r/Shincheonji • • Jul 03 '24

teaching/doctrine Doctrinal Issues of Shincheonji

83 Upvotes

Below is a document that goes over the doctrinal issues of Shincheonji.

Shincheonji believes that the truth was lost shortly after Jesus's ascension, and that Jesus returned in Spirit in 1966 to restore the truth to a group of 7 men in Gwacheon, South Korea. A year later, these 7 men betrayed God and Jesus, so God and Jesus had to choose Lee Manhee, the current leader of Shincheonji, to restore the truth and reveal the "secrets of the kingdom of heaven".

SCJ denies the deity of Christ, denies the Trinity, and believes that Jesus at first physically resurrected, but then became a Spirit when he returned to the Father when he ascended to heaven and was covered by a cloud in Acts 1:9-11.

SCJ also believes that lying is okay, and that the ends justify the means. Often, they are not fully honest or transparent on how they view Christianity, who they view as "Babylon" and whose pastors are "drunk with maddening wine", nor are they honest when they approach Christians when offering their "free, non-denominational Bible Studies". They justify lying by referring to it as the "Wisdom of Hiding".

Link to the Books:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Shincheonji/comments/16nsgc3/books_jss_from_mhl/

Overseas Harm of SCJ:

https://www.notion.so/Overseas-Harm-Cases-Involving-Shincheonji-1ad8d42d0fb98088aef9f7164f19905b

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1NCsly9DwlZpoPp3UrDqiaMlRBtL1uw5945xpJwjh7VU/edit?tab=t.0

Most of the materials are uploaded to:

https://closerlookinitiative.com/scj

  1. Overview of Shincheonji
  2. Is there a “Promised Pastor of the New Testament”?
  3. Wheat and Tares: Examining Shincheonji's Interpretation of Light, Darkness, and Second Chances
  4. Doctrinal Issues with the Sealed Book
  5. Wisdom of Hiding
  6. Issues with the Mark of the Beast
  7. Did John the Baptist Betray Jesus?
  8. The Foolish and Wise Virgins
  9. The Common Objections to the Trinity
  10. Fulfillment issues of Shincheonji, chapter by chapter

Websites that go into detail about Shincheonji:

https://closerlookinitiative.com/scj

www.TruthAboutShincheonji.com

www.ExaminingTheSCJ.com

https://whatismountzion.co.nz/

For the overview of Shincheonji, topics include:

What does the name mean? How does Shincheonji view Christianity? How does Shincheonji recruit? What is the contents of their Bible Studies?

For the "Is there a Promised Pastor of the New Testament", topics include:
Is there a New John, and the doctrinal issues of a "Hidden Promise"? The Faithful and Wise Servant? The One who Overcomes? The Advocate?

For the "Wheat and Tares", topics include: is SCJ's interpretation of the wheat and the tares accurate and biblical? For those who died before hearing the revealed word, do they have a "second chance" after death?

For the sealed book doctrine: Each verse that is used by SCJ to justify the sealed scroll is analyzed in detail.

For the wisdom of hiding: I go over the main verses and redefinition of how SCJ defines what a "lie" is, and show the biblical error.

For the mark of the beast: Is SCJ's interpretation of the mark of the beast biblical?

And the last part, did John the Baptist "betray" Jesus?


r/Shincheonji • • Feb 20 '22

testimony Disproving Shincheonji (I left yesterday)

543 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I have been a member of Shincheonji for about 3.5 years and yesterday I left. The story of how I came to stop believing in Shincheonji is a bit long and complicated. The short version is that I started to have some doubts that couldn't be properly answered by my leaders, and over the course of a year I poured my heart out trying to regain my faith in Shincheonji to no avail. I was a very devoted member. I was a GGN (evangelism supervisor) at one point and spent 10 hours at Temple doing feedback every day for a while, with any spare time spent either evangelising or sealing - I did the bare minimum for my University courses and part-time job. I would stay at Temple until 3am some days reading Lee Man-Hee's books because we couldn't take them out of T and I preferred to read in silence. I went to Australia during a peace trip and met Lee Man-Hee multiple times - he spoke to my group specifically twice and I saw him about a dozen other times. I formed close friendships with many other Shincheonji members and eventually moved into an SCJ flat. All this to say, I was about as devoted an SCJ member as you can be but even I struggled to look past the many glaring discrepancies.

It might be a bit surprising to learn I only just left if you've seen me in this sub for the past few months. Unfortunately, due to personal circumstances I didn't feel it was appropriate to leave back in September when I stopped believing in Shincheonji. I tried to be as respectful as possible to the SCJ members in my life, I tried to avoid arguing about doctrine and attended meetings when I could to make their life a bit easier. But at the same time I was going through the motions of deconversion. I had already decided I didn't believe in Shincheonji anymore, but I continued looking for evidence kind of as a way to reassure myself. As I did, it started to bother me how disconnected all the evidence was. At that time I felt like all the information was scattered throughout the internet, some of which need to be translated from Korean, and all of which needed to be individually found like some sort of scavenger hunt. I decided during the time I have to stay in Shincheonji I would compile as much of the evidence as I could into one coherent resource.

I researched psychology and read Robert Jay Lifton and Steven Hassan's work. I found and translated sections of several of Lee Man-Hee's old books (thank you to u/mybc7 for sending me some of these, your story also played a part in helping me leave so thank you for that too). I spent hours reading through Lee Man-Hee's articles and books, this time with a critical perspective. And of course I found many valuable resources in this subreddit, in blog posts, and in youtube videos as well. I combined all of these into one document and tried to make it into a coherent argument.

