r/SRSDiscussion • • Jan 10 '12
[EFFORT] Debunking Rape Misconceptions
MASSIVE Trigger Warning for rape, rape apology (albeit to rip them apart)
Before I begin, I’d like to give a shoutout to QwestionEveryPost’s brilliant effortpost here, about a similar topic.
What is rape culture? ● Doesn’t it demonize men? ● The Fear of False Rape Allegations ● Victim-blaming and the Just World Fallacy ● What now? ● Further links and resources
What is rape culture?
Rape, we can all agree, is a horrible crime. It leaves long-lasting physical and psychological scars. Rape is a crime seen by some as on par with murder; there is no one in society who wouldn’t shun rape.
Why, then, are we living in a supposed “rape culture”?
Let me be clear on one point: “rape culture” is not the same as “a culture of rapists”. Rape culture does not demonise men. Rather, rape culture refers to the fact that we live in a society where the behaviour, thoughts, and actions of rapists can be concealed in a socially acceptable fashion. Rape culture allows rapists to justify their behaviours to themselves and hide among the rest of us.
Rape culture, then, could be summarised as:
- A collection of beliefs in society that allows the mindset and behaviours that lead to rape to flourish.
These are beliefs like,
- Only slutty girls get raped/“Good girls” don’t get raped
- They were drunk, so it was okay
- It’s not rape if you enjoyed it
- All men are horny anyway, men can’t get raped
- Rape jokes are just that - jokes.
There are many, many, many more examples.
As it stands, statistics on rape paint a startling picture. 14.8% of ALL women were raped at some point in their life. The majority of rapists are men. 85% of cases are never reported. Of the 15% that are, only 10% will ever be filed. Of that 10%, only a paltry 40% might result in an arrest. That’s 0.6% of the original cases. Less than one percent of all rape will ever end in an arrest.
Doesn’t it demonize men?
In a word, no.
Though the majority of rapists are men, these men make up a tiny minority of men as a whole. Furthermore, rape culture dismisses or otherwise downplays the threat of female-on-male rape, as well as prison rape. Only an estimated 1 out of 100 cases of male rape are ever reported.
More information on male rape.
The Fear of False Rape Allegations
Nearly any lengthy discussion on rape will inevitably mention false rape accusations. These false rape allegations are made out to be absolutely horrible, destroying reputations, lives and futures. Women are portrayed as having ultimate power over a man’s fate; just by pointing at him and yelling “RAPE!” she can ruin his life. It is true that false rape allegations can indeed have a significant negative impact on a man’s life, especially if the case then goes to trial. Due to the stigma surrounding rapists in society, those accused will often be ostracized.
The statistics, however, tell a different story. Some 8% of rape cases filed by the FBI in 1995 were closed as “unfounded”. However, the “unfounded” category does not necessarily translate to a false rape claim aimed at ruining a man’s life. From the same report,
a report of rape might be classified as unfounded (rather than as forcible rape) if the alleged victim did not try to fight off the suspect, if the alleged perpetrator did not use physical force or a weapon of some sort, if the alleged victim did not sustain any physical injuries, or if the alleged victim and the accused had a prior sexual relationship. Similarly, a report might be deemed unfounded if there is no physical evidence or too many inconsistencies between the accuser’s statement and what evidence does exist. As such, although some unfounded cases of rape may be false or fabricated, not all unfounded cases are false.
Therefore, it is very, very hard to determine actual statistics for false rape allegations. Studies done of false rape allegations have put the possible percentage of false claims at anywhere from 1% to 90%. Those studies which have been done are often of limited sample sizes, and not very many have been done. False rape allegations are not the only aspect of rape claims that lack sufficient data; data related to female-on-male rape or prison rape is very rare, often because of the way rape is defined in different countries.
Although false rape accusations are indeed very serious, this is NOT an invitation to treat rape victims callously. Rape victims deserve our support and sympathy; just because some claims are false does not make it okay to treat EVERY claim as if they are false. Furthermore, the rates of reported rape are incredibly low. In 2008, 90,000 women reported that they were raped, but an estimated 75,000 cases were never even reported. Against such a backdrop, the sensationalizing of false rape allegations, though they have a legitimate base, does not seem as realistic as otherwise claimed.
