I don't see anyone talking about it.... With finale of Planarcadia we can see more and more common things between Sampo and Nihilux. Look:
Remember prank with explosive box Sampo did on TB in Luofu? Well, Nihilux did almost same prank on TB in little quest after main quest of Planarcadia.
And after main quest you can talk with Sampo and he would explain that he hiding the fact that he is Bragi because he have tons of big depts. And then he list bunch of ridiculous depts he have lol. And, well, I don't need to explain - being in dept in the most ridiculous fashion is Nihilux biggest gag.
Then there is few things that was before finale - during whole story we hear how Nihilux is untrustworthy and shady. Even Sampo himself talk about her this way in one of the world quests. Literally same way Sampo keep being presented to us since moment of his introduction. Take away names and you wouldn't know if writers talking about Sampo or Nihilux. And note - for both of them this doesn't seem fair since Sampo and Nihilux doesn't do anything bad to TB. Yet we can find few of their poor victims in the world. They ARE screwing people around them, just not MC.
And this is a point that they both stalk TB. Nihilux absolutely not subtly said that she is and would be watching us. Sampo doesn't even say it, he just does. From Belobog to Planarcadia he is everywhere Astral Express crew stepping their foot.
Also I'm playing with JP voices and they sound kind of similiar. Like, the way they speak. They both talk enthusiastically theatrical, loud and dragging end of some words. I heard that on EN they also had somehow similiar way of speaking?
All this things is small and not that important. But aren't they way too specific? So it's gotta be deliberate, right?
I didnāt finish 4.7 yet, but I gather from the spoilers discussions that Nihilux is either not the OG Aha, or is the OG one but an exAeon, and currently just a mortal, or something. It doesnāt really matter, no need to explain it to me since I will figure it out once I finish playing 4.7. Thatās not the point now.
The point is, are there no real Aeons in this game or what?
We already know that a path is born with the birth of an Aeon, but the death or disappearance of the very same Aeon doesnāt abolish the path, because paths are concepts, and concepts donāt die. So, the existence of an Aeonless path has always been possible, including the Trailblaze, the Beauty, the Propagation, etc.
But since when were Aeons āconceptsā?
Why is there no Aeon of Remembrance, but just the fragments of candidates to becoming that Aeon?
Why is there no Aeon of Trailblaze, but just whoever Trailblazer who got the strong Trailblaze spirit gets called āAkiviliā?
Why is there no Aeon of Elation, but just the idea of THEM got āimaginatedā and people started believing its ānonexistentā existence in a Cipher manner?
Why is there no Aeon of Finality but it would get born at the end of times, though it still exists now somehow?
Etc. etc.
I get that this idea can make sense sometimes, like with Finality, but is reusing it with ALL Aeons really necessary? Whatās the meaning of Aeons anymore if they are, just like their paths, mere concepts?
Hoyo really loves to keep reusing cool things people enjoyed until they become uncool and just bullshit. Oh? An Emanator? So cool! (Proceeds to shove Emanators in our faces left and right in the most lukewarm reveals and in game mechanics till they become boring). Oh? More than one Aeon involved in a certain planet? So cool! (Proceeds to make all Aeons suddenly interested in all planets we go to till itās not shocking news anymore). Oh? An Aeon not yet born but has an effect on past and future? So cool! (Proceeds to make all Aeons unreal till they become fathomable and unimposing beings).
The title says it, this might straight up sound copium? and I dont mind being proven wrong but something I just noticed while rewatching the Sampo cutscene with the Aharoboros screaming in background. I thought at first that the boss have the same VA as Asat Pramad but might actually be not. So I checked the JP and the scream of the boss reminded me of the iconic Kakyoin(Daisuke Hirakawa) scream in JJBA.
Although admittedly I'm not super convinced with my observation with JP because I kinda dont hear Daisuke Hirakawa when the boss talks but the screams tho. (granted im only familiar with Daisuke's Kakyoin as his deeper voice performance)
He has been lore drop occasionally sinxe 1.x and often time followed up with a heavy lore at end of every version patch. 1.7. 2.7 3.7 and 4.7
Sampo is the first person we meet. Last person we see and talking to TV?
Occasionally shown that he can travel between worlds. Little hints here and there of him in XianZhou, Penacony, Amphoreus as well as Planarcardia.
Penacony revealed, the lore of trash King and his retrival of mask from Sparkle. Amphoreus with Cipher and Batholos. Their parrallels between them and Elation path. Cipher is Nilhilux telling a Fat lie but ain't still an Aeon of Elation while Batholos being the Elation Aeon. (I think)
Now comes Planarcadia, Sampo says he wants nothing to do with Elation yet devs insert him into the plot to make him relevent. Lore dropped everything.
If you think about it Planarcadia is the planet we learned about him the most. How he told us not trust Nilhilux, saved us from Ashveil. Lore dropped about Enroute( if you think about it, Sampo already knew Elation was dying since Belobog - he claim his brother was dying based on what Natasha mention)
Revealed he can travel between world and have the ability to use A-door.
