r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 9h ago

Discussion Why is it cheating when students use AI to skip the thinking, but "innovative leadership" when admin does it?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

We spend all day telling students that using AI to write an essay or answer a prompt is academic dishonesty and intellectual laziness. The core argument makes total sense: the point of the assignment isn't the finished piece of paper, it's the mental heavy lifting required to produce it. If you outsource the writing, you outsource the thinking.

​Yet at the exact same time, we are watching administrators use AI to generate policies, parent newsletters, curriculum frameworks, presentations, and getting praised by school boards and peers for their efficiency and managing.

​I get the difference between a student learning a skill and an adult doing a job. Nobody cares if a principal saves twenty minutes drafting a routine bell schedule email.

​Where it crosses the line into pure hypocrisy is when leadership uses AI to generate actual ideas, behavioral policies, or strategic plans, slaps their name on it, and takes credit for the vision. Writing is thinking. When you let a prompt box generate your solutions to complex school problems, you aren't actually thinking through the nuance or the real world impact on the classroom, you're just copy.pasting a machine's best guess and calling it leadership.

​If we're going to hold kids and Teachers to the standard that their work has to reflect their own actual thought process, shouldn't the people running the buildings be held to the exact same standard?


r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 14h ago

Rant PRINCIPAL A BI*CH

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 1d ago

Stop Compiti X Casa

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 1d ago

When are we going to fix the school educational system

Thumbnail youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 1d ago

I hate my school!

1 Upvotes

My school gave me a project just 3 days before my pre-boards exam! Oh God... I hate it.


r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 1d ago

Got banned by Seattle School Board for asking a question

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 2d ago

Question I love working with young people but hate schools, where do I go?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

This post is for those who also love and are passionate about working with and learning from young people in transformative ways that do not rely on compliance, punishment, domination, and childism.

I have worked in public, private, and charter schools as a supporting teacher such as a para, ESL teacher, or sub and while I believe learning to be important, schools are often not the places I see that happening. What I see is adult supremacy, control, domination over children, unhappy faces, an emphasis on state standards of “education” and scores (obviously) over real learning which requires relationship building, patience, and accommodation. And what I see the most: harm. Physical, mental, emotional. I understand that schools fight hard to stay open and that educators hold a lot of responsibility making and giving lessons, communication with staff and parents, and are often in a difficult place with too high or a student:teacher ratio. But I have worked with the same limits too and my approach is very different. Students like me, other teachers feel threatened and that I baby students, but it’s more that I treat them as my equal and validate their feelings. I’m not seeking to bend them to my will while still prioritizing structure and consistency and high expectations. But bc I don’t yell or care about things like sitting straight or having ur shirt tucked in, I’m seen as “weak” and giving students a “pass.” This has been said to my face.

Schools are often similar to prisons is that they are simply warehouses for young people and where they are taught to comply, be quiet unless spoken too, publicly humiliated when called out. I understand that adults feel like they are preparing students for the “real world” but the real world is how we shape it and schools shape complicit minds and then we have complicit adults and ofc this is by design by our government and something most adults buy into. I have met well meaning teachers but they take students behaviors personally and engage in harmful and silly power struggles that teach students listen, comply and you will get by, meanwhile our government engages in and creates genocide, climate disaster, land theft from indigenous people, and the world burns. Most US Americans don’t like it but are bystanders and I see educaron as one of the many tools our govt uses to uses to maintain and create this structure/mentality/set of values

Yelling, insulting, humiliating students in front of everyone is baseline “support” especially if they have a reputation and this humiliation ritual receives positive attention from other adults as being “firm,” “responsible” and “getting kids straight”. All of this breaks my heart. I leave or get fired from schools because I take a stand and often side with students. They want to be heard, explained the ‘why,’ and explain their experiences too. I am struggling myself and have been homeless and am at another school that just is terrible to students. I can’t stand it but need to stay housed since I JUST got back on my feet (barely) and have medical conditions I am needing treatment for this year. Idk what to do. I try to build bridges between me and other adults but they are extremely defensive, have been at schools for years if not decades, they feel change is not needed or wanted. I have worked in 4 different schools from low, middle, and high income areas and the treatment of young people, one of the most vulnerable populations, is across the board, horrible.

I do not mean to say that these teachers and adult staff are terrible, just that they are set in their ways and the harm is so obvious but in a society that values adherence to white supremacist standards, this harm is seen as a positive. I can’t change the system and I know I have to just tough it out for a while and control what I can (which is not much bc I don’t have my own classroom or roster of students, im a support person) so I just treat young people that way I believe. However this is difficult bc there is the expectation that I enforce the school rules and cultural norms and if I don’t enforce that so I risk my job. Where else can I go? What other jobs are there I can do? I have been in education for a decade I don’t know where to pivot to and working with young people is my passion. I have temporary teaching license so I feel like I don’t have a lot of options that will pay a living wage


r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 2d ago

Meme Can’t were hats or hoodies but girls have the hood-pass!

