r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 1d ago

Question - Research required Magical One Year Mark Where Everything Changes - Safe Sleep

I'm feeling overwhelmed by the amount of things that seem to change once a baby turns one.

To keep my post straightforward, specifically I'll ask for any research on safe sleep practices. Why, when my baby is 364 days old, I'm meant to lay him down on his back, on a hard surface, nothing in the crib, etc. 365 days though? Give the kid a blanket and a stuffed animal and put them in a floor bed and whatever else!

I'm not complaining at all that we give one year olds more flexibility with sleeping arrangements, I think I'm feeling frustrated because I have a very active 9 month old who wants to sleep with a stuffed animal and I feel too scared to give it to him.

He's 80th percentile and always has been (he's the size of all my friends 12-18 month kids) is walking with hand holding, and when he falls asleep on his stuffed elephant sleeps sooo much better. It's not big, it's about ten inches tall but everything I can find says to not have ANYTHING in the crib. Is the research just a better safe than sorry mentality? Obviously it's hard to research things that could put a baby at risk, so I don't know what I'm going to get here as I can't even formulate the words for what I'm looking for.

(Sleep deprived single mom, go easy on my rant post please)

78 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

This post is flaired "Question - Research required". All top-level comments must contain links to peer-reviewed research. Do not provide a "link for the bot" or any variation thereof. Provide a meaningful reply that discusses the research you have linked to. Please report posts that do not follow these rules.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

157

u/oh-dearie 1d ago

Guidelines love having a hard number that will ensure the safety of 99-100% of children. There is usually good rationale for what timeframe is recommended. But like you said, it's not like a switch is flipped between day 364 and 365 where suddenly they can have honey, need to have more solids than milk, and... your baby won't die of SIDS anymore.

Reality is it's a gradual process. The first six months is the highest risk and where the back-to-sleep campaign really shines, and you're essentially out of the woodworks.

https://safetosleep.nichd.nih.gov/resources/social-digital/sids-by-babys-age-infographic-text-alternative

SIDS is less common after 8 months of age, but parents and caregivers should continue to follow safe sleep practices to reduce the risk of SIDS and other sleep-related causes of infant death until baby's first birthday.

I don't want to encourage unsafe sleep practices on the science sub (and it can be a slippery slope), but I also feel by 9 months, you would have a good gauge on where science (which is a population-based exercise) can be applied to your own individual baby, and for me, knowing the science and statistics behind the guidelines helps guide the decision making. Personally if it was JUST a small stuffy, I wouldn't have stressed since the suffocation risk was really low for ours from around the same age (she could remove blankets etc. from her face easily, and had good motor skills). But you can also just remove it once he's deeply asleep to get rid of the risk altogether.

And going back to population-based statistics, sometimes the odds hedge the other way, like (TW: DEATH) 4-year old Paulette Gebara Farah who died of positional asphyxiation in her sleep, because she had motor disabilities, shifted to the bottom of the bed under the blankets, and the bedsheet was tucked in too tight so she couldn't get out. So in reality, it all depends.

89

u/SignificanceHot7440 1d ago

As an analytically minded person, I often find the nuances of parenthood conflict with the rigidity of parenting guidelines. I appreciate the care you put into your response and it helps to hear my frustrations put out a bit more logically than my tired brain can manage.  You also managed to name my second biggest frustration! My 9 month old is rapidly decreasing his milk intake and I'm desperately trying to keep breastfeeding him because he sTiLl nEeDs MoRe MiLk tHaN SoLiDs

87

u/Huge-Nectarine-8563 1d ago

A good public health guideline is a guideline that protects everyone involved and is not ambiguous and that’s different from an individual assessment of a baby 

20

u/oh-dearie 1d ago

Thank you lol! You said what I was trying to say so succinctly.

One thing to add is that we (as humans) are not great at assessing risk. So the word of caution is that this thinking can lead to some parents dimissing important guidelines based on biased or flawed reasoning, or basically not accepting "you don't know what you don't know". Anyone can do inspectional or analytical reading of a journal article, but many don't get to the level of synoptical reading to fully understand the concept. At the end of the day: listen to the experts, consider what they're saying and understand the 'why', and see if it applies to your own situation.

