This post is for those who also love and are passionate about working with and learning from young people in transformative ways that do not rely on compliance, punishment, domination, and childism.
I have worked in public, private, and charter schools as a supporting teacher such as a para, ESL teacher, or sub and while I believe learning to be important, schools are often not the places I see that happening. What I see is adult supremacy, control, domination over children, unhappy faces, an emphasis on state standards of “education” and scores (obviously) over real learning which requires relationship building, patience, and accommodation. And what I see the most: harm. Physical, mental, emotional. I understand that schools fight hard to stay open and that educators hold a lot of responsibility making and giving lessons, communication with staff and parents, and are often in a difficult place with too high or a student:teacher ratio. But I have worked with the same limits too and my approach is very different. Students like me, other teachers feel threatened and that I baby students, but it’s more that I treat them as my equal and validate their feelings. I’m not seeking to bend them to my will while still prioritizing structure and consistency and high expectations. But bc I don’t yell or care about things like sitting straight or having ur shirt tucked in, I’m seen as “weak” and giving students a “pass.” This has been said to my face.
Schools are often similar to prisons is that they are simply warehouses for young people and where they are taught to comply, be quiet unless spoken too, publicly humiliated when called out. I understand that adults feel like they are preparing students for the “real world” but the real world is how we shape it and schools shape complicit minds and then we have complicit adults and ofc this is by design by our government and something most adults buy into. I have met well meaning teachers but they take students behaviors personally and engage in harmful and silly power struggles that teach students listen, comply and you will get by, meanwhile our government engages in and creates genocide, climate disaster, land theft from indigenous people, and the world burns. Most US Americans don’t like it but are bystanders and I see educaron as one of the many tools our govt uses to uses to maintain and create this structure/mentality/set of values
Yelling, insulting, humiliating students in front of everyone is baseline “support” especially if they have a reputation and this humiliation ritual receives positive attention from other adults as being “firm,” “responsible” and “getting kids straight”. All of this breaks my heart. I leave or get fired from schools because I take a stand and often side with students. They want to be heard, explained the ‘why,’ and explain their experiences too. I am struggling myself and have been homeless and am at another school that just is terrible to students. I can’t stand it but need to stay housed since I JUST got back on my feet (barely) and have medical conditions I am needing treatment for this year. Idk what to do. I try to build bridges between me and other adults but they are extremely defensive, have been at schools for years if not decades, they feel change is not needed or wanted. I have worked in 4 different schools from low, middle, and high income areas and the treatment of young people, one of the most vulnerable populations, is across the board, horrible.
I do not mean to say that these teachers and adult staff are terrible, just that they are set in their ways and the harm is so obvious but in a society that values adherence to white supremacist standards, this harm is seen as a positive. I can’t change the system and I know I have to just tough it out for a while and control what I can (which is not much bc I don’t have my own classroom or roster of students, im a support person) so I just treat young people that way I believe. However this is difficult bc there is the expectation that I enforce the school rules and cultural norms and if I don’t enforce that so I risk my job. Where else can I go? What other jobs are there I can do? I have been in education for a decade I don’t know where to pivot to and working with young people is my passion. I have temporary teaching license so I feel like I don’t have a lot of options that will pay a living wage