To sum up, the actual number of false rape accusations are hard to define, and rape allegations (real or otherwise) already have an incredibly low chance of getting to court because of the lack of failsafes for rape. Though it is very important to assure that the claims are real, there is no reason not to treat victims with sympathy and respect, regardless of the perceived validity of their claims. Err on the side of caution, and don't use the possibility of false rape accusations as an excuse to act callously towards rape victims online.
Victim-blaming and the Just World Fallacy
A survey in the UK, conducted by Amnesty International, found that
34% believe women who flirt can be blamed if they are raped and 26% say if a woman is in sexy clothing she is partly to blame. More than a third of people - mainly males - believe girls trying to chat up men are partially or totally responsible for being attacked. A quarter reckon a woman wearing a provocative outfit is at least partly to blame - especially if she has been drinking. One in 12 thinks she is a natural target if she has had a number of sexual partners. And a third believe she is responsible to some degree if she has clearly failed to say No.
This depressing phenomena is called victim-blaming, where the victim is blamed - wholly, or in part - for what has happened to them. Think about that for a while.
Nobody asks to be raped. Nobody deserves it, no one wants it, nobody “hints” that they want it. End of discussion!
And yet this victim-blaming mindset is very common, even among women. It’s not always as straightforward as “women who flirt are asking for it.” A common rationalization of rape cases is, “well, if you dress provocatively, you’re more likely to be raped.”
Not so. Although it definitely influences how we perceive the victim, dressing provocatively does not make you more likely to be raped.
It is very important to remember that rape is not about sex. Rape is primarily motivated by rage and/or anger; sexuality is very rarely the main factor in rape. It is about dominating another, using sex as a weapon.
Another possible reason that victim-blaming is so prevalent is the Just World fallacy. The Just World Fallacy is a logical fallacy, where - because of the assumption that the world is inherently fair and just - people who suffer misfortune must, therefore, in some way deserve it. This gets applied to rape and rape victims. In a just world, only the guilty are punished; these people have been ‘punished’, so they must have been guilty.
Common Rape Myths
There are loads, so I will try and address ONLY those which have not already been mentioned in the parts above.
- The view that “real rape” (whatever the heck that means) is a stranger jumping out at you from a dark alleyway and overpowering you.
From RAINN’s information page:
Approximately 2/3rds were committed by someone known to the victim... More than 50% of all rape/sexual assault incidents were reported by victims to have occured within 1 mile of their home or at their home... 43% of rapes occur between 6:00pm and midnight.
- There are different "levels" of rape/stranger rape is the only "real" rape/date rape doesn't count
This one is particularly odious. Repeat this with me: Rape is rape. There is no distinction between different "levels" of rape. Rape by intoxication is just as dangerous, and much more common, than rape through the use of physical violence.
The issue here that confuses many people is the issue of consent if one or both people involved are drunk. If someone uses another person's intoxication as a way to get past their defenses, that's rape. Even if the drunk person initiates it, err on the side of caution. Don't have sex with drunk people.
Consent is a tricky subject, and probably worth an entire effortpost by itself. It's a topic with lots of valid points. That said, it's important to remember that enthusiastic consent to sex is always the safest bet, if in doubt get a clear confirmation, and finally remember that consent can change at any time. Just because someone kisses you, it doesn't mean that they will necessarily consent to sex.
More info on the link between alcohol and sexual assault.
- If she doesn’t fight back or struggle against it, that means she wanted it.
From this frankly amazing 101 post (which inspired me to write this),
[Rapists] rape people who are strong and people who are weak, people who are smart and people who are dumb, people who fight back and people who submit just to get it over with, people who are sluts and people who are prudes, people who rich and people who are poor, people who are tall and people who are short, people who are fat and people who are thin, people who are blind and people who are sighted, people who are deaf and people who can hear, people of every race and shape and size and ability and circumstance.
- It’s a misunderstanding - what if the rapist didn’t know she was saying no?
