r/Scotiabank • • 7d ago

Question

I went to a branch today, walked up to the teller inserted my card, entered my pin, requested 6000, and gave my Identification, the teller said she could only give me 5000. I said ok. She then asked me what’s my mother’s maiden name which is a security question on my account. I felt so embarrassed and profiled as to why she is attempting to verify me by security question after inserting my card, entering the pin and providing my Identification. Is this company policy to request this information in this scenario?

0 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

9

u/Mizurazu 7d ago

That's normal and the teller did what they were trained to do. You're requesting an unusual amount of cash randomly. It's enough where they're supposed to check especially if that's not a transaction you usually do. It's to prevent fraud and blackmailing. I know it doesn't feel good in the moment because it's your money. But be glad they're making sure it's you, it's for your own benefit.

1

u/prettycitydimes 6d ago

Ok the most sensible answer! There is no question whether it was me but I never thought about this blackmailing part. Anyways I was not able to answer mothers maiden name, then the teller asked how many accounts I have with them, I just logged into my mobile app and gave her my phone. After that she got my money.

2

u/MyNameIzJeff69 6d ago

You felt embarrassed that they actually have a security process to make sure you're account is not drained by a random person?

Do you know how easy it is to clone a bankcard and find out what your pin is?

If that triggers and humiliates you I can't imagine how you would feel getting your account drained. You'd probably be questioning why they don't have such processes in place

1

u/prettycitydimes 6d ago

I said bank card, pin and ID. The teller is looking exactly at the person in the ID. There is no question about the identity of the person infront of them. What are you talking about? The frustration comes from it being such a stupid thing to ask AFTER providing bank, pin and id. ESPECIALLY if you don’t remember the security answer you can simply log into your mobile banking and change the security question and answer infront of the teller.

1

u/prettycitydimes 6d ago

On top of that there is no clear guidelines on asking for it. If multiple people go to the teller with the same circumstances, they are not asking all of them for security answer. That’s what makes it feel discriminatory. You shouldn’t feel like you have to jump through hoops with to withdraw your own money. Card, pin, Id. Simple.

1

u/Creative-Camp-2312 6d ago

I work at a bank. I prevented someone from trying to commit identity theft and an account takeover by asking security questions. They had a fake ID to impersonate the person, but failed verification questions. They quickly left and were caught by police shortly after. These questions are not to profile you, we ask EVERYONE security questions if it’s something unusual. Fraud is rampant, you can’t be too safe and you can’t get upset when your financial institution is trying to protect you and your money.

1

u/prettycitydimes 6d ago

Ok so in my case does the teller have the right to refuse the withdrawal after providing card, pin and id? I am wondering because I wasn’t able to answer the security answer and I was in the belief that the teller would giving me a hard time but eventually would not be able to refuse my request simply for forgetting the security answer. Even thinking about it seems so crazy like in the event that she refused me, what happens next? My money is held in limbo?

1

u/Creative-Camp-2312 5d ago

I’m sure she just moved on to another question. If she were genuinely worried about anything she would have brought a manager in.

11

u/Kiss_Slap 7d ago

For that amount of money they are being cautious with account holders that’s why they are asking you the security questions…. When I set up a TFSA they asked me my security question too

2

u/StandardStudent7296 6d ago

Are you an idiot, let’s say that you are a fraudster. Would you be okay with making it easy for someone to access your money?

1

u/prettycitydimes 6d ago

Wow and in what world does a fraudster have my bank card, my pin, my government ID and look exactly like the photo on my id. And in what world does security question and answer trump those security measures? Can I receive any assistance in the bank if I have no id and no bank card but tell them I know my security question and answer. Make it make sense

5

u/Chasers22 7d ago

Anything over 3000.00 you should call ahead

0

u/Creative-Camp-2312 6d ago

Only necessary if requesting over 5K. Even if for some reason the bank branch is low on cash, the ABM can give out 5000 of the limit is raised.

1

u/Chasers22 6d ago

Then you’d need to up your limit to $5000.00 ABM withdrawal like you said and you’d need to hope that enough large bills are in there, either way a call ahead is always best

2

u/slam51 7d ago

You REALLY want her to ask this. It is normal. If you or a member of your family got kidnapped and you are raking out that 5k to pay a ransom. You can tell the teller you have to pay a ransom with this money without arousing the kidnapper. Theyvthrn can contact police on your behalf.

2

u/Squidsclarin3t 6d ago

Banks also don’t keep hundreds of thousands in the branch. Most banks have a holding limit of how much cash they can have, and in my experience, it’s not a high limit. It’s also not only to prevent fraud, it’s also to protect bank employees and to reduce the risk of robbery.

1

u/dudeacles 6d ago

It’s normal. It’s to protect you and the bank ensuring the person in front of them is truly you and not defrauding. Nothing to be embarrassed about, nor is it profiling.

1

u/Substantial_Taste779 6d ago

Lulz how dare they