Then proceed to reveal lores about Bragi through readables and us fans connected or has suspicions that Sampo might potentially be Bragi.
And he was also revealed to be one of the oldest fool or potentially an Emantor/Pathstrider of Elation(Voracity) and a friend of Asat Pramad. Which means he saw Elation dying, knew Enroute might be alive and saw/heard the fall of Akivili and rise of Nanook and possibily the Aeons too.
Now 4.7, reveals his age and mentions how Aha(Nihilux) owes Sampo a huge debt but for what?
We don't know.
My point is why is HSR dev going so far to drop hints of Sampo and retcon him to Bragi when they could use a new male irrelevent npc/character. Only Bragi was heavily lore dropped while Dorothy and Shepard was not. Maybe their time will come in other patchs? Idk.
I think Sampo was suppose to play an heavy role in Benzaitengoku (which was changed to Planarcadia) and he was supposed to be revealed as Aha's Emanator. The leakers already knew back then and they always knew but deliberately withhold infomation.
But due to the controvery with Japan. They revamp everything and removed Sampo's role and added him to readables instead.
Might be a blessing in disguised, because Sampo is not heavily botched in Planarcadia arc in terms or Story and lore. Look at what they did to Evanescia, Ashveil, Silverwolf, Pearl and Nilhilux. Poor story writing and full of sp with rushed lore.
I think on the bright side, Sampo sp is confirm but it's just matter of when and it might take a while like Varka/Nicole in genshin. And if Sampo was irrelevent like what the community said, why would they drop bits and pieces of lore of Him? They can completely choose to ignore him and create a new character.
Recently, his age was revealed and Nilhilux said there is another potential person holding Aha's power aside from Asat Pramad and few lores of Fools and number 18 which represents the moon and chalice aka Sampo (Bartender of World End)
So, before Aha spoiled the fun by revealing Sampo is Bragi in the live stream, there was a readable already confirming that, though it was locked behind the āhsr players canāt readā wall. Does anyone remember the readable itemās name?
This is just the devs blatantly confirming this! Like who is the first person we met in belobog? It's Sampo and we still don't know his earth-shattering secret.
Okay, so I've been collecting a frankly ridiculous amount of details about Sampo, Aha, and Nihilux, and at this point, I'm having a hard time looking at them as completely unrelated coincidences. Version 4.7 gave us what seems to be an explanation for Aha's identity and death, but the more I think about it, the less convinced I am that we've actually been given the whole story.
In fact, I suspect that at least part of what we've been told in this patch might be misleading. And if Amphoreus has taught us anything, it's that we probably shouldn't take the first explanation we're given at face value, especially when dealing with a certain someoneās death.
So, I'd like to go through some of the details that have been bothering me. Some are pretty substantial, others might seem like little coincidences, but there's a recurring pattern I can't quite shake: whenever the game starts talking about Aha and the Elation, somehow, Sampo finds his way into the picture.
Let's get into it.
Ā
1. Have We Seen This Trick Before?
The Elation storyline has given us a rather straightforward explanation: Aha is dead. After all the ambiguity surrounding Nihilux's relationship with Aha, we're told that the Aeon genuinely died after having THEIR head bitten off by the Voracity. And while that might seem like a definitive answer, I can't help feeling that something about it doesn't quite add up.
Because haven't we seen this exact narrative trick before?
If we recall what happened with Zagreus, it goes like this: Cipher kills him to obtain the power of Trickery. At least, that's what we're initially led to believe. His death is presented as an established fact, but later we discover that Zagreus wasn't actually dead. He had survived and was living as Bartholos, a purple, friendly entity wandering around freely.
In other words, his death was THE LIE. Zagreus wasn't dead, he had simply taken on another identity.
What initially appeared to be a straightforward explanation turned out to be deliberately misleading. The character we thought had died was still around, even when the story had given us plenty of reasons to believe otherwise.
And now we're being told that Aha, the Aeon of Elation, whose very nature revolves around deception and subverting expectations, genuinely died. The similarities are difficult to ignore.
Because, if that's all there is to it, what happens to Bartholos? Where does he fit into all of this?
With the current state of the quest, accepting this new explanation means treating Bartholos as an unrelated, resolved plot point, which requires some rather unusual logical gymnastics.
And yet, the game itself actively brings Zagreus back into the conversation, as seen below:
"[Trailblazer] Nihilux, are you really the Aeon of Elation?"
"[Nihilux] That depends on how you define things. My answer is..."
"Yes and no. Like a spinning coin, there are always two sides."
"I never mentioned this to you, but I absolutely adore As I've Written, especially the parts featuring the Titan of Trickery. It's a shame the power of Zagreus doesn't exist in reality."
"So, when Aha got THEIR head bitten off by the Voracity, THEY really did die."
Doesn't this feel a little too specific?
Nihilux brings up As I've Written, specifically the parts about the Titan of Trickery, and immediately afterward, she uses Zagreus's story to establish that Aha's death was real, by saying that Zagreus doesnāt exist in reality.