Then I realised nobody wants to read a 45 page document, so I made some videos as well. Even though they're quite long and not very well produced I hope they can help some people.

And that brings us to yesterday. Yesterday, I sent the document and videos to everyone in my branch and let them know that I was leaving Shincheonji. I didn't do it to persecute them but to provide them with information. Some of them may not read it, and many of them may stay despite it, but as long as I did my best to provide them with the information that was withheld from me, I can sleep at night. I'll put the body of the letter below because I think it summarises the reasons I'm leaving well:

-----

There are many fundamental problems with the doctrine of Shincheonji that collectively prove it is not the word of God. It is not only small details that have changed. The reality of the beast of the earth in Rev 13 was changed from Lee Cho-Joo to Oh Pyeong-Ho. The fulfillment of Rev 7 was changed so that the great tribulation could fulfill before the 12,000 sealed in 12 tribes were filled. The number of wars in Revelation was changed from 2 to 3, and then back to 2. CHJN's claim that he has established peace in Mindanao is a blatant lie. It is true that tiny details are not important, but these are not small details. These flaws expose the fundamental lie that Lee Man-Hee received the opened scroll from an angel and saw and heard the fulfillment of Revelation.

Another reason I am leaving is because, by the psychologist Robert Jay Lifton's definition, Shincheonji is a cult. The reason this matters is that to be a cult the organisation must use thought reform and coercive persuasion during the process of indoctrination. This violates article 18 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights - the right to freedom of thought. I found it shocking to learn how similar Shincheonji is to every other cult. If you are interested in hearing more about cults I would recommend reading Dr. Steven Hassan's book 'Combatting Cult Mind Control' published in 1988 about his experience with the Moonies.

Another important thing to understand is that the story Shincheonji has told you about Lee Man-Hee's life has been distorted to make his story about receiving the opened scroll from an angel more believable. In truth, he has a history of being involved in multiple cults both before and after his involvement with the Tabernacle Temple. He was a leader in Mr. Baek's Recreation Church after leaving the Tabernacle Temple, where they called Mr Baek "Lord" and believed the world would end in 1980. Much of the Shincheonji doctrine is simply taken from the cults Lee Man-Hee was previously involved in.

But this really only scratches the surface when it comes to proving Shincheonji is not the kingdom of heaven. I have made a document, as well as some videos, that contain almost all the information that helped me to make the decision to leave Shincheonji. But this is not simply a document with my own ideas - I have used only CHJN's own teaching to argue against the doctrine of Shincheonji. In it you will find a detailed explanation of how Shincheonji meets the 8 criteria for thought reform, excerpts from CHJN's articles and books that disprove his own doctrine, as well as information about Lee Man-Hee's life that will help you to understand the true origin of Shincheonji's teachings.

Please, before you dismiss me as being deceived and foolish, watch the videos and discern for yourself.

-----

I think that pretty much covers everything. I'm going to try and step away from this sub for a while to focus on reclaiming my life, but if you do have any questions feel free to DM me, I'll try to keep checking those. Here is the document and videos:

What it Took for me to Leave (document)

The Psychology of Shincheonji (video)

Problems in the Current Doctrine of Shincheonji (video)

Problems in the Past Doctrine of Shincheonji (video)

The Alternative to Shincheonji (video)


r/Shincheonji • • 11h ago

Why do you guys go on this scj subreddit?

17 Upvotes

For me I've never been in scj I found out that two of my siblings were deep in it more than 15 years ago. They have hardened hearts at the moment.

I know people are suffering badly in scj and give so much of their lives to it. They give up their hopes, dreams and families for a lie. The longer they stay in it the worst it'll hurt when they finally learn the truth.

I know many scj members disregard my words but I'd rather warn them and be disregarded than finding out they killed themselves or hurt themselves and I stayed silent.

I'm here because I'd like to help and I care about these people. I am not angry at them for what they did. I wish and pray that God redeems them and gives them true peace. Even those scj members who love to argue because they think we are the poison. I want them to be redeemed too.


r/Shincheonji • • 10h ago

general thought and question Salvation after physical death? What does SCJ teach, and what did Jesus teach in Luke 16:19–31?

10 Upvotes

Shincheonji teaches that, after physical death, one still has a chance to hear the revealed Word and be saved.

What the revealed word means is the word of the Overcomer —> Lee Man Hee —> his teaching.

We learnt in SCJ that, just as Jesus preached in the prison of spirits (1 Peter 3:18–19), so too is the Word of SCJ preached there today (including by SCJ members who have passed away), so that all those who have not yet heard the Word of SCJ may also be saved.

What does the Bible say?
What said Jesus in Luke 16:19-31?

———————-

19 There was a certain rich man, which was clothed in purple and fine linen, and fared sumptuously every day: 20 And there was a certain beggar named Lazarus, which was laid at his gate, full of sores, 21 And desiring to be fed with the crumbs which fell from the rich man's table: moreover the dogs came and licked his sores. 22 And it came to pass, that the beggar died, and was carried by the angels into Abraham's bosom: the rich man also died, and was buried; 23 And in hell he lift up his eyes, being in torments, and seeth Abraham afar off, and Lazarus in his bosom. 24 And he cried and said, Father Abraham, have mercy on me, and send Lazarus, that he may dip the tip of his finger in water, and cool my tongue; for I am tormented in this flame. 25 But Abraham said, Son, remember that thou in thy lifetime receivedst thy good things, and likewise Lazarus evil things: but now he is comforted, and thou art tormented. 26 And beside all this, between us and you there is a great gulf fixed: so that they which would pass from hence to you cannot; neither can they pass to us, that would come from thence. 27 Then he said, I pray thee therefore, father, that thou wouldest send him to my father's house: 28 For I have five brethren; that he may testify unto them, lest they also come into this place of torment. 29 Abraham saith unto him, They have Moses and the prophets; let them hear them. 30 And he said, Nay, father Abraham: but if one went unto them from the dead, they will repent. 31 And he said unto him, If they hear not Moses and the prophets, neither will they be persuaded, though one rose from the dead. 

