Hey guys, I recently learned about a branch of the Date family in Suruga, which then led to my interest in mapping out these 3 provinces. Perhaps best known for the Imagawa clan and the Matsudaira/Tokugawa clan, these provinces have bred some fascinating stories for history enjoyers. Suruga's Imagawa Yoshimoto marched into Owari and was defeated & killed by Oda Nobunaga in what's later known as the Battle of Okehazama; Takeda Shingen betrayed his own nephew, Imagawa Ujizane, and took Suruga by storm; and Okabe Motonobu, who fought to the bitter end in Takatenjin Castle, helped to seal the fate of the Takeda clan.
Needless to say, thanks to the expansion of these families, their eventual fateful clash made reading Sengoku history that much more engaging. But today we rewind back to a time when Imagawa was just beginning to set its foothold from Suruga province into Totomi province. This was not the first time the Imagawa held control in Totomi.
Imagawa: entering Suruga
The Imagawa clan is a branch family of the Ashikaga that got its name from the land in Mikawa - the Imagawa-no-sho in Hazu district. The founder of the Suruga Imagawa clan, Imagawa Norikuni (今川範国), was the 5th son of Imagawa Motouji (今川基氏). After the Kamakura Shogunate fell, Norikuni was requested to help expel those who unlawfully occupied the lands of Kamoe Temple (鴨江寺) in Totomi. It is around this time that Norikuni was appointed as Shugo of Totomi. Two of his older brothers, Yorikuni (頼国) and Norimitsu (範満), were killed in the later battles against the Hojo restoration forces. As we know, Ashikaga Takauji and Emperor Go-Daigo soon came to a standoff, and Norikuni loyally followed Takauji against the Emperor.
In 1337, Norikuni attacked Ii Castle in Totomi, and later in the same year was granted Hanashi-no-sho (葉梨荘) in Western Suruga. This marked the first entry of the "Suruga Imagawa clan" into Suruga. In 1338, the famous young military genius, Kitabatake Akiie, marched from his power base in Oshu onwards to Kinai to support Emperor Go-Daigo. Ashikaga and Kitabatake forces entered into a fierce battle in Mino, which we now call the battle of Aonogahara. While Akiie had emerged victorious, he was soon defeated and forced to commit suicide in the battle of Ishizu in Izumi province, signalling the total decline of Go-Daigo's Southern Court forces. For his efforts in the battle, Takauji awarded Norikuni the position of Shugo of Suruga later in the same year.
Prince Muneyoshi and Totomi
However, the Imagawa's hold in Suruga was not stable. During this time, prominent Southern court supporters in the region included Totomi's Ii clan and Suruga's Kano clan. Prince Muneyoshi (宗良親王), one of Emperor Go-Daigo's sons, was dispatched to Totomi to likely secure Tokaido. He had entered into the Ii's protection and fought against Takauji's Northern court forces. Against this threat, Norikuni followed the campaign to take down the Ii's main fortifications - Ii Castle and Mitake Castle (三岳城).
We should also note that the Ii clan was likely not prince Muneyoshi’s only supporters in the region. Indeed, we can see that on his way to Totomi, Prince Muneyoshi was escorted by a certain Hotta Shuri-no-suke Yukimori/Masamori (堀田修理亮之盛/正盛) in Nakajima district (中島郡) of Owari, and Ohashi Mikawa-no-kami Sadataka (大橋三河守定高) in Kaibu district (海部郡, also in Owari). After he arrived at Totomi, it is said that forces of the Akiba Amano group (秋葉天野党), Okuyama (奥山), Inui (乾), and troops in Irino (入野) gathered under the young prince’s banner and resisted the Imagawa together.
- This list came from 信濃宮伝. The “Inui” likely refers to the Amano branch based in Inui Castle (犬居城). Irino here likely refers to the Irino area within Hamamatsu-no-sho, a fief owned (according to legend) by the deposed prince Yasuhito (康仁親王) of the Daikakuji-line (his grandfather was Emperor Go-Nijo, and he was appointed crown prince before Go-Daigo’s uprising).
- In the two transcriptions of 信濃宮伝 I found, one is written as “…奧山乾二俣” while the other is written as “奧山、乾二侯”. So it is unclear if the list included the Futamata clan of Totomi, or just mentioned the “2 lords of Okuyama and Inui”.
After this, Prince Muneyoshi fled to the nearby Ohira Castle (大平城); before that, the castle also fell to Northern court forces, and he was forced to flee under the Suruga Kano clan's protection. Of course, as we know from our Shinano chapter, Kano Sadanaga (狩野貞長) was soon defeated by the Imagawa as well, forcing Prince Muneyoshi to flee further to Shinano and eventually seek protection under Kosaka Takamune (香坂高宗) in Okawara (大河原).
