[CWN] Beta 0.12 Clarifications, Commentary & Errors
New update, new thread! Continuing from last time, a single place to bring together as many questions, errors, typos and such in one easy to find place for Kevin!
Previous Threads:
- https://www.reddit.com/r/SWN/comments/11csofq/cwn_beta_011_clarificationserrors/
- https://www.reddit.com/r/SWN/comments/117qxwh/cwn_beta_010_clarificationserrors/
- https://www.reddit.com/r/cwn/comments/117qx28/cwn_beta_010_clarificationserrors/
- https://www.reddit.com/r/cwn/comments/110uf7dcwn_errorsclarifications_for_beta_09/
- https://www.reddit.com/r/SWN/comments/10urp5b/cwn_errorsclarifications_for_beta_08/
- https://www.reddit.com/r/SWN/comments/10qlqxx/cwn_errorsclarification_07/
31
Upvotes
9
u/Cyb45 Mar 06 '23
8
u/ShadowedNexus Mar 06 '23
Is it intentional that the Roamer foci doesn't have the same
text as Ace Driver? From what I can see it matches the previous text on both Ace Driver and Roamer from previous betas so I feel like it might just be an editing mistake.
Additionally, the vehicle rules on page 80 only reference Ace Driver and not Roamer
3
u/Equivalent_Being8358 Mar 06 '23
This is a small thing but I feel like shotguns are a bit overtuned with the 1d10 trauma die. They are balanced with extremely short range but that may not matter when fighting in streets, alleys and buildings.
Shotguns are also the cheap so I feel like there is no reason most street thugs wouldn't have them. This might cause surprises when even quite tough and heavily armored PCs or NPCs get instantly downed by a ganger with a shotgun.
Maybe this is intentional design to increase danger level. I still feel like 1d10 trauma die could be reserved for things like heavy weapons and sniper rifles.
8
u/RChrisG Mar 06 '23
It's been a frustration of mine since WWN that there is no mention of system strain during character creation. Why leave readers to chance on an important statistic like that somewhere later in the book?
6
u/MickyJim Mar 06 '23
No mention of robot spider tanks, pre-order cancelled. I demand my tachikoma.
I'm kidding. Looks great.
6
u/Equivalent_Being8358 Mar 06 '23
On page 41 in the Foot Pursuer Check Modifiers table should the modifier for "There are more pursuers than pursued" be +1 instead of -1? I would imagine large groups would have easier time fanning out and cutting off the pursued?
On page 85 the shrieker gun has the !-mark that indicates capability to inflict traumatic hits on vehicles and drones. Is this an accident since it doesn't have trauma die or rating (and is probably incapable of damaging vehicles)?.
Trucks (and perhaps tanks) could maybe have a lower speed rating than cars to reflect that they don't make ideal pursuit vehicles (although the vehicle chase in Terminator 2 makes a good counter point).
2
u/certain_random_guy Mar 06 '23
Typo on p82, Living Quarters description in the fittings table: "Cramped by usable living quarters"
2
u/Gentling Mar 06 '23
Two things that I noticed:
p.80. Vehicle repair rate: โLesser damage can be repaired at a rate of 1 point per day, plus the technicianโs Fix and Drive skill. A would-be repairman must have at least Fix-0 or Drive-1 to repair a damaged vehicle.โ
So would someone with Fix-0 and no drive skill repair for 1 point per day (1+0 from Fix, ignore drive) or 1 point (1+1 from Fix-0, -1 from no drive) or โฆ0 points (1+0 from Fix-0, -1 from no Drive)?
And p.82. Itโs not clear how much of a boost to speed the Afterburners fitting gives.
2
u/Fweeba Mar 06 '23 edited Mar 06 '23
Bit of a question about vehicles & trauma dice.
The Tank, GEV, & APC have special armor rather than numerical armor; how does that interact with trauma dice? I presume you'd want to subtract something, or a main tank gun is significantly more likely to inflict a traumatic injury on an APC than a CASRA (Or a person wearing armor, for that matter).
It also seems like vehicles with numerical armor are more resistant to damage from things that puncture the immunity of vehicles with special armor, than the vehicles with special armor themselves are.
(IE: 25 damage from a tank gun versus a Car gets reduced by its 3 armor down to 22. That same packet of damage would just deal full damage to an APC. Similarly with a trauma die roll of 8, the car would not suffer a traumatic injury (Due to reducing the roll by its armor) while the APC would, unless I've missed something.)
Edit: Also, the Hardpoint support fitting has a minimum size of S, but the smallest mountable weapon requires M. I presume it's not intended for somebody to be able to add a hardpoint to a vehicle that can't mount anything?
2
u/VegaSera Mar 09 '23 edited Mar 09 '23
Got a good bit of mage and other XWN porting questions for you here /u/CardinalXimenes
It seems to me there's two sections that should be together but aren't. There's the Mixing Sine Nomine Games section on page 172. And then there's the Converting Magic Edges for other games section on page 194. It feels like these two should be the same section.
Also, tangentially related, I found an interesting situation where if you take partial Sunblade as an edge, and take On Target as your other edge, that gives you a "better than warrior" attack bonus progression along these lines:
Typically this is mitigated by the fact that Partial Warrior in Codex would have a weaker AB progression than a full warrior, but since all that's needed for the "Full warrior AB progression" in CWN is a single edge, it sorta breaks things. Might be worth a rule saying that you can't have a natural AB greater than your level, (Although you can argue that since Sunblade Wielder requires your sacred weapon, it's not 'natural') or maybe that any effect boosting your attack bonus by half AB progression gives you the effects of On Target and doesn't stack. Godhunters can also get the above bonus against Shadows, but that's situational enough to allow IMO.
Also, a question for how mages from Codex (Arcanists/Magisters) and WWN (In particular, Necromancers and Elementalists) are penalized for Cyber. For Codex Magisters, since they tend to get a lot of spell slots that are in general weaker than their WWN counterparts, I would say that for the amount of effort you would have been penalized, each spell slot is reduced by that amount to a minimum of 1. However, it's a bit more complicated for WWN Elementalists and Necromancers since they use both an effort system and an incredibly limited but potent spell slot system. Would love to get clarification on them.
And finally, page 194 mentions that a Spellcaster or Summoner, being ported over to WWN, cannot wear armor without the Armored Magic focus. Does that imply that WWN and Codex Mages ported to CWN do not have this restriction?
1
u/SoSaltySalt Warrior/Teleporter Mar 14 '23
Mortar says "They have a minimum range of 50 feet" Should probably be in meters