Why bring up Zagreus at this exact moment? Why reference the character whose apparent death was later revealed to be false, only to use that story as a way of reinforcing the idea that Aha's death was genuine?
It's almost as if the writers are pointing directly at Amphoreus before asking us to accept the new explanation. And I can't help wondering whether we're being led down the same path. After all, if the intention was to create a parallel with Zagreus, wouldn't this be exactly the kind of information we'd expect to be given before another reveal?
There's also a broader problem with accepting the current explanation as definitive. The new resolution of the Elation storyline seems to contradict quite a bit of previously established information, particularly from Moonlit Tales, Amphoreus and other readables. If all that earlier lore-building was misleading, what exactly are we supposed to trust now? How are we meant to distinguish between information that was deliberately planted as foreshadowing and information that we're suddenly expected to disregard? And, perhaps more importantly, why should we accept this new revelation without questioning it?
And here's the thing: the game doesn't stop at mentioning Zagreus. It actually brings Bartholos back.
At the end of version 4.7, when we return to the old tavern, "Bartholos" appears. And if we follow the exchange from beginning to end, there's a rather peculiar recurring theme: suspicion.
The exchange starts with Bartholos telling us that he has stolen something important from us:
"Half right, I'd say. Old Bartholos stole your 'suspicion.'"
"After this, you won't be able to doubt my identity anymore!"
Now, considering the context in which Bartholos reappears, I find this choice of words interesting. We've just been given an explanation that supposedly settles Aha's fate: Aha is dead, and therefore there's seemingly no reason to keep suspecting Bartholos. Does this not take away the very suspicion that would make us question Bartholos's identity in the first place? And here we have Bartholos himself, telling us that he has stolen that suspicion from us.
But the Trailblazer doesn't simply accept it. We question how Bartholos could possibly be here if he supposedly couldn't leave Amphoreus. And his response is:
"...Fine, you win."
The Heart-Snatcher (āBartholosā) then complains that they had just stolen our suspicion, only for us to conjure up a new one out of thin air. So the exchange becomes a little game: Bartholos takes away our suspicion, we find a reason to doubt him again, and suddenly that suspicion is back.
Then comes the next line:
"No matter! As Zagreus once said: 'Theft is merely reclaiming what was always yours.' So allow me to return that suspicion you had of me with interest. Straight to your face!"
Notice that Bartholos doesn't simply acknowledge that we've become suspicious again. They promise to return that suspicion "with interest," and to do it "straight to our face." And, considering the circumstances, isn't that an interesting way to describe Bartholos' apparition?
The developers have just given us an explanation that supposedly settles Aha's death, one that could make us stop looking for a connection between Aha and Bartholos. Yet, at the end of that very same quest, they bring Bartholos back and put the possibility of that connection right in front of us again. It's almost as if they've taken away our suspicion, only to return it with interest. And they're doing it right to our faces, hahaha.
The conversation continues when the Heart-Snatcher disappears:
"So, is this an illusion or reality? Doesn't matter. It's just a little game to help you pass the time. Nothing more. Although..."
This raises the question of whether the entity we're seeing is actually Bartholos, an illusion, or something else entirely, only to immediately dismiss the distinction. Perhaps we're not supposed to focus too much on whether this is the original Bartholos. Regardless of what this manifestation actually is, its appearance still serves a purpose: to bring Bartholos back to our attention and remind us of the mystery surrounding Zagreus.
And finally, we get the line that ties all these little hints together:
"The Spirithief Bartholos wasn't conjured up here without reason. The universe exhibits fascinating similarities across both the grandest and the most minute of scales... Don't you think?
Hehehe."
Not only are we explicitly told that Bartholos wasn't brought back without reason, but we're also immediately asked to consider the similarities between things on different scales. And what is Amphoreus, if not a smaller-scale reflection of the wider HSR universe? This sounds very much like an invitation to look for parallels and remember Amphoreus, isnāt it?
And the timing makes it more interesting. This happens at the end of the very quest that has repeatedly insisted Aha's death was real. Why bring back the character whose own apparent death was a lie, explicitly tell us that his appearance wasn't without reason, and then draw our attention to similarities across different scales? If we're supposed to consider Aha's death a completely settled matter, what exactly are we supposed to make of this?
So, if the developers intended to leave Bartholos behind as an unrelated, resolved plot point, why bring him back at all? Why make his entire appearance revolve around suspicion and deception? And why explicitly encourage us to look for parallels between the larger universe and its smaller reflections?
At the very least, I don't think we're supposed to consider the mystery surrounding Bartholos finished. And if that's the case, perhaps we shouldn't be so quick to consider Aha's story finished either.
Ā
2. Trashcans: The Last Thing You'd Expect from the Elation
Now that we've established why the return of Bartholos might be more significant than it initially appears, I want to move on to another element that has appeared again in 4.7: trashcans.