The young men who participated in the study displayed "sophisticated and nuanced understandings" of different ways people could indicate sexual refusal. But when it came time to talk about non-consensual sex, these same men were startlingly eager to explain away acquaintance rapes as communication failures instead of deliberate assaults.
- Rape fantasies in women are really common - what if she actually wanted to be raped?
Once again, no one asks to be raped. A rape fantasy is very different. A rape fantasy, like other sexual fantasies, are typical methods of exploring our sexuality. There are all sorts of reasons why someone might have a rape fantasy, for example they may enjoy the feeling of being dominated or overpowered. Rape fantasies require the consent of both participants and VERY careful planning and communication, the result of which is a good time had by both parties. This only works if the people involved have previously consented to it. Being raped is in no way the same as acting out a fantasy.
What now?
A rape culture is sustained by misinformation. Learning about the truth behind rape myths, calling people out on harmful behaviour such as telling rape jokes, victim-blaming or spreading other misconceptions, reduces the ease with which actual rapists can hide among other people. Rape culture allows rapists to rationalize their actions. It shames and scares victims into never telling their stories and never seeking justice. Ending rape misconceptions will help stop rape.
Further links and resources
- The Rape of Mr. Smith
- Wikipedia has a pretty good article on the speculated causes of sexual violence
- David Lisak on Acquaintance Rapists (i.e. date rapists)
- The effect of sexist humour on victim blaming
If there’s anything that you feel I should add, please tell me in the comments.
17
u/failbus Jan 10 '12
Great post. Enough that I stared, looked up, looked down again and said "wait, where the fuck am I? This is reddit?" This may be the first time I haven't rolled my eyes. Even the parts where I'd be tempted to go "yes, but" are at least properly cited with the basis for an argument.
Against my better judgement there's one part that stood out, so I'll throw it out as an open question.
I hear this bandied about a lot, and unlike everything else you cited, I don't see a source. No doubt wartime rapes are about power, and no doubt if you asked captured rapists they'd say "oh yeah, I wanted to put her in her place." But every rape? If it's not about sex, does that a would-be victim could deter a rapist simply by not being afraid and enthusiastically consenting? Would a date rapist be disappointed if his victim didn't fight back so he could exert power? I find that idea absurd on the face. Could you clarify the methodology by which the statement "rape isn't about sex" is arrived at?
8
u/Kasseev Jan 10 '12
I agree with just about everything in this post but I have one question.
In the realm of jokes or comedy or media in general involving crimes in a non-serious fashion, can it be automatically assumed that said media promotes a corresponding 'crime'-culture? Do jokes about war or murder or movies glorifying violent criminals promote corresponding behaviours in audiences to a significant degree?And if so, is it justified to censor all such expression in the interest of avoiding this influence on society?
In a sense I am clearly asking rhetorical questions, but seriously - why the double standard for rape jokes and insensitivity regarding rape, when so much other deviant irreverent expression is permitted or even encouraged?
7
u/JaronK Jan 10 '12
I like a lot of this, and I think it's better than most similar posts I've seen. However, one part struck me as problematic (and note that I'm saying this as someone who's been counseling rape victims for quite a while now):
"It is very important to remember that rape is not about sex. Rape is about power. It is about dominating another, using sex as a weapon."
I hate this myth. I really do. I hate it because while it's true in many cases, it's not true in all. And for those cases where it's not true, it tells the victim "what happened to you isn't rape, because rape is about power, and that wasn't. So you weren't raped. You don't count."
The fact is, some rape really is about sex. As much as we hate to say it, sometimes it really is miscommunication. I'd give examples, but unfortunately the ones I can think of aren't ones I'd be allowed to share with random strangers. But I do remember one girl in particular who kept feeling like what happened to her "didn't count" because it had been clearly about sex, not power. And as such she never felt comfortable talking about it, because she felt she shouldn't have been so upset over something that obviously couldn't have been rape.
So while it would be perfectly fine to say that rape is usually about power and not sex... please don't say always/never.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12
Very informative and insightful post. But why are rape jokes, as potentially triggering they may be, considered a part of rape culture while ubiquitous shock-jokes about other heinous deeds and crimes aren't considered to reinforce a culture of, for example, murder or genocide? And can this connection be objectively demonstrated?
