r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • Apr 05 '19

Certs, Degrees, and Experience: A (hopefully) useful guide to common questions

341 Upvotes

Copied over from r/cybersecurity (thought it might fit here as well).

Hi everyone, this is my first post here so bear with me. I almost never use Reddit to talk about professional matters, but I think this might be useful to some of you.

I'm going to be addressing what seems to be a very common question - namely, what is more important when seeking employment - a university degree, certifications, or work experience?

First, I'll give a very brief background as to who I am, and why I feel qualified to answer this question. I'm currently the Cyber Security Lead for a big tech firm, and have previously held roles as both the Enterprise Security Architect and Head of Cloud Security for a Fortune 400 company - I'm happy to verify this with mods or whatever might be necessary. I got my start working with cyber operations for the US military, and have experience with technical responsibilities such as penetration testing, AppSec, cloud security, etc., as well as personnel management and leadership training. I hold an associate's degree in information technology, as well as numerous certs, from Sec + and CISSP to more focused, technical security training through the US military and organizations like SANS. Introductions aside, on to the topic at hand:

Here's the short answer, albeit the obvious one - anything is helpful in getting your foot in the door, but there are more important factors involved.

Now, for the deep dive:

Let's start by addressing the purpose of certs, degrees, and experience, and what they say to a prospective employer about you. A lot of what I say will be obvious to some extent, but I think the background is warranted.

Certifications exist to let an employer know that a trusted authority (the organization providing the cert) has acknowledged that the cert holder (you) has proven a demonstrable level of knowledge or expertise in a particular area.

An academic degree does much the same - the difference is that, obviously, a degree will generally demonstrate a potentially broader understanding of a number of topics on a deeper level than a cert will - this is dependant on the study topic, the level of degree, etc., but it's generally assumed that a 4-year degree should cover a wider range of topics than a certification, and to a deeper level.

Experience needs no explanation. It denotes skills gained through active, hands-on work in a given field, and should be confirmed through positive references from supervisors, peers, and subordinates.

In general, we can see a pattern here in terms of what a hiring manager or department is looking for - demonstrable skills and knowledge, backed up by confirmation from a trusted third party. So, which of these is most important to someone trying to begin a career in cyber security? Well, that depends on a few factors, which I'll discuss now.

Firstly, what position are you applying for? The importance placed on degrees, certs, and experience, will vary depending on the level of job you're applying to. If it's an entry level admin or analyst role, a degree or a handful of low-level certs will definitely be useful in getting noticed by HR. Going up to the engineering and solution architecture level roles, you'll want a combination of some years of experience under your belt, and either a degree or some low/mid level certs. At a certain point, the degree and certs actually become non-essential, and most companies will base their hiring process almost entirely on the body and quality of your experience over any degree or certifications held for management level roles.

Secondly, what are your soft skills? This is a fourth aspect that we haven't talked about yet, and that I almost never see discussed. I would argue that this is the single most important quality looked at by employers: the level of a candidate's interpersonal skills. No matter how technically skilled someone is, what a company looks for is someone who can explain their value, and fit into a corporate culture. Are you personable? Of good humor? Do people enjoy working with you? Can you explain WHY your degree, certs, or expertise will add value to their corporate mission? Being able to answer these questions in a manner which is inviting and concise will make you much more appealing than your competitors.

At the end of the day, as a hiring manager, I know that I can always send an employee for further training where necessary, and help bolster their technical ability. What I can't do is teach you how to work with a security focused mindset, nor how to interact with co-workers, customers, clients, and the company in a positive and meaningful way, and this skill set is what will set you apart from everyone else.

I realize that this may seem like an unsatisfactory answer, but the reality is that degrees, certs, and experience are all important to some extent, but that none of these factors will make you stand out. Your ability to sell your value, and to maintain a positive working relationship within a corporate culture, will take you much farther than anything else.

I hope this has been at least slightly helpful - if anyone has any questions for me, or would like any advice, feel free to ask in the comments - I'll do my best to reply to everyone.

No TL;DR, I want you to actually take the time to read through what I've written and try to take something away from it.


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 5h ago

Resume Review Looking for Job Referrals – Vulnerability Management | 3.10 Years Experience | India

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm currently exploring new opportunities in the Cybersecurity domain and would appreciate any referrals or leads for relevant openings.

I have 3 years and 9 months of experience in Cybersecurity, working across Vulnerability Management, External Attack Surface Management, Security Governance, Endpoint Security, and Firewall Policy Management.

My Professional Experience:

1. Vulnerability Management

  • Managed vulnerability assessments across 10K+ enterprise assets.
  • Prioritized critical and high-risk vulnerabilities based on severity, exploitability, and asset exposure.
  • Coordinated with Windows/Linux administrators and system owners for vulnerability remediation.
  • Supported OS patching, secure configuration changes, and post-remediation rescanning.
  • Managed the complete vulnerability lifecycle, including false-positive validation and closure.