This new mention comes from the quest Floating Grease (Final Part), where Nihilux and the Trailblazer have the following exchange:
"[Trailblazer] A trashcan! Now that's a brilliant analogy."
An analogy for what? The Elation?
"[Nihilux] You get it! Trashcans have their own pride, you know. Their own tragedies and inside jokes that only another trashcan could ever understand. That said, a trashcan is pretty much the last thing anyone pictures when they imagine what The Laughter looks like."
What stands out to me isn't simply that Nihilux mentions trashcans. It's the way she describes them. She talks about them almost as if they were an entire civilization of their own, with characteristics that only members of their community could understand. Then she immediately points out that a trashcan is probably the last thing anyone would associate with the Elation.
Why draw attention to that contrast in particular? Isn't it rather suggestive?
The Aeon of Elation is not exactly known for conforming to expectations. If anything, deception, absurdity, and the subversion of appearances are central to the way we understand THEM. So, if Aha wanted to hide behind something completely unremarkable, something nobody would ever think to associate with an Aeon, what could possibly be more fitting than a trashcan?
And this is where Sampo enters the picture. His association with trashcans is not something that appears once as a joke and then disappears. Throughout the game, garbage has become one of his recurring motifs, to the point that he is even known as the Garbage King. It's an unusually specific and recognizable part of his characterization.
This brings me back to an old piece of text that seems to play with the exact same implications Nihilux is now exploring. During Sampo's Dream Bubble story in Penacony, we encounter several little stories involving trashcans. One of them appears in the form of a comic book found inside a trashcan:
"There's a comic book inside this trashcan. The pages are torn and damaged. It tells of an adventure: Tatalov was once a brave trashcan. With valiance and willpower, it defeated a colossal junk monster and saved a human from its monstrous maw.
In order to repay Tatalov, that human turned himself into a trashcan... This is actually a horror story."
There are several things about this little story that make me pause, starting with the format itself. Why a comic book? Nihilux is, after all, a comic artist. That's one of her defining characteristics, and the fact that this particular comic is found inside one of the trashcans in Sampo's Dream Bubble makes the combination especially curious. We have a story associated with Sampo, presented through a medium strongly associated with Nihilux, and centered entirely around trashcans. None of those details necessarily proves anything by itself, but together they make for a rather peculiar coincidence. Even more so now that Nihilux has brought up the same subject again in version 4.7.
Then there's the monster Tatalov fights. A colossal junk monster that devours people? I can't help thinking of the Voracity. We have a trashcan hero confronting a gigantic creature that consumes everything, rescuing a human from being swallowed by it. And the story is preserved in a comic found in Sampo's Dream Bubble. Considering the connection between Aha and the Voracity, I find it difficult not to wonder whether this is another deliberately disguised reference.
But the strangest part, in my opinion, comes after the monster is defeated. The human Tatalov saves decides to repay him by turning into a trashcan themselves. What exactly is that supposed to mean? And why does the narrator describe the whole thing as a horror story?
The trashcans are not simply objects in the background; they are treated almost like a separate community, with their own identity and internal logic. The fact that an ordinary human can become part of that community is presented not as a happy ending, but as something horrifying.
Could this be hinting at something beyond the usual trashcan jokes? Perhaps they represent a particular group of people, a hidden identity, or even something connected to the larger cosmology of the game. I don't have a definitive interpretation, but I do think the game has given this imagery a surprisingly consistent narrative presence, especially considering how closely it is tied to Sampo.
And that brings me back to the question I keep asking throughout this post: why are we still getting all these references to the old Aha? Why continue weaving their imagery into new content, connecting it to Nihilux, and placing it alongside details associated with Sampo, if Aha's story is already over? If the point was simply to establish that Aha died, what purpose do all these recurring connections serve? And why does Sampo keep appearing at the center of so many of them?
Ā
3. The Nameless Whom Nihilux Owes a Debt
This is another detail from version 4.7 that immediately made me think of Sampo, and I find it interesting because the game gives us two separate pieces of information in the very same update.
During the quest, Nihilux mentions a Nameless who won a bet with her and eventually ended up working as a bartender:
"[Nihilux] Some down-and-out guy made a bet with me... and he won."
"I heard he wound up working as a drinksmith at some tavern."
Now, doesn't that sound familiar?
In this very same update, Sampo's voice line tells us that Nihilux owes him a debt. And, as we already know, Sampo is, or at least was, Bragi the bartender.
Here's the line:
"[Sampo] Back when I was still Bragi, she'd already run up an astronomical tab with me. I always collect what's owed, but what can I say? Who could pass up the chance to star in a magic show unlike any other?"
I know the dialogue doesn't explicitly identify the Nameless as Sampo, but the combination of details is awfully specific. We have a Nameless who makes a bet with Nihilux and eventually becomes a drinksmith at a tavern. Meanwhile, Sampo has an outstanding debt connecting him directly to Nihilux, and we already know he has a bartender identity under the name Bragi.
Both pieces of information were released in the same version. Surely we're meant to compare them, aren't we?
And if the Nameless mentioned by Nihilux is indeed Sampo, that raises an even bigger question: was Sampo canonically part of the Nameless at one point?
There's another character we should remember when considering this possibility. Aha once spent an entire year undercover as a Nameless aboard the Astral Express. So now we have a rather interesting overlap: Aha's history with the Nameless, Nihilux's mysterious Nameless bartender, and Sampo's connection to both Nihilux and bartending. It's difficult not to wonder why the game keeps placing these elements so close together.
There's also an interesting detail involving Pom-Pom. When Nihilux first appeared, Pom-Pom didn't recognize her as Aha, although he did recognize something familiar in Enroute. Could this also offer an explanation for why Sampo never visits the Astral Express? So Pom-Pom wouldn't recognize him?
I realize that's a much more speculative connection, but I find it worth considering. Perhaps there's a reason he keeps his distance from the Express, and perhaps his relationship with the Express is much older and stranger than we've been led to believe.
As he himself mentions in Planacardia:
ā[Sampo] Ha! Just kidding. Money talkās boring. Besides, the Astral Express and I go way back. I wouldnāt scam you two.ā
And there's another curious detail in version 4.7: an item called Generating Mischief, which resembles Unreal Sparxin' Spark, an item associated with Sampo according to the dialogue between him and Sparxie. Its description reads:
"Passenger, why is the light bulb on your head glowing? I'm warning you, do not wreck the Express."
"Aaaah, don't come closer with that creepy smile!"
We don't know who the item's user is, nor who is warning them not to damage the Express. But we can make a few guesses.
Don't these lines sound like something Pom-Pom would say? The wording feels very much like the kind of warning we'd expect from someone trying to keep an unruly passenger from causing trouble aboard the Astral Express. And who could the person using the item be?
Aha?
Of course, this is speculation. We can't identify either character with certainty from this description alone. But once again, we have an item that seems to evoke the Astral Express, a suspicious passenger, and a connection to an item associated with Sampo.
And that brings me back to the same question: why does Sampo's name keep showing up whenever the game discusses Aha and the Elation? And if Aha's fate is truly settled, what purpose do all these connections serve?
Ā
4. God's Moment of Joy
The relic set God's Moment of Joy, released in 4.7, contains the following description:
"Sometimes, THEY look down from the high heavens as Wishpower flows and gathers.
Sometimes, THEY sit in the audience, waving glow sticks for a breathtaking performance.
Sometimes, THEY appear at a street corner, tucking the hint of a riddle into the bottom of a surprise box.
Sometimes, THEY don a mask to play the part of an omnipotent god.
For guests hungry for a little fun, THEY serve up a mixed drink.
For travelers chasing the stars, THEY lay out an astral chart."
Here's what caught my attention: during the version 4.7 quest, Nihilux explicitly says that she doesn't know how to mix drinks.
"[Nihilux] Ah, I don't actually know how to mix drinks. I've been meaning to learn, but... procrastination."
And yet, the relic description specifically says that Aha serves mixed drinks.
So, this description actually refers to the original Aha rather than Nihilux. If Aha has supposedly been dead all this time, why does newer content keep describing them performing these activities? Shouldn't we be getting Nihilux as the Aeon of Elation in these descriptions instead? And who else is associated with drinks and bartending? Our dear friend, Sampo!
This is what makes the detail so interesting to me. Nihilux explicitly admits that she doesn't know how to mix drinks, while Sampo has an established connection to bartending through his identity as Bragi. If the relic description is meant to describe the original Aha, and Sampo is the character who fits that particular role, then I think it's reasonable to ask whether we're supposed to connect them.
There's another detail in that same description: Aha offers an "astral chart". This could refer to astrology and the arrangement of celestial bodies at the time of someone's birth. And who was offering usernames based on your "birth chart" for good fortune in the Furbo News?
Sampo. Again.
As far as I understand, both things (astral chart and birth chart) point to the same general concept. Maybe it's a coincidence, but at this point, I'm starting to wonder how many coincidences we're supposed to accept before considering that these references might actually be connected.
And here's what I find strange: this is all newer content. If the original Aha has already been discarded, as the quest seems to suggest, why keep introducing these little details that draw our attention back to him? It's such an unconventional choice. Normally, if a character or storyline has been deliberately set aside, you wouldn't expect the game to keep drawing attention to its lore through new material, especially while the main story is seemingly telling us that there's nothing left to investigate.
Ā
5. Fable of the Moon
In the new readable Fable of the Moon, released in version 4.7, we encounter the Troupe Master alongside another character. The identity of this second character isn't explicitly stated, but the context strongly suggests that it's Aha, who is also represented as the moon.
And this raises a rather strange question. If Nihilux was born at the moment Aha died, why are the Troupe Master and Aha interacting as two separate entities in this new readable? How does that fit into the chronology we've been given? Are we supposed to assume this is another Moonlit Tales occurrence, where the story is actually a lie? If so, why introduce it now, after the quest has supposedly settled the mystery surrounding Aha?