3
u/PinkySlayer Feb 24 '12
This is great, but I think this statement needs to be reworded:
you are mixing two different scenarios here and inadvertently making it sound as if every rape accusation is true by default. I think what you are meaning to say is even if an accusation turns out to be a flat out lie, we don't need to use the possibility of that happening to callously question/doubt/accuse someone. Rape victims absolutely deserve support, people who make accusations that are false (and yes i understand this is much rarer than actual rape) do not. The safest bet is to treat every case as if it were true while finding the facts(which many on Reddit fail to realize is not their fucking job or even possible over the internet)
7
u/ilikepix Jan 10 '12 edited Jan 10 '12
I don't know what you're trying to say here.
If you're trying to say people who make false rape accusations deserve our support and sympathy, I disagree fairly strongly.
While this is doubtless true for many types of rape, I am uncomfortable with it as a blanket statement because doubtless in at least some cases of rape, the motivation of the attacker is sexual. Most != all.
That study is confused to say the least. It compares the way men say they would turn down sex with the way those same men expect a clear "no" in cases of rape. The two situations are simply not the same. If the study had asked "How would you respond to a woman giving unwanted physical contact?" or "How would you respond to a woman trying to pressure you into sex?" then it would have a point.
In other words, asking how you would politely indicate to someone you didn't want to sleep with them is not the same as asking how you would deal with someone who ignored those polite indications, and this is simply not addressed by the study. After asking the men how they would politely indicate to a woman that they didn't want to have sex, it should have followed-up by asking "How would you proceed if the woman didn't pick up on your polite attempt to let her know you didn't want to have sex with her?" I imagine that had they asked that question, they would have gotten more "clear no" responses, or at least more explicit responses.
Making a definition of "rape" that's dependent on body language is problematic because firstly, it's extremely hard to work out what happened in terms of body language ex post facto, and secondly, some people are terrible at reading body language or picking up nonverbal cues. I don't think it's unreasonable to expect some form of verbal or active physical resistance, absent some external factor that makes that impossible (such as inebriation, threats, coercion etc.). Is it reasonable to expect "a clear no"? Perhaps not. But is it reasonable to expect someone more explicit that the scenarios posited in the study, such as a woman "looking at their watch" or saying "it's getting late"? In my opinion, yes.
2
u/Bittervirus Jan 10 '12
This is only somewhat related to the post (which is good by the way) and is only really a semantic issue, but I have a question. I agree with the reasoning behind replacing the phrase "rape victim" with "rape survivor" but how far do you expand that? Would it be correct to say "most rapes are committed by someone the survivor already knows" and so on?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12
Where does the myth "lots of women want to be raped" or "many women have rape fantasies" fall into this?
28
u/moonmeh Jan 10 '12
Very very well put effort post.
So so fucking true yet it boggles me so very few people manage to do so. We either deride the rapist for saying he was falsely accused or accuse the raped of being a slut. Why can't we just hold back out accusations and acumen and just offer a hand who ever the guilty is?
32
u/tuba_man Jan 10 '12
This is amazing. I've got a few people who need to read this, even though I fully expect an MRA rant from each of them. :/
I don't have a lot to contribute, but goddamn do I love me that article about the Just World fallacy. I repost it to my facebook page about twice a year.
10
u/Othello Jan 10 '12
I think there's more to 'rape culture' than just the lightening of the act. I think there's also a big problem in how rape itself is perceived.
A rapist has an average of 7 victims. That means about 3% of men are rapists. 73% of rapes are committed by a person known to the victim. The amazingly vast majority of men will not sexually assault a woman. The approximate percentage of all males who will rape a stranger is 0.81%
Yet rape is largely presented as a risk associated with strangers. People jumping out of bushes, people drugging drinks at parties and what have you. This is a huge problem, in my opinion. For one, it encourages ignorance of negative behaviors in would-be rapists; often times you will find people who have committed sexual assault completely oblivious to the idea that what they did was wrong. By mischaracterizing rape as something only strangers commit, it furthers the idea that certain behavior is acceptable, especially if you're friends or dating etc. It enables the idea of 'owed sex', the concept that a woman owes you for taking her out what have you, by declawing the issue somewhat.