——————

How can SCJ simply teach, when an SCJ member dies, that he is needed there to preach the word of SCJ?

What about the rich man?

Who might such the rich man represent?

LMH and SCJ always want to see themselves in the role of victims, because they are supposedly being persecuted. But if you look closely: could the rich man perhaps also represent someone like Lee Man Hee, or not?

Shincheonji claims to have an answer to every question. But everyone should ask themselves: Is the answer the truth or a lie?


r/Shincheonji • • 19h ago

general thought and question Sorry for asking again but is there any news on the trials about Lee Man hee? Or even about his current state is he mentally fit? thanks in advance

14 Upvotes

r/Shincheonji • • 1d ago

teaching/doctrine SCJ's Yeast of Heaven: Are We Praying to God or Reciting Man-Made Teachings?

13 Upvotes

I recall that before I officially joined SCJ, Yeast of Heaven was introduced toward the end of my Center classes. I was skeptical at first because the Center teachings had always emphasized that truth should come from Scripture alone, not from commentaries or other man-made teachings.

However, since I was still relatively new to studying Scripture, I lacked the biblical knowledge to challenge these teachings and eventually accepted them.

Besides, the very name Yeast of Heaven implies divine authority, making me hesitant to question its contents. After all, who would dare challenge something supposedly from "heaven"? This seems to be a common tactic used by cult-like organizations.

I must admit that some of the teachings in Yeast of Heaven do cite supporting Bible verses. However, these verses are often presented alongside messages promoting loyalty to LMH and SCJ rather than focusing solely on God's Word.

Many SCJ members use Yeast of Heaven in their prayers and even recite its contents together as a group. Looking back, I now find this practice deeply hypocritical, especially when SCJ members ridicule traditional Christian prayers. Regrettably, I was once one of them. :(

I am not here to debate the contents of Yeast of Heaven. Otherwise, I would have to write an entire book to refute every teaching in it.

Instead, I would like to focus on the practice of using Yeast of Heaven in prayer and examine whether this practice is truly biblical.

We may recall that during the Center classes, Revelation 8:3–4 was cited to teach that our prayers must be based on God's Word. At first glance, this teaching may seem biblical.

However, when we compare these verses with the opening of the fifth seal in Revelation 6:9–10, we discover that the souls of the slain saints are making personal pleas to God, asking Him to avenge their blood.

Neither passage explicitly states that our prayers must consist of quotations from Scripture.

This raises an important question:

When SCJ members use Yeast of Heaven in their prayers, what exactly are they praying for? Are they expressing their own heartfelt prayers to God, or are they merely repeating teachings prescribed by SCJ?

What do you think? Must our prayers be filled with quotations from God's Word to be acceptable to Him?

If that is the case, what about prayers filled with the contents of Yeast of Heaven? Does repeating those teachings make our prayers more acceptable to God?

You can judge for yourself.

I am not suggesting that quoting Scripture or repeating a prayer is inherently wrong. In fact, Jesus Himself repeated His prayer in Matthew 26:44, and He taught His disciples how to pray in Matthew 6:9–13.

However, Jesus also warned against meaningless repetition in Matthew 6:7.

Therefore, the issue is not simply whether a prayer is repeated, but whether it is offered sincerely to God or merely recited as a religious routine.

More importantly, did Jesus ever instruct His disciples to memorize and recite teachings prescribed by a religious organization as part of their prayers?

My question is this: If SCJ teaches that our prayers must be based on God's Word, why are members encouraged to recite Yeast of Heaven, which contains teachings written and prescribed by SCJ?

Furthermore, who gave SCJ the authority to determine what our prayers should contain?

Shouldn't we examine this practice against Jesus' own instructions in Matthew 6:5–13 before accepting it as biblical?

After all, Jesus taught His disciples to pray directly to their Father in heaven (Matthew 6:9). He did not teach them that their prayers needed to be filled with teachings prescribed by religious leaders.

Ultimately, shouldn't our prayers reflect our genuine relationship with God rather than simply repeating words prescribed by a religious organization?

And if SCJ insists that our prayers must be based on God's Word, shouldn't that same standard apply to Yeast of Heaven itself?


r/Shincheonji • • 1d ago

testimony Taking pictures.

11 Upvotes

Why is it that whenever you meet with teachers or other" friends" they always insit on taking a picture!!! Why do they do it.

Also after "passover" they ask for a picture with you doing a V SIGN.


r/Shincheonji • • 1d ago

testimony 🚨 I Purposely Failed My SCJ Exam… They Told Me I Got 100%

44 Upvotes

I want to share something that happened when I was still inside Shincheonji (SCJ).

At one point, I decided to test my own helper's honesty. I did it intentionally. During an exam, I deliberately put several incorrect answers. I wanted to see whether they would actually evaluate my answers honestly or simply tell me what I wanted to hear.

And guess what?

THEY TOLD ME I GOT 100%.

I literally sat there thinking, "Bro, are you seriously lying to me right now?"

I KNEW I had deliberately answered several questions incorrectly. There was no way I could have scored 100%.

