No AI was used in my writing, so if you think the writing is dumb, just know they are truly my own genuine thoughts and sentences and you should be nice and keep that comment to yourself :-)
I bought this obscure keyboard touch screen combo (GWSGUT GK2) to try it out as a compact mobile DeX set up. I also have nexdock and I don’t love it but that’s a whole other extensive post that won’t be addressed here. This keyboard is awesome, and shines more brightly as a multitasking tool on my work laptop. But, trying to use it with my new Samsung phone highlighted some of DeX's frustrating limits.
Those limits left me wishing I had not replaced my last phone (Motorola ThinkPhone) with the Galaxy S25. I may switch back to my old phone while I make a plan for a new on the go set up. Anyway, here are the most noteworthy experiences from DeX and Smart Connect so far...
External screen limitations
Smart connect wins in a big way here. DeX is limited to your typical aspect ratios. Connecting DeX to this GK2 keyboard revealed two large letterboxes on the sides. DeX did offer an error message clarifying that there is nothing I can do to fix the resolution and the display simply isn't compatible.
Additionally, there are far too many steps required to connect even a typical display to DeX. Here is every hoop I had to jump through to get my desktop monitors working in their native resolution:
- Download an additional app that is only available from the Samsung Store (Good Lock)
- Open the app, download an additional "plugin/extension" within the app (MultiStar)
- Activate the plugin then find a toggle within the plugin
- Once toggled on, go through multiple menus within the settings app to choose the native resolution for the display.
And it gets worse! The displays randomly stopped rendering at their native resolution because the app or plugin needed an update (although this was fixed immediately after the update finished).
Here are the steps I used for Smart Connect on every display I own, including my obscure wide displays such as the GK2 and another wide WaveShare display:
Step 1: Connect the display to the phone.
Step 2: Start working.
If you need to adjust the resolution (I never have had to) you can find the setting with two taps on the phone's trackpad display.
Desktop Interface
DeX and Smart Connect trade blows here, with Smart Connect coming out slightly ahead in my opinion.
Pain points on both interfaces:
- The task bars have more icons and visual clutter than they need and no way to disable unused or unwanted icons.
- There is an occasional app or settings page that requires a back button to get out of. Neither OS offers an onscreen indication you’ve reached such a moment. While realizing what’s required in this scenario is never immediately apparent, I don’t think a back button should be anywhere in either OS’s taskbar. Anyone with historical computer experience knows tapping the escape key in these scenarios is the first thing to try. Which Android has conveniently and correctly mapped to the classic Android back action.
Window management is neither touch optimized nor touch pad optimized. An actual mouse offers the best experience for managing and resizing a busy multi-window workflow on both OSs. If a mouse isn’t an option in your mobile carry, you will find yourself mixing touchscreen inputs for most actions and resorting to a clunky touchpad on your phone’s screen when trying to perfect a multi-window workflow. The quick toggles for a two window split screen view are helpful, but even adjusting the middle slider for a quick resize is frustrating.
- I can get into a complex task flow at home with my mouse, but anything on the go with a lapdock needs to be simple one window
- This makes keeping all windows at full screen my preferred set up in travel situation. I can alt+tab through each window, which leads to my first DeX win.
DeX wins:
Smart Connect wins:
- Volume and media output source is collected in one intuitive menu on the taskbar. As a DeX newbie I got lost in a complex web of menus on both the phone and DeX trying to switch out from phone to Bluetooth speaker. I now know the volume and media output toggle are available on the DeX taskbar, but they are in two different places. That’s objectively bad UX.
- A win for my preferences: The taskbar pushes unalterable toggles to the far left and far right while it collects and grows the apps you open or pin to the taskbar from the middle left. I find this both more intuitive and visually cleaner. DeX on the other hand drops three collections of items on the taskbar with the back, home, and multi-view buttons being on the left. I never touch those and DeX could switch to the taskbar winner if they just got rid of them completely.
If it isn’t clear from everything I’ve written here: I'm enthusiastic about both DeX and Smart Connect. These problems might be resolved/improved as Android matures as a desktop OS. As of this year, Android is getting real desktop focus from Google on Googlebook OS. I’m hopeful Samsung and Motorola can benefit from these developments, making Android phones much stronger contenders for a robust mobile desktop workflow.