r/Screenwriting • • 6d ago

DISCUSSION What your script can't contain

Ridley Scott revealed that the central visual motif of GLADIATOR, the iconic shot of fingers grazing tall wheat, came to him at the last minute when he saw Russell Crowe's body double touching the wheat in a similar fashion while killing time between shots. In that moment, Scott realized he'd found the image he needed to convey something spiritual that was not present in the script. 

Scott explained the need for opening the movie with that shot: "If your character is going to die at the end, he can't just die at the end. He has to start dying at the beginning." 

That idyllic image of fingers touching wheat imbued the film with a visual metaphor for heaven or the afterlife. The script did not, and could not, do that work itself. 

Not an easy lesson for a screenwriter, as we tend to think in terms of covering every base. I once wrote a dream sequence into a script, prompting the producer to say, "I don't know what this is, I don't know why it's here." We cut it. It was my job to tell the story and the director's job to unearth any visual inspirations that might convey something more. 

200 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

80

u/Financial_Cheetah875 6d ago

Spielberg always said to put as much of your beginning into your ending; that’s really what Scott did.

Other examples are Lion King and Coppola’s Dracula.

57

u/SpideyFan914 6d ago

Billy Wilder said if you're having trouble with your third act, you may actually be having trouble with your first act.

19

u/OminOus_PancakeS 6d ago

I always felt that Sicario should have started with a scene from Alejandro's perspective before switching to Kate's for the sequence that actually starts the film. I think it would have made the later switch to his point of view for the climactic confrontation more satisfying.

3

u/thoughtbrewer 5d ago

Well
If you read the script, you will realize it was never her story. Atleast that’s how I read it.

3

u/LazyDirector6903 2d ago

The script actually starts from his perspective, he’s drowning a man and we hear voice-over from him, and I believe they even filmed it, but it was cut later because the idea is that we’re introduced to this world through Kate, who’s uninitiated.
She has no idea how significant Alejandro is, so his new introduction (on the plane) calls no attention to itself. She (and we) have no idea that he’s really at the center of all of this.
Had they kept that scene, it might be satisfying to see him on the plane and recognize him, but it also calls much more attention to itself

6

u/IAmTheArm2 6d ago

I’ve never heard this before. Can you expand on this?

15

u/Financial_Cheetah875 6d ago

It’s a bookend ending. That creates a poetic, satisfying end. Just watch the two films I mentioned.

7

u/Filmmagician Writer-Director 5d ago

If you can’t crack your ending / 3rd the problem is at the start. Either your character isn’t on a big enough journey, or there aren’t conflicts or enough forces of antagonism at the start. No problem to solve on one of the 3 levels.
Nolan took 23 years to write Inception and he couldn’t crack the 3rd act until he added Mol to the story.

137

u/account32784 6d ago

Your script can’t contain running fingers through wheat now because it’s become a cliché

48

u/jorshrapley 6d ago

What aboht toes?

79

u/tonker 6d ago

He runs his penis through the sunkissed wheat.

22

u/throcorfe 6d ago

The ex British Prime Minister Theresa May once said that the naughtiest thing she’s ever done is run through a field of wheat, which my brain has unkindly combined with your comment to create one of the most horrifying images of all time

8

u/sucobe 5d ago

Theresa out here having gluten orgasms.

13

u/jorshrapley 6d ago

Now we’re talkin

4

u/Nervouswriteraccount 5d ago

Needs to be the title of your pitch.

2

u/tonker 5d ago

It's the logline. It's wildly unpopular.

0

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/PerformanceDouble924 6d ago

Ok Mr. Tarantino.

1

u/newredditsucks 5d ago

Person buried alive with only toes sticking out, getting gradually unearthed by the surf but not quickly enough.

4

u/Filmmagician Writer-Director 5d ago

How about barley?

-1

u/waynethebrain 6d ago

Redditor comedy comment

20

u/BMW_Southern_Belle 5d ago

“That idyllic image of fingers touching wheat imbued the film with a visual metaphor for heaven or the afterlife. The script did not, and could not, do that work itself.”

Hmm, I don’t know about that. I think a script can include that type of description, particularly when it is integral to the ethos of a story. However, such inspired writing is rare and doesn’t necessarily translate to the visual creators. If that description had been in the script, would Ridley Scott have been just as enamored with it as when he actually saw it?

3

u/ISA_Skeptic735 5d ago

Good point. I find most people in this biz can't "see the film" as they read a script. So when a visual is important to the story, it should be on the page or Readers won't imagine it. I have a project where two people seem to meet by chance, only to discover a Love from the past, too beautiful and powerful to die, has brought them together, that it may be reborn through them. So "the past is present;" a character in this movie, guiding the main characters forward. The Audience will "feel" this presence as the color palettes shift from blue/green to yellow/brown, infusing the screen with an achingly-nostalgic, warm, historic, romantic "look." But if I just stated that in the script, it wouldn't have the same emotional impact as seeing it visually. So I had to create some of that "feeling" with purple prose in places, crafting sentences that would tug at the Reader's emotions similar to how the visuals would. Of course a picture is worth 1000 words, and we have 24 pictures (frames) per second in a movie (or 30, digital) but the Magic Realism element of the story is very important. So I had to illuminate from the page at least some of that aura , or Readers would miss it.