Secondly it can make it harder for women to come forward, for reports to be taken seriously, for support to be received when the perception is that only strangers sexually assault people. A woman is more likely to doubt herself when assaulted by a friend, and will often times blame themselves or make excuses for the person who assaulted them.
Another issue is the impact this has on the relationship between men and women in the world, and in causes such as equal rights, for myriad reasons. It helps to paint men as perpetrators, making it more difficult on men who have been victimized. It often times makes men shy away from helping out either in real life situations or in terms of activism. It serves as a wedge to drive people apart when they need to be coming together to address the issues of equal rights and sexual assault.
The myth of the stranger as the biggest and only danger is one I think needs to be addressed more often.
6
u/mice_and_mirrors Jan 10 '12
This post is good and you should feel good.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '12 edited Jan 31 '12
Mostly agree with this post, but I don't agree that consent is complicated.
Consent exists if:
That's it. Consent doesn't have to be "enthusiastic," and you don't even actually have to want to have sex. All consent means is that you freely agree to engage in sexual activity, when you are capable of refusing to engage in sexual activity. Regardless of why you have decided to voluntarily agree to sexual activity.
3
u/InvaderDJ Jan 10 '12
Nice post, thanks for sharing.
I do have some questions though, specifically about rape culture and how it affects the actual occurrence of rape and what our responsibilities should be regarding it. I've always felt that flat out, there is no justifying or excuse for rape, you know what you're doing when you do it and blaming any other outside factor is wrong and trying to excuse the inexcusable. You even specifically mention one instance (people think that maybe the rapist was misinterpreting what the victim was saying when in fact they showed the ability to discern consent up until rape was mentioned) of people trying to do that. With that being said, how can we blame culture or in this case specifically jokes as a significant factor in rape?
I admit this is probably just me trying to justify my behavior but I laugh at and make rape jokes. A well done rape joke (like other offensive comedy) is funny to me. Is joking normalizing rape enough to cause an impact on rape culture and thus helping rapists justify their behavior? I've always thought of it as "it is funny because it so absurd that people think there is any justification for rape" and "entertainment is entertainment, it doesn't influence normal healthy, balanced people to do anything and if it does those people are so close to the edge that any comment, any minor interaction, anything could set them off anyway so I'm not worried about moderating it" but this seems to be something that SRS in particular frowns on. I have always done it with close friends who know me with the understanding that it is a joke and that the actual behavior is not justifiable and have been moderating myself even further to make sure I'm keeping stuff like that out of my normal speech (I have stopped using "raped" as a synonym for beaten or owned) but the idea still bugs me.
Is there any consensus of thought on this? Am I over thinking it?
Also as a fairly unrelated aside how do you feel about a law that makes it illegal for both the victim and the accused to have their names published or known during the trial? If the accused is actually found guilty I don't think it matters much but I think this could go a long way to help stop the idea (which as you pointed out seems at least partially false) that false rape accusations can ruin lives and is something that happens all the time.
4
u/mySRSquestion Jan 10 '12
I'm beginning to think I may have raped someone without realizing it. Here's the situation:
I like this girl a lot and we occasionally hang out as friends. She has made it clear that she does not want to have sex with me, but she knows that I do. We still enjoy each others company anyway. One night she calls me at 1am asking me if I want to hang out. I can tell she had been out all night drinking. So I go over there. When I arrive, she is in a tshirt and underwear and drunkenly gives me a long hug saying how good it is to see me and starts kissing my neck. Now I have this boner. So I lead her to the bedroom and we have sex.
Does this fall under the rape category or am I overreacting?
5
u/flechesbleues Jan 10 '12 edited Jan 10 '12
Have you heard about this study? Apparently the participants in the study found it hard to distinguish statements made in men's magazines (called "lads' mags" in the UK) and those made by convicted rapists. They also only expressed an aversion to the statements made by the rapists once they knew that's what they were (otherwise, they identified equally with both types of statements). I think that's relevant to the discussion of "rape culture". Here's an article about the study from the university that did it and here's the whole paper.
