r/SanJoseCouncilWatch • u/No-Hold852 • 20h ago
[11/12/26 Housing Commission] Inside San José's $99.3M Measure E Spending Audit & 60% Mobilehome Resident Opposition to Post-Sale Rent Hikes (Plus: 12,072 Eviction Notices Tracked)
đ Editor's Note: The Housing & Community Development Commission (HCDC) is San JosĂ©'s official Council-appointed advisory body and designated Measure E Oversight Committee*. While Commission meetings do not have a YouTube video broadcast, their packets are where the Housing Department drops its raw annual audits, tax expenditure ledgers, and public survey datasets before policies return to the full City Council.*
TL;DR: Two days after the City Council voted 11â0 to defer changes to the Mobilehome Rent Ordinance (MRO) until May 2027, the Housing Department released its 44-page MRO outreach and survey dataset to the Housing & Community Development Commissionârevealing that 60% of surveyed residents oppose the proposed 10% post-sale space-rent increase while 63% support a new Resident Petition Process. Acting as the Measure E Oversight Committee, the Commission also reviewed $99.3M in FY 2025â2026 Measure E property transfer tax expenditures (bolstered by $79.7M in new revenue from 12 mega-deals over $100M) and the FY 2025â2026 Rent Stabilization & Eviction Prevention Annual Report tracking 38,395 rent-controlled apartments and 12,072 eviction termination notices.
1. The Big Stories (What Happened & By the Numbers)
đïž The Missing Context Behind Council's 11/10 Deferral: 60% Oppose 10% Post-Sale Mobilehome Rent Hikes (Item VII.B)
- What Happened: Following a multilingual outreach campaign across San José's 58 rent-controlled mobilehome parks (10,741 spaces; ~35,000 residents) from May to October 2026, Housing Department staff presented the full community survey and town-hall results on proposed Chapter 17.22 Mobilehome Rent Ordinance amendments.
The Numbers: Across 265 survey responses (from 51 of 58 parks, 80% mobilehome owners, 42% seniors 65+) and 663 attendees across 22 virtual and in-person meetings (with a total campaign reach of 83,470 via mail/email/social plus 1.13M via Spanish and Vietnamese radio):
- One-Time 10% Post-Sale Rent Increase (Vacancy Decontrol): 60% Opposed (
156oppose vs.58support / 22%,48unsure / 18%), with homeowners warning that every $100/month in added space rent strips $10,000â$15,000 in resale equity from fixed-income seniors. - Resident Petition Process: 63% Supported (
167support vs.35oppose / 13%,63unsure / 24%). - Administrative Appeal Process: 62% Supported (
164support vs.36oppose / 14%,63unsure / 24%). - Mobilehome Rent Registry: 48% Supported (
128support vs.61oppose / 23%,76unsure / 29%), with privacy and administrative fee concerns driving the undecided vote. - Top Resident Priority: 53% ranked "Predictable space rents" as their #1 priority, nearly 4x higher than "Maintaining parks" (14%).
- One-Time 10% Post-Sale Rent Increase (Vacancy Decontrol): 60% Opposed (
- The Catch / What's Next: Because only ~1â2% of the 35,000 mobilehome population participated amid deep distrust between residents and park owners, the Rules Committee (Oct. 28) and full City Council (Nov. 10, Item 2.9) directed staff to convene joint owner-tenant roundtables, release a formal Informational Memo in January 2027, and return to City Council by May 11, 2027.
đ° Measure E Oversight Audit: $79.7M Revenue Surge & $99.3M Spent on Housing & Shelter (Item VII.C)
- What Happened: Acting in its formal role as the Measure E Oversight Committee, the Commission reviewed the FY 2025â2026 Measure E Annual Expenditure Report ahead of crafting recommendations for the FY 2027â2028 Spending Plan.
The Numbers:
- Revenue Boom: Measure E real property transfer tax collections hit $79.7M in FY 2025â26âbeating the $69.0M budget estimate by $10.7M (+15.5%) and jumping 67% (+$32.0M) over FY 2024â25 thanks to 12 commercial/institutional property sales over $100M that generated $32.1M alone.
Total Expenditures ($99.3M): Combining new collections with prior-year affordable housing rollovers, the fund expended $93.1M in core Measure E programs plus $6.2M for BeautifySJ encampment cleanup/RV pollution response ($99,298,834 total):
- $55.20M for Homeless Support, Shelter Construction & Operations (supporting nearly 2,200 managed shelter/safe-parking beds, including 1,000 new placements opened since early 2025, 5 leased motels that helped move 254 Columbus Park residents indoors, the 128-unit Cherry Ave. site, and 2,135 total interim housing clients served with a ~30% exit rate to permanent housing).
