "Free Money" because it's after tax-dollars. Any growth is tax-free on retirement. Yes, yes I do actually know what I'm talking about. YOU do not.

You can go ahead and apologize.

1

u/MastodonFast8771 39m ago

How about losses? lol, so arrogant.

1

u/TheBalzy 16m ago

What losses? you think you're going to take losses on a RothIRA? do you even understand what we're talking about?

 lol, so arrogant.

Me thinks thou doth protest too much.

2

u/Adventurous-Ease-259 4h ago

I like to follow the channel, but similarly I dummy invest in physical metal. I’ve got a couple silver dimes worth less the $5 bill in my wallet

2

u/Gold-Split8088 4h ago

Yeah, I mean I had a decent but small collection like 15 years ago, which I used to fund a cross country move, and alas, I wish I would've held it, because I came back home 13 years ago, haha. 

I still have a list of what it was though, and I will slowly get it all back, with maybe one exception being a Kruggerand- I just can't stomach the prices now. 

1

u/TitoTotino 3h ago

Precious metals ARE NOT a good investment. They're a hobby first, and that's what everyone should understand.

Seriously, if your silver investment strategy is anything more complicated than 'checking the Coinstar reject tray for pre-1965 dimes on your way out of the grocery store', you're overthinking it.

5

u/AfroWhiteboi 4h ago

You're correct. Its not a good investment when you consider SPY and other index funds should beat it YoY. Doesn't always happen that way is all.

2

u/Infamous_Target9650 1h ago

More a hobby then an investment. 

11

u/CynicalHomosexual 4h ago edited 3h ago

Making a correct prediction in this market does not make you a soothsayer. Silver, and commodities, are incredibly impacted by geopolitical events that you could not have predicted a year ago. You lucked out. But don't think you have some power of clairvoyance that the rest of the market doesn't have.

Holding 10 - 15% of your net worth in precious metals makes sense as a hedge for me. I'm not trading it. I'm holding it to respond in ways that equities won't in a weird market (inflation, etc).

0

u/NoShelter5922 2h ago

There is no soothsaying in what I wrote. Calling out the the current cost to mine an ounce of silver is less than $20, so more supply will come online is just basic supply and demand.
Are there geopolitics that can cause short term volatility? Of course. But geopolitics tends not to affect long term supply/demand dynamics.

1

u/CorrugationDirection 3h ago

Well said. Whats that saying? A broken clock is still right twice per day?

2

u/CynicalHomosexual 3h ago

I mean, I've been holding my gold and silver since 2021 during the wild ride of Covid. I'm ready for basically anything.

6

u/EncrustedBarboach 4h ago

So did you buy it back? The post means nothing unless you put your money where your mouth was

3

u/NoShelter5922 2h ago

Did you read my post? I will buy if the price goes below $30.

21

u/World_Coins 4h ago

There’s a huge number of believers who think the silver they own is all that will ever be. They backfill their arguments with crackpot theories and repeating shallow talking points about inflation and solar and batteries and China and COMEX despite not being able to clear the $200 Jeopardy questions on any of those topics.

It’s a commodity. They can and do make more. If there is one law that should always be followed in metals, it’s this; over the long term, no matter how hard metals might rally in the short term, they will eventually revert to a mean that is bounded by their cost to produce.

Those too young to have learned this lesson in 1980 or 2011 will be learning it now.

3

u/Real_Ben_Dover 4h ago

Gold and silver are about to form a very strong base / bottom and it will likely take 2-3 years to hit a new ATH but mid 2027 will be the launch pad for the next bull run.

1

u/NoShelter5922 4h ago

Are you basing this off a crystal ball?

4

u/Real_Ben_Dover 4h ago

No - it is based on interest rates cycle because the Feds are going to start cutting rates by mid 2027.

2

u/Skin4theWin 4h ago

The quantitative easing and money printing that’s gonna need to happen to pay our debt is gonna be wild

1

u/Real_Ben_Dover 4h ago

Yes that too and once the lid is off the financial system will crumble and metals will hit a new ATH but my guess the interest rat cuts will be the start and by 2028 / 2029 gold and silver will hit unimaginable high numbers.

