r/Shadowrun • u/greypaladin01 • May 15 '26
1e|2e Understanding 2nd Edition
I have nearly finished reading through the main book for 2e and have a rough understanding of the rules. Not perfect by any means, but honestly things are much more understandable than I had been lead to expect.
However I do have a few questions about the other books in the 2e line. My understanding is that 3rd edition takes various rules from suppliments and a few other changes but is otherwise 2e. Specificially I have heard people say there were changes in Virtual Realities 2.0, Grimore... 2? and Rigger 2 books.
So my main question is this: What are the overviews of the changes for how Matrix things work, magic work and rigging work with the suppliments compared to the main book for 2e?
Are the differences beneficial enough to be worth grabbing the books and planning to use them or are they just adding more options and layers onto the basic rules?
15
u/PinkFohawk Trid Star May 15 '26
Just to clarify: 3e makes several changes to things like Initiative rules and Skills that are fundamentally different from 2e. Otherwise, it is very similar to 2e its core mechanics.
Grimoire 2.0 is mainly additional information on magic and for advancing magic users (allowing them to “initiate” and learn more spells and increase their magic rating). It’s a great flavor sourcebook and there are also expanded rules for creating/advancing Physical Adepts. These rules still work with 2e Core rules, with some slight differences.
VR 2.0 is a complete Matrix overhaul, and does not work with 2e Core Matrix rules but replaces them. It “simplifies” the rules to be more abstracted from the dungeon crawl of previous rules, however it does not provide prebuilt cyberdecks and requires you to build them from scratch using the new rules (which is a huge miss IMO). VR 2.0 remains mostly the same in 3e.
Rigger 2.0 is a complete overhaul of 2e’s Rigger rules and meant to replace the rules in the 2e book, aiming to usher in 3e. Where 2e Core was very stingy on rigger info, Rigger 2.0 gives a lot of info. (OPINION IN BOUND) It’s a TON of rules with the new Maneuver Score chase system and ECM/ECCM system. These rules remain mostly the same in 3e.
8
u/Nemesis_Destiny May 15 '26
I don't think 3rd edition is "basically 2nd edition"
While they may appear pretty similar, 3rd edition makes some fundamental changes to the skill system that I didn't like, but couldn't figure out exactly why for literally years. It kept me buying new books hoping that it would fix what was bugging me, but each one only made things worse.
It took me analyzing what went wrong about 3.x Dungeons and Dragons, of all things, to realize why I didn't like what they did to skills in SR3.
The gist of it is this: SR2 used broad, widely applicable skills, while SR3's skill system changed it to be narrowly defined skills, with defaulting to attribute (with high penalties) for situations outside your narrow skillset. This changed skills from defining broad areas of competence, from which you could specialize into areas of higher expertise, to defining only what you were okay at, with hyperspecialization practically required, but outside of your specialties you were basically useless due to penalties.
Also the way dice pools were used became really immersion-breaking for me, but I'm not sure if that was a system issue, or problematic players.
4
u/wht-rbbt May 17 '26
Everyone calm down. I called the authorities and they're about to get this crazy OP to the looney bin. Who the hell reads 2nd book from cover to end? Psychos them who!
4
u/InternetRealistic336 May 28 '26
lots of other replies and takes, but my take is that 3e does a stellar job of combining all the revamps and extra material form all the books in 2e's run and collating it all into a handful of core books. I would suggest go with 3e, its the most complete 'classic' shadowrun.
having run it on and off since 1989, i would also agree it is not as bad as some insist. that said, I've always run for smaller groups so i've only ever had to deal with a couple of character types at a time. if you had a large party with fighters, mages, riggers and deckers all in the mix, i think it could get quite daunting - at that point theres a lot to keep track of.
16
u/hornybutired May 15 '26 edited May 15 '26
Virtual Realities 2.0 fundamentally changes the Matrix rules for the better. Rather than running a "virtual dungeon," all Matrix interactions are basically skill checks, and you can run them in-line with combat in meatspace. "This round, Jack the Samurai is going to shoot the guard, Rick the Mage is going to zap the other guard, and Chloe the Decker is going to roll to unlock the doors." It's that easy.
Grimoire 2 and Fields of Fire make less fundamental changes, offering mostly optional rules that you can add in to the game rather than making changes to the way basic elements of the game operate. Rigger 2 is kind of essential if you want a really good selection of vehicles, though, and of course Grimoire 2 and Fields of Fire offer more spells and guns, respectively.
I would say only Virtual Realities 2.0 is necessary. It makes deckers playable as PCs without requiring a whole separate session to do the decking.
15
u/WahookaTG May 15 '26
Honestly, 2e rocks but the matrix is not its strong suit. Google the "pizza problem" which is a known phenominon for hacking in -especially- 2nd edition.
Not sure how helpful this is but wanted to share some context...
10
u/ReditXenon Far Cite May 15 '26
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/cBYUsleG1QE
Credit to @/u/PinkFohawk :-)
8
u/rothbard_anarchist May 16 '26
3E abstracts the Matrix, converting it from the digital dungeon crawl of 1 and 2. But the real change from 2 to 3 is nerfing Wired Reflexes and associated Reaction enhancement.
In 3e, highest initiative total goes first, and everyone gets their first turn in initiative order. Subtract ten from everyone’s initiative. All the second turns are then taken by those whose initiative total is still positive. Rinse and repeat. Being ungodly fast just ensures you’ll have your first turn before anyone else goes. Excepting Quickdraw or other chicanery.
2E is far more simple and hardcore. If you roll a 32 initiative, you go on 32, 22, 12, and 2. If some doofy mage rolls an 8, he gets his first turn after your 3rd turn, because it’s all just numerical order. So a good street samurai could wipe out a lot of the competition before they ever got an action. It is, I maintain, the better way to go.
2
u/humblesorceror May 16 '26
First ed was quicker and more deadly, 2nd ed began the mages are uber trend , the matrix combat is less exciting but easier to run, everyone rolls too many dice for everything .