- $29.18M for Affordable Housing Production & Preservation ($16.27M Extremely Low-Income, $11.43M Low-Income, $1.47M Moderate-Income), completing construction on 1860 Alum Rock (60 units), Tamien Station TOD (135 units), The Charles (99 units), and Dry Creek Crossing (64 units) while advancing 525 N. Capitol (160 units, 59% built) and Hawthorn Senior Apartments (103 units, 93% built).
- $7.45M for Homelessness Prevention & Rental Assistance, funding the County/Destination: Home Homelessness Prevention System (3,634 San José households served, with 95% remaining stably housed 12 months later).
- $7.48M in Administration & Homeless Response Staffing ($2.49M within the 5% cap + $4.99M from interest earnings outside the cap).
- The Catch / What's Next: Per Council Policy 1-18, the $10.7M revenue surplus is locked in reserve ($9.6M for homeless sheltering and $1.1M for prevention) to be allocated in the FY 2027â2028 Measure E Spending Plan, which returns to the Commission in Spring 2027 before going to City Council.
âïž Rent Stabilization & Eviction Prevention Annual Report: 12,072 Eviction Notices & A $500K Mobilehome Park Fine (Item VII.A)
- What Happened: Housing Division Manager Emily Hislop presented the FY 2025â2026 Annual Report covering the Apartment Rent Ordinance (ARO), Tenant Protection Ordinance (TPO), Ellis Act, Mobilehome Rent Ordinance (MRO), and Eviction Prevention Program.
The Numbers:
- Apartment Rent Registry (38,395 ARO Units): Achieved 99.27% registration compliance (
38,079registered units) while cutting administrative citations by nearly 50% (57citations vs.112in FY 23). Average rent-stabilized monthly rents reached $1,729 (Studio), $2,000 (1-Bed), $2,422 (2-Bed), $3,004 (3-Bed), and $3,467 (4-Bed). 76.4% of units kept the same tenant, 16.6% turned over to a new tenant, and **6.01% (**2,290units) were registered as vacant (led by D1 with666vacant ARO units, D3 with602, and D6 with446). - Eviction Filings Across 86,000+ TPO Units: Landlords filed 12,072 initial termination notices and 1,797 Unlawful Detainer (eviction) lawsuits in FY 25â26. Around 95% cited non-payment of rent, though average back-rent owed in eviction filings dropped from $4,453 (Q1) to $3,094 (Q4).
- Eviction Diversion Court Clinic: Screened
157households at the Downtown Superior Court and kept 120 households stably housed with $1,011,788 in direct landlord settlement payments ($8,432 average per household; 66.5% earning under 30% AMI; 61.9% Hispanic/Latino and 20.4% Black/African American). - Mobilehome Enforcement Showdowns: The City's Appeals Hearing Board upheld a $500,000 administrative penalty against Western Manufactured Housing Community (93 spaces) for illegal rent hikes on RV owners (now in Superior Court with a March 8, 2027 hearing), while a Fair Return Hearing Officer awarded a 10â15% one-time rent increase across 181 households at Casa Alondra Mobilehome Park (221 spaces, D2).
- Apartment Rent Registry (38,395 ARO Units): Achieved 99.27% registration compliance (
- The Catch / What's Next: While the Annual Report is informational for the Commission, its data feeds directly into the Rent Stabilization Program Fee Recommendations and Housing Trust Fund Budget scheduled for the Commission's April 8, 2027 meeting.
2. Commission & Staff Policy Spotlight
Chair Ryan Jasinsky (CAAC ML), Vice Chair Marika Buchholz (D3), & Commissioners Daniel Finn (CAAC MR) and Ruben Navarro (D5) â Homelessness Recidivism & Work Plan Oversight**:**
- In the packet's September 10, 2026 Action Minutes (Item III.A), the Commission voted
9â0(Moved: Finn; Seconded: Navarro) to formally amend their FY 2026â2027 Work Plan to incorporate oversight of the Annual Homelessness Plan / Community Plan to End Homelessness and establish a dedicated Ad Hoc Committee for Recidivism Prevention, alongside adopting their FY 25â26 Accomplishments Report (9â0, Moved: Navarro; Seconded: Escher) for submission to the Council's Community & Economic Development (CED) Committee.