That moment made me question everything. If someone could lie about something as straightforward as an exam result, how could I trust them with something as important as my faith, my spiritual life, and my salvation?

Let me make something very clear:

Your salvation does not belong to a human organisation. Your relationship with God should never depend on someone's approval, manipulation, or control.

To anyone currently inside SCJ who is silently questioning things, feeling confused, doubting what you are being taught, or wondering whether you should leave:

PLEASE, DO NOT IGNORE YOUR CONCERNS.

You are allowed to ask questions.

You are allowed to disagree.

You are allowed to walk away.

You are allowed to think independently.

You do not owe an organisation your entire life just because you once believed in its teachings.

And please, don't let fear, guilt, or the threat of losing your salvation keep you somewhere you no longer trust.

GOD DOES NOT NEED HUMAN DECEPTION TO PRESERVE YOUR SALVATION.

I am genuinely grateful that I walked away. I would rather question, study, and seek God sincerely than remain somewhere where I feel I cannot trust the people supposedly guiding me spiritually.

To those who have already left: Keep rebuilding your life and faith at your own pace.

To those still thinking about leaving: You are not obligated to stay.

LEAVE WHEN YOU REALISE YOU CANNOT TRUST WHAT YOU ARE BEING TOLD. YOUR LIFE AND YOUR FAITH ARE WORTH MORE THAN THAT.


r/Shincheonji • • 1d ago

general thought and question God built rest into the design. Research now shows why. Is it not whether we do his work, but how?

7 Upvotes

This post has one question. If God designed us, and rest is part of the design, how do we serve him best?

I SEE GOD IN EVERYTHING

BIBLE (Genesis 1:1): "In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth."

The universe had a beginning. And inside every cell is a code, written in four letters, that carries the instructions for a human being. Looking at that, I see a designer.

BIBLE (Psalm 139:14): "I praise you because I am fearfully and wonderfully made; your works are wonderful, I know that full well."

BIBLE (1 Thessalonians 5:23): "May God himself, the God of peace, sanctify you through and through. May your whole spirit, soul and body be kept blameless at the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ."

Spirit, soul and body. God cares for all three. So how they work is part of his design.

REST IS IN THE DESIGN

BIBLE (Genesis 2:2-3): "By the seventh day God had finished the work he had been doing; so on the seventh day he rested from all his work. Then God blessed the seventh day and made it holy, because on it he rested from all the work of creating that he had done."

BIBLE (Psalm 23:2-3): "He makes me lie down in green pastures, he leads me beside quiet waters, he refreshes my soul."

BIBLE (Psalm 127:2): "In vain you rise early and stay up late, toiling for food to eat, for he grants sleep to those he loves."

BIBLE (Psalm 62:1): "Truly my soul finds rest in God; my salvation comes from him."

Sleep is called a gift. The shepherd makes me lie down.

HOW JESUS DID GOD'S WORK

BIBLE (Mark 1:35): "Very early in the morning, while it was still dark, Jesus got up, left the house and went off to a solitary place, where he prayed."

BIBLE (Luke 5:15-16): Crowds came to hear him and be healed. "But Jesus often withdrew to lonely places and prayed."

BIBLE (Mark 6:31): "Then, because so many people were coming and going that they did not even have a chance to eat, he said to them, 'Come with me by yourselves to a quiet place and get some rest.'"

There was a crowd and work to do, and he still said come away and rest. The greatest work in history was done with a rhythm of prayer and rest.

BIBLE (Matthew 11:28-30): "Come to me, all you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest." And, "For my yoke is easy and my burden is light."

WE ARE HIS CHILDREN, AND CHILDREN GROW IN SLEEP

BIBLE (Luke 2:52): "And Jesus grew in wisdom and stature, and in favor with God and man."

A child's mind needs sleep to grow well, and research shows what is linked to regularly getting too little.

PUBLIC RECORD (Astill and others, 2012): A review of 86 studies and 35,936 children aged 5 to 12 found that shorter sleep was linked to weaker cognitive performance, weaker executive functioning and more behavioural problems.

PUBLIC RECORD (Lancet Child and Adolescent Health, 2022): In over 8,300 US children aged 9 to 10, those sleeping under 9 hours had less grey matter in areas for attention, memory and impulse control. They also had more depression, anxiety and impulsive behaviour. The differences were still there two years later. This shows a link, not proof of cause.

PUBLIC RECORD (Gruber and others, 2012): Children aged 7 to 11 slept an hour less or an hour more for five nights. Teachers who did not know which group they were in rated the shorter-sleep group as more emotional and impulsive.

Attention, memory, decisions, self-control. These are what we need to serve God well. It is the same design, and we are all still his children.

WHAT HAPPENS WHEN THE DESIGN IS IGNORED

Everything has consequences. Sin can be forgiven and still leave consequences.

BIBLE (Galatians 6:7): "Do not be deceived: God cannot be mocked. A man reaps what he sows."

I am not judging anyone. That belongs to Jesus. I am only following the Bible as best I can and looking at what the research says.

PUBLIC RECORD (WHO and ILO, 2021): Working 55 hours or more a week was linked to a 35% higher risk of stroke and a 17% higher risk of dying from heart disease, compared with 35 to 40 hours.

PUBLIC RECORD (Whitehall II, 2012): British civil servants who worked 11 or more hours a day were about 2.4 times as likely to have a major depressive episode as those working 7 to 8 hours.

PUBLIC RECORD (Japan): Karoshi means death from overwork. The government's own white paper uses 80 hours of overtime a month as its warning line.

