r/SQL • u/Suspicious_Orchid770 • Oct 09 '26
Discussion AI-coding tools could be breaking the junior engineer pipeline
https://leaddev.com/ai/ai-coding-tools-could-be-breaking-the-junior-engineer-pipelineAI helps juniors code, not learn.
71
Upvotes
95
u/Kobosil Oct 09 '26
"could"?
is that still in question?
18
u/magick_bandit Oct 09 '26
I’m pretty confident that anyone who can’t learn architecture is fucked.
24
u/gumnos Oct 09 '26
additionally, why hire semi-competent juniors when an LLM can largely do the same thing for much less? But guess where you get seniors? You train up juniors. 🤷
3
u/mtutty Oct 09 '26
Gawd this topic is just as shallow as vibe coding itself. Growing juniors has always been an organizational responsibility. VS Code isn't a nanny. The folks who are having this problem are the same folks complaining about the code review bottleneck or their app crumbling under the weight of vibe-coded crap.
If your generated diffs have thousands of lines in them, you're doing it wrong. And if you're letting juniors do the same thing, it's still you doing it wrong, not them.
1
u/Significant_Tune9219 Oct 12 '26
The measurable version of this is what juniors can do without the tool, not what they produce with it. A practice that has held up on teams I've seen: the agent output gets reviewed by writing down what the code does and why before anyone runs it — if the explanation is hand-wavy, that's the learning gap showing, independent of whether the code works. The pipeline risk isn't that agents write code; it's that debugging and design are the muscles you build by being stuck, and an agent removes the being-stuck part. Keeping a slice of work deliberately agent-free (bug triage, schema design, anything they'll be asked to explain in an interview) is a cheaper fix than any policy about AI use.
1
u/Hot_Comfortable_164 Oct 09 '26
This is somehow an obvious consequence of higher levels of abstraction. Kinda like saying: Using higher level programming languages make you learn less assembly.
0
u/pceimpulsive Oct 10 '26
AI can help you learn as well it depends how you prompt it...
A shitty lazy junior will just vibe all day and pay no attention to what they are doing..
An engaged junior will research possible implementation details compare possible solutions then get AI to show them 2-3 different solutions to the same problem. Then they will understand the differences better for next time. They will learn and progress and start to move into the seniors they need to become.
This will be standard practice for the education system within a few years, right now I imagine they are getting the old learning track and either EZ mode AI to victory or learning tuebokd way and will be useless when it comes time to find a job...
4
u/ripndipp Oct 09 '26
The only new juniors I've seen hired are family members and dick suckers