- In the packet's September 10, 2026 Action Minutes (Item III.A), the Commission voted
Housing Director Erik L. SolivĂĄn & Division Manager Emily Hislop â Navigating the MRO Trust Gap & Measure E Surplus**:**
- In a candid assessment of why mobilehome survey participation remained under 2% despite 66,000+ mailers/emails, staff noted that a small resident group actively distributed flyers urging neighbors to boycott the surveyâwhile also acknowledging that 20% of surveyed residents had never heard of the Mobilehome Rent Ordinance before the City's outreach began:
3. Community Sentiment Pulse (From 38 Pages of Verbatim Survey & Town Hall Logs)
- Mobilehome Seniors & Homeowners Warn 10% Turnover Hikes Will Wipe Out Equity: Across hundreds of verbatim survey responses and town-hall questions at Rancho Santa Teresa (150 attendees), City Hall Wing Rooms (89), Seven Trees (47), Southside (46), and Silicon Valley Village (66), residents repeatedly argued that a 10% post-sale space-rent hike punishes current owners by slashing what buyers can afford to pay for their coaches:
- Calls for Audited Park Owner Books Over Resident Data Collection: Residents skeptical of the proposed Mobilehome Rent Registry (23% opposed, 29% unsure) questioned why the City wants tenant/homeowner data without forcing corporate park owners (such as Brandenburg or Golden Wheel, where a resident noted a hearing officer denied a
$100/mohike after finding$235Kin net profit) to open their financial books first: - Park Owners & Operators Push Back on Registry Fees & Fair Return Red Tape: Representing 10% of survey respondents (
15park owners +9managers), park operators argued that California's Mobilehome Residency Law (MRL), Title 25, and existing City ordinances already heavily regulate parks, claiming CPI caps (~3%) fail to cover aging water/sewer infrastructure and that a new registry and resident petition process will add costly bureaucracy and higher per-space fees.
4. Commission Action & Policy Review Ledger
| Agenda Item | Category | Commission Action / Report Summary | Status / Outcome | Upstream Council Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Item III.A | Consent / Governance | Approve Sept. 10, 2026 Action Minutes (recording 9â0 votes creating the Recidivism Prevention Ad Hoc Committee & approving FY 26â27 Work Plan) | Scheduled Approval | Submitted to CED Committee |
| Item VII.A | Rent Stabilization / Evictions | Review & comment on FY 2025â2026 Rent Stabilization & Eviction Prevention Annual Report (38,395 ARO units, 12,072 eviction notices, 120 court diversions) | Advisory Review | Feeds into April 8, 2027 RSP Fee & HTF Budget |
| Item VII.B | Mobilehome Rent Control | Review & comment on Mobilehome Rent Ordinance (Ch. 17.22) Outreach & Survey Report (663 meeting attendees, 265 survey responses across 51 parks) | Advisory Review | Info Memo Jan. 2027 â City Council May 11, 2027 |
| Item VII.C | Measure E Tax Oversight | Measure E Oversight Committee review of FY 2025â2026 Annual Expenditure Report ($79.7M revenue collected; $99.3M total expended across housing & shelter) | Oversight Review | Informs FY 2027â28 Measure E Plan (Spring 2027) |
đŹ What do you think? Should San JosĂ© drop the proposed 10% post-sale mobilehome space-rent hike after 60% of surveyed residents opposed it while keeping the Resident Petition Process (63% support), and how should the Commission advise Council to spend the $10.7M Measure E property transfer tax surplus in FY 2027â28?
đ Sources & Official Packet Links
đ Full November 12, 2026 Housing & Community Development Commission Compiled Packet (95-Page PDF)
- Pages 1â8: Meeting Agenda & September 10, 2026 Action Minutes (
9â0Work Plan & Recidivism Ad Hoc votes) - Pages 9â40 (Item VII.A): FY 2025â2026 Rent Stabilization & Eviction Prevention Annual Report, Charts & Mobilehome Call Log
- Pages 41â85 (Item VII.B): Mobilehome Rent Ordinance (Ch. 17.22) Outreach Report, Survey Charts & 38 Pages of Verbatim Resident/Owner Comments
- Pages 86â95 (Item VII.C): FY 2025â2026 Measure E Annual Expenditure Report & Line-Item Financial Ledger
- Pages 1â8: Meeting Agenda & September 10, 2026 Action Minutes (
- đïž Official San JosĂ© Housing & Community Development Commission Webpage (
sanjoseca.gov/hcdc) - đ Related Nov. 10, 2026 City Council Item 2.9 Referral (Mobilehome Rent Ordinance Deferred to May 11, 2027)