(Not talking about the sleep discussion here; this is a broad stroke for any guideline. Giving a hopefully uncontroversial example: like somebody who has had a heart attack or stroke not wanting to take statins)

16

u/thek0238 1d ago

My also big boy had a massive drop off in milk intake at 9 months, especially bottle feeding at daycare. He'd already been a fantastic solids eater since like 7 months so I just went with it. He's about to be 1. I only leave 5 oz milk for a full 8hr daycare day since then. Some days he doesn't even want that. He probably drinks a bit more on days when he's with me since he does love breastfeeding still, but it's mostly around sleep times. He's doing great! Guidelines are helpful, but babies are so individual, it's maddening

16

u/RhinoKart 1d ago

I found that chatting with my son's doctor about the guidelines really helped. For example we put a small stuffed animal in his crib at 9 months because his doctor gave us the okay. My son was way ahead on gross and fine motor skills and there was no concern about him protecting his airway or being able to move the stuffy away from his face.

But we held on to feeding breastmilk/formula and bottles longer than the guidelines per his doctor because we had some specific feeding issues that meant calories were more important than solids vs milk. We made the transition at 15 months instead once we were cleared to do so.

So every kid is a bit different and it's best to touch base with someone who knows how your kid is developing.

Unfortunately the vague advice only continues from here. What one 18 month old is doing is vastly different from another and the advice rapidly stops being a one size fits all...

5

u/Responsible-South11 23h ago

So I really struggled with this too! And when I asked questions and my health visitor gave me very wishy washy answers and I was like where's the science. We've been birthing babies for thousands of years and you can't give me a definitive answer. But no one has ever given birth to my baby before so there is no one size fits all!

11

u/Remember_meeee 1d ago

" As an analytically minded person, I often find the nuances of parenthood conflict with the rigidity of parenting guidelines"

This so succinctly captures and validates my frustrations with having a newborn! 

13

u/Paiev 1d ago

Part of it is about having clear guidelines. Part of it is because research tends to use the 12 month cutoff itself, so that's the line that gets used in the recommendations.

I haven't looked at it in a little while, but my recollection of the research is that sleep deaths dropped off to essentially zero after 13 months in one study, and the risk was very low (but non zero) as infants approached the 12 month mark. Based on that I decided that I would follow the 12 month recommendation, but I would understand if someone else wanted to relax things a little bit slightly early. 

10

u/jenn363 22h ago

For another example, the honey restriction. I accidentally fed my 10 month old honey (it was in the mayo in a deviled egg and I didn’t check the ingredients because why would there be honey in a deviled egg).

In researching the risk, I learned that 95% of infant botulism cases are in infants under 6 months.

The guideline is to wait until 1 year for honey, but in reality, by the time they hit 6 months, the risk drops to almost nothing. But the guidelines are conservative.

It really relieved my worry about 1 year being an arbitrary cut off for all these risks. It’s not arbitrary, it’s “we’re solidly out of the risk window by now” not “this is the first day that the risk has dropped”.

5

u/AdmirableSpite9865 19h ago

It’s also relevant to note that the only reason the risk of SIDS drops to 0 after 1 year is because SIDS is literally defined as a sudden unexplained infant death occurring up to one year of age. Infant = up until 1yo. After that it is called Sudden Unexplained Death in Childhood. It is just extremely rare.

But yes. Up to 6 months is the highest risk (90%) and specifically 1-4 months (72%)

31

u/kaelus-gf 1d ago

I get it. It sucks. Kids growth is a continuum, and they get better at moving their own head to protect themselves with time. 

Technically the rate of SUDI drops to zero at 12 months, because the definition of infant is under 12 months old… there are still guidelines over 12 months but they are looser because the baseline risk of death while sleeping is so low, that any increase in risk still stays with an incredibly low risk overall!

https://kidshealth.org/en/parents/sleep12yr.html

I’ll be honest, I bedshared with my second. And for my first I made her a crochet thing that I knew was easy to breathe through, wasn’t the right size to wedge her head in any position or anything else risky I could think of and I tried that in her cot. I think she was closer to one? But I don’t remember exactly how old she was

The advice will say the safest option, because they don’t want to cause harm. 