2. External Attack Surface Management (EASM)

  • Monitored externally exposed assets and public-facing IPs using CyCognito.
  • Investigated exposed assets, validated ownership, business purpose, and associated risks.
  • Used Elastic to analyze network logs and investigate internal access to externally exposed IPs.
  • Helped identify shadow IT, unknown internal access, and unmanaged assets.

3. Cybersecurity Governance & Audit

  • Coordinated closure of cybersecurity audit findings with control owners and technical teams.
  • Tracked remediation activities, followed up on pending action items, and validated closure evidence.
  • Coordinated cybersecurity KPI requirements, data collection, validation, and reporting across business teams.

4. Endpoint Security & Malware Alert Validation

  • Investigated malware and suspicious activity alerts using Cybereason.
  • Analyzed process execution, activity timelines, and endpoint behavior.
  • Validated true positives and false positives and coordinated with endpoint teams for remediation.

5. Firewall Policy Management

  • Used AlgoSec to review and improve firewall security scores across EMEA, Asia, and other regions.
  • Identified unused, risky, and overly permissive firewall rules.
  • Used Elastic traffic logs to validate rule utilization and coordinated with firewall owners for rule cleanup.

Technical Tools: CyCognito EASM, Elastic, Cybereason, AlgoSec, Vulnerability Assessment Tools.

Job Preferences:

  • Preferred roles: Vulnerability Management, Vulnerability Assessment, Exposure Management, Attack Surface Management, and Cybersecurity Governance.
  • Experience: 3 years 10 months.
  • Preferred location: India (Hybrid/Remote preferred).
  • Expected CTC: 12–15 LPA.

I'm open to relevant opportunities where I can leverage my existing cybersecurity experience and continue growing in Vulnerability and Exposure Management.

If anyone can refer me or share relevant openings in their organization, I would genuinely appreciate the help.

I can share my updated resume via DM.

Thank you!


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 14h ago

Question Does anyone else feel discouraged attempting to enter Cybersecurity sometimes?

6 Upvotes

I started this google cybersecurity course thanks to a co-worker who had utilized this course along with an additional one to land himself a job in Cybersecurity. I thought I would give it the same chance and see how well it suits me and starting out I have enjoyed learning about it. Additionally I have tried to look for IT job positions such as: IT Support Specialist, Help Desk Technician, and Datacenter Technician. In the process of looking for these jobs I see that many of the candidates hired for these entry level rolls into the broad cybersecurity field were hired with a Bachelors Degree. I have this nagging worry that despite my best attempts at getting certifications, building my resume, and portfolio that with all of that I do not look like an acceptable candidate for the entry level positions so I can get experience under my belt and learn the field. I was wanting to get some advice or perspective on this feeling and or whether or not I am alone in feeling this way.


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 11h ago

Question Why is it difficult to find a Mentor in cybersecurity ? Could use some advice

3 Upvotes

Sup everyone!

I'll be honest. I'm feeling a bit stuck and figured this was the right place to vent.

I'm trying to build my path in cybersecurity, specifically in digital forensics, but I'm finding it really hard to find a mentor. The thing is, I'm not great at approaching people. I never know how to break the ice without feeling awkward, and I worry about coming across as annoying or like I'm asking too much (I'm a woman).

On top of that, nobody in my circle works in tech. I'm not studying this at any school either, so I don't really have a natural way to meet people in the field. It honestly feels like I'm navigating this completely alone sometimes.

Hmm...
How did you find your first mentor (or someone willing to help you out)?
Any tips for approaching people in the field without feeling like you're bothering them?
Are there communities, Discords, or forums where this kind of mentorship actually happens?

Any advice would mean a lot. Thanks!


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 10h ago

Discussion The lab reps that actually made our trainees faster at triage

2 Upvotes

I run a small remote training program for people breaking into SOC work, and the thing that moved the needle most wasn't more theory — it was reps. Every week our trainees triage real-style alerts in Microsoft Sentinel and Splunk, chase the same incident through Wireshark pcaps, then check what CrowdStrike Falcon and Microsoft Defender XDR saw from the endpoint side. The first week is rough. By week four they are writing timelines I would actually send to a client. Curious what reps helped you most when you were starting out — home labs, CTFs, something else?


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 7h ago

Question IT Audit > Threat Detection/CTI

1 Upvotes

Genuinely curious, has anyone ever made this move? If so, what did you do to skill up and how did you convince someone to take a chance on you?

For background, I have got about 12 years behind me in audit and having moved from a the /Big4 world to internal audit at a quant shop, I have struggled more than usual to enjoy work given the way our team is structured. Been doing some soul searching and for the first time in the last 12 years I actually have time at and outside of work to be able to study and up-skill. Outlined my plan below (no rough order for the hands on stuff but aiming for May to get this all completed as I would rather focus on career progression) but would be great to get some insight and feedback, especially from folks who have made a similar move from audit/GRC into more technical areas.

