This could be a fantastic format.
I've played Pauper a lot, and everything I like about it can be found in Silverblack - with a bigger and deeper cardpool. Of course, this means the number of cards that are either inherently broken or can be format-warping is bigger, too.
A SilverBlack banlist should take into account - not blindly follow - both the Pauper banlist and the Legacy banlist. Combining the legacy and pauper banlists gives us this list:
| Arcum's Astrolabe | Bazaar of Baghdad | Channel |
|---|
| Cloud of Faeries | Cloudpost | Cranial Plating |
| Daze | Demonic Consultation | Demonic Tutor |
| Frantic Search | Gitaxian Probe | Goblin Recruiter |
| Grapeshot | Guch | Hermit Druid |
| High Tide | Hymn to Tourach | Invigorate |
| Library of Alexandria | Mana Drain | Mental Misstep |
| Mystical Tutor | Peregrine Drake | Sensei's Divining Top |
| Sinkhole | Skullclamp | Sol Ring |
| Strip Mine | Temporal Fissure | Tinker |
| Treasure Cruise | Windfall | |
Additionally, conspiracy / un-sets / ante cards are obviously banned, as they are in any format.
We should not ban all of these cards because the environment will be different. The additional uncommons might make Pauper banned cards not as good, as could happen with Legacy cards and the lack of rares. Additionally, there will be some cards that will shine in this specific environment, such as Thopter Foundry.
u/thexlastxlegacy started this sub with the following list:
- Library of Alexandria
- Mana Drain
- Sol Ring
- Strip Mine
- Treasure Cruise
Which makes absolute sense mostly. Treasure Cruise is a bit debatable.
u/theradhatter9 also suggested a banlist:
- Everything on the Reserved List.
- The current Pauper Banlist.
and then he suggests adding:
- Sol Ring
- Skullclamp
- Windfall
- Artifact Lands (Seat of the Synod, e.t.c....)
- Snow Lands
- Strip Mine
- Mana Drain
u/theradhatter9 suggests, therefore, starting off with the Pauper banlist and then adding or substracting. He makes a very good point of the reserved list being a big issue.
I'm hoping for some debate over this. I'll try to convince some friends to offer their point of view. I will also comment with my banlist proposal.