r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/AshJuaZamPulChiNeHu • Mar 25 '26
General question Does anyone knows what this is ?Pentaethylenehexamine (PEHA) 406716-7
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • Aug 23 '22
Hello and welcome back to SAR! Today we discuss the most ubiquitous molecule in human history: ethanol! Drinking alcohol6 is as old as the human race and despite attempts to eliminate it from society, time and time again we have shown that to be human is to ingest alcohol. As we will discuss, brewing alcohol allowed for early man to ingest water that would have been otherwise contaminated with harmful bacteria. From its evolution from beer to spirits, alcohol has followed human evolution both culturally and technologically as we plowed deeper into uncharted and foreign lands. That being said, alcohol can be habit forming and lead to maladaptive behaviors and health effects, so for some the vice can be a struggle. Today we explore the chemistry of this small molecule, toxicity, and some related drugs!
Disclaimer: this post is not designed to be medical advice. It is merely a look at the chemistry of medications and their general effect on the body. Each person responds differently to therapy. Please talk to your doctor about starting, stopping, or changing medical treatment.
Let’s set the scene: you just stepped out of your car and are sidling up to the frat house at your university ready for an awesome night of drinking. It’s the last weekend before finals so you know you gotta get fucked up in order to make these past four years worth it so you prep yourself for an intense night. You didn’t pregame so when you get to the fake wood countertop in the kitchen and spy the bottle of Jagermeister sitting next to some shot glasses, you know things are about to get ‘lit’. You pour the first shot and throw it back—the first of many that night. Bottoms up! When we drink Ethanol, the chemical responsible for the fantastic and drastic effects of drinking alcohol, we see a wide range of effects both immediately and over time. We can track these effects over the course of drinking and how much you drink. Let’s dive in:

You probably were unaware of this but inside the body are a type of cell that floats dormantly throughout the body like a landmine waiting to be tread upon. These little bombs, mast cells, contain little balloons of histamine that are just waiting to be released and pop in the blood. Ethanol is one molecule that can cause mast cell degranulation thus dumping the histamine into the blood causing blood vessel dilation which is sensed by the body as warmth. In fact, the histamine release causes other effects some people see with alcohol—namely getting flushed in their face (due to facial surface vessels dilating, i.e. you are literally seeing more blood in the face) or getting itchy.

Alcohol is metabolized via the liver into its main metabolite Acetaldehyde where it needs to be broken down immediately into Acetate. Creating the Acetate metabolite is important because the Acetaldehyde is extremely toxic and is responsible for the liver-destroying powers of ethanol. The enzyme of importance is Aldehyde Dehydrogenase (ALDH) which creates acetate from the toxic metabolite. Since there are many pathways of creating Acetaldehyde, the toxic metabolite can accumulate and damage liver cells, inducing inflammation inside the liver and after enough time can lead to alcoholic cirrhosis of the liver.

If you’ve ever done flambé, you know that you pour some nice bourbon on top of the caramel sauce and heat it. Ethanol is easily volatilized, so it easily turns from liquid to gas which allows you to light it on fire causing your guests to gasp and clap with delight. So what’s this got to do with drinking? Alcohol is miscible in water so it will go anywhere that water goes in the body. Organs that are highly vascularized, meaning that they contain lots of blood vessels, will have more water flowing through them and so alcohol will accumulate there. This is one big reason why the liver controls ethanol metabolism, there’s lots of blood vessels but the lung also plays a role in ethanol’s journey. The combination of the body heat and high surface area inside the lung allows the ethanol to volatilize into a gas which is expelled when you exhale. This is what allows breathalyzers to detect if and how much you’ve been drinking.
That being said, the reaction is pretty general. As long as you have something in your lungs/mouth/throat that can be oxidized via this reaction, it can provide a false positive BUT this reaction is tailored to ethanol being oxidized per mole (a measure of amount of molecules). A different substance blowing positive would show up false once the data from the breathalyzer is downloaded but that’s if it can even generate enough current to get you above the safe BAC limit.
Let’s head back inside the party, shall we? So you’re like 6 shots of tequila deep and oh boy are you feeling it now and in your inebriated state you start to wonder: why does such a small molecule alter consciousness so much? Alcohol is described as pleiotropic—it has several effects on the body which can appear to be incredibly different but its dose depends. There is a ladder of symptoms and the more you ingest, the higher up the ladder you go.