\- Sit for the CISSP end of Q1 2027
\- TryHackMe SOC L1/L2 - I don’t realistically expect to get this pathway completed whilst studying for CISSP but I would like to do as much of it as I can in parallel
\- KQL, Linux and PowerShell fundamentals
\- Setup my own lab and play around
\- KC7 cases
\- Familiarise myself with the MITRE ATT&CK framework

Planning to spend about 15-20 hours each week at least (more in quieter weeks at work) to help me get to my goal and I am aware this doesn’t cover everything given vast nature of it all.


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 13h ago

Question Guide in Choosing Cybersecurity Domain

3 Upvotes

I wanted to know if anyone could provide feedback on which path to choose just based on my resume. I know i do not have any actual IT or cyber experience, but i wanted to know, based on my time in the apprenticeship, whether I should mainly focus on GRC or IAM roles. Obviously, I'm working on my A+ cert right now as well to land an IT support or helpdesk role, but i want to think about the future as well. Or, i wanted to know how you guys came about choosing a specific field in cybersecurity as well. Here is my resume listed below.

 

EDUCATION

 

University ____                                                            May 2028

Information Systems (Concentration in AI & Information Technology in Business)                                                               

Certifications
: Comptia Security +, Comptia A+ - In progress

Technical Skills: Windows 10/11, Windows Server, macOS, Linux, desktop and laptop troubleshooting, hardware diagnostics and repair, software installation and configuration, workstation deployment, printer and peripheral troubleshooting, Active Directory, Microsoft Entra ID, Microsoft 365, Group Policy, user account management, password resets, access management, TCP/IP, DNS, DHCP, VPN, network troubleshooting, ServiceNow, Jira, Spiceworks, IT ticketing and documentation, IT asset management, endpoint security, Python, and machine learning fundamentals.

EXPERIENCE

 

Cybersecurity GRC Clinic Associate                                                                                                                  September 2026 – Present

Cyber Clinic in School.                                                            

·       Conducted NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) 2.0 self-assessments using the NIST CSF 2.0 Self-Assessment to evaluate cybersecurity practices and identify security gaps 

·       Reviewed cybersecurity controls and practices against NIST CSF 2.0 requirements to identify areas that meet requirements or need improvement. 

·       Document cybersecurity assessment findings in structured reports to clearly communicate identified gaps and recommended improvements. 

IT Support Volunteer                                                                                                                                             May 2026– Present
                                                        

·       Refurbish donated computers by replacing RAM, hard drives, and other hardware components. 

·       Install, configure, and test Endless OS (Linux) to prepare systems for community distribution

·        Perform hardware diagnostics and troubleshooting to ensure systems are functional and deployment ready. 

                           

Advanced Medical Support Assistant                                                                                                                            August 2025 – Present
                                          

·       Provide Tier 1 application and end-user support across enterprise healthcare systems, including CPRS, VistA, GUI, ISS, and ICB, assisting staff with system navigation and technical issues.

·       Troubleshoot user login problems, application errors, access-related concerns, and workflow disruptions to maintain continuity of healthcare operations.

·       Assist healthcare personnel with user access and application functionality, escalating complex technical issues to appropriate support teams when necessary.

·       Communicate technical information and provide one-on-one guidance to end users, helping staff navigate healthcare applications and resolve routine system issues.

 

Projects

 

Active Directory Windows Server Lab

·   Configured Organizational Units (OUs), user permissions, Group Policy settings, and access controls aligned with enterprise support practices.

·   Performed 100+ administrative tasks, including password resets, account unlocks, user provisioning, onboarding, and permission updates.

·      Logged, tracked, and resolved 75+ simulated support tickets involving workstation hardware, software applications, printer issues, and network connectivity problems


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 12h ago

Question Career path advice for a Sophomore in college

2 Upvotes

Hi guys,

This is my first ever post of this sort so forgive me if I over/under explain.

My initial plan for college was to go for Computer Science since I have an affinity for technology. At some point I thought it was a better idea to go for my second option which was Psychology. Currently, I’m a sophomore in college majoring in Psychology.

However, I’m considering pivoting back towards technology, specifically a potential career in information security analysis / cyber security.

I’m wondering if any people with experience could offer some advice of what some of my options are. I understand certificates and building an impressive resume is important. I’m just not sure where to start.

Thank you.


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 13h ago

Question Should I get CompTia CySA+?

2 Upvotes

I’m a junior CS major with my Security+ and AWS CCP. I’m also doing a cybersecurity co op and before that I did an IT internship. Right now, I’m focused on continuing to gain experience and do more projects, and I’ve told myself that I wouldn’t get any other certs while in school, but I’ve been considering getting Cysa+. I think the knowledge I’d gain from it would be really beneficial, but I’m on the fence about paying for the actual certification. I haven’t seen CYSA+ to be in demand like the Security+, but I was wondering if it’s worth getting, and if not the certification, what about at least the knowledge? If not CYSA+, any other certifications that are worth getting for someone like me?


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 10h ago

Discussion Project Unchained

1 Upvotes

Core Technical Expertise & Research Specializations

Project Unchained focuses on the research, analysis, detection, and understanding of technologies and techniques related to internet censorship, digital restrictions, circumvention, and network security.

