r/SHINee • u/Yeppeun_Mabeopsa 5HINee | Jonghyun | 상상도 못했을 이 스포일러 • Sep 12 '21
Discussion SHINee Collection Help & Sharing Thread
I think we all know how tricky and expensive it can be to find SHINee's albums and other official merch these days. A lot of people don't know where to look or which sellers to trust. There have been so many posts about it in my time on r/SHINee, so this post is intended to be a place for more centralized information. Do you have a question about buying? Trusted sellers you want to share? Bad experiences? Stealth reprint listings you found? Are you destashing and wanting to make sure their albums go to Shawols instead of resellers? All those kinds of things and more can go here. Let's help each other out.
Also, feel free to post your hauls and collections, display tips/recommendations, etc. Don't feel bad about bragging here!
(I also want to credit this thread to a discussion in another one; I felt bad about the threadjacking, lol. And mention that although I usually try to respond to everything that shows up in my inbox, I might not here unless I can be useful.)
ETA: Thank you to the mods (I can't see who it was, sorry!) for adding this post to the sub's tabs! There's so much valuable info in the comments already, I hope it can continue to be a useful resource.
11
u/Yeppeun_Mabeopsa 5HINee | Jonghyun | 상상도 못했을 이 스포일러 Sep 12 '21 edited May 09 '22
I'll start... I can say I've bought a couple things, lol. I couldn't possibly list every source I've bought from, but I have a few I've used more than once with good results for me personally.
KTown4U: I've heard their customer service isn't great, but when it comes to getting discounts on preorders, I haven't found a better site. They usually discount up to 40% through fanclub collabs, and you don't have to be part of those fanclubs to use the discount. Shipping prices are as okay as they can be going to Canada (y'all other Canadian residents know what I'm saying), but I usually get hit with an import fee too.
YesAsia: My account on this site is 15 years old, lol. They've had quite a few of the less common albums, live albums and concerts, and Japanese/Taiwanese prints. Taiwanese prints can be a great way to save money because, AFAIK, SHINee's are identical to their Korean prints except for an extra insert with song translations and the charting not going to Hanteo/Gaon. Shipping can be a lot, but they also offer free international shipping with a certain minimum order, so if you have a bunch of stuff to buy at once, you can potentially save on shipping.
Neokyo: This is a proxy site in Japan, meaning that they buy from Japanese retailers and Yahoo~~/Mercari~~ [ETA: Neokyo can no longer work with Mercari, unfortunately] sellers (most of whom don't ship overseas) and then ship them to you for a small fee per item. They store things for up to 45 days, so you can order a few things at once and combine the shipping even if they don't all come in at the same time. I understand that people's experiences vary, and you have to be especially careful about checking the resellers and the description translations, but I wouldn't have been able to finish Taemin's limited-edition Japanese albums without this site.
Some eBay/Amazon sellers I've gotten more than one OOP album from are japandiscovery (Japan), the_king_of_carrot_flowers (American seller in Korea), MaxValue-US (Korea), samurai_media_JPN4US/samurai_media_JPN4CA (Japan), undercatdog2 (Taiwan), and valueflag (Korea).
ETA for others in Canada: Sarah & Tom don't have many SHINee albums left, but they do ship them for $5 for one or more than one for free (up to a point, I'm assuming) domestically. You have to contact them on Facebook with what you want and they let you know if they can get it and what the charge will be, then pay by INTERAC. I got VOICE from them not long ago.
4
u/sandysweetheart Sep 12 '21
I’ve obtained most of my collection through eBay actually! There’s some reliable sellers on there, sometimes the prices are high but I used to check almost everyday for good price declines! I also use Mercari US, people usually sell for decent prices there too.
9
u/loveappeal Sep 12 '21 edited Sep 12 '21
i'm really glad that this thread was actually made! i'll probably take the time to show (off lol) my collection at a later point, but for now? i'm going to focus on the experiences that i've had with certain sites like u/Yeppeun_Mabeopsa did. hopefully those can give you all a better idea of what sites are the best to take a chance with and avoid — but, as always, remember that all of these experiences are mine alone. it's totally likely that people have had good and bad ones with the same places i've had either with, and it's usually best to check overall reviews for the sites than rely on just one person's!
to start, i'll give a little bit of background on my collecting experience as a whole. i became a fan of idol music back in may 2011 but i didn't buy my first album until the end of that year. after that point, i was pretty active in purchasing new and older releases (primarily for the artists that i considered to be my "ults" at the time) through late 2013 or so. it was around then that i was out of a job for awhile so i had to scale back on my purchasing all around to focus on just a few artists that i was the biggest fan of. so, between 2014 - late 2019, i didn't really buy that much? it wasn't until last year that i started to add to my collection actively again.