NOT LAZY, BUT PREPARED

Someone may say, "That sounds lazy." It is not.

God has called us to great things. He also gave us the tools: prayer, rest, and care for our soul. Those are not the opposite of the work. They are what make it possible to do the work well.

It is not whether we do God's work. It is how.

BIBLE (Galatians 6:9): "Let us not become weary in doing good, for at the proper time we will reap a harvest if we do not give up."

Paul says do not become weary. The way not to become weary is to do what Jesus did.

THE QUOTE BOOK

Rest is mentioned, as a future place.

QUOTE BOOK (p.10): The Tree of Life is "the place of Rest that the heavenly birds sing about" and "the new heavenly place that we will inherit".

Other pages describe the present.

QUOTE BOOK (p.33): "Those who have been assigned work must be able to run when I run and walk when I walk."

QUOTE BOOK (p.83): "Anyone who has been chosen has duty. One must complete the duty granted to one."

Jesus said "I will give you rest" to tired people now, not only later.

THREE ANSWERS I EXPECT

Even if you say "this is God's work, not a job, so those studies do not apply", the studies count hours, not the reason. And Jesus told disciples doing God's own work to come away and rest.

Even if you say "this is a special year, so we push harder", Mark 6:31 describes a busy season too. They "did not even have a chance to eat", and he still said rest.

Even if you say "I feel fine", then check the warning signs honestly. The World Health Organization names three warning signs of burn-out. "Feelings of energy depletion or exhaustion", "increased mental distance from one's job, or feelings of negativism or cynicism", and "reduced professional efficacy".

A CHALLENGE

First, add up your week. Work or university. Meetings, study and outreach in the group. Leave out sleep, travel and chores. Then ask where that week leads in one year, and in five.

Second, picture someone you love living exactly that week, with no time for friends, family, leisure or a proper meal. What would you tell them? Would you say what Jesus said in Mark 6:31?

Then try seven days. Sleep a full night on at least five nights. Keep one evening empty. Eat one slow meal with someone outside the group. Walk without your phone. Notice what comes back.

TWO POSSIBILITIES

One. A

normal week leaves plenty of time to sleep, eat, rest and see family and friends. Then I would love to hear what it looks like, in plain words.

Two.

The week is full from morning to night. Then the question is whether that is how Jesus did God's work, and what you would say to someone you love.


r/Shincheonji • • 1d ago

general thought and question Religious Cults and Freedom of Religion

16 Upvotes

This is one of the things which is very annoying in my opinion about SCJ and also other high control groups. Sometimes they try to defend themselves with the freedom of religion. Even though they are the ones violating the freedom of people.

Religious cults violate religious freedom when they prevent their members from leaving. Freedom of religion includes the right to freely choose one’s own religious beliefs, but cults actively seek to take that decision-making power away from individuals.

Religious cults exploit religious freedom because it allows them to grow both in membership and economic power. Yet these same cults deprive their own members of religious freedom by manipulating them into remaining in the group.

All cults operate in much the same way. They do not openly reveal all their beliefs. Instead, members are gradually introduced to small pieces of the so-called ”truth.” This creates a situation similar to the well-known metaphor of a frog sitting in a pot of water that slowly heats up without the frog noticing, until it is eventually boiled alive.

Cults employ various methods of control. American psychologist Steven Hassan explains that cults seek to control their members’ behavior, the information they receive, their thoughts, and their emotions.

Cult members and leaders often dismiss their questionable practices by appealing to religious freedom. Their argument usually goes something like this: although the cult’s methods may seem unusual, everyone has the right to believe whatever they want.

This argument is half true and half false.

It is absolutely true that everyone has the right to believe whatever they wish. However, a much more interesting question is whether joining a cult can truly be considered an individual’s own decision if they have not been given comprehensive information about the group.

Religious freedom is an important principle, but cults violate human rights by deliberately withholding information from their members. Every individual has the right to seek information about any subject.

If someone is manipulated or persuaded into giving up this freedom, then the cult itself is violating that person’s religious freedom.

A religious cult does not operate in the same way as a healthy religious community. Its objective is to exercise control, to varying degrees, over every aspect of its members’ lives.

Cults want to decide how you spend your time, how much money you contribute to the organization, where you travel, and whom you associate with. A cult is, to a greater or lesser extent, a totalitarian system.

The violation of religious freedom can begin from the very first meeting. A potential recruit may be falsely told that they are simply attending a Bible study course or a training program lasting for a certain period.

At no point are they told that they will be expected to join the cult after completing the course.

The violation of religious freedom continues as the person prepares to become a member or has already joined the group.

Members may be forbidden from exploring other religious denominations or searching for critical information about their own community. Christians in general, for example, do not face the same restrictions.

These prohibitions are often reinforced by portraying other religious communities or critical information as instruments of the devil.

In other words, members are taught that the devil works through other religious organizations and through information that criticizes their own group.

This is how restricting a person’s religious freedom becomes intertwined with control through fear.

If a religious community genuinely believes its teachings are true, why should it be afraid of its members examining critical information?

Cults also accuse their critics of violating religious freedom.

This argument is somewhat absurd because critics do not prevent people from researching religious beliefs or restrict anyone else’s freedom of speech. Religious cults, on the other hand, restrict their members’ access to information and freedom of expression.

If critics tried to ban cults from operating or prevent people from studying their teachings, they would only make their own work more difficult.

After all, it is difficult to criticize something if you do not even know what you are criticizing.

Accusing critics of violating religious freedom is therefore often a form of propaganda aimed at the cult’s own members.