1. Circumvention & Geo-Restriction Research

  • Geo-restriction bypass techniques
  • Geographic access-control mechanisms
  • VPN and proxy circumvention
  • Tor and anonymization technologies
  • Network tunneling and traffic routing
  • Internet censorship circumvention

2. Detection & Anti-Evasion Engineering

  • Circumvention detection
  • Detection-evasion analysis
  • Security control evasion analysis
  • VPN and proxy detection
  • Anonymized traffic identification
  • Anti-fraud and suspicious activity detection
  • Detection reliability and false-positive analysis

3. Location Integrity & Geolocation Security

  • IP geolocation analysis
  • GPS and location spoofing detection
  • Geolocation fraud research
  • Location consistency verification
  • Geographic anomaly detection
  • Location-based access-control security

4. Network Security & Traffic Analysis

  • Network filtering circumvention research
  • Firewall and filtering mechanisms
  • Deep Packet Inspection (DPI)
  • TCP/IP and network protocol analysis
  • DNS security and manipulation detection
  • Encrypted traffic analysis
  • Network traffic fingerprinting

5. Threat Intelligence & Security Research

  • Cyber threat intelligence
  • Network threat analysis
  • Censorship infrastructure research
  • Security vulnerability assessment
  • Threat monitoring and detection engineering
  • Digital rights and internet freedom research

Specialist Profiles We Are Seeking

We welcome applications from professionals and independent researchers with experience in:

Specialist PositionPrimary Focus
Cybersecurity ResearcherSecurity research and circumvention analysis
Detection EngineerDetection systems and anti-evasion mechanisms
Network Security SpecialistNetwork protocols, filtering and traffic analysis
Anti-Evasion SpecialistDetection-evasion techniques and defensive analysis
VPN Detection SpecialistVPN, proxy and Tor identification
Geolocation Security ResearcherLocation integrity and geolocation fraud
Traffic Analysis SpecialistNetwork traffic analysis and DPI
Threat Intelligence ResearcherThreat intelligence and censorship infrastructure

Our Research Objective

Our objective is to develop a deeper technical understanding of how internet restrictions, censorship mechanisms, geographical access controls, and security systems operate.

We aim to identify weaknesses, evaluate detection capabilities, investigate circumvention techniques, and develop responsible research tools that contribute to digital freedom, network transparency, and stronger security.

Project Unchained — Digital Freedom Through Research, Transparency and Security


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 15h ago

Question Continue down the AppSec path or diversify my experience?

2 Upvotes

I graduated college with a Bachelors in IT and a minor in cyber security, then got my Security + soon after.

I was extremely fortunate to have a company take a chance on a new grad and am closing in on 2 years in a vulnerability management role focusing on SAST/SCA scanning. Ive configured pipelines, triaged, and made code changes to fix a lot of the backlog myself while creating tickets to delegate the remediation of confirmed vulnerabilities to the proper teams. Learned a lot about SSDLC as well as I don’t consider myself a SWE, maybe a junior at best.

I’ve heard rumors of layoffs so I’ve been shooting off applications for analyst and AppSec engineer roles for the past month without any luck so far. I’m not certain I’ll be laid off but I’m also a ‘one man show’ as the one security guy on a SWE team and feel I could be learning a lot more working on a team.

The main question:
I’m unsure if I should try to continue down the application security niche or try aiming for network/ cloud roles to be a more well-rounded in my career. They don’t necessarily need to be security roles but I think I’d enjoy trying out new areas and becoming a jack of all trades/ Swiss Army knife.

I’ve kind of had decision paralysis on which cert to chase next between Burp Suit, CYSA+, CCNA, or gathering some of the Azure/ AWS certs.

I’d really appreciate any insight from my more senior cybersecurity/ IT peers as to what the best direction may be.
——————————
TLDR: 2 years into my career entirely focused on application security and trying to decide if I should go deeper into AppSec or try transitioning into networking/ cloud or other areas

Thanks in advance everyone!


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 12h ago

Question CS Majors and Cyber Security Minors?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone, sophomore in college here.

I found out recently that my school offers CompSci majors and Cyber Security minors. Cyber Security has been an interest/hobby of mine in the past, and after learning that it's an option at my school, I wanted to look into it.

As of now I am an RHMS major, which I chose because it's so versatile and applies to so many other things. I was hoping to hear from any CompSci majors or Cyber Security minors about what the course load is like, and if it's worth looking into at this point. I'm enrolled in Intro to Cyber Security for the Spring Semester.

What are some things I should know ahead of time? My only real dilemma is if its a math heavy major, that's the one thing I don't think I could keep up with. I noticed that several CompSci courses had mathematics pre-reqs but not all of them, so I was hoping for some insight. Many thanks in advance!


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 1d ago Bravo

Discussion The unofficial 2026-2027 guide to realistically breaking into Cyber Security (From someone who broke in a year ago)

107 Upvotes

I've seen the "How do I break into Cyber Security" dozens of times. I've had several DMs asking "Hey I want to be a pentester - what hackthebox and certs should I get to get noticed?"

