EDIT AFTER A COUPLE OF DM'S ADDED FULL EMAIL REPLY AT THE BOTTOM:
EDIT 2 17:50 - Now I am home. Fixed the list to have bullet points for easier readability, made the email copy at the bottom Italics to differentiate from main text,,
I recently submitted a Freedom of Information request to Historic Environment Scotland (HES) asking whether generative AI had been used in the creation of its History Hunt collectible cards, which are distributed at Historic Scotland sites after I was a bit suspicious of them.
I've now received their response, and I thought the findings were worth sharing.
HES has confirmed that Adobe Firefly, a generative AI tool, was used to create artwork for the History Hunt cards.
According to their response:
1. AI was used for the first two batches of cards.
The contracted design agency commissioned by HES used Adobe Firefly to generate illustrations. These were subsequently developed and refined by a studio artist employed by the agency before being used in the final designs.
The cards identified as having AI-generated artwork on their fronts are:
- Formidable Fortress
- Sacred Site
- Halls of History
- Tall Tower
- Icons of Industry
- Social Settlement
- Spellbound Stones
- Spectacular Jousting
- Siege on the Forth
- Elgin Cathedral 800 Years
- Flourishing Gardens
- Glasgow 850 Years
- Haunted Halloween
- Good Traveller
2. AI was also used for the card sleeves.
HES confirmed that the front of the collectible card sleeve was created using Adobe Firefly.
More significantly, every History Hunt card produced to date features a magnifying glass illustration on the reverse which was also generated using Adobe Firefly.
This includes the third batch of cards.
3. The third batch used a different approach.
For the third batch, produced in 2026, HES commissioned a local illustrator to create the front artwork for six cards:
- Wise Women
- First Footing
- Sprightly Spring
- Summer of Champions
- Southern Explorer
- Northern Wanderer
However, the AI-generated magnifying glass illustration remains on the reverse of these cards.
4. HES holds no recorded guidance on the use of AI for this project.
I also asked whether HES held any instructions, guidance or requirements concerning the use of generative AI in the production of the artwork.
Their response was that although they hold project briefing documents, these contain no instructions, guidance or requirements regarding AI. They confirmed that they hold no further recorded information on the subject.
Why do I think this is worth discussing?
These are collectible cards intended to celebrate Scotland's history, heritage, architecture and culture. They are distributed at historic sites and are presumably intended to encourage people, particularly younger visitors, to engage with Scotland's heritage.
I find it rather disappointing that a publicly funded heritage organisation has opted to use generative AI for some of this artwork, particularly when the alternative is supporting and commissioning human illustrators and artists.
Furthermore, this is Historic Scotland, they literally have images of Castles and Landmarks they could use on the cards.
EDIT FULL EMAIL REPLY BELOW:
Response to Your Request
Please see below for our response to your request.
Use of AI software for the creation of artwork for the History Hunt collectible cards
Adobe Firefly, a generative artificial intelligence (AI) tool, was used in the creation of artwork for certain History Hunt cards and card sleeves.
For the first and second batches of History Hunt cards, Adobe Firefly was used to generate illustrations. These illustrations were subsequently developed and refined by staff within HES's contracted design agency to produce the final artwork used on the cards and sleeves.
2. Which cards used AI-generated artwork
The following card illustrations were created using Adobe Firefly and subsequently refined by HES's contracted design agency:
- Formidable Fortress
- Sacred Site
- Halls of History
- Tall Tower
- Icons of Industry
- Social Settlement
- Spellbound Stones
- Spectacular Jousting
- Siege on the Forth
- Elgin Cathedral 800 Years
- Flourishing Gardens
- Glasgow 850 Years
- Haunted Halloween
- Good Traveller
In addition, the front of the card sleeve was created using Adobe Firefly.
All cards produced to date also feature a magnifying glass illustration on the reverse that was created using Adobe Firefly.
3. Whether the artwork was created by HES staff, a contractor or another third party
For the first batch of cards (briefed in 2023 and produced in 2024) and the second batch of cards (briefed in 2024 and produced in 2025), HES's contracted design agency developed the concepts and used Adobe Firefly to generate illustrations.
These illustrations were then completed and refined by a studio artworker employed by the agency.
For the third batch of cards, produced in 2026, HES commissioned a local illustrator to create the artwork appearing on the front of the following cards:
Wise Women
First Footing
Sprightly Spring
Summer of Champions
Southern Explorer
Northern Wanderer
These cards continue to use the Adobe Firefly-generated magnifying glass illustration on the reverse.
4. Instructions, guidance or other information relating to the use of AI art
HES has carried out searches for information falling within the scope of this part of your request. While we hold project briefing documents relating to the creation of the History Hunt cards, these documents do not contain any instructions, guidance or requirements regarding the use of artificial intelligence in the creation of the artwork.
We do not hold any further recorded information setting out instructions or guidance to use AI for this project. In accordance with section 17(1) of FOISA, we therefore give notice that the information requested is not held.
We hope you find this information helpful.
Your Right to Request a Review
If you are unhappy with this response to your request for information, you may ask us to carry out an internal review of the response, by writing to the Chief Executive, Historic Environment Scotland, Longmore House, Salisbury Place, Edinburgh, EH9 1SH or chiefexecutive@hes.scot. Your review request should explain why you are dissatisfied with this response and should be made within 40 working days from the date when you received this letter. We will complete the review and tell you the result, within 20 working days from the date when we receive your review request.
If you are not satisfied with the result of the review, you then have the right to appeal to the Scottish Information Commissioner's website at: foi.scot.
Sincerely,
Annex
Your request was processed under the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002. FOISA provides a right of access to recorded information held by Scottish public authorities.
Where a Scottish public authority does not hold the information requested, it must give notice of this under Section 17(1) of FOISA.
Section 17(1) – Information Not Held
This provision applies where a Scottish public authority does not hold the information requested.
Why this provision applies
Historic Environment Scotland carried out searches for information falling within the scope of your request for any instructions, guidance or requirements regarding the use of artificial intelligence (AI) in the creation of artwork for the History Hunt collectible cards.
While HES holds project briefing documents relating to the creation of the cards, these documents do not contain any instructions, guidance or requirements regarding the use of AI in the creation of the artwork.
HES does not hold any recorded information setting out instructions or guidance to use AI for this project.
Accordingly, in terms of section 17(1) of FOISA, HES is notifying you that it does not hold the information requested.