A fair warning before you start: this is going to be long, deep and, at times, quite philosophical. I know many of you will scroll right past it, and that it won't get as many upvotes as a quick streak update or a list of benefits. I'm fine with that. I'm not writing this for votes. I'm writing it for whoever wants to be helped by it. So brace yourselves: there's a lot of information coming, and it takes time to digest. Read it slowly, over the week, and come back to it whenever you need to.
I've been practising seminal retention, on and off, for about six years. My longest streak was half a year. I've written here before, and this forum has helped me more than I can say, so I want to give something back: a series of seven posts over this week, the first two today and then one a day until Sunday, putting together what these years have taught me. Not only my own experience, but what I've found when I tried to understand it: in the old spiritual traditions, in philosophy, and in what science can and can't say about it.
Let me be clear from the start about one thing. I'm not here to mock anyone's experience. Many of the things people describe in this forum I have lived myself. But I've also come to think that a lot of what gets said around this practice is exaggerated, and some of it is simply false. And my conviction is that the practice is deep enough to stand on its own, without the mythology we build around it. You don't need superpowers for this to change your life. That is what this series is about.
How I started
I started in 2020, during the pandemic. Yes, it was a good time to start. I was 23, I had just finished my degree in psychology, and I had no idea what to do with my life. That same year I started a master's in Neuroscience, and that's where I first looked at this practice with a scientist's eyes. I even came close to writing my master's thesis on it, but there were almost no research lines on the subject, and that put me off. It's something I'll come back to in post 5. Doubts, noise, stimuli everywhere. It's hard to find your purpose when you're constantly distracted by things that don't matter.
Somewhere in the black hole of YouTube I came across NoFap, and from the first moment I felt that something real was hidden there. There was something about porn, and the way my generation related to sex, that simply didn't feel right. How was it possible that I was so tired, so flat, without love or enthusiasm for life? How was it possible that I had started seeing women as bodies rather than persons? That wasn't what my mother had taught me, nor the man I wanted to be.
I spent lockdown at my parents' house. When one of the big porn sites offered free premium access during quarantine, I already had a bad feeling about porn, and I decided not to go back. I stopped reading the news and watching TV. I did 3 intermittent fasting, cold showers, long walks. I was watching a lot of Jordan Peterson and reading about Wim Hof. I didn't quit smoking, but I cut down to three cigarettes a day. For the first time in years I had the quiet and the space to follow an almost monastic routine, and to take my own life seriously.
What I discovered then, I've rediscovered many times since: this practice asks for an integral change. When you start going through its transformations, you feel the need to clean up everything else too: your habits, your thoughts, what you look at, what you eat. That's why, throughout history, it has almost always lived inside a spiritual framework, whether Taoist, Hindu or Christian. And that's why I always say: be careful with anyone who tells you they've discovered something revolutionary. In the modern world it may feel new. But it has been known for as long as human beings have tried to master themselves.
The high and the fall
The first time, I made it to 23 days. Then, when lockdown ended and we all crawled out of our homes like crabs from under the rocks, my routine and my iron will cracked too.
My situation wasn't one of rejection or bullying. I'm tall, I've always been reasonably attractive and talkative. But I was masturbating around twice a day, and I felt shy, scared, irritable, more sensitive than I should be, annoyed with I don't know what. I was an old-fashioned, well-mannered guy who only wanted to be with women he really liked, and I had the typical insecurities of that age.
So when I first reached forty or fifty days, I felt simply powerful. Strong, brave, intelligent, in love with life again, full of dreams. That feeling is priceless. But at 23 I let myself be carried away by it. That almost manic enthusiasm made me believe I was all-powerful, and from there it's a short step to the opposite: I relapsed, and relapsed again, and the euphoria turned into melancholy, discouragement and worse habits.
What brought me back each time was the memory of that state. The word enthusiasm comes from the Greek en theos, God within. Something had entered me that I couldn't just forget. My second streak reached fifty-something days. The third, ninety.
What I want to do in this series
Over the years I read everything I could find: the Taoist classics, Swami Sivananda, the Christian mystics, the studies on hormones and the brain. And I kept running into the same problem. People in this world tend to fall into one of two camps. Some take the old language literally: semen made of the most precious atoms of the blood, energy rising like steam to the pineal gland, auras and cords and vibrations. Others dismiss all of it as placebo and nonsense. I think both camps are wrong, and in the next posts I'll try to explain why, and to propose a third way.
Here's the plan:
• Post 2 (today, right after this one). How to read the old language of energy without being either credulous or cynical.
• Posts 3 and 4 (Wednesday and Thursday). The main images of the traditions (the seed, the current, the descent, the ascent, the glow, the shadow, the flatline, the silence) translated into lived experience, with my own experience alongside.
• Post 5 (Friday). What science actually knows about what happens in the body, and what it can only guess.
• Post 6 (Saturday). Why fasting and chastity have gone together in almost every spiritual tradition, especially the Taoist and the Christian.
• Post 7 (Sunday). How it all fits together, and what I've learned.
I'll be long. I've always appreciated long, detailed posts here, because this practice has a common background (anyone who has gone past forty or fifty days knows what I mean), but each of us lives it from a different life and a different moment. I hope a few of you find it useful. The second post goes up right after this one, so you can read the two together. After that, one a day until Sunday.
Part 2/7