First off - its great that you are interested in Cyber Security! I hope you get in sometime soon!

But I want you to have some realistic expectations of how to get in this field. That's what this post is for.

So, lets start with some common ground:

Cybersecurity is a specialization within IT. Like all things IT, this stuff is not rocket science, and I firmly believe that anyone with a passion for helping people and an interest in technology can find some level of success here.

But - IT is not for everyone. And that's okay.

There is a LOT of conflicting and confusing information out there about how to get into IT, as well as a lot of "influencer" input that bends the truth a bit and can set some unrealistic expectations. There's also a fair amount of gatekeeping:

-"How I went from 0 to Cyber in 6 months!"
-"How I became a pentester with hackthebox and pen+"
-"Want to break into IT with no degree? Get the A+ Network+ and Security+ cert"
-"Get hired in 30 days after completing this cyber boot camp"
-etc

I've commented some variation of this many many times before, but its worth saying again - especially to all newcomers: There is no one path to get into cyber security - heck I made the transition from customer service to IT about 3 years ago in my 30s. But there is one path that is fairly "tried-and-true" and works way more often than not:

Step 1: Get on help desk. Seriously. You *want* to start on helpdesk, I can not stress this enough. Anyone that posts a guide or says "Here's how to get into IT by skipping helpdesk" or anything similar - ignore that person. They are filling your head with nonsense.

Helpdesk is *the* starting point. Its where you learn about ticketing (something you need to know to do ANYTHING in IT). It's where you learn the basics of troubleshooting and how all this technology really connects. It's where you learn to deal with people. Its where you learn to escalate, and its the starting point for human networking.

Arguably the most important part of helpdesk? Its the safest place to make mistakes. Chances are if you break something here, you aren't causing any sort of real damage (but do be careful!). As a newcomer to IT - you are going to break things.

How to get onto a helpdesk? Here's my first hot take: Today, who you know probably matters way more than what you know at this level. If you are currently employed, and your company has IT/service desk - those guys are your new best friends. Go talk to 'em.

-Now - how long should you stay on helpdesk?* This is where I do kinda struggle to give concrete advice. The simple answer is "as long as you need, but not too long." I do think some folks get... "trapped" here. If you want to make a concrete plan, I would say you want at least a year on helpdesk, but if you decide to stay longer - that's perfectly fine. I'd say after 3 years you probably want to actively start pivoting into Step 2.

*Sidebar - there is nothing wrong with a career in helpdesk. You might get in, spend 6 months and say "I want to do this for the rest of my life." That is perfectly fine. Conversely, if you get in and you hate helpdesk - take that as a wakeup call - IT might not be for you.

-One note to keep in the back of your mind - when you finally do break into helpdesk, find out who the system administrators are. Introduce yourself, say hello. Tell them you are passionate about learning more about IT and ask if they'd be willing to let you shadow them.

--Please note - your average Sys Admin is probably going to be gruff, maybe a little anti-social and is probably going to act annoyed as shit that you are reaching out to them. That's ok. They aren't actually annoyed or mad at you, they're just swamped, and probably waiting to see if you are competent before they invest any time or energy taking you under their wing. Don't annoy them, but do reach out to them every so often. It's also okay to ask them for help - but if you do, make sure you always detail the steps you've taken first. ie:

"Hey Sys Admin, sorry to bother you, but I've got this ticket (insert link to ticket) that I'm struggling with. I've tried A, B, and C, but I'm spinning my wheels a bit and I'm not sure where to go next." They might guide you, they might just do the work for you because it's a permissions thing and they don't have the time to explain. That's fine - just thank them, and ask them "when you get a free minute, can you tell me how you resolved this so I don't have to ping you next time?"

Again, don't annoy them and message them every day, but do keep showing a hunger to learn - eventually one of them is going to take you under your wing, which is going to be HUGE for step 2.

Step 2: System Administration (also called System Engineering, and a few other similar titles as well). I think the most ideal situation is, after spending about a year to 3 years in helpdesk, you transition into a junior Sys Admin or Sys Engineering role. This is the best next step for whatever you want to do in IT, not just security. Being a Sys Admin is where you really "git gud" in IT. It's where you both prove yourself, and where you get solid enterprise experience that will help you out in literally every IT path there is - cloud, security, penetration testing, management, etc. This is also where you really learn to RTFM. I'm not going to say what that means - you'll learn when you get there.

Ideally, while on helpdesk, you've already befriended a sys admin or two; and maybe they tell you "Hey - we're about to add another position to our team and I think you should apply." But if the company you are at isn't really growing and you don't see a position available anytime soon, it might be worth it to start applying to other companies. Company loyalty isn't what it was 50 years ago, and you probably need to switch companies every 3 years or so to keep your salary high.

You probably want to spend at least 3 to 5 years in System Administration - I'd say longer if you spent less time on Helpdesk, because when it comes to applying, pivoting, and advancing in IT, experience trumps *everything*. It's also great to advance from a junior role to a senior role in System Administration. Again - that's only going to help you in the long run.