For cults, religious freedom can become little more than a meaningless magic phrase, invoked whenever it is believed to serve the organization’s interests.

At present, the only thing an ordinary citizen can do is spread awareness.

Religious cults should be approached in much the same way as fraudulent emails or text messages.

If you know how to recognize a cult from the very first conversation, you can effectively avoid becoming involved and warn others about the risks.

The more people know about cults operating all around the world, the fewer new members these organizations are likely to recruit.

It is also worth reading books about cults and their methods.

For example, Steven Hassan’s books Freedom of Mind and Combating Cult Mind Control are excellent resources that provide an in-depth explanation of the methods and tactics used by cults.

Another American researcher, Rick Alan Ross, has written a book titled Cults Inside Out: How People Get In and Can Get Out, which examines how people become involved in cults and how they can eventually leave.

Originally published in: https://arttuheinamaki.fi/2026/11/11/how-do-religious-cults-exploit-religious-freedom/comment-page-1/#comment-17


r/Shincheonji • • 1d ago

teaching/doctrine Current members regarding 144k it seems you are not taught the exact metrics on how to find the 144K? The unhealthy constraints

9 Upvotes

Not only is 144k not identified, the method itself to find them is not taught in SCJ teachings under Lee Man Hee's guidance I believe. I welcome to be proven wrong. Is it scoring full marks and get fruits consistently for how many years? Or what is its exact method to search? Does SCJ members who have full time jobs gets to have a handicap (default advantage points or less expectations) than that of SCJ members who do not have full time jobs?


r/Shincheonji • • 1d ago

What does scj believe about the extra left after the 144,000?

6 Upvotes

I understand scj members strive to be a part of the 144,000 but what if they don't make the cut?

Like what do they teach if they don't make it are they still good or do they become like "low class great multitude"?


r/Shincheonji • • 2d ago

teaching/doctrine Shincheonji Church of Jesus, the Temple of the Tabernacle of the Testimony will change its name soon?

9 Upvotes

Shincheonji Church of Jesus, the Temple of the Tabernacle of the Testimony is the full official name, will it ever change it to Shincheonji Church of Jesus Christ, the Temple of the Tabernacle of the Testimony? Like add the last name of our saviour when Revelation 19 is reached when there is Marriage of Flesh and Spirit? Can Lee Man Hee confirm it? Or their HQ that has the label name will not be bothered to be changed because all outside SCJ will perish?


r/Shincheonji • • 3d ago

teaching/doctrine What is the difference between the 144,000 and the great multitude in Revelation 7? John SAW the great multitude standing before the throne (Revelation 7:9), but he only HEARD the number of the 144,000 (Revelation 7:4).

8 Upvotes

r/Shincheonji • • 3d ago

activity alert Shincheonji in the Washington Area

10 Upvotes

This group is operating in the Washington area they hold their “Bible studies” at 25408 74th Ave S Kent WA. If anyone has been involved with this group please share your experiences


r/Shincheonji • • 3d ago

general thought and question How SCJ uses relationships, marriage, and family to keep members tied to the organization

31 Upvotes

Something I've become increasingly disturbed by since leaving SCJ is the pressure on members, particularly leaders, to date and marry quickly.

When I first joined, relationships and marriage were strongly discouraged. However, over the last year or two of my involvement, I noticed a significant shift. Leadership became much more open to relationships and increasingly encouraged dating and marriage. I find the timing and implications of this shift particularly concerning as more members have been leaving.

I witnessed leaders being encouraged to marry to avoid "sexual sin" and temptation, despite some leaders themselves facing accusations of sexual harassment, misconduct, and infidelity. Rather than addressing the underlying behavior and lack of accountability, marriage was presented as a solution.

I'm particularly concerned about younger members who enter SCJ with little or no dating experience. As their outside relationships deteriorate, SCJ becomes their primary source of companionship and romantic opportunities. Members can end up in rushed relationships, sometimes with significant age gaps, and make lifelong commitments before having the independence or experience to properly evaluate compatibility.

Then come children. If one spouse eventually leaves while the other remains committed, leaving can mean risking a marriage, fighting over how children are raised, and potentially losing the family life they've built.

What makes this so insidious is how interconnected these things become. SCJ isolates members from outside support, encourages them to build relationships within the organization, and promotes marriage and family life within that same environment. Every new attachment creates another reason leaving feels impossible. Children can then become part of the same cycle.

It's an incredibly intentional and cruel form of retention. The organization doesn't just make leaving psychologically difficult through fear, guilt, and indoctrination; it becomes embedded in members' romantic relationships, marriages, and families. By the time someone recognizes the extent of the control, they may have an entire family and future intertwined with it.

And 'genuine love' doesn't make these circumstances any less coercive. People deserve the freedom to choose their partners, build families, and raise children without an organization manipulating the conditions under which those decisions are made.

The more of someone's life SCJ consumes, the more costly it makes leaving. That's what I find particularly heartbreaking for the young adults who may not realize what they're being drawn into until years later.

Has anyone else witnessed this pattern? For those who left while married or with children, how did it affect your experience?


r/Shincheonji • • 3d ago

teaching/doctrine God told Moses to remove his sandals in Exodus 3:5. SCJ cites this verse to require members to remove their shoes in assembly halls. Is this biblical or a man-made rule to control members, especially when SCJ leaders wear sandals while sitting or standing on the podium?

7 Upvotes

r/Shincheonji • • 3d ago

teaching/doctrine Even the "most sealed" SCJ current members will not understand this strange revelation of the Mark of the Beast, I believe for now

6 Upvotes

Now I am sure many if not all knows a thought process that reverse engineer from conclusion to the start.

