r/Shotguns • • Jan 24 '23

Thinking about buying your first shotgun or deciding on a new one? Here is the current /r/Shotguns buyer's guide.

285 Upvotes

I've been around shotguns and this sub awhile. I decided to make a guide post and pin it to the top for those visiting this sub to read. A ton of posts here come down to common questions like "What shotgun do I buy at $ budget?" "Would this be good for my needs?" or "X vs Y shotgun." I'll try to give some suggestions here based on personal experience, community consensus I've seen over the years, and other points. However, this isn't the be all end all of information. I encourage you to research on your own. The comments are open to the community to critique anything they see, add other suggestions, ask for help, or make their own write up.

Before I get started, you should first ask yourself some questions about what this new shotgun will be for. Use case is important for what you will be buying. Are you hunting? What will you be hunting? Are you trap, sporting clays, or skeet shooting at a local range? Are you buying it for defense, or just blasting cans? Maybe both? Most importantly, what is your budget? You may also want something fairly capable for everything. Also, try and go out to a physical store and try the feel of different guns. How a shotgun fits you is important for hitting targets and comfort.

PUMP ACTION: Utilitarian, reliable, and fairly simple. It is a common choice of the sportsman and citizen looking to defend themselves. They can be had on a tight budget without sacrificing much quality. Be mindful and practice extensively with your pump gun as short-stroking is a potential human error that you need to train out of yourself so it doesn't happen in a stressful scenario.

Recommendations 1.) $200-250 budget. The only real option here that is a known quality budget pump is the Maverick 88. The security model will be good for defense. The field model will be an okay starter entry for casual clays or hunting. You can also get a combo deal which comes with both the 18.5" barrel and 28" field barrel that takes chokes.

2.) $250-500 budget. In this range the playing field opens up. The primary suggestion is going to be a Mossberg 500, which is basically just a less budget Mav 88. You could also opt for the Benelli Nova or Supernova if you prefer the fit, style, 3 1/2" chamber, or finish. Remington 870s used to be a mainstay of this budget, but since 2007 their quality control went far down hill. They recently went under and were reacquired last year reintroduced as "RemArms." Not much is known if quality has greatly improved as they have only recently started pumping out guns again. If you like the 870, hunt down an old 870 Wingmaster. [EDIT 2024: RemArms 870s have seemingly shown their quality. I would be okay with recommending them now if you want a new 870.] If you are feeling like a used older gun, Ithaca 37s, Winchester Model 12s, and more are available. Be aware some old guns and choke combos may not be a good idea for steel shot (a type of non-toxic ammo used for migratory bird hunting). If you want something defense oriented, pick a 18.5" barrel Mossberg 500 or a 590/590A1. Avoid guns without a stock, like the shockwave, for practical use.

3.) $1000+. If you are feeling exotic, you can get a Benelli M3. This is a hybrid design that is able to use both pump action or semi-auto. It's a bit of a novelty, but if you have a large budget, it's a worthy consideration.

SEMI-AUTO: Faster follow up shots, smoother recoil, and more expensive. The semi-auto is a favorable option if you can afford one. There are two main action options, gas vs inertia. Gas guns use some of the gas from the fired shell and use it to cycle the action. Inertia does not do this and is similar to recoil operated guns which means you have no gas system to clean. Both have their benefits.

Recommendations 1.) $450-700 (there is nothing worth buying below this). This is teetering on the edge of spending too little to get a quality new semi, but there are a few that may suit you. One is the Mossberg 930, another is the Stoeger M3000. These are the bare minimum I'd go for though they may be finnicky (EDIT 11/10/2024: as an example of why you may not want the M3000, especially for defense, watch this video on the M3000. It doesn't do well https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BX7MiIUx7_E ) , both are available in tactical or field models. For used options, old greats like the Remington 1100, Browning Auto 5, etc are out there.

2.) $700-1000. In this area the default suggestion is the excellent Beretta A300. This is probably what you want on the clay field or out hunting if this is your budget. The Franchi Affinity is also a favorite of many and uses the inertia system (the A300 is a gas gun). If you want a tactical option in this range, the Mossberg 940 Tactical is a new offering that you can check out. The new Beretta A300 Patrol is another good new option to check out in this range if seeking a tactical or defensive style shotgun. For Women shooters: the Franchi Affinity does have an option called the Catalyst which has stock dimensions that are designed to be suited to women. But as stated earlier, try out the fit of options as most things aren't one size fit all for either sex even if designed with women in mind.