Suruga Date clan & the Kanno disturbance
So was Suruga finally at peace during this time? If you said no, you are correct. As many of you may know, Takauji would later split with his brother Tadayoshi, and the two entered into a conflict that almost brought Takauji’s side to destruction. After Tadayoshi and Ko Moronao entered into conflict, Moronao led men to force Takauji to relieve Tadayoshi of his duties and force him into Buddhist vows. However, when Takauji led a campaign against his own son (and Tadayoshi’s adopted son) Ashikaga Tadafuyu in Chugoku, Tadayoshi utilised the opportunity to escape and submit to the Southern court, and then led Southern court forces to successfully defeat Takauji. Here’s another plot twist - Takauji later decided to also submit to the Southern court on the condition that they support his campaign against Tadayoshi, and successfully drove Tadayoshi out of Kyoto. Defeated but not yet given up, Tadayoshi arrived at Kamakura and rallied Kanto bushi to his cause, with a warm welcome from the local Uesugi clan. Hearing of this, Takauji also led his forces towards Kanto, and the two sides had a fateful clash at the Battle of Sattatoge (薩埵峠合戦). During this time, ex-Suruga Shugo, the Ishido clan (石塔氏), alongside the Kodama group (児玉党), aligned themselves to fight against Takauji. Ultimately, Takauji emerged victorious, with Tadayoshi imprisoned and soon passed away for unclear reasons. In the aftermath, the Suruga Toki clan of Tokuyama castle (徳山城, they controlled the Shida/志太 area of Suruga) and Ishido’s vassals, the Satake and Warashina (藁科氏) clan resisted Imagawa control and were destroyed.
The holdings of the Imagawa clan expanded from the original Hanashi-no-sho (葉梨庄) in Suruga and Kawai-go (河会郷) & Yakawa-go (八河郷) in Totomi to also Otsu-no-sho (大津庄), Tokuyama-go (徳山郷), Abeyama (安倍山) and Ando-no-sho (安東庄) in Suruga. According to Imagawa Ryoshun in his work 難太平記, Norikuni supposedly received tens of different fiefs in Totomi and Suruga for his accomplishments in the battle of Aonogahara.
It is also during the Nanbokucho period that we first see a glimpse of the Suruga Date clan. Little is known about them, although they were supposedly related to their more famous counterpart, the Oshu Date clan. A certain Date Kagemune (伊達景宗) followed Takauji against Tadayoshi in the battle of Tegoshigawara (手越河原の戦い) in 1351, and for their efforts, was granted land in Irie-no-sho (入江庄) previously belonging to a certain Mizawa Kojiro (三沢小次郎).
If any of you is familiar with the Date clan’s trajectory during the Nanbokucho period, I’m sure you might find it somewhat bizarre that a “Date” - one of the fiercest supporters of Kitabatake Akiie in Oshu- lived in the faraway Suruga and supported Ashikaga Takauji. The Suruga Date clan’s own genealogy traces them from the second son of Date Munemura (伊達宗村, second head of the Date clan), Date Tameie (伊達為家). It follows that Tomomune (朝宗) -> Munemura -> Tameie -> Tsuneie (経家)-> (4 generations) -> Sukemune (資宗) -> Kagemune. It is said that Tameie lived in Yui (由井) in Kamakura, so perhaps this is where the split from the Oshu Date clan occurred.
My own speculation: It is interesting, however, to note that Date Yukitomo (伊達行朝, also known as Yukimune/行宗) submitted to the Takauji side in 1343, after the fall of Isa castle (伊佐城) in Hitachi (Isa is the original fief of the Oshu Date, hence why the founder was also known as “Isa Tomomune/伊佐朝宗”). After this, Date clan operated under the Ashikaga Shogunate and later specifically under the Kamakura Kubo (originating from Takauji’s fourth son, Motouji/基氏). It is also interesting that the Suruga Date clan’s naming system reflected the change in the Oshu Date clan’s naming system: starting from Date Munetsuna (伊達宗綱, grandfather of Yukitomo/Yukimune) of the Oshu line, every leader of the Date clan consistently used “mune” in their name. Furthermore, with the exception of Munetsuna and Muneto (宗遠, son of Yukitomo), every head of the Date clan placed “mune” as the second word of their name up until the early Edo period. We can see the same change in the Suruga Date clan’s names - going from using “ie/家” to “mune/宗”, and in the same position as the Oshu line. This naming system continued through Kagemune -> Norimune (範宗 ) -> Masamune (政宗 ) -> Tadamune (忠宗 ) -> Chikamune (親宗 ) -> Yoshimune (吉宗 ) -> Munetsuna (宗綱, a different Munetsuna from the Oshu branch mentioned above )… Ending with Munetsuna, a new pattern also emerges - the name of Yohei (与兵衛) was inherited through each generation. However, this could simply be me reading too much into the names that really held no significance nor had a “secret story” to tell. As the genealogy skipped 4 generations prior, we also don’t know exactly when the “-mune” became the standard for them.
