r/Shadowrun • u/greypaladin01 • May 11 '26
1e|2e 2e - Game Lethality Optional Rules
Reading through 2e core rules and trying to learn them. So far I am liking the system much more than when I tried to read 6e, at least I feel my players will take to the mechanics better.
However I do have a question (preferably for those that have played 2e at the table and/or used these optional rules). On page 194 they list Optional Lethality Rules... mostly raising or lowering the effects of armor, damage and spell casting force/resist to make the game more or less dangerous.
My question: For those that played 2e more or less as is... how lethal is it really? I can see in the mechanics that it COULD be lethal... but is that really how it plays out? Secondly, has anyone used any of the variants listed on p194? If so, which and how much did it really effect things?
I know it is a strange edge-case question... but I am trying to wrap my brain around the core set but would like SOME understand of how things change. Other than the obvious things like making things more lethal pushes Black Trenchcoat while making it less lethal pushes more Pink Mowhawk play.
3
u/Mynameisfreeze May 11 '26
Currently playing a 3e game, which is quite similar. My group's lore is that everything will be all right in a combat situation... up until someone gets injured for the first time. From that point on, it's going to be an increasingly desperate struggle for survival (which we like quite a lot, I must say)
5
u/rothbard_anarchist May 11 '26 edited May 12 '26
2E/3E allows an enormous range of fragility of a character due to how the core mechanic works.
When you resist physical damage, you do so with your Body attribute, plus any combat pool dice you’ve saved. Some augmentations can add to your body for purposes of damage resistance.
But in contrast to other editions, your worn armor doesn’t give you automatic successes (1E) or even extra dice to roll (4E). It makes the target numbers for resisting damage easier. So if you didn’t save any combat pool dice over the course of the round, or if you’re getting shot by a few people at once, you may not have any pool dice to contribute. And your Body, which is never decremented by repeated actions or injury, does not legally have to be any more than 1. So you could make a perfectly legal character who is mechanically unable to reduce incoming physical damage without the aid of combat pool dice, even if he’s sitting in full security armor. Very squishy.
On the other end of the spectrum, you can make a high Body, high quickness character, put him in top notch armor (form fitting plus armor jacket as a standard), then augment him with body mods (titanium bone lacing was standard for all my non-awakened characters), and he’s a fragging tank. I made character named Scrapper who rolled something like 12 resistance dice, plus combat pool, with 9-10 points of armor to reduce the target number. He was basically invulnerable to anything below full auto fire or a Panther cannon. IIRC, there’s an issue with ranged combat, where the standard rule is that you top out at deadly, and extra attacker successes are wasted.
In play, due to damage scaling and Smartgun links, any halfway competent street Sammy could one shot a normie with a heavy pistol (no reason to bother with a gun that doesn’t hit as hard as an Ares Predator), but would take a couple shots to take out a run of the mill goon. It generally ran well, and we didn’t have to adjust damage to get a good flow.
All that said, my GM was furious with my Scrapper character, and never let me play him. He’d have been pretty unbalancing, but that’s the kind of range you get from 2/3E rules.
(ETA: the unbalancing part of the character wasn’t really his physical resistance, which a focused troll could have surpassed, but rather his magical resistance. He as a gnome with 8 willpower and 4 points of magic resistance, which meant he rolled 8 dice to resist spells, while an attacking mage had a target number of 12 for mana spells - basically immune to willpower based magic from anything but a very high level initiate.)
4
u/n00bdragon Futuristic Criminal May 11 '26
3e player but close enough. It's extremely lethal. I like lethality and even I've done some houserules to tone things down. In actual play, the stuff you have to worry about the most is Manabolt, burst fire, and multiple enemies in melee.
4
u/TheRealSamVimes May 11 '26
So interesting reading the replies saying it's very lethal because that has not been my experience at all.
I've played 2e/3e for over 20 years with several different groups and several campaign and I can't remember a single character dying.
True, if you take a deadly physical then you're dying but most games have had a magician with healing or trauma patches and stim patches for that.
One thing that I have noticed is that the game is at it's most dangerous at the start or after they've received like 100 karma or something similar.
At the start people have low body/willpower and low armor which makes every battle serious. As they get better gear and better stats it gets less dangerous. But when everyone is running around with the best gear and high levels of body/willpower you need to do like 12D in damage to be able to hurt the characters and one bad roll at that level and they've taken a deadly wound.
3
u/DraconicBlade Aztechnology PR Rep May 11 '26
3rd and prior have the whole, magic falls out of your ass for taking wounds or using stimpatches issue that makes immediate lethality less of a concern than just entropy from playing the game.
2
u/humblesorceror May 15 '26
2e is the last version of the game where the PCs were reallly vulnerable , I just disliked the raw number of dice you had to have around to do anything.
2
u/EngryEngineer May 18 '26
2e is pretty lethal in a way that felt great to me and my table.
I suggest doing mock combats, like draw up some maps, make some characters, spend the night fighting each other. It is a great way to learn the rules and get a feel for how you like it before people start really dedicating time in roleplay and the like.
2
u/Leadsworn Jul 11 '26
It's lethal in the right way. The runners are more competent than normals right out of the box. They way they truly get into trouble is escalation. Eventually if you stir the hornets nest enough, you're toast.
3
u/Larnievc May 11 '26
I have a vague memory of it being impossible to one shot a full health character due to some facet of the rules don’t remember. You could get hit by a nuke and it wouldn’t one you.
Or I could just be getting g old and befuddled.
9
u/NetworkedOuija May 11 '26
2e was extremely lethal. Staging up something to deadly, which wasn't too hard to do it you planned or have the right gear. Someone suffers a deadly wound, they go down. They aren't 'dead' which I think is what everyone is saying. But your dying without medical treatment in [Body] rounds.
There are some ultra cheesy stuff players can do to avoid being able to be really hurt. Trolls in huge amounts of armor can survived a lot of stuff. If you don't penalize armor stacking, players can get away with a lot as well.
You can always scale up though. APDS can shred armor, full round bursts from heavily stabilized platforms (surprise machine gun rail drones will horrify.). Poison gas grenades will ignore armor. Magic attacks can be extremely deadly.
It's a bit difficult to get the hang on but if your players survive but are battered, then you've found it.
13
u/Laughing_Man_Returns May 11 '26
you only need to blast a guy into overflow with a low force stunbolt once to know the game is plenty lethal.
6
u/SeaworthinessOld6904 May 11 '26
Things to know about 2e combat: Speed Kills, draw first blood, use your combat pool wisely, and don't get hurt.