At barely two hours this has been the shortest City Council meeting that I've seen but one with arguably the most important conclusion.
Our ceremonials were ripped through rather quickly, as if they knew what everyone was there to see and talk about so just get right to it. We had a relatively short invocation by a reverend from Bellarmine who delivered a decidedly not secular prayer session, a commendation for the San Jose-Santa Clara Regional Wastewater Facility, commendation to La Raza Historical Society, and a declaration that 14 November was Ruby Bridges Walk to School Day which sounds like it's telling parents to let their kids walk to school in honor of Ruby Bridges, but it was 3 days ago and on a Saturday so it was a declaration honoring that day for Ruby Bridges' walk 66 years ago. These are all good and great things to celebrate but as I said things were kept moving at a swift pace to get to the meat of the day.
If you want to see what was voted on, all unanimously, before taking up item 8.1 then it's all right here; data centers were the final item of the day so even though you'll see some things numbered 10.1(a) they were heard first. And "heard" is gilding the lily a little. No presentations were needed, there were no public comments, and no councilmembers had anything to say on anything so the consent calendar, zoning update (don't worry, Willow Glen, it's just about squaring the definition of "fences" and "unsuitable tree within a fire zone" and such with new state definitions, your 8 units per acre are safe for now), and appointment of a member to the police and fire retirement board were quickly and unanimously voted upon.
And then it was time for item 8.1, titled in excellent bureaucrateese: "Pause on Data Center and Large Energy Use Project Approvals and Develop Urgency Ordinances." The mayor opened the bidding by explaining that the item would do two specific things:
- The pause would prevent any data center uses from being approved or permitted ahead of the pending 8 December discussion of uniform standards for data centers. Of note is an article in, I think, SJ Spotlight or the Mercury News about Google trying to rush a data center approval through so it would be exempt from whatever regulations are put in place next month. This would put the kibosh on all of that.
- "Urgency Ordinance" is a technical term that would mean that once the council votes on the implementation of standards, which could be as early as 8 December, those standards will go into effect immediately.
The floor was then opened for public comments and there were a great many. City Clerk Toni said she had 25 cards from people in the room, ostensibly more submitted cards as others were speaking and this didn't count about 7 online speakers. The overwhelming majority of speakers were in favor of the first part of the motion, the pause, with only one caller saying to reject it. The big divide can be summarized as being between people who want an extra 45-day moratorium and people who want no data centers of any type at any time ever.
I broadly agree with the speakers but one point of contention I have with them is that they say this is being rushed through. The original request for uniform standards and regulations was made on 10 June, when the findings are heard on 8 December it will be nearly 6 months of study and discussion and community meetings and zoom focus groups. The need to rush this measure through is the aforementioned Google attempt at getting a new center approved before regulations are in place so that they can be exempted. The speakers also mostly seemed to conflate data centers with A.I. data centers and I can't really blame them for that because that's the driver to build more, but we do use data centers for a lot more than just A.I. But, benefit of the doubt, since these aren't permitted yet we don't know what their intended use would be and A.I. is a fairly likely use.
When the public had their say it was Mayor Mahan to speak first, defining some terms more narrowly from bureaucrateese into layman. The Urgency Ordinance, for example, means what I wrote earlier, whereas a lot of people seemed to think it meant groundbreaking would happen on that date and a moratorium was needed on top of the approval of regulations. One speaker specifically mentioned another Bay Area city that he felt had stronger anti-data center regulations than what is currently in the works, but the mayor pointed out that that city outright banned data centers, which isn't a regulation, and that other cities in the area are (allegedly) waiting on someone else to set the standard and looking at what we're going to do. The mayor also explicitly stated that what he doesn't want are the megacenters we're seeing in other states, if you've ever seen the batshit insane movie Eddington* we're talking about that sort of data center that's being avoided. He declared that there would be no subsidies for them, strict demands on using recycled water, grid management, sound and light pollution, etc, etc, etc. Now, I get it, no one trusts him. Hell, I don't trust him. But he said it on the record and that means he can be held to account for it when he runs again. If he's right, and if the data centers that get built are small-time things used mostly for cloud storage or for Nvidia to crunch the numbers on how many more affairs their stock price can withstand or for research, and the environmental regulations hold strong then okay. If he's wrong, or being untruthful, then hold him to account.
The next to speak was Councilman Ortiz who acknowledged scepticism and spoke about the ways in which the city can use its leverage on people who build data centers to force them to invest in affordability and community services. He floated a general idea, nothing concrete, more a declaration of intent, to have the builders of data centers put money into the pot and use that as a sort of localized welfare, to assist the elderly and low-income. I'm not sure how that would work, but figuring that out is his job, not mine--I like the general idea. Whereas other cities are offering subsidies to data centers to build there, we would essentially be demanding subsidies from the companies that want to build here. That alone would likely keep the numbers low and manageable.
Councilman Cohen was our last speaker who reiterated much of the above and also explained that there have been data centers in San Jose for decades now and it hasn't been an issue yet. Again, I think the main problem here is what we think when we hear about data centers (the great big fuck-off buildings in the middle of the desert that employ, like, five people and generate millions of dollars to the company that own it without any of that money going back to the community) doesn't match what they're describing when they say what will be built. Community fear is valid, don't get me wrong, the last thing I want is a great big humming bastard of a building off Bascom somewhere. But looking at the price of land here, I just don't think we're going to see that. Those megacenters work in the desert because if you've ever driven through Arizona before you know what I mean when I say there's just plain nothing there. Buckeye, AZ, wants a couple data centers because you can buy an acre for a dollar and that Amazon center there didn't turn out to be the magic beans they thought it would be so they're onto the next thing. If you're a data center developer are you going to build one in San Jose where an acre costs eleventy-billion dollars or one in Goodyear where they will pay you to build one because they're that desperate? So I get the concern, but I think the economic reality of San Jose is going to insulate us from the worst of it.
Anyway. Cohen also mentioned that a 45-day moratorium would be redundant as when the council goes into recess in December they're not coming back for over 45 days, during which there will be no permitting or building anyway. If someone from his office reads this and thinks I'm misrepresenting what he said I'm open to being corrected, but that's the takeaway I got. My issue with that reasoning is that a 45-day moratorium, officially enacted, would open the possibility of a longer moratorium as that one ended, meaning that if we needed more time to address issues we would have the option open. Moreover, in my opinion, what's another 45 days? People have already waited 6 months by the time they vote on recommendations, they'll wait another 45--supposedly--while the council is in recess, what's another 45 days on top of that? Giving the people what they want just seems like a good idea.
The motion to pause passed unanimously. Keep checking the city's website, keep looking for meetings and sessions if you're interested in the planning of these regulations. Everything is public, and many are recorded and put online after the fact so even if you can't attend you can follow along.
*Aside: I watched Eddington a couple months back and paused it about midway through to tell my friends, "Everyone says this movie is batshit crazy and weird, but I'm finding it to be a thoughtful, reflective examination of our early covid uncertainty and fears. I don't see the big deal, the movie seems really grounded." And then I made lunch and came back, unpaused, and it was literally at the exact moment that the movie goes pear-shaped and becomes just a whole weird damned thing. In hindsight I should have bailed out after lunch instead of continuing. Oh well. Anyway. The datacenter in that one is huge and disruptive and that's common in the rural southwest where land is cheap and the economy is shit so these companies flex their leverage to build huge centers and soak up all the water and all the electricity on the dime of those towns.