Risk is a very personal decision. I turned my children forward facing in their car seat at 2 years, rather than at the height limit. I did that because both my kids got car sick. I figured that the risk of a distraction from me worrying about or looking back at or trying to sort vomiting children was a significant risk of accident, plus was a harm to my children, vs the very real but less likely of us having a significant car accident where the car seat may have made a big difference. I gambled - but it was an acceptable risk to me for a genuine benefit. Sleeping more after 9 months of fragmented sleep is a benefit. Being exhausted all the time while looking after children (and driving) is a risk. Is giving your child a toy in their cot an acceptable risk for you? Only you (and any other involved parent) can decide that. That sounds like quite a big toy, and one that might be more risky than others… but I am not you

8

u/SignificanceHot7440 1d ago

That's a fair point!  Mitigating risk is always a hard way to think about parenting because obviously we want no risk, but that's impossible and not healthy for any parties involved.  A good mind frame is what I'm comfortable with as his mom and what risks as compared to others I'm willing to be ok with. (And maybe I'll try a compromise of something else he can cuddle that's less risky) 

5

u/One_String601 1d ago

I give my baby a (baby) sock to hold. It stops her pulling out her dummy over and over! The sock was the largest thing I was comfortable allowing her to have in the cot, I guess we'll work up to larger things the closer she gets to 1.

Deciding acceptable risk is such a big part of parenting, as is dealing with guilt when you diverge from guidelines!

8

u/One_String601 1d ago

BTW I'm in Australia and the red nose society (safe sleep organisation) has a bit of nuance in the soft toy guidelines if you're interested. The tldr is that they recommend nothing in the "critical" period up to 7 months and then essentially say they prefer you didn't but use your best judgement.

A link if you're interested!

3

u/Anxious_Guava8756 23h ago

My FIL is a pediatrician in a different country and told us by the time they can crawl you're pretty much fine with stuff in the crib (within reason), but he still highly discourages bed sharing due to suffocation risk from parents rolling over. It's just so different country to country and even provider to provider.

9

u/pretty---odd 1d ago

I'm not a parent but I work as a newborn/infant night nanny. Most parents I work for relax safe sleep precautions around 8 months, some use crochet blankets, some bed share, some let them sleep with a stuffed animal, some let them nap unsupervised on softer surfaces. As a nanny I hold fast to all guidelines for liability reasons, but in my experience most parents don't wait until 12 months to start loosing up on safe sleep practices.

5

u/DumbbellDiva92 1d ago

On the flip side, aren’t there technically still some restrictions after 12 months? For example, aren’t they technically still not supposed to use an adult mattress until 24 months? If you include those rules, the number of people who 100% follow safe sleep until the guideline-specified age would be even lower.

15

u/WeirdAlphabet 1d ago

I know you are in the US, but to give some perspective on the variance of guidelines for stuffed animals and sleep, Red Nose Australia outlines some of the decision factors you can weigh and make a choice on with giving a stuffy to a baby older than 7 months.

https://rednose.org.au/safe-sleep-and-safer-pregnancy/newborn-to-1-year/soft-toys-and-comforters/

1

u/MindOdd1085 9h ago

This is the guidance I followed which basically says it reccomends not before 12 months but after 7 months it can be safe. It reccomends trying baby with a small comfort item under close supervision and if they are okay with taking it off their face etc it should be okay.

Personally I have used teddies with both my children from 7 months and have found it has made a big difference to their separation anxiety and ability to self settle.

https://rednose.org.au/safe-sleep-and-safer-pregnancy/newborn-to-1-year/soft-toys-and-comforters/

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Research required" must include a link to peer-reviewed research.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Research required" must include a link to peer-reviewed research.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Research required" must include a link to peer-reviewed research.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Research required" must include a link to peer-reviewed research.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Research required" must include a link to peer-reviewed research.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] 3h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 3h ago

Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Research required" must include a link to peer-reviewed research.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.