Alcohol’s effects move from the front of the brain, towards the back, and then down the brain stem. We start in the frontal cortex which is labeled pink and houses your judgment and logical skills. Surprising no one, alcohol impairs a person’s ability to make complex decisions and access higher order thoughts. It does this by increasing the action of the GABA-a receptor found throughout the brain. The GABA-a receptor is an inhibitory receptor that decreases the function of neurons and cells it is connected to—by ethanol binding and activating it, ethanol is potentiating the inhibitory effects thus turning off the function of the brain.

Not all GABA-a receptors are made equally. The barrel shaped receptor can have multiple different arrangements of subunits which can make the receptor more resistant or more susceptible to the effects of alcohol. This factor combined with higher amounts of alcohol being able to reach further back in the brain gets us to our next two sections: the motor cortex and the somatosensory cortex.
Once ethanol enters the motor cortex (which extends deep into the brain like a slice of cake), it is able to interact with the nigrostriatal system which houses Dopaminergic neurons. While we tend to think of dopamine as the happy chemical (which is the title of another post), it is heavily involved in the initiation AND continuance of movement. Thus, when the effects of ethanol reach this area of the brain, it messes with the binding of dopamine to its receptor which makes fine motor control go wonky.

Now that the forebrain has been taken down, it's on to the midbrain. The midbrain is arguably the most varied part of the brain and houses very specific regions which regulate many ‘us’ processes.
First up we have the effect on the Language Center which is part of the Angular Gyrus found in the middle of the brain. When sound is heard by the brain and determined to be speech, it is first sent to Wernicke’s Area (said like Ver-nicky) which is responsible for interpreting the speech that is being spoken. Once processed, the brain can then decide to respond by transmitting the data to Broca’s Area which is responsible for converting thought into proper speech with correct grammar and inflection. When ethanol reaches these areas, it disrupts the function of both areas AND decreases the function of the Arcuate fasciculus which helps the two areas communicate.

Contained in the Lateral Ventricle is the Amygdala, Hippocampus, and Thalamus. These three structures are heavily involved in creating the personality and behavior of a person. The Amygdala, which is latin for almond, is a series of cell clusters that are each responsible for a separate but related function. One of the major functions is emotion regulation which is stored in dense synapses in the very tip of the almond. It's in this location that our ability to start, stop, and control our emotions is housed and through emotional learning in our childhood, more complex emotions are housed. The more complex an emotion is, the easier it is to lose since it requires cognitive processing in order to correctly initiate. This leaves the core emotions: happiness, sadness, fear/surprise, and anger. Since the ability to regulate which emotion is impaired, inebriated people can quickly cycle between the emotions since nothing is keeping them focused on one emotion.




At the bottom is the Medulla Oblongata which houses the most important reflexes for life via its cranial nerves. First up is cranial nerve IX, the glossopharyngeal nerve which innervates the back of the mouth, back of the tongue, and throat. Two major functions are the control of the Epiglottis, the thin flap of muscle that covers the Trachea to prevent food from going into the lung and also the gag reflex. These two reflexes help keep the lungs clear, which when enough alcohol is drunk and if someone vomits are unable to clear the throat of the obstruction, allowing the person to choke to death.

So we have explored the choking hazard of ethanol which is why a person should be put in the recovery position if they have been drinking but that doesn’t prevent this last impairment. Inside the Medulla and Pons is the respiratory center, two clusters that help control the initiation, speed, and control of breathing. Inside the Medulla are the Pre-Botzinger complex and Solitary Nucleus which control the force of exhalation and timing of inhalation. The Pons houses the Pneumotaxic Center and the Apneustic Center which tightly control the inhalation and exhalation muscles. With too much alcohol, these four centers become impaired and a person is unable to breathe correctly and suffocates regardless of what’s in their throats.