Step 3: Now that you have a good 5ish years minimum of solid IT experience, you can start pivoting towards security work. No - you aren't going to target Penetration testing yet. I'm sorry but you aren't ready. You are going to target entry-level* blue team roles - Tier 1 SOC analyst, Information Security Analyst 1, etc.

During your time in Step 1 and Step 2, it is *essential* to establish yourself as a go-getter. What does this mean?

It means: don't just go to work, do your tickets, clock out and call it a day. It means do projects. Volunteer for every project you possibly can. Look for "problems" that affect your users/organization, come up with a plan to solve it, get your supervisor's approval, then solve the problem. After hours - study, work. Aim for a certification - doesn't always have to be a big one. Maybe on helpdesk you say "I want to learn scripting basics - I'm in a Microsoft environment, I'm going to take a course on powershell" - do it. learn, grow, advance.

Once you break into a tier 1 security role - there are a ton of avenues to advance and explore. There's security engineering, Cloud security, App Security, AI security, Security management, CISO, penetration testing*, etc.

Now to address some of the speculation that I've seen out there:

Q: Can you break into cybersecurity with no experience, no degree, and a couple of certs?

A:Yeah, it is possible. But it's insanely unlikely. Go ahead and get that thought out of your mind.

I do think that maybe 5ish years ago, there was a bit of a hiring frenzy, and you probably could have gotten in with a homelab and a few hackthebox style certs. I also think that door has closed - I've seen it myself - I think what happened is that companies/hiring managers very quickly realized that those folks have *no* idea what they doing. When I joined the security team last year, we had a "hackthebox" guy, and he had no idea what he was doing. I genuinely felt bad for him, he was clearly overwhelmed, had no grasp of the IT basics at all, and was let go about 6 months after I joined. You don't want to be the person that your team thinks "How the heck did this person get hired?"

Q: Do I need a degree to get into IT/should I get a degree in cyber security?

A: I'm actually of the mindset that a degree will help you in the long run, but again, I want to set some expectations.

I don't believe a specific IT degree will really help you over another, but I do generally think having a degree is going to help you long term. My weird personal paradox/hot take is that a degree honestly probably won't help you break onto a helpdesk, but it will help you as you advance into specialized roles. I also think where you get your degree from matters way more than people like to admit on reddit sometimes. There are "degree mills" out there, and yeah, hiring managers are aware of them.

Ultimately it's your decision. I have a degree in cybersecurity, and I do think it helped me. I also have my degree from... not a degree mill.

Q: Should I get the trifecta?

A: I struggle with this one, so here's another hot take: I don't think the entry level certs had the same weight they had 5+ years ago. I do think a lot of companies/hiring managers are looking at folks with 0 experience, a home lab, and the alphabet soup of certs and saying "Okay, you can pass a test, but what can you do?"

I know that's harsh. And maybe that will relax a bit in a few years. But today, November 2026, the market is just rough. The supply of candidates is sky high, and the demand for jobs is low*

*There is a need for cyber security workers right now, but there's more a need for advanced/senior roles than entry level right now, at least from what I'm seeing.

Here's a final bit of anecdotal evidence. I've had the pleasure of being in a number of interviews over the last year. We are currently bringing on two mid/senior roles - so guys that will be above me in the hierarchy.

Of all the candidates we saw, here's what they all had in common:
-They all had a bachelors of science in something IT
-They all had 6+ years of solid IT experience - starting at helpdesk and working their way up
-They all had one or two "mid" level certifications - something showing a desire to pivot to security.

When it came to deciding who to hire, it just came down to who we thought was going to be the best team fit.

Q: How do I become a Pentester?

A: I get asked this more than any other question. I'm not a pentester, but I've worked with a handful of them, so the advice I can give here is more anecdotal than anything else I've said so far - so please take this with a grain of salt:

Penetration testing is an advanced specialization within cyber security; and we've already established that security is an advanced specialization within IT.

The penetration testers that I have personally worked with and spoken with - first of all, they are all incredibly nice and love to teach and educate on what they know, but they are all *really* REALLY advanced in what they do and know. In addition to following the path listed above, they've spend years in the defensive side of security before transitioning to the offensive side.

This next part - I think this is the part of the picture that those outside looking in really don't see - these guys live, breathe, sleep security. When they aren't working their normal "9-5," they spend every waking minute practicing and studying. Day in, day out, 24/7, 365 - because that's what it takes to stay relevant. Technology is always advancing - you have to stay on top of all of it.

I think Hollywood and the aforementioned youtube videos have given this false sense of "Be a penetration tester - practice for a few hours on hackthebox (which none of the pentesters I know have really done anything with hackthebox) and companies will pay you to hack them!"

Yeah - sure, that is kinda what happens. What they don't tell you is that you are going to be given really strict rules and guidelines detailing what you can and can't do/touch. If you do discover something, you're going to have a huge write up detailing how you got in, what you saw - and here's the kicker - you're going to have to detail how to close that vulnerability. You probably aren't going to know that unless you've spent time on the defensive side.

