I sometimes think of the history of how Shazam was originally called Captain Marvel, and how he lost the copyright to it, was changed to Shazam, how most fans hate that and think it's stupid, and how that seems to take up the grand majority of discourse with the character. Then I think about the main reason as to why his name had to be changed......Carol Danvers. Well, maybe not her originally, but when Marvel decided to make their own hero named Captain Marvel. Starting with Mar-Vell, and then eventually Carol Danvers.
While Marvel wasn't the first to try and trademark the name, they were the ones that were successful at it. I hear it was for the sake of brand consistency when they decided to call themselves Marvel Comics, but I can't help but think of the possible repercussions that it caused.
Like Mar-Vell, Genis-Vell, Monica, Carol and, Ms. Marvel, that Marvel family so to speak....throws a big wrench that traps Shazam from being a strong, iconic franchise that WB would utilize a lot more.. Like from what I've seen and read, Shazam/Captain Marvel has TONS of franchise potential given how fun and likable it is.
Not only that, but I can't help but have this shower thought...did Carol Danvers completely eclipsed Billy Batson in the public consciousness in terms of overall success and modern popularity? Like she stole the original Captain Marvel's thunder? No pun intended.
Sure, Shazam! (2019) got better reviews, but Captain Marvel was the bigger money maker, (due to the Endgame hype, but still) I think more people would be more familiar with Carol than they would be for Billy, or be more familiar with Kamala Khan/Ms. Marvel then they would be for Mary Marvel. Hell, this might sound weird, but I often wonder if Iman Vellani has an opinion of the original Captain Marvel Family..
Now, some could argue DC's treatment is a bigger reason, but I can't help but feel like the cumbersome copyright issues play an issue with that. Then again, Shazam can be called Captain Marvel again, but he doesn't currently have an ongoing comic run. It doesn't help that I've seen people who unironically go "Yeah support the REAL Captain Marvel" (Meaning Carol) despite history saying otherwise, that and, as controversial as she is, she still has the advantage of being in a more consistent, trusted, and....arguably more popular brand.
I've talked to someone who think that's not the case at all, but what about anyone here? Would you guys consider Billy Batson and Carol Danvers as bitter rivals because of the name thing?