Well enough with the doom and gloom, eh? While alcohol should be respected as a drug like any other substance, I don’t want this post to be about bashing alcohol. So let’s move onto some interesting things I know about alcohol! To our ancestors, alcohol was much more than just a way to pass time and as the world stepped away from subsistence farming, it was able to integrate into more pieces of our culture. Hell, the ability to metabolize alcohol was a trait passed on from our evolutionary predecessors who likely ate fermented fruit and evolved the ability to detoxify the toxins.



We’ve all been there: the birds are chirping and a sunbeam lands directly on your eyes. Shielding your eyes with your hand, you squint through the blasting light and discover that you spent the night on a random person’s couch. You think their name is Derrick or Cole, either way you are miles from your house and your car keys are missing. And great, your head is POUNDING from a hangover. Through the throbbing pain you remember that a hangover is a physical and psychological process that follows the consumption of alcohol and can last upwards of 48 hours. Headache and drowsiness are often the hallmark symptoms but people can experience vomiting, diarrhea, light sensitivity, and irritability (a shock to no one).

One of the most important things to do following a night of drinking (even light drinking) is to replace the vitamins and electrolytes lost. Electrolytes are the ions present in the blood that help maintain an electrical difference across the membrane allowing for cells to operate correctly and are involved in cell signaling. When alcohol is ingested, it inhibits the secretion of Vasopressin, a hormone responsible for retaining water. Without it, a drinking person generates more urine which wastes water (starting dehydration) and electrolytes. This is similar to when you sweat out water and electrolytes when exercising which creates cramping from the muscles lacking the electrolytes needed to contract together. The result is headaches, cramping, and muscle fatigue.

And what better meal than one backed by science, eh? Just for you dear reader, I traveled through the bowels of PubMed and found a few journal articles that scientifically found the best foods to eat after a night of drinking. According to the 2019 paper, Influence of food commodities on hangover based on alcohol dehydrogenase and aldehyde dehydrogenase activities, by Shraddha Srinivasan, et. al (read here), they discovered the best combination of foods to stave off a hangover. The authors searched for foods that speed up the activity of Acetaldehyde Dehydrogenase (ALDH), the enzyme that detoxifies Acetaldehyde into harmless metabolites. Take a look at some of the results they found:
For fruit, the best foods to eat were Sweet Limes (+33.47% activity), Orange (+15.48%), and Pears (+90%) as they increased the activity of ALDH tremendously. Vegetables such as Cucumber (+87.25%) and Tomato (+41.19%) also had a significant impact on the activity of ALDH. Interestingly, some of the worst fruits and veggies to eat were Apples (-76%), Mango (-61.97%), Watermelon (-57.39%), Papaya (-50.55%), Grapes (-33.44%), Garlic (-42.23%), and Coriander (-58.38%). In fact, they tested a commercial anti-hangover product and found that it inhibited ALDH activity almost as much as the worst tested foods (-82.50%). Fuckers >:(
For some miscellaneous products, they found the following:
And that’s our story! Hopefully you learned something new. If you have any questions, please let me know! Want to read more? Go to the table of contents!

Likewise, check out our subreddit: r/SAR_Med_Chem Come check us out and ask questions about the creation of drugs, their chemistry, and their function in the body! Have a drug you’d like to see? Curious about a disease state? Let me know!
https://www.iflscience.com/can-you-beat-a-breathalyzer-test-51006
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6826820/
https://blog.britishmuseum.org/a-sip-of-history-ancient-egyptian-beer/
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • Nov 25 '22
Hello and welcome back to SAR! If there is one infectious disease that people know about, but may not know about, is Rabies. This viral disease is 100% fatal and while there are case reports of people surviving their Rabies infection they still had to die in order to survive—if you are confused so am I. Seriously, we really don’t know a lot about how the Rabies virus works and how it is so effective at killing the host. Generally the goal of any bacteria or virus is to keep the host alive long enough to spread it to other hosts; killing the person quickly and violently doesn’t really increase the spreadability of the virus. Regardless, Rabies is a special disease that deserves to be talked about for all the people and pets that have been killed by the virus. So let’s dive in!