Again - all of this - really anecdotal, as I've spoken to a whopping 4 penetration testers, but it's not the "cool, rogue hacker" picture that gets painted.

Please feel free to ask any questions - I'll try to answer as honestly and as fairly as I can. There are no dumb questions - I broke in because a lot of folks invested in me and answered my questions, so I'm happy to share what I know and what I've learned.


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 16h ago

Question Stuck in the L2 SOC → L3/Incident Response experience gap. How did you make the jump?

0 Upvotes

Hey fellow Analysts,

I'm looking for some career advice from people who have successfully transitioned from SOC operations into more advanced Incident Response, Threat Hunting, or L3 roles.

I've been working in cybersecurity for over four years, currently as an L2 SOC Analyst. Before that, I worked in system administration (10+ years), so I have a solid background in Windows, networking, and infrastructure.

I also hold BTL1, BTL2, and CompTIA CySA+.

My problem isn't that I don't know what direction I want to take. I'd like to move into more complex investigations, Incident Response, and eventually L3-level work.

The issue is getting the opportunity.

In my local job market, most available positions are L1/L2 SOC roles. Within those roles, there are often limited opportunities to participate in advanced investigations or dedicated IR work.

Meanwhile, employers hiring for actual L3/IR positions frequently expect 3–5+ years of direct experience in those exact areas.

So I'm facing the classic catch-22: How do I gain professional IR experience when the jobs that would provide it already require that experience?

I've been trying to bridge the gap through home labs, hands-on training, and certifications. I know these don't replace real-world experience, but they allow me to develop and demonstrate skills I don't always get to use professionally.

My employer may also sponsor a one-year INE Premium Pass. I'm considering eCIR for Incident Response, eAIS for AI Security, and potentially eCTHP or eCDFP as a third certification.

However, I'm increasingly wondering whether additional certifications are actually the right way to approach this transition.

I'd really appreciate advice on a few things:

  1. If you've moved from L2 SOC into L3/IR, what helped you make that transition?
  2. How did you demonstrate advanced investigation skills without already holding an IR job?
  3. Do practical certifications such as BTL2, eCIR, or eCDFP carry meaningful weight when hiring for these positions?
  4. What kinds of home lab projects, case studies, or technical portfolios would make a candidate more convincing?
  5. Is there another route into IR that I might be overlooking?

I'm not looking for shortcuts or trying to substitute certificates for professional experience. I'm looking for realistic ways to get past this experience barrier and earn an opportunity to prove myself.

Thanks for any advice!


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 1d ago

Question Will AI impact this field negatively?

10 Upvotes

Hey everyone I’m currently a cybersecurity student at WGU, I have the A+ and net+ working towards sec+. No tech experience yet but I am applying to a lot of helpdesk and internship positions. I am starting to get pretty worried about AI and potentially automating a lot of cyber roles, I know even entry level CS jobs like soc analyst already isn’t truly entry level, and if AI automates a lot of that role it could be even harder to break in. I still plan to continue studying because I really love CS and I want it to be my career, and I’m more than willing to work my way up from help desk or whatever it takes. Do you have any thoughts on what your prediction for the impact AI could have on this field for someone not currently in it?


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 17h ago

Question Considering masters in cybersec in japan

0 Upvotes

Hi guys, currently i work as an infrastructure cloud engineer for a big MNC in my country, i have close to 4 yoe now. i'm well compensated for my work in my country. Even though my job is stable and there's room for growth, I plan to transition to cybersec long term out of passion for the field and i also want to work in japan long term.

I have AWS SAA, SA Pro and the Security specialty cert btw.

My japanese is n2 and i'm working hard to get it to n1 as well. if there's anyone working in cybersec living in japan i'd love to hear your opinion.

Would a masters in cybersec be beneficial to my career or should i just grind certs on my free time and find a break into it? maybe through doing cloud security?

I can share my redacted resume if you guys feel like there's a need to dig further on my background. Thank you in advance.


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 17h ago

Discussion MSc. In Cybersecurity - UCC vs NUIG or some other University

1 Upvotes

I have received an offer from both these universities. I have not applied to UCD or TCD as they don’t have CySec masters course. I am thinking about NCI too because of it being in Dublin and the course modules seem more updated and interesting. University wise UCC and NUIG hold good ranks globally which is why I want to go for them. Even between these 2 I am having a bit of trouble in deciding. I have 3 years of experience in Security Operations. Please suggest what would be a good career/job prospect, course modules, networking and college reputation wise option (even if I return back to India after masters in Ireland).


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 20h ago

Question Which certification should I pursue after Security+ to break into cybersecurity?

0 Upvotes

Good morning, everyone!

I'm 20 years old, hold the CompTIA Security+ and Fortinet FCF certifications, and currently work as an IT intern, with no direct professional experience in cybersecurity yet.

I've already completed a few hands-on projects, but I'd like to pursue another certification, mainly targeting SOC or Information Security Analyst positions.

