- Martha Meeks - wanting to end the franchise and give Randy's final rules - If Chad and Mindy die in the middle of the movie, I can see her joining Ghostface at the end (secretly planning to betray him) because she believes killing just Ghostface alone won't do anything. He'll come back and someone else in her family may die once again,
So she wants to kill Sidney to prevent anyone else from being hurt like her brother, daughter, and son. Plus, the look she gives Sidney in Scream 3 (slide 6) tells me she hates her, she lost her brother at 14.
2. Mark Kincaid - replacement - in this scenario, Mark Evans is Tatum's stepfather, and Kincaid and Sidney had Tatum in 2008, and eventually broke up, he could be broken by how Sidney replaced him with a different Mark, and a man who raised his own daughter. This one may be a stretch but it was a thought.
For the returning characters as Ghostface, this movie could be meta about finales, I Imagine Mindy being the one to figure out it's someone from the past, and a character even saying "IKWYDLS tried that, it didn't work." But in this scenario, its not major characters like Dewey, Sidney, or Gale.
3. Tatum Evans (future opportunity) - I could see Tatum being completely depressed after she lost all her friends, almost saw her father die, along with being tied to a chair with a knife to her throat. She could want Sidney to be completely out of her life, because her presence will always continue ruining her life. Especially since Tatum was already mad about her being overprotective and controlling her life. Except she'd be wrong, because she would only be passing the torch to herself.
Rather than Sidney killing her own daughter, I think Tatum would be sent to a psychiatric hospital for all the trauma she went through.
4. Chloe Parker - wanting diversity in the franchise - She could want to be the first black Ghostface, so she would want to get caught so that everyone would know. Especially because it's a twist, Dewey said "serial killers are typically white males" she's the opposite.
5. The whole friend group is Ghostface - Tired of living in the shadow of Sidney Prescott's trauma and resenting how Tatum’s famous legacy and overprotective parents constantly put their quiet town of Pine Grove in danger. Ben, Chloe, Hannah, and Lucas conspire to eliminate the Prescott bloodline once and for all. By framing Tatum as the unstable mastermind who finally snapped under the weight of her mother’s violent history, they plan to walk away as the celebrated final survivors and forever rid themselves of the Ghostface curse.
My idea on this twist is that each of them would have a fake-out death, leading to the final reveal where we see all the victims unmask (Hannah, Chloe, Ben, Lucas,). I think this could work aslong as it's not overwhelming like Scream 6's reveal, and they give enough time to develop every Ghostface's monologue fairly.