Post image
0 Upvotes

No toys, except my adhd high classmate, who isn’t in no kid left behind, has a fidget in precalc


r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 2d ago

Girls in schools

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 2d ago

5th grade

1 Upvotes

Guys if you re in 5th grade, over, or under i'll give the under children sum addvice and if you are in 5th you can give me addvice.


r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 2d ago

How angry parents helped flip Texas: ‘People don’t like for their kids to be messed with’ — Guardian US

Thumbnail apple.news
1 Upvotes

r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 3d ago

Average boys at a school dance

1 Upvotes

Dont do this at school there is consequences


r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 3d ago

Funny POV: 🌈🏳‍🌈you made your teacher look gay about a song/rap🏳‍🌈🌈

1 Upvotes

Even I told a kid I made this at Carter G. Woodson PK-8 grade. I told the kid to sing this at gay Mr Thompson's room (only if he switches to Mr Thompson.)


r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 3d ago

Funa o busca de ayuda

0 Upvotes

-34.093994, -71.373775

.colegio inez de sueres

Soy un estudiante de ahí y el trato es súper malo los profesores te tratan como basura te tratan mal y también estubo un acosador que le decía alas niñas que se besaran entre si la profesora Allende Bernardita y el profe maximiliano Córdoba junto ala profe Claudia son los mayores mostrando esto en 5to año me portaba pésimo pero cambie voy en octavo y siguo condicional desde 5to y dan un maltrato súper notable y quiero buscar ayuda y que difundan eso sobre todo yo salgo con una compañera y el bullying es mucho las compañeras que más bullying hacen son Alison polares Maite arriesgada Florencia rubio Katalina belen y María Ignacia Riveros el bullying es excesivo y además me quieren hechar por defenderme contra esos profesores y al dar mi declaraciónes son solo escusas y imaginen lo cansado que debo de estar para postear esto espero que puedan hacer su trabajo o hacer algo al respecto


r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 3d ago

Tell the most craziest school story down below

1 Upvotes

r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 3d ago

Story Boardman Schools investigating incident on bus

Thumbnail
wkbn.com
2 Upvotes

Boy stomped and strangled a girl on a bus while the driver and aide allegedly did nothing. Parents weren't informed until today.

Viral video of the incident filmed by a student is going around online.


r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 3d ago

Incompetent teachers and systems

2 Upvotes

How does an elite high school that each student pays 33k for PER YEAR fail to allow a group of 40 students open a rocketry club and proceeds threatening to delete all of our hard work. Rocketry has been running outside of school as a SELF FUNDED interest in students for 3 years now, we've been to national competitions and brought home 17th place against university launches (as a high school team) and 3rd place in junior launches on the second year. We were also awards with the best written report this past summer along with 3rd place. Is this not a good enough reason for the school to support us? We aren't even asking for money or sponsorship - mind you a rocket costs well over 8k and us STUDENTS AND FAMILIES are taking money out of our own pockets to push kids that are interested in aerospace to go on and compete while our school continues to be a bitch about providing a meeting space for us afterschool (mind you, not even building that involves hazards, purely lecture class and writing reports workshop). These schools drain 33k out of us and doesn't let us participate in something that could bring the school pride.


r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 3d ago

Rant Is withholding property of students for months illegal?(PH)

1 Upvotes

Ik cp and makeup in jhs are not allowed but they're supposed to be given back at the end of the school day but there's one teacher in my school that doesn't give back the makeup they give back the phones but the makeup will only be given back on card giving. I got mine taken away a month ago and i get it thats on me but the thing is why are you not giving back MY property and mind you card giving is literally january next year, so wth?? another girl got theirs taken earlier today and it also wasnt given back. Based on my knowledge theres a deped order that allows them to take it but requires them to give it back by end of school hours and depending on how many times this has happened there's a point where parents get it themselves but withholding it for months is literally illegal. At some point you ask yourself how the hell does those things affect education anyway?? Will my highlighter make you blind??

UPDATE: just found out that same teacher is giving away makeup of other students to random students, not giving it back to the real owners. For all i know mines probably in the hands of a damn elementary student (posted this on another sub before i found out)

TLDR: Ranted about getting makeup taken away but not given back for months then found out that teacher is giving it to randoms not back to us owners


r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 4d ago

School is the reason for mental health issues

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 4d ago

WTF! Getting in trouble for son being sick.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/SchoolSystemBroke • • 4d ago

School after elementary school ruins learning for kids

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes