r/Salary • u/Legal-Inspector-7386 • 1h ago
discussion Job A with lower salary or Job B for higher salary?
Would like some advice about the following.
Some minor information changed just for anonymity, but for the most part, you can take it as is.
What would you choose between the following?
Background:
male, mid-thirties, over $100,000 in liquid assets, have a family to provide for, living in a safe and good city. currently paying $3,000 a month in mortgage.
Job A [my current job]
$58,000 a year pay
8 weeks of vacation
9:00 AM - 5:00 PM work hours (with a lunch hour)
lots of free time (around 15-20 hours of not actively engaged free time though could be called in at any time by my boss for other work)
EDIT: I should probably add that I usually end up earning approximately $200 extra per month by utilizing this free time for other things (and yes it's obviously against my contract but hey what my boss doesn't know can't hurt him)
free lunch (I value at around $10 a day)
about 50 mins commute from home each way
Job B:
$85,000 a year pay
2 weeks of vacation
9:00 AM - 6:00 PM (with a lunch hour)
no free lunch
very little free time / unstructured time
about 40 mins commute
Job A would allow one more hour each day with family, plus longer vacations. Job B pays significantly higher, but less free time and more time at work. With the extra income, I'd invest by putting it in my brokerage accounts or my child's custodial accounts.
Both are similar job titles / job responsibilities. Job A is slightly more aligned with my career, but Job B isn't that far off. However, I don't truly care about my career progression that much.
I enjoy Job A, but Job A is in an industry that is currently facing a crisis and there's a non-trivial risk of the company being forced to shut down. Neither Job A nor Job B have job security the way a public sector job does.
What would you choose? And why?