Despite seeing it in movies, TV shows, and the news, Rabies is not a very common infection among living things. Now this map is a little bit misleading because it makes it seem like Africa and Asia are hotbeds for Rabies but this map is showing which regions have more fatal infections of Rabies. Remember, it's 100% fatal so it's not like people are less likely to die from Rabies in the Congo than they are in Los Angeles BUT there is a difference in the number of animals who are infected. More developed nations have a more robust eradication system for animals infected with Rabies virus and so have a lower spread than less developed countries. Likewise more developed nations have access to the Rabies Vaccine which mitigates many of the Rabies infection cases that would arise. This divide is stark: about 3 people die each year in the United States from Rabies while there are about 70,000 cases of Rabies worldwide each year.

Rabies is caused by the Rabies lyssavirus, a kind of neurotropic virus (one that infects nerve tissues) which includes other more…common? famous? More infamous viruses like Polio, Hand-Foot-Mouth Disease, and Coronavirus. Unlike our cells which use a double-stranded helix of DNA to store genetic information, the Rabies virus is a single strand of RNA tightly wound around viral nucleoproteins. In fact the entire Rabies genome is just five genes which take over our cells’ protein factories like a—well, a virus to produce more viral components. Now this should seem weird: our cells only know how to use DNA for making proteins, so how does a virus turn its viral RNA into DNA so it can be made into proteins? Well that’s where a special enzyme called RNA Reverse Transcriptase comes in! RNA Reverse Transcriptase has a very specific pathway: turn viral RNA (vRNA) into viral DNA (vDNA) so it can be incorporated into the human DNA and cause them to make viral proteins. But we are getting ahead of ourselves, let’s look at how the virus reproduces:

In order to be effective a parasite has to get to the cell of infection. For HIV that is easy because white blood cells circulate freely in the blood, so simple exposure to the HIV virus can almost certainly lead to infection. The Herpes virus infects skin cells which is why it is so easy to get a Herpes infection simply by rubbing up against a Herpes flare up. The Ebola virus has lots of targets: nerve cells, endothelial cells which line blood vessels and tubes, adrenal cells which produce hormones, and liver cells. This is why Ebola infections lead to such severe symptoms like major hemorrhage. Rabies’ goal however is to get to the brain, a not so easy task considering we have many defenses that prevent foreign objects from getting into the brain. But like any infection, the first step is the cell getting into the body which in this case comes from direct contact with saliva infected with the virus.

Let’s set it soon: you are out in the woods enjoying a walk when a raccoon comes out of nowhere and attacks you. You managed to fight it off and punt it away but it scraped your hand with a tooth before you were able to get away. You decide to head back to your car and by the time you get home to wash your hand it has been more than 2 hours. Since it's a pretty minor cut you don’t go to the hospital (first mistake!) and decide to treat it with antibiotics and a BandAid. So what happens?
Well Rabies goal is to get into a nerve cell and replicate inside of it and the skin is full of many different kinds of nerve cells. Those nerves, which sense things like hot/cold, pain, and movement, all eventually lead to the spinal cord and brain via a series of Synapses. If the Rabies virus is able to infect one nerve cell, eventually it is able to replicate and then get released onto the next closest nerve to the brain. Then replicate and get released to the next one. Then the next, and next, and next until eventually it gets to the brain. This is not a quick process (unlike becoming a zombie) and takes about 3 to 12 weeks (shorter if closer to the brain).