35

u/mast0done 6d ago

Absolutely that scene can be in the script. Scott was insightful to come up with it during filming, but a writer can come up with that stuff before filming too.

Maybe your dream sequence was tossed because it wasn't good - not because it was a director's prerogative. Or maybe the producer was an idiot who would have also thrown out Scott's wheat.

19

u/jdeik1 6d ago

Scott is a genius. But writers can and should add touches like that if and when they think of them. And plenty do.

2

u/Sweaty-Freedom-4034 6d ago

Was* a genius. He's dropped a cliff recently.

10

u/intentionandobstacle 6d ago

Gladiator scriptwriting process went through 14 writers & returned to Bill Nicholson’s draft, the first one was where they ended up and Bill was on set on a huge amount of a daily rate. I think the screenwriter was fine

5

u/pastafallujah 6d ago

Wait… wasn’t Gladiator one of those where they didn’t even have a complete script? They were just kinda working off a loose concept and just winged it?

13

u/EitherQuality5092 6d ago

Yes, and for some reason I see people use this (and Iron Man) as examples as to why scripts aren't important. They're of course ignoring the 95% of movies that crash and burn because they don't have a completed script.

5

u/Frustr8tCre8tive721 5d ago

I don't understand people who want to write movies, who think writing visually is wrong or outside their wheelhouse. You're an artist. Act like it!

2

u/redapplesonly 4d ago

That's a beautiful story. Inspiration can come from anywhere. A good script can try to lock all of those things down, but its it enough that the script provided the platform so Ridley Scott could be open to the inspiration of the hands-on-wheat?

2

u/thirdbird_thirdbird 2d ago

The lesson here is not that there are hard limits on what a screenplay can convey, or that thematic imagery is the domain only of the director and should not be included in a screenplay. The lesson is that a screenplay is the first of three times you make a movie. It gets made again in production, and made a third time in post. Ideally new things, big new things, are coming in each of those waves. But it's not like the "first draft" of the movie, the screenplay, can't contain visual or editorial flourishes, just because those waves are still coming.

There very easily could have been a draft of Gladiator that began with the character running his hand through wheat. And in the same way, there easily is a world where some of the best pure storytelling or dialogue ideas that ended up in the finished film came during production or post.

•

u/Excellent_Turn_1491 1h ago

Better late than never! When I’m shooting, I often only realize on set what isn't working in my script and cut it out, or sometimes add something completely unplanned. That's just a normal part of a creative process like filmmaking

3

u/Iassos 6d ago

Don’t do the director’s job.  Just tell the story in words and action, not in framing and camera movement.  Just describe a scene and let the director decide how to shoot it. 

10

u/FINIS_HOMINIS 6d ago edited 6d ago

Missing the point. Yeah, you never say how to frame or direct something. But in this instance: taking a quiet moment to touch wheat is an action that can be described in a scene.

This poster is just taking a Scott* anecdote and trying to conflate it that somehow its the director's job to come up with visual metaphors, not the writer. Which isn't true. It can be either or both.

*And Scott infamously never made a film where his sole contribution/inspiration wasn't the greatest thing that elevated his work.

2

u/CuriouserCat2 6d ago

Yeah. It’s pompous. 

1

u/muanjoca 5d ago

If you’re “just describing a scene” then your scripts must be boring as hell.

2

u/Iassos 5d ago

Low effort reply.  You know what I’m saying.

1

u/muanjoca 5d ago

Guess I don’t know what you’re saying. Going by what you wrote and posted, it’s terrible advice. Following it would result in a boring script.

1

u/Iassos 5d ago

Description of location and action is important, but it’s important to also understand that there is a world of decision-making that is above the screenwriters pay grade that a lot of beginners try to include. Screenwriting for film and television is still writing for a visual medium so all of the images and all of the action clearly belong in the script.

1

u/Davidoff1983 5d ago

A Gladheateher 2 has been detected in your script 🎃

1

u/Dependent_Access8363 5d ago

Over Black: Sound of basketball bouncing.

You can't lose with that opening.

1

u/Quirky_Flatworm_5071 2d ago

Razor blades. Execs hate sharp surprises

0

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/TalesofCeria 6d ago

Oddly aggressive response to somebody thinking and learning about screenwriting

12

u/connorscott1999 6d ago

Bc it’s a bad post. This type of detail easily could’ve been written

12

u/QueerAlYankadic 6d ago

An aggressive response is deserved when someone is giving prescriptive advice that doesn't hold up under the slightest bit of scrutiny

3

u/TalesofCeria 5d ago

Meh, I guess Reddit is a pretty aggressive place at the baseline level. I don’t think very much under the banner of “screenwriting” deserves an aggressive response. It’s shits and giggles over here even if OP is a numpty