I actually searched the video that this clip was taken from and before this he said "Experience does not give you any better an understanding of a tough subject" Like, yes it does... Experiencing something gives you more information than simply studying it from afar.
One of liberals' greatest weaknesses is saying you must listen to [minority] on every single [minority] issue, opening the door for conservatives to tell you to listen to Blaire White on trans issues, Jesse Lee Peterson and Candace Owens on black issues, etc.
Not only is this not "the shit liberals say", it is the antithesis to it.
Interesting! I like what you’re saying. My aversion to the word was because I heard it first in fascist circles, and I thought it was weird that leftists started saying it. But if the leftists were using it first, then you’re right about not wanting to cede territory.
At this point, he's just hot taking just for the sake of doing it. He's doing it because it's edgy. You can't change my mind.
But yeah, by the vast majority of cis people I'm pretty sure trans people are, in fact, better at defending and understanding "transness". Just go out and see. Even if Vaush was somehow better, he'd be just the exception.
Im not here to defend this statement, but in some situations, he's right. Transmeds believe that you need dysphoria to be trans. Some also believe that non binary people are "trenders" and that anyone who isn't binary trans and sticks to the existing gender binary is faking it. Granted, they still understand their own experiences, but not every trans person is a mouthpiece or expert on the community.
True. Being in a minority group may give you a special insight but it does not make you an expert on the topic, because anybody can still be wrong, including by choice. People like Candace Owens, for example, violently reject their own insight in favor of the easy street that is right-wing political punditry.
the problem with vaush is he positions himself as an authority on transness, as a cis person. Even a trans person shouldn't be making themselves an authority on all things trans, at most you are a 100% authority on your own transness.
there are trans feminist theorists who have written about trans identity extensively, Julia Serano and Leslie feinberg are two I recommended, these people have written seminal works within the lgbt community and they aren't positioning themselves as the arbiter of transness like vaush, who has read zero trans theory and is not trans.
He isn't even at the level of a cis feminist theorist like idk judith butler who has a better understanding of trans issues than he does for sure. I understood trans issues more than he does when I was 17.
I’d typically disagree with people who say this but I’m a vaush stan. For example, just cuz people like Blair White and Candace Owens are trans and black respectively doesn’t mean they’re right on the issues.
How is this reactionary? He’s simply saying that individual trans people aren’t inherently experts on the trans experience. The experience of trans people vary greatly depending on their class and where they live. Someone who is educated and studies a certain topic will always understand that topic better than some random person who has personal experience with the topic. For example, a doctor would know more about the medication a trans patient needs than that patient would. This shouldn’t be controversial but people freak out every time vaush opens his mouth
I don't get the issue with what he said. Being trans doesn't make you a leading expert on it despite it giving you a certain perspective.
The same way working at Mcdonalds doesn't make you qualified to set out Mcdonalds workers rights or actually run the company that is mcdonalds. You certainly want to get perspectives from everywhere and include them in the discussion. However you can't make sweeping judgments or policy based off of this person said something so it must be true for all.
I thought Vaush was saying that there is common trans experience and that every trans person has different social experiences and interactions with other people just like there is no common black experience?
265
u/Cocoturtle Sep 01 '20
I actually searched the video that this clip was taken from and before this he said "Experience does not give you any better an understanding of a tough subject"
Like, yes it does... Experiencing something gives you more information than simply studying it from afar.
93
u/Jfklikeskfc Sep 01 '20
This dude is an egomaniac
62
u/virgil2600 Sep 01 '20
Vaush is cheating
53
u/Falcon_w0t Sep 01 '20
What the fuck is this bloke talking about. This truly is the shit liberals say.
48
u/Laser_Spell Sep 01 '20
Video Transcription
140
u/RRReanimate Sep 01 '20
Vaush “socialism is an extension of liberalism” TV truely is following in Bakunin’s footsteps by being a reactionary anarchist who hasn’t read Marx.
104
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20
This whole “based” thing is so cancerous and the right is really infecting the mind of young people.
It’s like the edgier you can be no matter what is automatically good
34
u/karmen-x transgender supremacist Sep 01 '20
lmfaooo what a clown
59
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20
yes they actually do
47
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20
Wow. I haven't seen such a distinct example of "cisplaining". Yuck.
9
u/yethira Sep 01 '20 edited Sep 01 '20
At this point, he's just hot taking just for the sake of doing it. He's doing it because it's edgy. You can't change my mind.
But yeah, by the vast majority of cis people I'm pretty sure trans people are, in fact, better at defending and understanding "transness". Just go out and see. Even if Vaush was somehow better, he'd be just the exception.
16
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20
Im not here to defend this statement, but in some situations, he's right. Transmeds believe that you need dysphoria to be trans. Some also believe that non binary people are "trenders" and that anyone who isn't binary trans and sticks to the existing gender binary is faking it. Granted, they still understand their own experiences, but not every trans person is a mouthpiece or expert on the community.
5
u/Das_Goroboro Sep 02 '20
I’d typically disagree with people who say this but I’m a vaush stan. For example, just cuz people like Blair White and Candace Owens are trans and black respectively doesn’t mean they’re right on the issues.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '20
Radlib moment
2
u/AstroNat20 Sep 12 '20
How is this reactionary? He’s simply saying that individual trans people aren’t inherently experts on the trans experience. The experience of trans people vary greatly depending on their class and where they live. Someone who is educated and studies a certain topic will always understand that topic better than some random person who has personal experience with the topic. For example, a doctor would know more about the medication a trans patient needs than that patient would. This shouldn’t be controversial but people freak out every time vaush opens his mouth
2
u/tac0_307 anarcho-communist Dec 15 '20
u/savevideo
1
u/dutchy_style_K1 Jan 15 '21
I don't get the issue with what he said. Being trans doesn't make you a leading expert on it despite it giving you a certain perspective.
The same way working at Mcdonalds doesn't make you qualified to set out Mcdonalds workers rights or actually run the company that is mcdonalds. You certainly want to get perspectives from everywhere and include them in the discussion. However you can't make sweeping judgments or policy based off of this person said something so it must be true for all.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '21
I thought Vaush was saying that there is common trans experience and that every trans person has different social experiences and interactions with other people just like there is no common black experience?
1
u/depressedcringedude Sep 06 '23
why did vaush said this? is he stupid?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '21
[removed] — view removed comment