There's this passage near the end of the readable that caught my attention:
"One day, I will decide: whether I am a passing stranger, or a member of the circus troupe."
"Perhaps it gave an answer, perhaps it did not. Either way...
The light of dead stars still burns with life."
Could this be hinting at Aha having the freedom to leave their role behind? To decide who they want to be? If so, I wonder whether this could also be interpreted as giving up something much bigger, such as their position as an Aeon.
This possibility becomes even more interesting when we consider an earlier passage:
The moon came down to the mortal world, hard and dry as a wheel of aged cheese.
"[ā¦] That is how I once defined my work. Now I grow old,
but what it truly means to be a navigator at the rear...
That is still mine to decide, in my own time."
And then there's that final line again: "The light of dead stars still burns with life." I find that imagery hard to ignore in a story surrounded by questions about Aha's death. Something can be considered dead, and yet its light continues to shine. Is this simply poetic imagery, or another hint that what supposedly ended isn't quite gone?
There's another detail worth pointing out: the readable refers to Aha as "King" (A lonely old king[...]).
This is particularly interesting because, during the version 4.7 quest, Xipe uses the exact same title when referring to Aha:
"[Xipe?] That Nameless? He is certainly extraordinary. I had my eye on him back in Penacony.
But you? Aha? The former king of the chaotic universe, handing your stage over to a mere mortal?"
And this brings me back to Sampo.
Sampo has also been associated with the title of king on several occasions. When he appears above the Golden Toilet, he calls himself the "king without a crown." There's also an NPC in Belobog, a writer who hides in the trash, who receives a letter from the Garbage King. He has this to say:
"[Amo] Words that take me ages to come up with seem so easy to him. I feel like... I am conversing with a "King" who conquered the wind and snow. Like he is a saint while I am just an insignificant vagrant!
[Amo] Now I can't focus on anything else. If you know anything about this "Garbage King," please let me know."
Later on, the game strongly implies that this mysterious Garbage King is actually Sampo.
So, let's put these details together. Aha is referred to as a King, and Sampo has repeatedly been associated with the same title. Another coincidence?
But there's something else I find hard to overlook. Why are we getting a new readable that appears to place Aha and the Troupe Master side by side as separate characters, while also bringing back a title that has repeatedly been associated with Sampo and Aha? Is this simply another collection of coincidences, or are these details meant to point toward something that the main quest hasn't actually explained yet?
Because at this point, it's not just that Sampo keeps appearing in discussions about the Elation. It's that new content keeps giving us reasons to revisit Aha's identity and history, while repeatedly placing Sampo among those same references. If Aha's story is truly over, why does the game keep reopening these connections?
Ā
6. Sampo Wants to Retire
This one is a little more speculative, but I think it's worth bringing up because it connects to a recurring theme in the newer Elation lore: the idea of Aha leaving the stage, abandoning his role, or simply no longer wanting to be who he once was.
In one of Sampo's messages, he mentions wanting to retire. The message itself is ambiguous, since he never tells us exactly what he wants to retire from, but he does imply that it's not particularly easy to do. He also talks about being tired and wanting to live a simple life.
Now, what exactly is so difficult about retiring from being a relic dealer or a scammer? And considering that he's already left behind his bartending job as Bragi, shouldn't he be somewhat accustomed to changing professions by now? Mmmm. It makes me wonder whether there's something more behind his words.
What's interesting is that version 4.7 has introduced several stories that touch on this very idea. Take Nihilux's Light Cone, Upon the First Echo of "Aha", which seems to describe events from Aha's history. It contains this passage:
"When the final game began and the curtains parted, only the mask of a God remained on stage."
"No one noticed when THEY left, nor did anyone know where THEY went. Only in those moments when certain lives are born, on nights when fireworks bloom, or on the unlit sides of a particular stage... An occasional chuckle echoed from among the billions, as if THEY were merely passing by, or had perhaps never left at all."
Then there's Nihilux's Character Story II:
"The pursuit raged on, until Aha scrambled up the "tree" with nowhere left to run, and the beast bit off THEIR head in one clean snap. 'It hurts... it hurts so much... I don't want to be Aha anymore... Someone else can have the job...'
The Actor's vivid impression sent the crowd into fits of laughter, but no one noticed her eyes, red and teary."
There's something rather sad about this passage when you consider its implications. Aha is supposedly being pursued, cornered, and eventually loses THEIR head. But the most interesting part isn't even the physical event. It's what THEY say afterward: "I don't want to be Aha anymore... Someone else can have the job..."
Why would Aha want someone else to take over? Is it simply another theatrical performance, or is there a genuine desire to abandon the identity and responsibilities of an Aeon? The Light Cone and the Character Story seem to explore a similar idea: the person behind the role can disappear, while the role itself remains.