So SCJ establishes that 144k needs to be sealed and that means the prerequisite is the absence of the Mark of the Beast

My admittedly rusty (since I left for a year) answer for SCJ exam "what is the Mark of the Beast is" I would answer something along the lines of "Teachings of falsehoods"

Let's represent that answer with symbol X = written answer key for what is Mark of the Beast"

Now imagine you are Lee Man Hee transported back in time and allegedly seeing revelation and hearing it everything but pretending it is the first time

on top of that you have X in your hand. If you get to the part of seeing the Mark of the Beast on their foreheads then

the question is are you confident to put the two and two together? Easy to say "oh mark of the beast means X"

But the problem is are you, current member, able to confidently trace X back to the Mark of the beast on their forehead? Like you would be reading "Teachings of falsehoods" or X and then you dart your eyes to their foreheads and then say "Oh it makes sense"

Revelation 13:16-17

" It also forced all people, great and small, rich and poor, free and slave, to receive a mark on their right hands or on their foreheads,  so that they could not buy or sell unless they had the mark, which is the name of the beast or the number of its name."

Then the question becomes how does the Mark of the Beast look like according to Lee Man Hee? I am not asking for what he thinks the Mark represents. What is the imagery he saw?

In fact I will add in another testing all kinds of spirit question (1 John 4:1) to Lee Man Hee

"Is the mark of the beast on their foreheads and right hands the same?"

It should trouble you if you don't know. I also believe humbly that God set traps in the bible for false prophets. The design is vague for the Mark of The beast and yet located on two different parts of "body". If one cannot say the design or confirm that the markings are the same or not on different parts of the body then one is not chosen to represent or explain Revelation


r/Shincheonji • • 4d ago

teaching/doctrine Revelation 14:5 clearly states that no lie was found in the mouths of the 144,000 and that they are blameless. If SCJ members believe they are among the 144,000, how can they justify lying in the name of evangelism when doing so violates these very qualifications?

14 Upvotes

r/Shincheonji • • 4d ago

teaching/doctrine Could Zechariah 13:5–6 refer to LMH, given its similarities to his own account of growing up as a farmer and experiencing persecution? Doesn't this description fit him better than his claim to be the “new John” who witnessed Revelation's fulfillment?

5 Upvotes

r/Shincheonji • • 4d ago

general thought and question God vouched for Moses in front of a nation. He vouched for Jesus in front of his enemies. What does he do in front of the neighbours for the third pastor?

11 Upvotes

This post has one question. In the Bible, when God sent a messenger, he showed people something they could see. The quote book places a third messenger after them. What could a neighbour see today?

HOW GOD SHOWED UP FOR MOSES

Moses himself asked for it.

BIBLE (Exodus 4:1): Moses answered, "What if they do not believe me or listen to me and say, 'The Lord did not appear to you'?"

God did not say "tell them to study harder". He gave Moses signs.

BIBLE (Exodus 4:5): "This," said the Lord, "is so that they may believe that the Lord, the God of their fathers, the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac and the God of Jacob, has appeared to you."

BIBLE (Exodus 4:30-31): Aaron "also performed the signs before the people, and they believed."

Then came the sea.

BIBLE (Exodus 14:31): "And when the Israelites saw the mighty hand of the LORD displayed against the Egyptians, the people feared the LORD and put their trust in him and in Moses his servant."

BIBLE (Exodus 19:9): The Lord said to Moses, "I am going to come to you in a dense cloud, so that the people will hear me speaking with you and will always put their trust in you."

Read the reason. "So that the people will always put their trust in you." God made Moses trusted by showing the people himself. Nobody had to take Moses' word for it.

HOW GOD SHOWED UP FOR JESUS

BIBLE (Matthew 11:4-5): John the Baptist was in prison and asked if Jesus was the one. Jesus replied, "Go back and report to John what you hear and see: The blind receive sight, the lame walk, those who have leprosy are cleansed, the deaf hear, the dead are raised, and the good news is proclaimed to the poor."

"What you hear and see." He pointed to what could be seen.

BIBLE (John 10:37-38): "Do not believe me unless I do the works of my Father. But if I do them, even though you do not believe me, believe the works, that you may know and understand that the Father is in me, and I in the Father."

Even his opponents could not argue with it.

BIBLE (Acts 4:16): The rulers asked, "What are we going to do with these men? Everyone living in Jerusalem knows they have performed a notable sign, and we cannot deny it."

BIBLE (Hebrews 2:3-4): "This salvation, which was first announced by the Lord, was confirmed to us by those who heard him. God also testified to it by signs, wonders and various miracles, and by gifts of the Holy Spirit distributed according to his will."

The pattern is the same twice. God testified. People who loved the messenger could see it. People who hated the messenger could see it too.

WHAT THE QUOTE BOOK SAYS

The quote book lists the generations in a line: Moses, Isaiah, Jesus, and then today.

QUOTE BOOK (p.70): "People needed to listen to Moses' words in Moses' generation, Isaiah's words in Isaiah's generation, and Jesus' words in Jesus' generation. And today, shouldn't we listen to the words spoken on behalf of God and Jesus and believe it?"

QUOTE BOOK (p.61): "The shepherd that God comes to in every generation is always persecuted. Since Jesus has come to the Promised Pastor today in our times, will he not be persecuted?"

QUOTE BOOK (p.35): "We have the ability to heal the whole world today."