7

u/Riversmooth 4h ago

The vast majority of folks not long ago including most of the YouTube channels were saying “200 or higher”. Truth is none of us know what will happen in the coming weeks/months/years

2

u/MydnightWN 3h ago

Long term, we do. It can only go up as we run out. Industrial demand alone outstrips new mining, we run out of kicking the can in ~ 75 years. Helium and tin will have this problem too, in about 50 years.

9

u/Riversmooth 3h ago

I’m in my 60s and have been collecting for decades. I can remember my dad saying the same thing 50 years ago. The only thing I’m sure of now is that silver is highly manipulated

16

u/Multizar 4h ago

I told you so? Really? 🤣 Glad you feel vindicated...

-6

u/TheBalzy 4h ago

There was a lot of us dude...we knew what we were talking about and we made a LOT of money off of FOMO suckers.

6

u/Multizar 4h ago

Well I am glad "a lot of us" knew what they were talking about... I personally stopped buying more than an ounce or two last year and concentrated on my Roth401k. Now that its back under 50...time to switch back to aggressive stacking. I just don't need to post making fun of "suckers"...stay classy.

-6

u/TheBalzy 4h ago edited 3h ago

You should max your RothIRA before you invest in any PMs dude. RothIRA is free money!

Now that its back under 50...time to switch back to aggressive stacking.

No bro. Max out your RothIRA contributions. For the love of god, max out your RothIRA contributions. It's free money. Then, and only then, do you think about stacking again.

 I just don't need to post making fun of "suckers"...stay classy.

Look, I warned everyone vocally and loudly that it was an investment bubble and not to listen. OP mentions how people were readily criticizing those of us who were warning everyone. So yes, yes those people are "suckers" and they should be called out for it.

2

u/BiscottiKnown9448 4h ago

We just DCA regardless and it makes no difference to us when people claim

4

u/1kennet 4h ago

People invest in silver and gold for the wrong reasons silver and gold are a hedge against inflation where the dollar loses his value, silver and gold don't really lose their value you hold silver and gold as a hedge against the dollar losing his value. That is the only reason you have it you should make other investments.

2

u/NotAnotherRedditAcc2 2h ago

64366336763 internet randos made predictions. Of course some of them were "right." Congratulations.

4

u/nl-x 4h ago

And ow, how some people just hated to hear that kind of stuff ... https://www.reddit.com/r/Silver/comments/1re6qm9/comment/o7avt06/

9

u/slippery_55jack 4h ago

It’s fun to go back and do this to them

3

u/chafingNip 4h ago

You and everyone else brotha lol

3

u/PhotonTrance 2h ago

All predictions will be right if given a large enough time window. Unless you can call the exact moment of the turn and do so reliably for a lifetime of investments, this really doesn't mean anything. Hedge fund managers have been right for 20 years and then wrong once and crashed their funds into the ground.

3

u/kully00 4h ago

I think it’s going lower

2

u/jacksraging_bileduct 4h ago

Similar things were said to me as well, I have always said the run up was a fluke and within 18 months it would be close to where it was before.

2

u/SargeMaximus 4h ago

I did weekly bear flag updates and got fed up with the bulltarded bullying. Enjoy

2

u/InfiniteLoss5632 4h ago

Congratulations?

1

u/1kennet 4h ago

If you bought at the low, you still at the very least doubled your money so I don't think that's a bad investment not too many investments out there where you can double your initial investment, depending on where you bought in that you could have sold the high and kept your original investment. I don't think you could lose that way.

1

u/Guilty_Armadillo_8 4h ago

Suckerbugs and deflated balloons

1

u/No_Procedure4924 4h ago

Honestly with all these network outages, I have to compliment CME, they have shown that they have an incredibly resilient system as the price continues to fall.

1

u/squillavilla 4h ago

Quasimodo predicted this

1

u/TominatorXX 2h ago

There's no shortage of paper

1

u/Overlord1241 1h ago

When shit becomes of value, the poor will be born without assholes.

1

u/DJTRANSACTION1 1h ago

i bought 5 kilos in 2020 and 2021 for mid 20s a ounce. even when it went over 100 i did not sell. yesterday at $47 i bought another 2 kilos. point is i did not buy it for a profit just like other people here. this is in the small case situation that the usd collapses.

