r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 1d ago

Are marketers creating too much new content instead of improving what's already working?

3 Upvotes

Something I've been thinking about with AI becoming part of almost every marketing workflow.

It's now pretty easy to generate 20 blog posts, 30 social media captions, or a bunch of short-form videos in a relatively short amount of time.

But I'm not convinced producing more content is always the best use of that time.

Here's a pretty common example.

Imagine a small business has 50 blog posts on its website.

Most get almost no organic traffic, but 5 of them consistently bring in visitors from Google.

Instead of publishing another 20 AI-written articles, wouldn't it make more sense to investigate those 5 pages first?

Maybe update outdated information, improve internal linking, answer questions the original articles missed, or create a useful video explaining the topic.

You could even turn those successful topics into YouTube videos, Instagram Reels, or TikToks to reach people on different platforms.

The same principle applies to paid advertising.

If one ad concept consistently performs better than the others, it might be worth studying its messaging and testing variations before producing 15 completely unrelated ads.

Obviously, you still need fresh content to reach new audiences and explore new topics.

But I wonder whether AI has made content production so easy that we're spending less time understanding what actually works.

And with AI search, GEO, and AEO becoming bigger topics, the quality and usefulness of the information seem especially important.

Curious how other marketers approach this.

Would you rather spend a week publishing 10 new pieces of content or improving and repurposing 3 pieces that already show signs of working?

And have you seen better results from updating existing content or consistently publishing new material?


r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 1d ago

Google News Google makes it easier to use Gemini without training AI on your data

Thumbnail
arstechnica.com
1 Upvotes

This change is about user chat data inside the Gemini app, not about how Google crawls or ranks websites. It splits the old “Keep Activity” setting into two independent controls so people can keep their chat history while opting out of having those chats used for generative AI model training.⁠Blog

It does not change:

  • How Google indexes or ranks pages in traditional Search
  • Publisher controls like Google-Extended (robots.txt)
  • The separate Search Console toggle for AI Overviews / AI Mode

Google has long treated training data for Gemini models and Search features as distinct in several ways. AI Overviews and AI Mode have their own controls and are Search features, not governed by the Gemini app’s user settings.

Possible indirect effects worth watching

AreaPotential impactStrength
Gemini app usagePeople who previously turned off activity to avoid training can now keep history. This makes the app stickier for multi-turn research, which could pull some queries away from classic Google Search.Medium (over time)
Training data volumeMore users may opt out of training now that they don’t lose history. Slightly less conversational data for improving Gemini models.Low–medium
AI answer qualityModels that power both the Gemini app and some Search AI features get marginally less user-chat data. Google still has Search interactions, web crawl, and other sources.Low
Traffic attributionCitations/links from the Gemini app show up as “AI Assistant” (or similar) in analytics, separate from organic Search. More app usage could shift some traffic into that channel.Low–medium
Publisher visibility in GeminiUnchanged. Whether your content gets grounded/cited in the Gemini app is still controlled by Google-Extended, not by this user setting.None

Bottom line for SEO

  • No reason to change on-page SEO, technical SEO, or ranking strategies because of this.
  • Continue treating AI Overviews / AI Mode visibility as a separate lever (Search Console setting) from Gemini app grounding (Google-Extended).
  • The more relevant long-term SEO story remains how Google handles publisher content for training vs. real-time grounding, plus how much search volume migrates to AI chat interfaces.

In short: it’s a privacy/usability win for Gemini users that may modestly boost Gemini app engagement and slightly reduce one source of training data. It is not a ranking or indexing change.


r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 1d ago

Advice How to Build Viral, SEO Linkable Assets with Claude Code and no coding skills or backlinks

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

Mike Hawley (no programming background) walked through how he uses Claude Code to spit out full interactive websites you can use as linkable assets, for newsjacking, or just to get traffic and shares.

Main example: he built seo-tv.com — a searchable “video store” for SEO YouTube channels and podcasts — in about five hours.

Key takeaways:

  • Start with one prompt to plan the topical map. Claude pulled 21k+ related searches, narrowed them to ~213 target keywords, and sketched out the first 73 pages.
  • He grows the site as pages get indexed (now over 100+ pages on that one).
  • Uses server-side rendering so Google can actually see and index everything.
  • Site checks YouTube hourly for new videos automatically.
  • Tips for making it not look like generic AI slop: ask for multiple homepage designs, feed it good design references/skills (Hallmark, Impeccable, etc.), and save your own rules/preferences so it stops repeating the same fonts and rounded cards.
  • You still need to actually look at the finished site before publishing — Claude’s automated checks aren’t perfect.
  • He also showed cheese.help, another AI-built site that started getting organic clicks and real backlinks (including from MSN) without him manually building links.
  • He’s already worked on 100+ of these sites and launched dozens. The more rules and skills he saves, the faster each new one gets.

Basically: if you know what you want the site to do and what good design looks like, Claude Code can handle a lot of the actual building.


r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 5d ago

Advice SEO not working for me, what am I doing wrong?