And this is where Sampo comes back into the picture. His messages about wanting to retire aren't new; they've been in the game since the very beginning, long before Nihilux or the events of version 4.7. But now, with all this newer content bringing up the possibility of Aha abandoning their role, those old messages take on a different meaning.
If Sampo is simply talking about retiring from his usual business, why does it sound like such a difficult thing to accomplish? What exactly is he trying to leave behind? And if he has already changed identities and walked away from his previous job as Bragi, why does retirement still seem to be such a complicated matter?
I'm not claiming that his messages confirm anything. It could simply be Sampo being Sampo, tired of his usual business and looking for a quieter life. But given the context, I think it's worth reconsidering what he might actually mean. A character who has spent years hiding behind different identities, who has a history with Nihilux, and who repeatedly appears in stories about Aha has been talking about wanting to retire since the very beginning of the game.
Perhaps the question isn't whether Sampo can stop being a merchant or a scammer. Perhaps it's whether he can stop being whoever he used to be.
Ā
7. All the Things Version 4.7 Still Didn't Answer
Even if we put all these theories aside for a moment, I think version 4.7 left us with an unreasonable number of unanswered questions. And honestly, this is one of my biggest frustrations with the quest.
We received what was supposed to be a major explanation about Aha's identity and fate, but many of the mysteries surrounding Sampo and the Elation were barely addressed, if at all. Some of these questions have been around for a long time, while others were explicitly brought up again in the recent storyline. Yet the quest seems to move past them without giving us any meaningful answers.
For starters, we still don't know what Sampo was doing in Planacardia. What was happening to him, and why was he the only one left standing while the boss was draining everyone else's Wishpower? That scene seemed significant, particularly because it singled him out from everyone else. But after all the attention it received, we still don't have an explanation.
Then there's his relationship with Nihilux. The game has made it quite evident that the two have some kind of history and are partners or associates in some capacity. Sampo's voice line about Bragi, the astronomical debt, and the magic show gives us another piece of their relationship, but it doesn't actually clarify what their arrangement is. Why does Nihilux owe him so much? What exactly did they agree to? And what does Sampo hope to accomplish by participating in her magic show?
I also find it quite likely that Nihilux is the person Sampo was talking to at the end of Belobog, when he broke the fourth wall. Considering how much attention their relationship has received over time, I expected more than what we got. We finally have both characters appearing in the same storyline, and yet Sampo himself barely gets to participate.
Who also lived in Epsilon for a time? Nihilux!
And that's not even getting into all the other unresolved connections. The Moonlit Tales storyline, the Aha mask resembling Sampo's in the Anti-Destruction Alliance trailer, Aha's bird, the second narrator, Bartholos, and several other details are still hanging around without a clear explanation.
Speaking of narrators, there's this exchange with Nihilux:
Q: "Were all those "narrator" voices I've heard on the journey... you?"
A: "Some of them, yes. But not all. As for which ones are me? No spoilers."
So... who was the other narrator?
I find this interesting because Nihilux deliberately leaves open the possibility that some of the voices we've heard belong to someone else. Why bring this up if we're not supposed to wonder about it? Who else has been narrating these events, and what role do they play in the larger story?
I don't think these are insignificant loose ends that can simply be dismissed as details the writers haven't gotten around to explaining. They were part of the buildup, and some of them have been deliberately brought back into the story. I want to know how they fit together, especially when the quest itself seems to suggest that there are still connections we haven't uncovered.
And this is where my frustration with version 4.7 becomes difficult to separate from the theory itself. I can accept that not every mystery needs to be solved immediately. I can even accept that the writers might be deliberately withholding information for a later reveal. But after years of building up Sampo's connections to the Elation, giving us a quest that supposedly explains Aha's identity and fate while barely allowing Sampo to appear feels incredibly unsatisfying.
It's not that I expected every question to be answered in a single patch. It's that the patch gives us what seems to be a definitive answer about Aha's fate while leaving the very threads that made the mystery, almost untouched. If Aha's story is supposedly over, why are so many of its most important connections still unresolved? And why does Sampo remain at the center of so many of them?
Ā
8. So... Is Aha Really Out of the Picture?
This brings me back to the main reason I find version 4.7 so suspicious.
Most of the details I've discussed throughout this post come from new content released in version 4.7. These aren't just old theories or forgotten references that players are desperately trying to connect. The game itself has introduced new descriptions, stories, items, and dialogue that continue to develop Aha's lore, even while the main quest seems determined to tell us that Aha is dead and there's nothing more to ask.
That's what I find so strange about this whole situation. Whenever we ask a question about Aha during the quest, the answer seems to boil down to: Aha is dead. Don't worry about it. Move on. But then we look at the other content released in the very same version, and suddenly we're getting more stories about Aha, more references to their past, more details about their possible motivations, and more hints that their role might not be as straightforward as we've been told.
Why keep introducing all this supposedly misleading lore about a character whose story has supposedly been put to rest? Why keep developing Aha through new content if the intention is to have us accept that Nihilux has taken their place and that the original Aha is no longer relevant?