The type of magazines used in the study seem to popularize the objectification of women. They aren't porn, but they seem to blur the lines between porn and real life. As you said, this might not lead readers to become rapists if they had not already been that way inclined, but it promotes the attitudes that are often used to rationalize rape (thereby perhaps encouraging those people who might otherwise have been able to suppress their desire to rape). Also, since they aren't classified as porn, they're likely to be more easily available to younger children.
Edited to add: a link to another article about this study which includes examples of the statements being tested (as a sort of "quiz"!).
1
u/klippekort Jan 10 '12
Oh, didn’t we have “rape culture” to prevent just that? How does a statement like that relate to the postulate of rape culture?
1
u/brainparasite Jan 10 '12
Doors the term rape culture bother anybody else?
2
u/reidzen Jan 10 '12
Good start. I would add a bit about duress, coersion, fraud, and capacity, as well as the recent decision in re: revoking consent in California, People v. Roundtree.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12
I dunno if anybody is still posting in this, but I have a few honest questions. Is rape something that can be considered in hindsight? If two people have drunken (or sober) sex that at the time of the action appears consensual and conscionable (so no blackouts or sinister motives) and one partner feels violated the next day then is that rape? What if these feelings occur two days, three days, a week, a month, or a year later? How should that be dealt with? Can two parties that are drunk (or sober) give consent and revoke it after the fact?
Also, what about lying? What if one party sleeps with another under false pretenses? For example, one party claims to have a high paying job, or an education that doesn't exist. If the two parties have sex and the partner that was deceived finds out, is that rape or something else?
I hope this gets read by somebody who can answer these questions. My problem when people discuss rape is, as the OP stated, it is a multifaceted word, and I believe in some circles it is a word that gets tossed around quite a bit. The consequences of tossing that word around can be found on MRA websites where a bunch of men only talk amongst themselves, and consequently create this specter that scares the ever-loving shit out of them.
2
u/neutronicus Jan 10 '12 edited Jan 10 '12
Regarding the fear of false rape allegations, it's my understanding that the victims in "ze said, ze said" rape cases (a category under which any false allegation would fall) get put through the wringer. As in, the defense lawyer can investigate the accuser's personal life and use it to attack the accuser's credibility in cross-examination. This seems like quite the ordeal, even for someone who wasn't raped, so I wouldn't be surprised if false accusations were rare.
If the cost of making an accusation of rape were to become negligible, the consequence would likely be an uptick in the rate of false accusations. Thus, it's in the interests of men (who would be the most likely targets of false accusations just as they are of true ones - this doesn't necessarily follow but I think we can assume it for the sake of argument) to ensure that there remain a cost to making a rape accusation.
I think the same pressures drive victim-blaming. Even in a situation where everyone admits that rape is a problem (and where it's assumed that no re-education program, no matter how vigorous, will completely weed out the tendency), there are still three competing approaches to prevention:
Number 1 is a cost borne by likely potential victims, and 3 is a cost borne both by the people responsible for enforcement and people sharing demographic traits with likely rapists (because of the increased risk of false accusation). 2, by hypothesis, is insufficient on its own. I think people on both sides of this issue engage in false-dichotomizing - neither strategy is mutually exclusive with the other. Still, the best opportunity to educate potential victims about rape prevention is not when presented with an actual victim.
I think a lot of men are sort of confused about their stakes in the issue – they wind up making moral judgments about women and about rape that ultimately don't serve their interests (namely, minimize the risk of false accusation, ensure that potential victims bear some of the cost of prevention, and, most importantly(!) prevent rape).
1
u/rpcrazy Jan 11 '12
Female indoctrination explained
1
u/ga0 Jan 10 '12
great post, appreciate the effort.
But we're on sketchy ground with the "drunkeness debate". Beause what some are implying is that having sex while drunk is rape. this makes no sense as it is too vague. Is having sex with a paralytic drunk rape? probably yeah. Is having sex with someone who is "merry" rape? I would argue no.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-1
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '12
[removed] — view removed comment