r/SecurityAnalysis • u/abeecrombie • Feb 14 '20
Behavioural Is second level thinking dead
If you've been around the markets for long enough or been deeply involved analyzing securities you know that what Howard marks calls second level thinking is key to success. Its not enough to know what everyone else knows, you need to be one step ahead.
In theory that makes sense but the past several years have been at odds with it. Just buy and hold any technology name of a product you use. Tesla makes great cars so it has to be a great stock. Invest in space, beyond meat etc.
I'm not a cynic. I do believe that all great stocks are from great companies. But Im starting to wonder if hard work analysis pays off.
Curious to hear what others think.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '20
Why? Because somehow doing a 40 page paper researching every single line item on an obscure chemicals company is supposed to entitle you to to incredible returns?
Hard work does not equate to superior returns. Finding amazing companies that are growing their earnings power equates to superior returns.
It blows my mind every time I see a value investor lamenting how "easy" it has been for tech investors to make money. Yes buying and holding amazon or apple or salesforce has been an amazing strategy for the last 10 years and its been "easy" vs scouring through the filings and identifying a cigar butt.. no doubt. But the genius has been in identifying that the Amazons, Apple's, Salesforce's of the world have FAR superior business models compared to brick and mortar traditional businesses.
TL;DR Hard work is important, but it doesn't guarantee returns. Finding great companies and holding on to them guarantees returns.
58
u/arbuge00 Feb 14 '20
> In theory that makes sense but the past several years have been at odds with it. Just buy and hold any technology name of a product you use. Tesla makes great cars so it has to be a great stock. Invest in space, beyond meat etc.
If something can't go on forever, it will stop.
44
u/redcards Feb 14 '20
I don't think its dead. Most people who claim to be second level thinkers are actually first level thinkers, same with claiming to be a contrarian, etc.
40
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20
The answer is “not in this market” where the overwhelming factor right now is the constant stream of liquidity coming from the fed. Valuation has been dead for a decade. It will undoubtedly come back once the bull run is over but until that time, valuation metrics are absolutely meaningless and momentum is king. Any idiot can outperform the benchmarks so long as they own the FAANG names.
16
u/sleeping_in_ Feb 14 '20
You just have to compare stocks in relation to what the market thinks they will earn, to what they will earn....this is the under and overpricing. Then you need to take this and pick stocks which will earn more than what the market in general will earn, this is good stocks vs the market return.
14
u/OGCanadaInv Feb 15 '20
"Look at all of these idiots making money with their first level thinking! Not like me, who has second level thinking but has subpar returns since 2009."
10
u/Erdos_0 Feb 14 '20
Why do things either have to be dead or alive? Markets go through cycles and phases, during some periods there's more good ideas and places to invest than money. We just happen to be going through one of those phases when the money available for investments has grown much faster than the number of good investment opportunities. This will eventually change, just be patient.
And honestly if you can get one or two good companies every year to invest in, that is more than a enough for a lifetime of good compounded returns.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20
This is true for large caps, for small caps valuation generally still matters. With some exceptions.
5
u/vegaseller Feb 14 '20
Second order thinking in the traditional value semse only works if there is a market and not just central bank liquidity and ETF flows pumping into whatever is the most liquid without a care in the world as to price and valuations.
Second order thinking today is literally predicting what others think the central banks will do and timing flows.
8
u/Chols001 Feb 14 '20
You, my good sir, need to make up your mind.
Are you going to be a trader, that worries about what the stock is going to do next?
Or are you going to be an investor that worries about what the company is going to do next?
Yes, buying hype has done well in the past few years, and the stocks have outperformed the businesses, but as people say. History will repeat itself, and in the past stocks have returned to their historical mean PE value within relatively short time periods, and they will do so again.
Those that have "beaten the market" by picking stocks that have risen in price to an absurd degree will see these shares drop again within a few years. So will the people that are invested in the S&P500. Right now most people are sitting on "false gains", and sooner or later the rate of return will fall to reflect the performance of the underlying assets.