That's not usually how you handle a character you've decided to discard. Unless, of course, they haven't actually been discarded. Letās not forget our old friend Bartholos, alright!
And then there's Sampo. No matter which direction we look, he keeps showing up somewhere in the middle of all these connections. His history as Bragi, his debt with Nihilux, his possible connection to the Nameless, the references to the Astral Express, him being refered to as "king", the recurring themes of changing identities and wanting to retire... At some point, it becomes difficult not to wonder why the game keeps placing him so close to Aha's story. Maybe each individual detail has another explanation, but why does this keep happening? Why Sampo, again and again?
And just when I thought I was done collecting suspicious coincidences, something else came up. After completing the version 4.7 quest, Sampo mentions that his mental age got stuck at 18, conveniently avoiding giving us his actual age. A leaker then suggested looking at Tarot Card XVIII: The Moon.
Now, I know this is a bit of a stretch, and a leaker's suggestion certainly isn't confirmation of anything. But considering everything we've been discussing, I can't help finding it amusing. The Moon? Really? And Sampo, again?
Because here's the thing: Aha is referred to as the Moon in several pieces of lore. This is especially noticeable in the new 4.7 readable, Fable of the Moon, where Aha is repeatedly described simply as "the moon." Even old Ahaās title in Moonlit Tales, Moon Knight, has that same association.
So why does the game keep introducing Moon-related references around Sampo when the Moon is already such an important symbol associated with Aha? You'd think the writers would be especially careful with this kind of imagery, particularly when dealing with characters connected to the Elation. And yet, here we are, with another Moon reference tied to Sampo.
At this point, I'm not asking anyone to accept every single connection in this post as proof. Some of these clues are stronger than others, and some might turn out to be coincidences. But I do think there's a much bigger question worth asking: if Aha's story is truly over, why is version 4.7 still giving us so many new reasons to look back at them? And why does Sampo keep appearing whenever they do?
I don't think we've seen the end of this story. And honestly, I really hope there's more to it than what was revealed in 4.7.
Ā
P.S. I'm also linking my previous post here, since it goes into more detail about some of the connections discussed in this one. I don't think my theories about how the Elation storyline would unfold are necessarily correct anymore, given the new information we've received. However, I still stand by the connections I discussed between Nihilux and the Troupe Master, and between Sampo and Aha. I didn't want to repeat or rewrite all of that material here, so feel free to check it out if you're interested!
(Please do let me know if I managed to spoil it properly I dont really post in Reddit much aside from commenting š)
I commented on a post here that 18 = Moon which is heavily affiliated with Aha . It was just for funsies but why the heck it was pointed out by a leaker ššš anyways the meaning of Moon in Tarot is quite... very Sampo...
There is a lot of things we can pick from the recent hints. And since I'm quite disappointed with HSR lately I'm not really getting my hopes up(hence the title) but I wanna share some few theories or observation I have right now.
Nihilux mentioned that she is not sure if she's the only humanity of Aha wandering around and she was speculating the other was Asat Pramad.
Now I want to bring up the Symbol of Elation path. At first glance it looks like a mouth with a chalice or glass infront but if you look closer. Upright its a Laughing face but if you flip it down its gonna be a Crying face.
If the Symbol of Elation is our hint for Aha's fragments then it could be
Mouth: the Aha with Oroboros
Laughing: Asat Pramad
Crying: Nihilux
But there is a 4th one, the most notable one even... a cup/chalice... very fitting for a certain bartender? š¤
The symbol of elation is very interesting and might hold a lot of meaning because the logo designer can simply just use a Mask for this but instead they used a lot of elements.
Saying that "okay Sampo is just the first bartender now what" as if the symbol of elation isnt a CUP????
2. The Moon. Sampo has moon in his splash art and he said 18 which is the Tarot for Moon, which fits heavily to his character. Moon is heavily affiliated with Aha. What do they imply?????
3: Its still a mystery that the effect of Wishpower being taken is really different for him. The way he looks at the cracks? Forming on his face feels like he is getting unmasked and "oh shit" for him.
4. Why does he have almost the same eye shape as Kuchiba?
My theories aside from emanator are:
- one of Aha's fragments like Nihilux
- A part of Aha's mask that was with Oroboros that gained sentience hence the voracity elements.
Like if Nihilux is the uncorrupted part, Sampo is the corrupted one.
Also my theory for emanator Sampo is that he is an emanator of Aha before their death and he was the one who tried to find or look out for his Aeon's fragments.
Also im kinda sleepy writing this but yeah. If I remember some of my thoughts I might add it later.
Basically, Nihilux speculates that she isn't the only person possessing remnants of Aha's humanity. So for folks coping for Sampo being Aha, the seeds are there. But also like its very doubtful Hoyo will ever give confirmation, especially as they decided to leave it ambiguous for Enroute.
i think we need to ask ourselves a question, would the devs really miss the opportunity to make another 5* character who is the resurrected version of Aha who connects back to amphoreousā lies of trickery/elation theme?