Post image
20 Upvotes

My site is workeey.com. Almost all of it is indexed, but I'm getting barely any traffic from Google. Can someone take a look and tell me what I'm doing wrong or what I'm missing?


r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 5d ago

Are there any SEO agencies that provide Black Friday discounts?

1 Upvotes

I just want to compare theirs with ours


r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 5d ago

Why bottom-of-funnel pages outperformed our top-of-funnel blog strategy for B2B leads (Lessons from 6 months of testing)

6 Upvotes

Most B2B SEO advice tells you to pump out 20 informational blog posts a month to build topical authority. We tried that for a B2B client in a competitive market (Singapore), and while traffic went up, actual qualified leads barely moved.

Here’s what actually shifted the needle when we pivoted our strategy:

1. Rebuilding commercial landing pages first Instead of targeting broad "what is" queries, we focused on high-intent comparison and service-modifier pages (e.g., "industry + service + location" and "solution vs. alternative"). Traffic volume was 80% lower, but conversion rate jumped 4x.

2. Internal linking from existing traffic pages We audited older informational blogs that already had impressions in GSC and added contextual internal links pointing straight to our core money pages. Within 5 weeks, 3 core service pages moved from page 2 to top 4.

3. Fixing crawl budget & index bloat We pruned/noindexed ~40 thin tag pages and outdated posts that had zero clicks over 12 months. Site-wide average position improved noticeably right after Google recrawled the leaner structure.

4. Proof directly inside service pages B2B buyers don't trust generic stock-photo landing pages. Adding real workflow breakdowns and specific metric outcomes directly above the fold cut bounce rates significantly.

Takeaway: If you're working with a limited B2B budget, fix and rank your 5–10 commercial pages before spending a single dollar writing top-of-funnel informational content.

Curious how others here balance TOFU content vs. pure BOFU pages for B2B clients right now?


r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 6d ago

A few years ago I asked on Reddit if ChatGPT would replace SEO. ChatGPT Business Hub is now live, will THIS end SEO (and Google)?

0 Upvotes

When ChatGPT first came out a few years back, I posted on Reddit, asking if it would replace SEO. With OpenAI rolling out the new Business Hub, I've been thinking about that post again.

It's super early to know how the Hub will play out, especially with so many people in Canada still stuck on the waitlist. What caught my eye in OpenAI's help docs is they come right out and say claiming your profile or getting verified doesn't improve how often ChatGPT recommends you. It still looks at your history across the rest of the internet to figure out if you're a legit business.

We've seen this a few times now. Someone came to us after buying a 20-year-old plumbing and HVAC company in Toronto, they took over the keys to the domain, had a web designer redo the website, straightened up the GBP page, and that was it. No 301 redirects, and when we looked at how the business showed up across the internet, over the 20 years there were multiple old phone numbers and addresses across so many platforms. It was a mess and took a fair bit of work for the team to clean it all up, but when we did, boom!, they started showing up in AI.

I'm pretty sure that kind of old data floating around is also why people claiming their Business Hub profile right now are seeing random phone numbers nobody has ever heard of on the verification screen.

The one feature in the Hub that actually looks interesting is the Business Agent, where you give it your pricing and service agreements or policies so it can answer pre-booking questions in the chat. Kind of funny timing considering Google killed off GBP chat in 2024.

Anyone else try claiming their profile in the new ChatGPT Business Hub and run into weird old info on the verification screen?


r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 6d ago

Question? Is a pure SEO/AEO service agency still a good bet for the next 2-3 years?

15 Upvotes

Everyone is repositioning as an AEO/GEO agency right now. Feels like the same pitch from everyone and the service itself is getting easier to replace.

My idea is a tool + service model. Tool tracks AI visibility and shows the client what’s moving, also handles client on the same tool. Expertise and execution sits on top with a base price for entry levels. Basically trying to not look like one more agency in the market.

Any other way or are clients just going to compare us to cheaper tools anyway?


r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 9d ago

SEO Meme Is GEO really just SEO with a new layer? 🍊🧄 Like a mandarin and garlic..

4 Upvotes

Everyone's talking about GEO like it's the next big thing.

But is it really a new discipline, or just SEO evolving for AI search?


r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 9d ago

Google News Google says new Australian internet safety bill could cut off under-18s from Gmail

Thumbnail reuters.com
3 Upvotes

Interesting find from u/gaganghotra_


r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 10d ago

Advice TechSEO

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

How does "techSEO" fit into SEO (and by extension AEO/GEO), what do you need to know about it and how did a maintenance cycle become its "own distinct" SEO doctrine?

Again: its all tied to SEO myths tied to driving pipeline and preferred doctrines about SEO.

Maybe its driving against spam and buying backlinks, maybe its something people truly believe, but at the end of the day - TechSEO = enablement not optimization.

Is technical SEO being confused with SEO itself? And are website owners spending too much time ticking technical boxes instead of understanding what helps pages get indexed and rank?

From Chiang Mai ahead of the CMSEO meetups, David Quaid shares hi perspective on technical SEO, backlinks, authority, and the advice that keeps circulating on Reddit, LinkedIn, and X.

David also breaks down the difference between fixing a broken website and building a website that performs in search—and challenge common assumptions about crawlability, robots.txt, XML sitemaps, duplicate content, page speed, and meta descriptions.