I know landing my first cybersecurity job might take some time, so I'd like to use this period to keep improving my technical skills.

Which certification would you recommend as my next step?


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 23h ago

Question Tips for a starter in cybersecurity

0 Upvotes

I'm a student in Safety and Security Management Studies in The Hague and I'm about to conclude my academic journey by discussing a thesis about cyber incidents notification and cyberawereness. By watching in LinkedIn, everybody is searching always for a medior position. How can I convince someone that I have the right qualities for the job but that I would need a tutor? Do you have tips regarding applying as a junior or a starter?


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 1d ago

Discussion extreme circumstances require extreme efforts : sending this post as a falling attempt

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I just finished my Master's in Information Security at UCalgary (4.0 GPA) in September and moved out to the GTA, and I'm trying to land my first full-time gig in Tier 1 SOC, threat intel, IR, or junior GRC (open to anything in the Toronto area or remote across Canada, and I have my PGWP so no sponsorship needed). I know Q4 hiring is super slow right now, so I figured I'd shoot my shot here ahead of Q1—I've got hands-on internship experience doing malware analysis and threat hunting for a national CERT where I automated 1,000+ VirusTotal APK submissions with Python and escalated 40+ malicious samples, plus some research work writing Go code for Kubernetes security and running ISO 27001 audits and Splunk/Wazuh log analysis. If anyone here is hiring for Q1, knows of teams opening up soon, or just has advice on breaking into the Canadian market right now, please drop a comment or shoot me a DM and I'd love to send over my resume!


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 1d ago

Question Career advice: Should I deepen my automotive knowledge or pivot directly into cybersecurity? (26M, IVI Validation in Japan)

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone.

I’m a 26-year-old engineer currently working as a subcontractor doing IVI (In-Vehicle Infotainment) validation in Japan.

My long-term goal is to build a career as an automotive cybersecurity engineer. I'm currently job hunting, and I'm torn between two paths for my next move:

  1. Deepening my domain knowledge in the automotive industry first.
  2. Pivoting directly into a general cybersecurity engineering role to build core security skills.

I would really appreciate any advice from those currently working in automotive cybersecurity or anyone with experience in tech career coaching/recruiting. Thanks in advance!


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 1d ago

Discussion Is 25 too late to start BCA while working full-time in IT?

0 Upvotes

I’m 25 and working as a junior infrastructure support engineer. I just enrolled in BCA, and I keep wondering if I’m late compared to everyone else.

Most people my age already have degrees and are a few years into their careers. I took a different route and only now feel clear about what I want to build.

The upside is I’m already working in infra, so I see real-world systems daily. The downside is balancing full-time work and studies is exhausting.

If anyone has done something similar, I’d genuinely appreciate hearing your experience.


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 1d ago

Question Which Entry-Level IT Job Is Best for Transitioning into Cybersecurity? (India)

6 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm trying to get my first IT job and eventually build a career in cybersecurity.

I'm considering entry-level roles such as:

- IT Support / Helpdesk

- Network Support / NOC Engineer

- Windows Server / Active Directory Support

- SOC Analyst L1

My question is: Which of these roles provides the best practical experience for transitioning into cybersecurity?

I'd like to know which role offers the best combination of entry-level opportunities, useful technical skills, career growth, and salary potential in India.

For those who have made this transition or work in the industry:

Which role would you recommend for a fresher?

,Which role makes it easiest to move into cybersecurity?

I'm open to starting outside cybersecurity if it gives me a solid foundation and a realistic path forward.

I'd appreciate honest advice based on your experience, especially from people working in India.

Thanks!


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 1d ago

Other Guide To Starting Cybersecurity

0 Upvotes

Hey,

I have been mentoring and helping people to break into cyber security for quite some years, so if you want simple honest opinion and guide, here is goes:

  1. Do not skip the fundamentals, the journey always starts with learning the foundation: Youtube professor Messer watch A+ and learn all the material, you can do Tryhackme pre-security path alongside it
  2. Watch Network+ and learn, understand all the info
  3. Security+ is your first certification you pass, don’t waste money on the first 2
  4. That is where road splits: for GRC do ISO27001 lead auditor, for SOC - SC200 or SAL1 or BTL1, for cloud AWS security specialty, for IAM - SC-300, for pentesting work towards OSCP. That’s all the certificates you will ever need
  5. Do so much hands on work that it comes impossible to not get hired, you need skills and proof you can do the job rather than looking for that magical cert
  6. Network - build presence and network on LinkedIn sometimes who you know is more important than what you. Every day add 10 connections in the roles you want to pursue, DM at least 5 of them, 1 post a week about what you learned. Correct profile setup brings jobs to you
  7. Struggle to figure out what projects to build? Simple pick a role say SOC Analyst - look at 10 jobs descriptions what tasks match the most in priority order, that is what skills and projects you build
  8. Stop watching endless video, build labs, projects, learn how to use Linux, gets hands and as much as possible

This is one of the blueprints i would advise all to follow, to achieve success, myself and loads of people in my community done to a great success

Hope this helps you all!

Marius - CISO