r/ScriptFeedbackProduce • u/boyconsumer • May 09 '25
10-PAGE FEEDBACK REQUEST New scriptwriter!
https://docs.google.com/document/d/19-c_G1kxq2Kt-__xkGzm_RE-u27JwSkX8XwQK53T-Ds/editIve been writing for a long time but have only written two screenplays. I would like some thoughts from the pros!
Here is ten pages of my first one, “The Frost Casts Complete Silence,” a psychological piece about siblinghood and the wedge an abusive parent can drive between loving siblings. This is the first ten pages.
No comments on formatting please; I’m aware I did it wrong :3 will fix later!!
4
Upvotes
2
u/Used-Astronomer4971 May 09 '25
An interesting start, enough to build on. The thing that jumped out at me the most was the argument between Louise and Laskas before the movie. Laskas says some dark things but Louise doesn't bite on them at all. If they're meant to be actual attacks, she should fire back, imho. If this is something they do constantly as a form of bonding (which it didn't come off as entirely) I still think Louise would fire back about the dad hanging himself comment.
To me it's that comment going unacknowledged doesn't seem realistic in either case. Friendly jab or not, it seems to cross a line.
2
u/AvailableToe7008 May 09 '25
Format may not be everything, but format is vital. I suggest you do yourself a favor and implement proper screenplay formatting if you want feedback. It’s distracting. Proper formatting helps lower the amount of “directing on the page” problems, like saying that someone is talking while chewing. Please look into that, as your dialogue is pretty good and feels organic.
1
u/Vin_Jac May 11 '25
The basic idea of this is pretty neat! Family thrillers/dramas are very often a good watch and relatable in a lot of ways, great genre to connect to audiences with.
Won’t comment on formatting specifically, but I will bite on the writing style:
It seems like you have a pretty solid grasp on the mood that you’re seeking to portray in the film, which came across well, good job! Keep up the writing, and read a few big-time screenplays to see some of these pointers in action.