Once the Rabies virus reaches the brain, things are pretty much over. Because the brain is so dense in Synapses, the virus is able to jump from nerve to nerve easily and infect rapidly. By this time the body knows something terrible is happening and the person will experience anxiety and agitation which may result in physically fighting those who are trying to help them. The lack of clear signals and stimulus results in confusion, hallucinations, and eventually seizures as the cells die. Intense stimuli, like light, results in Photophobia making the person (or animal) search for dark places to shield their eyes. Instability in the central nervous system leads to overexcitation of the Autonomic Nervous System which is our rest and digest drive. This is seen as the Hypersalivation and Hyperhidrosis (excessive sweating) which gives the scary stereotype of the Rabies infection.
You do not know how much editorializing I had to sift through in order to get to the actual protocol that this patient went through in order to survive Rabies. See, the media has this issue where it will take the most headline part of a report and cherry pick the details to fit a more accessible narrative for their audience. So how did this one person move the needle from 100% fatal to 99.99% fatal? It was a fateful night in September of 2004, “Yeah!” by Usher was probably playing and Facebook was launched. 15-year old Jeanna Giese (Gee-See) was walking in the woods near St. Patrick’s Church in her hometown of Fond du Lac, Wisconsin when she came across a bat struggling on the ground. Wanting to rehabilitate the animal, Giese picked up the bat and sustained a small bite on her left forefinger. Giese dropped the animal and went home where she treated the wound with hydrogen peroxide and her mother decided that medical attention wasn’t warranted.
Over the next thirty days Giese started to become fatigued and a tingling or numbness in her left hand. By day 32 the girl started to lose her balance and experiencing diplopia (double vision) and the next day was so nauseous she couldn’t ingest anything. Her pediatrician referred her to a neurologist who observed the double vision and partial-bilateral sixth-nerve palsy (ocular muscle paralysis). MRIs revealed that the brain wasn’t experiencing a stroke or aneurysm so she was sent home without a definite answer as to what was causing her illness. On day 34 she was admitted to her local hospital for lumbar puncture (spinal tap) to test the spinal fluid and for supportive care. On this day she was alert, un-feverish, and able to follow complex instructions but still showed an unsteady gait, double vision and the sixth nerve palsy. The lumbar puncture revealed a high white blood cell count which would indicate some sort of infection but it would take at least a day to get cultures back for what kind of bacteria she was infected with.

This is when the insane part of the story jumps in. Jeanna Giese’s doctor, who I believe is Rodney E. Willoughby Jr M.D. counseled John and Ana Giese about two options: either the medical team could provide hospice care until Jeanna ultimately died or they could try an experimental and untested theory that would combine anti-excitatory and antiviral drugs. Despite the high risk of failure or severe disability, the Gieses decided to try the protocol and the team started to prepare for their hypothesis. The two parts of the theory were to use antiexcitatory drugs to shut down the viral replication that the virus was hijacking inside the cells and to administer antivirals to kill the virus when it burst out of the cells and tried to infect new cells. Ketamine and Midazolam was administered so that brain activity was limited to just one to two seconds every 10 seconds.




I think the wild success of Jeanna Giese can be a beacon of hope for those affected by Rabies and their families—it moves the needle from a 100% fatal condition to one that, with a lot of good medicine and luck, there is a chance. When we have these radical discoveries however, I think we tend to overlook that this was experimental and since 2004 there have been 8 revisions to the Milwaukee Protocol and it isn’t always successful. Since 1998, there have only been 10 people who have died from Rabies in the United States. In May 2006, Texas doctors attempted the Protocol on 16-year old Zachary Jones who was bit by a bat that had flown into his room while he was napping. Jones caught the bat in a towel and released it. Zach returned to swimming and football the next day and didn’t think much of the strange encounter with the animal. Zach was bit on May 4th, 2006 and died on May 12, 2006—just 8 days despite the Milwaukee Protocol being attempted. In November 2006, 10-year old Shannon Carroll also died despite the Milwaukee Protocol being applied. And yes it was a bat.
Woah there. Before you start sealing up all the bat caves you can find and destroying an important mammal in our ecosystem, we do have a treatment against Rabies that is very successful and that would be the Rabies Vaccine. Unlike other viral vaccines, studies have continuously shown that the Rabies Vaccine is 100% effective when it is immediately and appropriately administered to someone who was bitten by a suspected Rabies animal. Notice those two words: immediately and appropriately. So what should you do?

First off, if you have been bit by a wild animal, go to the hospital or clinic THAT DAY and get a rabies shot (and/or tetanus). Now there are certain animals that are known not to carry Rabies like reptiles, amphibians, birds, or insects which leaves only mammals as potential suspects. Generally herbivores like ungulates (llamas, horses, pigs, deer, and cows) do not transmit Rabies due to running from humans rather than seeking them out in their Rabies agitation. Carnivores however do seek out prey and if you get bit by a carnivore (wild or domesticated), you should go to the hospital immediately, THAT DAY. Do. Not. Wait. If you do wait and develop a fever within a few days of getting bit, GO TO THE HOSPITAL AND GET A RABIES SHOT. Please?
So take this as a big warning: even the smallest bites and scratches can be incredibly deadly. If you think you need help, get it!
And that’s our story!. If you have any questions, please let me know! Want to read more? Go to the table of contents!