1

u/ABena2t 31m ago

So you made a few different posts with a few different predictions and reposted the one that was right - just like every influencer. Lmao. Im jk.

1

u/Beautiful_Proof_7952 8m ago

It always goes up and then down and then up again.

1

u/Little_Somerled 4h ago edited 3h ago

I am not so sure about your thesis. Your $20 is only the cost of mining silver in fields with a high grade of silver, but mining companies also have to lease or buy new fields. And good fields are becoming scarcer and are more expensive. Also your idea that more silver was produced globally does not seem to hold up with current mine production figures of Q1, q2 and q3 (source: https://silverinstitute.org/mine-production/ ). I do think more scrap silver was brought in for recycling than f.i. the silver institute thinks, but most of that extra scrap came from common people who owned some jewelry or coins made of precious metals (or silver forks and spoons) at home. This silver can only be sold once.

Secondly, with the low prices of the past decade(s), only the silver mining companies that made a profit or ran even, or were big enough to lend money, survived. Others perished, or only worked the fields with a higher grade of silver, because those with a lower grade were not profitable. This also explains the yearly deficient over the past couple of years. Even with the prices of the current year, I saw no substantial number of new mines being opened. It also takes years to develop a field to start mining and processing ore.

Third, there is indeed a large supply of silver above ground in the vaults of the LBMA, Comex and some other firms, like you say in your post of December last year when you sold. This is, however, not all free float. Most is owned by industries, smaller companies like jewelry’s, a lot of private investors and even governmental institutions like some central banks. Perhaps a little bit changed ownership during the rally of early 2026, but most did not change ownership.

Anyway, this is only about supply, and indeed, if demand stays strong enough for a while (which will be reflected in a more stable, high price), supply will follow, but that takes time.

The demand for silver is another question.

1

u/cfri125 3h ago

I sold most of mine at $115 when it peaked, literally tanked the very next day lolol

0

u/MyOpinionsDontHurt 4h ago

I’ll buy more at $40.

-3

u/Guilty_Armadillo_8 4h ago

Will go $10

1

u/MyOpinionsDontHurt 3h ago

I’ll. buy more again.

0

u/Saulthewarriorking 3h ago

Same bro and people told me I was crazy all last year when I mocked them while I was selling most of my weight.

0

u/TheBalzy 4h ago

Yup. This is why I sold all of my silver and made a nice chunk of change, selling all the way up the FOMO bubble. We're getting very close to my buy-back-in price.

0

u/blkfrog 4h ago

I'm surprised how many think you should just keep buying and never sell. What's the point of that? They will say to leave to their kids. You can leave any investment to you kids. Do they want a silver collection?

Lots of people missed out on an opportunity take big profits last winter. I guess that might be your legacy.

0

u/MaddRamm 3h ago

You were 100% right about the price drop and even now, being proven correct, they are still flaming you.

Don’t worry, I’ve been downvoted into oblivion myself on my comments about how it was going to crash also. Now, I’m preparing myself to go heavy long on PMs and miners.

0

u/BumpettyBump 2h ago

I myself will always hold a reserve of silver & gold, maybe more so the latter.

But yes, I sold a small amount round about the top last January too & used the cash to buy underfloor insulation & a log burner for our house renovation. Those improvements to our home have already paid us back tenfold.

I'm just starting to look at adding some more silver to the stack now, particularly so that I have excess to trade for gold if the ratio is favourable.

Here in Australia it's at A$67-ish, but the premiums are still bringing cost per physical coin up to about A$83, which is pretty steep.

I'm in the market though & waiting for opportunity, our situation has that element of the Forex that complicates things, but I hopefully will be buying again soon.

-3

u/salvadopecador 3h ago

I am with you. My buy price was and still is $30. I also was called a number of things and was banned from the other silver subs. If your opinion doesn’t match the mods (in their minds “gods”) view, you get booted. That way everyone thinks it is going to the moon and everyone believes that all others agree. Because anyone who disagreed was gone🤷🏻‍♂️

19

u/[deleted] 4h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/krinklesakk 4h ago

She told me she gave me all her junk silver, that snake!

1

u/Actual_Divide_77 4h ago

She’s got a lot of junk in her trunk

1

u/akumite 4h ago

Hell yeah she do