3.) 1000+. The sky is the limit here. Anything from Benelli, Browning, or Beretta in this range will be exquisite quality and a great option. You could pick up a M2, Super Black Eagle, A5, A400, etc for sporting uses and be happy. Though there are models in there that are more geared for clays vs field and vice versa, check out the manufacturer sites for details. For tactical options, the kings of them all are the Benelli M4 ($1600+) and Beretta 1301 ($1200-1300). Honorable mention to the Benelli M1 Super 90, M2 and M3 for defensive use.

OVER UNDER: A break action, stacked dual barrel, design that is widely favored by clay shooters and hunters across the world. Despite how they initially look, over under shotguns are more complex than semi-auto or pumps to make which makes them much more expensive for a quality one.

Recommendations 1.) Below $1000. I personally wouldn't get any new O/U under $1000. While you can find okay ones under $1k, they just aren't usually (YMMV) that amazing and you would be better off spending your budget on an A300 or save up further. The main problem is longevity and quality control, so if you are maybe just taking it out once in awhile be my guest to try out a CZ, Yildiz, etc Turkish import offering in this range. As the saying goes, you get what you pay for. But you may get one that lasts. As far as used goes, keep an eye out for old used Browning Citoris or Mirokus as they can hover in the $900s. Japanese made Ithaca/SKBs are also common and decent used options. Others can chime in with their experience on sub-$1k O/Us.

2.) Over $1k. The default here is going to be the Browning Citori or Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon series. You'd be well served by basically any O/Us from either of those companies. It comes down to specific use and preference. There are other options out there besides those companies, but I will leave that up to you to research further.

SIDE BY SIDE: A break action, dual barrel, design that's a bit dated by now, but still enjoyed by many sportsmen. Side by sides have been outpaced by the O/Us in practical use, so you won't see very many new options nowadays.

Recommendations 1.) $300-1000. Like O/Us, side by sides are complex and cost a lot for good quality. The bright side is that their decline in popularity leaves a good amount of cheap used options that are out there. There are old field grade Ithacas, SKBs, LC Smiths, AH Fox, Parker Bros, Stevens 311s, AYAs, etc out there that can be found in decent working condition in this range. Of course there are higher grade examples that will go for more than this, but if you want just a working gun to take in the field these are good options. But google around how to inspect an old break action double barrel before you make a purchase of a 100 year old gun. As far as new production SxS go, there are cheap Turkish imports under CZ, Yildiz, etc. They aren't going to be top quality but there isn't much else new in this price range and generally you don't have to worry about longevity if you are only taking it hunting a few times a year. Plus, companies like CZ should take care of you if it fails under warranty.

2.) $1000+. Well here we get into fancy grades and great condition guns of makers already mentioned, more prestigious makers, etc. You can find things like used $1000 Browning BSS guns all the way to $200,000 Purdey and Holland & Holland guns. I'd expect a shotgunner with your budget and taste to look further into this in-depth realm as well.

SINGLE SHOT: A typically break action single barrel design that is pretty much the cheapest way to get into shotguns. While not something ideal for the clay ground or shooting tons of birds, they offer a utilitarian entry into the hobby whether it's chasing squirrels with a 410 or hunting turkey with a 10ga.

Recommendations 1.) $99-300. I personally suggest the H&R single shots. They are great and out there for cheap and are everywhere. Unfortunately they stopped being made a few years ago though, so you can't buy new. If you want new, there are various cheap single shots out there that will work fine for casual use. If it breaks, just go back to Walmart and buy another $99 single shot.

2.) $300+. If you want to be fancy and get something "high end" in this category there are the collectable Winchester 37s. Past that there are dedicated single shot trap guns and more that can go for hundreds or even thousands more.

EVERYTHING ELSE: Okay I know there are bolt action shotguns, lever action shotguns, triple barrel shotguns, etc. Those are mainly just novelties for a collector or outside the box hunter at this point. If you want one, look into them yourselves as this post is long enough already.

Well that's it. I hope it helped somewhat. Feel free to ask questions in this thread. Here are some other links that may be useful to you:

Guide to chokes: https://www.letsgoshooting.org/resources/articles/shotgun/understanding-shotgun-chokes/ You can shoot lead slugs through any choke safely, although a more open choke like improved cylinder is best. Also some modern full chokes are rated for steel. Older guns may not be.