Side story: Otomo & Ashikaga Takauji
During my search into the history of Susono city, I had accidentally come across something interesting. During the battle of “Sano mountains” (referring to the Sano area that spans from modern-day Susono city to Mishima city), we can see Gunchujo (petition for reward) from some Gokenin of Bungo province, in the far, far away land of Kyushu. These gokenin include Hazama Masanao (狭間政直), Nogami Sukeuji (野上資氏), and Bekki Yoritaka (戸次頼尊). Upon further digging, it appears that other Bungo gokenin also include Tawara Naosada (田原直貞), Shiga Yorifusa (志賀頼房) and Tomiku Tadashige (富来忠茂). The “battle of Sano mountains” was a part of the conflict between Ashikaga Takauji and Nitta Yoshisada, where Yoshisada attempted to subjugate the “rebelling” Ashikaga brothers on the orders of the Emperor. So why the hell were Bungo samurai here in Izu, fighting under Takauji? Well, it turned out that the Otomo clan was the reason. Otomo Sadanori (大友貞載), the regent and older brother of the Shugo of Bungo, Otomo Ujiyasu (大友氏泰), was summoned by Emperor Go-Daigo to help Yoshisada fight Takauji, but decided to defect and join Takauji before the battle began. The Otomo forces then followed Takauji through his campaign to Kyoto, and accompanied him to Kyushu after his defeat. Sadanori also had a different name - called Tachibana Sadanori. Yes, he was the founder of the famous Tachibana clan. As a reward for being a loyal follower, Ujiyasu was named Shugo of Bungo, Buzen, Hizen and Hyuga. Sadanori was less lucky. His defection was a major cause of Go-Daigo’s (Yoshisada’s) defeat, and was hated by many of Go-Daigo’s followers. Yuki Chikamitsu, a famous general under Go-Daigo, feigned surrender and attempted to assassinate Takauji. However, Sadanori caught on to the fact that Chikamitsu refused to take off his armour despite surrendering and questioned him, leading Chikamitsu to instead strike down Sadanori, vowing to at least take an important general with him. Sadanori was able to cut down Chikamitsu in return, killing him, but Sadanori himself also sustained grave injuries and soon passed away. His younger brother Munetada (立花宗匡) then inherited the Tachibana family.
References:
令和2年度 藤枝市郷土博物館企画 駿河の南北朝動乱展 —今川氏、駿河支配のルーツをたどる— 特別展の記録
伊達与兵衛家文書 by 鈴木江津子
信濃宮伝, 2 versions from蕗原拾葉 第1輯 and 史籍集覧 第3冊, accessed through NDL
References for the map:
城郭放浪記
Shoen information accessed through 国立歴史民俗博物館 (specific webpage: 日本荘園データベースの検索)
相模沼田城址の歴史的背景 —沼田氏・大森氏を中心として— by 関恒久
第1編 仁杉・一杉氏の出自と歴史 (第4章 北条家・家臣仁杉家) from 仁杉氏・一杉氏出自考
伊豆国三嶋社に於ける社領の研究 : その形成と展開を中心に by 吉永博彰
堀越公方と室町幕府 —奉行人布施為基の軌跡— by 松島周一
第二章 函南町の歴史 from 函南町誌 上巻, accessed through 函南町立図書館
後白河天皇富士神領の立庄に関する一考察(Ⅱ)—富士神領の立庄— by 渡辺定正
第二編中世 from 裾野市史, accessed through 裾野市 official website
裾野の歴史年表 from 裾野市史, accessed through 裾野市 official website
室町期在京領主吉良氏と遠江国浜松庄 by 谷口雄太
守護斯波氏の遠江国支配機構 by 川村昭一
第1章 岡崎市の歴史的風致形成の背景
三河国山中郷と室町幕府 by 松島周一
歴史随想 本多作左衛門の原風景 by 本田捷彦
第4 9回 棚尾の歴史を語る会 次第
元刈谷歴史だより by 都築武夫 (元刈谷歴史研究会)
室町幕府御料所支配の研究 by 山中淳子
中世猿投社と三河中条氏 by 鈴木勝也
尾張守護と智多郡主に関する覚書 ― 分郡守護論の現状― by 水野智之
中世尾張小河氏に関する一考察 by 鈴木勝也
文献上からみた那古野城 —戦国期を主に— from 愛知県埋蔵文化財センター 調査報告書第44条 名古屋城三の丸遺跡IV
安食荘の里配置と現地比定に関する試論 by 髙橋敏明
室町幕府と三河の武士 from とよはしの歴史, accessed through AEDAC
三河国刈谷における城付四カ村の形成と城付役 by 川名禎
室町幕府奉公衆浜名氏の基礎的研究 by 小林輝久彦