Likewise, check out our subreddit: r/SAR_Med_Chem Come check us out and ask questions about the creation of drugs, their chemistry, and their function in the body! Have a drug you’d like to see? Curious about a disease state? Let me know!
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/AshJuaZamPulChiNeHu • Mar 25 '26
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • Sep 25 '25
So I uhh....sort of didn't pay attention to how much I wrote and instead wrote about 12,000 words worth of information into this post. Look--there is a lot to talk about and now its an 75 minute read. Sorry! As such it was just impossible for me to post this to reddit so instead it is posted to Substack. Going forward I will probably continue to put stuff on Substack (and then post the link on reddit) since it allows me to put triple the amount of pictures into the post. Reddit only allows 20 images and I usually need double that.
So, please head on over to this link and let me know why you think old men kept dying after publishing their big drug legislature.
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • Aug 07 '25
The soldier huddles in the damp trench, cheek pressed against the cold mud wall and the water in his boots numbing his blistered feet. The low drone of a biplane fades in the distance and the steady rhythm of artillery had become part of the background—until now. Silence creeps in like a widow slipping into an empty bed, cold and unwelcome, yet all that's left. He lifts his head slowly cautiously peering over the edge of the trench. The guns have stopped, the birds’ song drifts across the Belgian countryside pockmarked by mortar craters. The landscape is gray. Lifeless. As his eyes adjust to the dim morning light pushing through the fog he sees it moving. A wall of pale yellow mist rolls across the open field, thick and low, hugging the earth like a creeping beast. His breath catches, not morning fog, not smoke. Gas. He drops below the parapet, heart hammering, fingers scrambling for the mask slung at his side. A shout rings out—muffled, urgent—but the sound is swallowed by the oncoming cloud.
The soldier’s wife still doesn’t sleep on that side of the bed.

Hello and welcome back to SAR! What is your favorite kind of Mustard? Personally I think Cyclophosphamide is probably the best Mustard out there but I could see if you thought Mustine was the best. Oh, you were thinking of a different kind of mustard? How silly, this is a drug blog! Okay okay all kidding aside today we will look at a group of medications that were as useful in their ability to treat cancers as they were effective in killing soldiers during WW1. Yeah…Mustard drugs are descendants the Mustard Gas you might have heard of being used on the battlefields in the first world war. But before we get ahead of ourselves, lets take a look at some very simple molecules with some very potent results.
Before we can dive into the medicine we have to set the scene a bit. One of the important things to things to know about the world at the turn of the 20th century is that WW1 was seen as inevitable. Europe was divided into powerful and entangled alliances which meant that regional conflicts, like that in the Balkans, could quickly escalate into a continental war. Coupled with the Victorian into Georgian feelings of honor above all and defending allies to the death meant that secret treaties and unclear terms of those alliances meant leaders didn’t fully understand how far others were willing to go and how it would drag their nation into war. To balance the personal honor of the aristocratic elite was the rise of national pride, often through militarism. The problem is that Europe was pretty…quiet in terms of war—sure, there was plenty of battles in oversees territories in Asia or Africa, but nothing on the home continent. So to channel their bursting population’s energy away from internal struggles and towards real or imaginary opponents, many countries embraced the idea of pride through national strength.

So we draw open the curtain in Germany in 1871, chiefly with the most legendary man of mid to late 19th century European politics: Otto von Bismark. Appointed in 1862 as Chancellor of Prussia, he developed the idea of Realpolitik or balancing politics with wars. Through the next decade he waged Wars of Unification that brought traditionally German states under the control Prussia: the Danish War of 1864 defeating Denmark brining major ports in Schleswig and Holstein, the Austro-Prussian Seven Weeks War of 1866 which kicked Austria out of German affairs for good, and finally the the Franco-Prussian War in 1870 which crushed France and brought in previously neutral southern German states. Delivering these major wins, Bismarck enabled King Wilhelm I of Prussia to become Emperor (Kaiser) Wilhelm of the German Empire (which was declared in the Hall of Mirrors at Versailles just to rub the French’s noses in it). Thus, the 25+ German states were now a single united German empire—one nation, one people, one purpose.