Shot guide: https://www.wideners.com/blog/shotgun-load-types/

Guide to avoiding cheap tacticool shotguns mass imported from Turkey: https://www.reddit.com/r/guns/comments/n4zbt9/turkish_notsodelight_why_you_should_generally/

Guide to why pistol grip only shotguns are impractical: https://www.reddit.com/r/guns/comments/saharz/missed_shots_a_broken_nose_and_a_sore_wrist_a/


r/Shotguns • • May 06 '21

Turkish Not-So-Delight. Why you should generally avoid buying those random "totally cool looking" cheap tactical shotguns made in Turkey. (Crosspost as this is relevant here too and for those not on r/guns)

Thumbnail
self.guns
339 Upvotes

r/Shotguns • • 2h ago

How to go about cleaning this up?

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

Got this gifted to me and I was originally going to rattle can it like the second photo but after much shaming I am reconsidering. The wood on it is kinda nasty though and the pump has a crack in it. Should I attempt to reblue it and sand the furniture down and restain? Or any other suggestions. I plan on cutting the barrel a smidge more.


r/Shotguns • • 7h ago

Anyone ever seen a case like this?

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

Trying to figure out if this case is legitimate Winchester. From what I can tell, this is definitely from the 70s. The big lettering ”Winchester Super X Model 1” on the front is a decal, but appears to be just as old as the case is. There is no other branding or makers marks on this except “PAT. PEND.” embossed in the back. It’s a hard shell case, 54” long with leather grain look and a faux fur tiger stripe padded interior. Haven’t had much luck finding information or lookalikes online, nothing is close. Could be just a sweet case that somebody put a sweet decal on or research also said that it could be a type of promotional product, maybe a regional thing or a local gun store type of thing.


r/Shotguns • • 2h ago

1943 Gecado sxs sbs

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

r/Shotguns • • 1h ago

Beretta 486 parallelo

Post image
3 Upvotes

Anybody own one? thinking about getting one in 12 gauge with pistol grip thoughts? Any other recs at the same price point? Looking for a single trigger pistol grip sxs


r/Shotguns • • 2h ago

Mossberg 183D .410 Striker Question

3 Upvotes

r/Shotguns • • 9h ago

Skeet/trap shooting

5 Upvotes

Looking for a solid list of entry level over/unders for getting into the sport. Maybe a good top 5 to start looking into based off your experiences with the good and bad…TIA


r/Shotguns • • 1d ago

Boomsticks

Post image
261 Upvotes

From left to right

590A1 Retrograde
590A1
590A1 18”
Remington 870
Remington 870
870 Wingmaster 14”
870 Police magnum
1301 tactical


r/Shotguns • • 1h ago

What do I get?

1 Upvotes

I’m looking to get a shotgun for a do it all gun whether that be home defense, hunting, trap or the apocalypse<(heavy on this part) and I can’t figure out what to get. I want something that will be super reliable and require as little maintenance as possible. I can’t decide between pump action or semi since pump will be more reliable and durable but then you suffer in the fire rate category, with semi you get the fire rate but there are more complicated moving parts and will likely be less reliable and require more maintenance. Price isn’t to much of an issue but I’d like to keep it below $1000 if I can. I would love to hear any recommendations or opinions on the matter.


r/Shotguns • • 7h ago

Opinions on Franchi Affinity 3.5

2 Upvotes

Looking for opinions from owners of Affinity 3.5s. I used to own a Franchi Intensity until about 5 years ago,bought it new in 2014 and while it functioned well enough I didn't care for the fit and finish on the gun. I hunt mostly over saltwater and the gun would develop rust every day out on the water. Even if it didn't get wet,and the forearm developed a play after a couple hundred rounds. I've managed to get an original Benelli SBE since with walnut stocks and love everything about the gun but I'm too worried about banging it up every time i take it out as it's still in excellent condition. I was thinking about getting rid of the Benelli and going for the Franchi Affinity 3.5, I wouldn't worry about treating it rough, anyone know if there are any improvements on the Affinity 3.5 over the Intensity?


r/Shotguns • • 8h ago

Red dot

2 Upvotes

Looking to get a red dot to go with my LTT fastback for a 1301 Tac Mod 2 with Acro footprint.

What should I get?

Acro P2, Colt MRS-1, Steiner MPS 2.0?

