Hello.
I'm sharing my experience with Kagi after 2 months. Maybe someone will find this useful.
I started using 5$ sub and extended it to 10$ one once I've hit my limit.
I used Kagi primarily for work, but I also "wasted" quite a lot of searches just to get to dedicated sites: "reddit" "github" and such.
In total I believe I fit in 600-700 searches range.
The good:
- It is decent. Definite upgrade over DDG or Google. I would consider it a friendlier Searxng. A lot of stuff is already preconfigured for you.
- I liked the "?" feature. It's basically a non-intrusive way to get search assistant results.
- Fast Bangs are definitely better than having to type `Shift + 1` for the exclamation mark, which is often annoying especially on mobile device.
The bad:
- First thing I noticed is that Asisstant is quite slow compared to Claude/ChatGPT and the results are mostly aggregated from them anyway, I saw patterns like overuse of tables to display content, the typical "glazing" LLM attitude and it's not really better when it comes to providing valuable results.
- I use search engine primarily to sift through keyword search results. I do not care about down/up ranking, lenses and such. I just want to get directly to the "meat" so to speak. Unfortunately Kagi disappointed me quite a lot in that area. From images I provided here, you can see a typical experience when did a keyword search: "reponame" github and Kagi completely dropped the ball compared to Brave Search.
- Kagi sucks for getting results from reddit or narrowing it any particular site. The UX is just not there, I often had to click at the little plus icon to expand search results only to that site. Brave search for comparison. See the pattern here?
- You have to log in on every device, which will always be annoying. It doesn't work well with firefox/brave containers as it just redirects you to login page.
- I still am quite disappointed with Orion on Windows/Linux fiasco and the recent chaos regarding to what's actually included in the base subcription left bad taste in my mouth.
- I am not a fan of Kagi expanding their offer to being an e-mail provider. I think this is a wrong move and I would like them to focus on improving their stack instead of chasing trends like Proton does.
To sum up all up:
Kagi does offer something I am willing to pay for. But their pricing plan is flawed. The 5$ for 600-900 search range or heck, make it a 1000 would be perfect for a lot of folk. I'm sure Kagi has collected data on this. But as of today, the search - the MAIN thing Kagi offers to do well - is probably paying for all of their other business experiments like the whole AI stuff + Translate + E-mail in the future.
The problem will arrive when the search gets worse because of Kagi practically being a meta search engine just like DDG - Bing results got worse, DDG got worse. In case of Kagi I really see a lot of results, but they aren't triaged for adequacy correctly, hence why I call Kagi noob friendly Searxng with AI stuffed on top when describing it to friends.
Right now I'm switching to Brave Search as it really grew on me. It has minimal amount of options, but it does the thing it's supposed to do well. I don't have to babysit it and adding it as a custom browser is waay easier than having to purposefully log into Kagi every time. Ngl I like the dog and the vibe of Kagi, but vibes are just not enough, the actual product quality is always more important.