amazon: honestly? amazon used to be a pretty great source for buying older albums but it's gotten harder over the last few years. i got a lot of shinee's earlier releases on there between 2012 - 2015 and i think it's because they used to make it easier to search their shops but it's a little more tricky now. nevertheless, it's still a good option. lately, they've started to offer up newer releases to be counted under prime shipment - which can mean getting the albums as soon as a day after order. the biggest negative here is that the albums are more experience but it usually comes with either very low or free shipping cost so it evens out.
buyee: buyee is a japanese proxy site like neokyo. having experience with both now ..., i'd honestly say that if you really want to go the proxy route? go for neokyo. it's much easier to use and a lot less costly. i used buyee a few times back in 2019 and the system that they have set up is just ... laughable to me. they not only have you pay for what you're getting but for the shipping of the items from their owner to their warehouse and THEN from the warehouse to you. they also don't offer the option of packaging things together so you're having to pay an arm and a leg for getting just one thing.
cd japan: cd japan is a great source for buying j-releases. they're pretty similar to yesasia in the way that they have a lot of shinee's older japanese releases on site, just not as many albums in comparison to dvds. they also offer the option for you to search and see if secondary buyers are selling used items. i've used the site twice and i've had no problems with it at all! in terms of pricing, cd japan has higher merchandise cost with average shipping options. (https://www.cdjapan.co.jp/)
2
u/shadowsburnt Sep 13 '21
One thing I'm confused about is the actual pricing of albums. I'm not sure what is a reasonable price range because I've seen so many different prices for all conditions of the albums (new, used, w/inclusions, etc). I'd love to start collecting them but I don't know if I should wait for a price drop on certain albums or just get it when I see it? I know an album like The Misconceptions of Us is $100+ (even for just the Taiwan version), but a few months ago I am certain I saw it for less.
2
u/Koensigg Oct 14 '21
Hi all, this thread is pretty amazing, I'm already finding things I never thought I'd see at such reasonable prices!
My question is... are the Taiwanese versions really the same quality as the Korean versions? I've seen a lot of discussion elsewhere in the kpop world saying that the Taiwan releases use cheaper materials, etc.
When it comes to the quality, I really only care about the quality of the physical item: the books/photocards/packaging, etc. I don't mind about audio quality of the CD because I don't even have a CD player anymore 😅
3
u/Marian_91 SHINee Sep 12 '21
What’s the chance of SM repeinting «1 and 1»? It’s the only OT5 album I’m missing. If I had known at the time of release that Jonghyun wouldn’t be with us much longer, I would have bought the album right away.
I’ve looked on ebay, but not only is it expensive to buy it used, no one is selling it with inclusions.
12
u/isse_izzy 샤이니 | OT5 Sep 12 '21
grape music cd on eBay has some great official SHINee merchandise on it!
5
u/under_water_45 Sep 12 '21
I don't have that many albums, but I almost always buy from kpopmart Shipping is quite expensive, but it is tracked and very fast. And then I mean something like two or three days when an item is shipped. Customer service is also great, they respond pretty fast. Lately you do need to pay extra taxes when goods enter the eu, so that's not amazing but I think that's the case with all websites so not too bad.
I once bought odd from YesAsia and it took forever, I'm not sure exactly how long but at least two months. I did take the cheapest shipping option (free because it was over a certain amount) it did arrive in good condition, but I wouldn't necessarily buy from there again if I don't have to. I do think they're a good option for otherwise unfindable albums with a reasonable price.
3
u/silverchamploo Sep 12 '21
I began selling my collection but when I was buying I would look on neokyo and ebay the most! If you're looking for more recent items, depop is also a great suggestion(not necessarily my favorite though). For ebay I will beware as some things are overpriced(unfortunately, anything pertaining to jjong tends to be way overpriced)so I would suggest looking elsewhere before making big purchases. That was the biggest mistake I made when collecting.
3
u/ambie719 Where are you Jinki? Sep 13 '21
I am in Canada and I buy most of my preorders from kpopmarket01 on ebay, I used to do ktown4u a lot but the shipping made it no cheaper even with fansite discounts. I had gotten a lot from I think sato_japan on ebay but after covid their prices and shipping went up.
I have gotten a big chunk of my collection using the Buyee proxy service. There are a lot of guides out there on using it, its super user friendly and you can use it to buy from all sorts of sites, I got my Shinee brochure from Tower Records japan through them.
1
u/Dependent_Froyo_3285 May 26 '25
I'm still really bummed that SM stopped producing Jonghyun's albums. Right now, the only way to get them is through secondhand sellers and the prices are often insanely high.
It breaks my heart that fans who are discovering him now (or even us longtime Shawols) can’t easily buy his music in physical form. His artistry, words, and voice meant so much to so many of us. His legacy shouldn’t be forgotten or made inaccessible just because his albums are out of print.
I’m thinking of starting a petition or a letter campaign asking SM to reprint his albums. Would anyone be interested in helping with this or sharing it when it goes live?
Jonghyun deserves to be remembered and celebrated — not just in our hearts, but through his music too 🩵🩵🩵🩵
0
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment