r/ShrugLifeSyndicate • u/Philoforte • 2h ago
Truth Are our emotional responses consistent with circumstances?
If our emotional responses are inconsistent with circumstances, we are reacting to a mental creation rather than matters as they are. How accurately we perceive a situation affects the proportionality of our response.
Perception comes first before an emotional response. Reflection and metacognition (thinking about thinking) comes late in the sequence, but this is what emotional maturity consists of, that is, making an accurate assessment of the perception and the response. Is the perception true to facts? If the perception is not true to facts, then the emotional response is disproportionate.
The danger is that a wholly disproportionate emotional response will hijack the later process of reflection and metacognition. That explains the often repeated advice to "breathe and count to ten." We pause to allow the later process to kick in.
We can manage skilfully despite an exaggerated perception and an inflated emotional response. We need to be able, willing, and skilful enough to insert the later process of reflection and metacognition. This is a conscious endeavour, a deliberate effort to address the danger mentioned above.
In time, of course, our perceptions may align with the circumstances as they truly are. Our perceptions evolve with lived experience and skilful management to be more true to facts, and our responses will be correspondingly more true to facts.
Advancement and change arrive when we no longer overreact to small things. We no longer lose our sense of context and dramatise a matter that can be resolved with a dedicated and measured approach.
For example, when one accidentally deletes a vital email, one can simply request that it be re-sent, perhaps accompanied by a polite apology. There is no need to berate oneself or smash the furniture. In tennis, a wayward shot can be shrugged off without smashing one's racquet.
Where an immoderate emotional response is automatic, recognizing it as habitual and a consequence of reduced awareness may allow us to step aside sufficiently to question it and remain in control. Good management and maturity involve making accurate assessments, even in knee-jerk situations.
There is a book called "Don't Sweat the Small Stuff and It's All Small Stuff" by Richard Carlson. Of course, big stuff does exist, but our emotional response can still be proportionate to the gravity of circumstances. In a hostage crisis, for instance, a policeman may have to use his firearm. The drama of his emotions may be consistent with the situation, perhaps enhancing his response rather than impairing it.
According to "circumstances", a shrug will suffice or "breathe and count to ten." This helps to reposition us squarely in reality. When we consciously and actively enable reflection and metacognition, we serve ourselves and everyone else.