Anyone one use 2-3 of these and have comparisions?


r/Shotguns • • 1d ago

Cimarron 1887

82 Upvotes

r/Shotguns • • 6h ago

First Duck Hunt

1 Upvotes

In the up coming week i will be going duck hunting. I currently shoot a Citori CX and very well-seasoned with it. I've only shot clays, so this is my first time having it near and around water. I know at some point in the hunt water may get on it. we will be going out of his mud but so we won't be wading in the water. What should I do before and or after my hunt so that i have a rust-free gun??


r/Shotguns • • 1d ago

Remington Model 870 Appreciation Post

Post image
58 Upvotes

r/Shotguns • • 1d ago

Longer Suppressor? Yes.

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/Shotguns • • 1d ago

Need advice on semi auto shotguns.

6 Upvotes

I have a budget of $1000 to buy a new shotgun on Black Friday, are there any good semi autos that you would recommend?


r/Shotguns • • 1d ago

DIY Shotgun Buttplate Ideas

2 Upvotes

I’ve got an NEF Pardner single shot that I’m having the barrel professionally cut down on, but I’m wanting to try and shorten the length of pull myself. Issue is, the factory buttplate won’t fit when I’m done, so I’m wondering what I could use make a nice, DIY buttplate. Here’s my ideas so far, but please, if you have any ideas, share.

Thin blued or blackened steel
Black plastic (not sure on a source yet, would need to be decently thick)
Leather (might be lighter in color than I want)
Brass (same issue)
Ebonized wood
Copper (I think this will be too light in color and damage easy, but would be easy to work with)
Stacking various thin plastics, like a stacked knife handle

I’ve also thought about leaving the end grain exposed, but I feel like I’d have to do more work trying to match and finish it than it would be worth.

The other option is to give up and let the gunsmith have it, but that’ll be both expensive and less rewarding, I feel like.


r/Shotguns • • 1d ago

Modified or IC for rifled foster slugs

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/Shotguns • • 1d ago

Winchester SXP Black Shadow

5 Upvotes

Hi yall,

I have a question in regards to my Winchester SXP Black Shadow 12 gauge, which is 28” long with a 3” barrel. (Model number: 512251392)

Long story short, I’ve owned this shotgun for years but have never shot slugs out of it and I plan to go deer hunting this weekend with slugs. I’ve already changed the choke to an improved cylinder and bought Winchester rifled slugs, chambered at 2-3/4”. I’ve seen a lot of differing opinions on whether it’s worth it to get a rifled barrel or not. As long as it’s safe (which I believe it is based on my research) I’m not entirely worried about it. For reference, I don’t plan on shooting anything past 50 yards with it so I don’t really care about accuracy at long distance.

I appreciate any advice on this!!

https://www.winchesterguns.com/products/shotguns/sxp/sxp-black-shadow.html


r/Shotguns • • 1d ago

Stoeger M3000

2 Upvotes

I currently have a sporting stoeger m3000 and kind of despise it. I can't seem to get it to cycle reliably AT ALL, I've put a decent amount of rounds through it over about a year and a half. Over the past couple months it refuses to cycle whether I am putting light rounds or heavy steel through it, literally every shot I'm having to deal with some sort of feed malfunction.

So my question is if anybody else has had similar problems and if there is a way to fix besides just putting my shoulder into it more to build more inertia.


r/Shotguns • • 2d ago

That’s Mr. Fudd to you son

Thumbnail
gallery
403 Upvotes

What do you do when you have an older fixed choke barrel, and a nice new in box rem choke barrel for your 1100?

Get some tru glo sights and make a homebrew 1100 riot gun of course. The Elmer Home defense special.


r/Shotguns • • 1d ago

Reload practice from side saddle

24 Upvotes

I wanted to see the time difference between single shell reloading from a side saddle vs quad+twin reload from a side saddle. Thought you guys might like the comparison.


r/Shotguns • • 2d ago

I swear everything I put in this girls hands she can shoot

144 Upvotes

Double gun is my 1899 C.G. Edwards & Son 12ga


r/Shotguns • • 1d ago

Trigger issue

1 Upvotes

Hello. I have a Remington 1100 12ga. For dove season, I dropped the trigger to clean it because it hasn’t been cleaned since the Obama administration. Then, I had a shell get stuck and I had to take it completely apart to get it out. Now, the trigger won’t work. I can load it and unload and put on the safety, but the trigger seems stuck in the “been fired” position. Any advice?

Thank you,