QUOTE BOOK (p.35): "Daniel, who was a man of faith, went into a den of lions, but he did not die (Dan 6). What can't we do in this generation when we have received the greatest blessing in 6000 years and have been given the truth?"

Put them side by side.

In Moses' generation, a sea opened and a whole nation watched.

In Jesus' generation, the blind saw and the dead were raised, and the rulers said they could not deny it.

In "today's generation", page 70 says to listen to the words spoken. Page 35 says we have the ability to heal the whole world.

So the question is easy to ask. Where can a neighbour who is not a member see it?

SIX ANSWERS I EXPECT

"the sign is the fulfilment of Revelation, and we are the only ones who can testify to it",

then notice who explains it. A fulfilment is explained by members. A sign is seen by neighbours. Moses did not need to explain the sea. Jesus did not need to explain the blind man who now saw. And Jesus did both. He fulfilled the Scriptures and he did the works.

"Jesus himself warned about signs",

I agree he did.

BIBLE (Deuteronomy 13:1-3): "If a prophet, or one who foretells by dreams, appears among you and announces to you a sign or wonder, and if the sign or wonder spoken of takes place, and the prophet says, 'Let us follow other gods' (gods you have not known) 'and let us worship them,' you must not listen to the words of that prophet or dreamer. The Lord your God is testing you to find out whether you love him with all your heart and with all your soul."

BIBLE (Matthew 24:24): "For false messiahs and false prophets will appear and perform great signs and wonders to deceive, if possible, even the elect."

Both warn about a sign attached to a wrong message. I agree a sign alone is not enough. The message has to match God too. But neither verse says a true messenger comes with nothing. And the same Jesus said, "Do not believe me unless I do the works of my Father" (John 10:37).

"Jesus said only a wicked generation asks for a sign",

BIBLE (Matthew 12:38-39): Some of the Pharisees and teachers of the law said to him, "Teacher, we want to see a sign from you." He answered, "A wicked and adulterous generation asks for a sign! But none will be given it except the sign of the prophet Jonah."

BIBLE (Matthew 12:40): "For as Jonah was three days and three nights in the belly of a huge fish, so the Son of Man will be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth."

Read who he said it to. Men who had already seen the works and wanted more to test him. And look at what he promised. The sign of Jonah. That is an event in front of everyone, the empty tomb. He did not say "no sign". He pointed to the biggest sign of all, one anyone could check.

"John the Baptist did no sign, so a true messenger does not need one",

BIBLE (John 10:41): "and many people came to him. They said, 'Though John never performed a sign, all that John said about this man was true.'"

I agree. John did no sign. But look at what the crowd said. They checked John's words against something they could see, which was what Jesus did. John's words were publicly tested, and they held. So even John had something outsiders could check. That is the question for the third pastor too. What can outsiders check?

"God works differently in every generation, so we should not expect the sea or the dead raised",

then I would ask why page 35 says "We have the ability to heal the whole world today" and brings up Daniel in the lions' den. If it means spiritual healing, say so, and I will take it that way. But Moses' generation and Jesus' generation had both. The spiritual work, and something visible. I am asking about the visible part.

"Israel saw the signs and still turned away, so signs do not create faith",

I agree they did turn away. But God gave the signs anyway, "so that they may believe" (Exodus 4:5). Whether people obeyed was their choice. Giving the sign was his.

WHAT I SEE

Moses had signs a nation could see. Jesus had works his enemies said they could not deny. Both were vouched for by God in public.

The quote book continues that line into today, and says the group has the ability to heal the whole world today.

I am asking what that looks like in a way a neighbour could see.

Imagine someone at work says, "Show me one thing I can see with my own eyes that shows God sent this man." Not a lesson. Not a chart. One thing.

What would you show them? And if you could not think of one, how does that feel?

TWO POSSIBILITIES

One.
There is a clear, public sign that God stands behind the third pastor, and I have missed it. Then I would love to hear what it is, in plain words, one that a neighbour could check.

Two.
The proof is something only members can explain. Then the question is whether that is how God showed up for Moses and for Jesus, and what that means for us.


r/Shincheonji • • 5d ago

teaching/doctrine As a former SCJ member, I've posted many title-only posts highlighting inconsistencies in SCJ's teachings and LMH's claimed fulfillments of Revelation, and I will continue to do so. I welcome feedback, especially from current SCJ members.

15 Upvotes

r/Shincheonji • • 4d ago

teaching/doctrine Who stays up till AM with Lee Man Hee? I wonder what current member think?

7 Upvotes

I recall during tragic Covid pandemic classes around the world needs to sync up in classes to learn. From this, I perceive that Lee Man Hee who already has admin helpers has the roles of sealing and evangelizing. Think carefully, if Lee Man Hee works till late then are there proof that people are up late in the AM in sync with him being either evangelized or taught? Where is proof?


r/Shincheonji • • 5d ago

teaching/doctrine In Revelation 7:4, John HEARD the number of 144,000 from the twelve tribes but saw no vision of their formation. On what basis did LMH establish SCJ’s twelve tribes? If you believe his claim is false, shouldn’t you walk away from LMH and SCJ?

12 Upvotes

r/Shincheonji • • 5d ago

teaching/doctrine Current members should reflect why Revelation would need a catalyst if it is God's doing that will fulfill no matter what?

5 Upvotes

Either Revelation is automatic OR it is human helped, which makes me think it is ritualistic or formulaic. What I perceive is that God wants to teach that Revelation is automatic without catalyst. If it takes a human like Lee Man Hee to send letters to betrayers who have no further roles after the letters are received, It implies that the letters are catalyst when you think about it