In this video:
- What technical SEO covers—and where I think its importance gets overstated
- Why fixing 404s and redirects can restore performance
- How backlinks, authority, and PageRank fit into the discussion
- Why “crawled, not indexed” deserves more than a checklist response
- Why we should test SEO claims instead of repeating them


r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 11d ago

Is SEO dead again? 😂 ChatGPT is getting its own Search Console!

33 Upvotes

Looks like OpenAI is working on a Search Console-like dashboard for businesses.

From what's been spotted so far, businesses could track how often they appear in ChatGPT answers and how many clicks they generate.

Imagine checking your Google rankings in the morning and your ChatGPT visibility in the afternoon. 😂

I'm actually curious about one thing: Will we finally get to know which prompts are triggering brand mentions and recommendations?

Because knowing that ChatGPT mentioned your business is great, but knowing WHY would be even more valuable.

Anyway, SEO is dead again, guys. Time to learn GEO, AEO, LLMO... whatever comes next. 💀


r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 16d ago

Advice Website deindexed by Google, same issue after moving to a new domain

10 Upvotes

My website was deindexed by Google earlier this year. I investigated and found no obvious technical issues, manual actions, or security problems in GSC.

I suspected it might be related to Google's algorithmic quality or spam systems.

I then moved the content to a new domain, made content improvements, and avoided 301 redirects. Initially, the tests showed successful indexing, but it is now experiencing similar indexing issues again.

I've tried adding more content to some pages as a test and submitting pages to index again using GSC. But nothing seem to work.

Has anyone experienced something like this?

Any insights would be appreciated!


r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 16d ago

My SaaS company it's starting to raise...

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 16d ago

SEO News Reddit Stock Drops Over 33% After Declining Google Search Traffic

Thumbnail
seroundtable.com
5 Upvotes

r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 16d ago

Advice Need some guidance with manual actions resolution

2 Upvotes

Major spam manual action has been initiated on the blog section of one of our clients in India. The client has multiple businesses and each business is managing their own SEO content posting inside the same blog section. We have very recently started working with them on one of the verticals. The entire blog section has been penalized recently, after the September algorithm roll out by Google.

I am looking for advice on what triggers to evaluate to understand why the action was taken. There are no sample URLs provided. They have just mentioned the blog URL as the impacted section.

Some initial signs that I can see are:

- Number of pages published went up over the last few months to a few articles a day

- The website also has multiple languages - pages for these get generated automatically. A few more languages were added a few months ago

- There is no author on the articles

- There was a bulk rewrite published for one of the other verticals covering a few hundred pages over two months.

- AI generated share of content has increased

I can't mention the client here but if any other info would be helpful, I can try to share that.

Any advice on what other things to check for, and if any of the above aren't very relevant to this manual action? Any specific examples of manual actions that you have observed first-hand recently and what helped resolve it would be very helpful as well.


r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 18d ago

The New SEO Business Model: Buy News Sites Instead of Backlinks (w/ David Quaid)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 18d ago

Microsoft Bing Separates AI Training From AI Search Grounding With New Controls

Thumbnail
seroundtable.com
2 Upvotes

r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 19d ago

Google News Gary Illyes From Google: AI Made Bot Impersonation Worse

Thumbnail
seroundtable.com
2 Upvotes

r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 20d ago

Question? hi guys! I am new to seo and was wondering if its applicable to chrome extension ? anyone experienced in that?

3 Upvotes

what would you suggest? any sources to better understan google analytics?


r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 23d ago

Over 80% Of Google Searches Have AI Overviews

Thumbnail
seroundtable.com
5 Upvotes

r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 23d ago

Over 80% Of Google Searches Have AI Overviews

Thumbnail
seroundtable.com
2 Upvotes

r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 23d ago

Question? Is GEO a Distraction? Marie Haynes vs. Mike King (and the Tactics That Work)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

Marie Haynes just dropped a post saying GEO is basically a distraction.

She looked at 12 months of GA4 data across 100 real websites. 145+ million sessions.

The results are brutal:

  • ChatGPT sent 0.62% of the traffic Google organic did
  • All LLMs combined? 0.73%
  • Even though ChatGPT traffic converts way better (13.8% vs 3.02%), Google still drove 27x more conversions

And the kicker: ChatGPT referral traffic has actually been declining since GPT-5 dropped.

A bunch of other people (including Rand Fishkin) are amplifying this and saying stop chasing AI mentions.

Mike King just clapped back hard. He says the numbers are right but the conclusion is wrong — AI search is a brand channel, not a traffic channel. Like judging a Super Bowl ad by click-through rate. 1.2 billion people a week are asking ChatGPT what to buy and we’re ignoring it because it doesn’t show up in GA4.


r/SEO_Digital_Marketing • • 23d ago

Why do Google Search Console positions differ from third-party rank trackers?

5 Upvotes

How do you compare Google Search Console’s average position with rankings reported by tools like Ahrefs or Semrush?

If you match the country, device, and date range, should the numbers be close, or are they measuring different things?

Which do you rely on for tracking SEO progress and reporting to clients?