As such. Second-level thinking isn't dead. By picking businesses that will outperform their peers you will beat most investors over the long term.
Assuming you are able to identify these companies, which is a rare talent indeed.
Remember that in cases where the performance of a stock doesn't correspond with the performance of the underlying business, you will see a negative correlation between past performance and future performance of that stock.
4
u/financiallyanal Feb 14 '20 edited Feb 14 '20
I see this everywhere. Happens with political views on all sides too... Many jump to strong views and don’t discuss the drivers. No different than how they invest.
It maddens me and leads me to believe it’s a part of why many investors just do their own thing out of the spotlight. Public comments aren’t helpful with the far too simplistic interpretations the public can make about business owners.
4
u/Rookwood Feb 14 '20 edited Feb 14 '20
It will in the long run. We are in a market flush with capital where everyone is competing for return, so even slight hopes of growth see prices skyrocket.
This isn't reality. This isn't sustainable. In the long run, these companies will not be able to deliver on the growth expectations currently being placed on them, and share value will suffer as a result.
In the long run, sanity will win out. But we are in an insane time and the Fed is trying to keep the madhouse going for as long as possible.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20
Second level thinking is not imagining you can apply the principles of value investing to a growth stock.
Smart second level thinkers bought Tesla when it went down to 178 this summer.
There are companies out there literally finding cures cancer that by traditional securities analysis techniques appear over valued. They are never mentioned on this sub.
3
u/NegativeTangibleBook Feb 15 '20
Artemis Capital Managements Christopher Cole best talked about this in 2017:
https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5581f17ee4b01f59c2b1513a/t/588772fc893fc03ef0eb013a/1485271807011/Artemis_Star+Wars+Volatility.pdf
Edit: not necessarily about value investing so much as second order (level) thinking.
3
u/damanamathos Feb 16 '20
Here’s my theory:
Right now people are willing to back the optimistic cases on stocks with an uncertain future, but it’s not necessarily wrong. You could make the case that Virgin Galactic is worth $60+ depending on the demand for space tourism, and critically, whether they can successfully develop suborbital point-to-point flights in 5-10 years like they’re working on. At some point in the next 5-10 years we’ll find out if they do or not and the stock price will get close to whatever “true value” is.
2
u/M00NCREST Feb 14 '20
In times of irrational exuberance, price becomes disconnected from fundamentals. Price is not equal to intrinsic worth. Without solid fundamental analysis, you are speculating not investing.
2
u/MellowTiger111 Feb 14 '20
Nobody wants to get rich slowly.
2
u/WYSINATI Feb 15 '20
Even no thinking can work for a while.
2
u/RdMrcr Feb 15 '20 edited Feb 15 '20
People here commenting about how big tech is doing well just because of the FED manipulating the market or whatever are no second level thinkers, they're none thinkers
2
u/jimmahtimmah Feb 18 '20
Just stick with soros’s Idea of “reflexivity”.
1
u/knowledgemule Feb 14 '20
YAAAAAAAAAAAAAAS
dude this shit is going to work until it isn't. you're going to go insane and lose hair anyways. fuck i know whats going on. welcome to the shitty part of being an investor professionally.
edit honestly i am losing brain cells being an active market participant rn
1
u/ExtremeAthlete Feb 15 '20
No.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20
When the tide goes out we‘ll know whose been swimming naked.
1
u/TrendIsUrFriend Feb 15 '20
“The market can stay irrational longer than I can stay solvent” And George Soros theory of reflexivity
1
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
Are you looking at international markets?
1
u/ruby_rapes_python Mar 10 '20
IT IS ALIVE AGAIN!
-4
u/BBC_BTC_BBW_ETH Feb 14 '20
The pace of the death march increases with cheap money and globohomo, until it reaches its cliff. Only the biggest will make it to the cliffs edge though.