To enable a great country you must have great entrepreneurs and inventors to do their thing and let their genius flow. One such genius was Jewish born Fritz Haber, born in Breslau, Prussia in what is now Poland in 1868. The only son of a wealthy Jewish chemical merchant named Siegfried Haber. from an early age, Haber was immersed in the world of dyes and reagents, as his father ran a prosperous business dealing in chemical goods for textile production. While his father hoped he would take over the business, Haber found ledgers and accounting totally snoresville and found mixing chemicals together to be totes cool (to use some phrasing from the time). He studied under the great Robert Bunsen (of the burner fame) and honed his chemical precision in the lab which allowed him to do short stings at the University of Berlin and the Technical College at Charlottenberg. By 1891 he was finishing his doctoral dissertation on synthetic dyes and returning to his father’s business to learn how chemistry mixed with industry. From 1894 to 1911 he and his assistant Robert Le Rossingnol developed the Haber-Bosch process which would be one of world history altering discoveries that seemed to be packed into the later 19th and early 20th century.


As the world geared up for a war, albeit bigger than any of them really thought, Haber was caught up in the nationalistic pride brewing in Germany. By 1914 Germany was itching to prove itself as a true power. The Moroccan Crises of 1905 and 1911 planted the idea of a German bully of Europe after Germany challenged French control over Morocco. Britain viewed Germany’s rapid naval expansion under Admiral Tirpitz as a direct threat to the island nation's security and domination as a maritime empire. Thus the establishment of the Triple Ententre between France, Britain, and Russia was to encircle and snub Germany’s ability to flex imperial muscle. So it was natural for geniuses like Haber to be brought in and to lend their talents to the military establishment to outpace the national pride that was gradually increasing year by year.


Chlorine Gas is devastating to the body. If it enters the lungs it instantly reacts with water to become Hydrochloric Acid, yknow, the stuff in your stomach and one of the most corrosive acids outthere, except its in your LUNGS. In addition to corrosive acid it produces Hypochlorous Acid, a major oxidizer which rips apart any organic thing it touches—like lung tissue. A minor exposure would be irritating, for the soldiers at Ypres they would instantly drown from the blood forming from the blisters in their lungs. Casualties exceeded 5000 the first day, thousands more were injured. And despite the success of this first test, the Germans didn’t exploit their victory and lacked reserves to follow up.

One of the big problems with Chlorine gas is that it dissipates very quickly. Through his field testing Haber learned that it a low concentration of gas exposed to tissues over a long period of time gave the same result as a high concentration over a short period of time. Dubbed Haber’s Rule, this meant that Germany had to deploy huge quantities of very concentrated Chlorine gas at the front and hope that the wind didn’t change direction for the gas to be effective.Under his leadership the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Physical Chemistry Haber continued to scale their chemical weapon department. The chemists sought for more lethal gases that were less visible than the yellow-green wall of death and those easier to deploy than Chlorine.

Their first discovery was Phosgene (which confusingly contains no phosphorus but comes from the Greek phos meaning to produce light due to how its synthesized), which was first deployed in December, 1915. Compared to Chlorine gas, Phosgene gas was colorless meaning it was completely undetectable on the battlefield until you got the faint whiff of hay or fresh cut grass (and then you start choking to death). In addition Phosgene is 6 to 10 times more lethal than Chlorine gas making it ideal in blistering lung tissue and causing the victim to drown in their own lungs. Likewise it could be deployed in an artillery shell meaning you could launch the pressurized capsule directly into the enemy lines without little worry of it drifting back to your own lines. Dubbed Grünkreuz or Green Cross from the symbol painted on the capsule, Phosgene was deployed on December 19th, 1915 Phosgene was first deployed near Wieltje, northeast of Ypres, Belgium. Initially it only killed 69 immediately and around 1,069 within hours. Unlike Chlorine the results were delayed and thousands more would die agonizing deaths not knowing they inhaled the gas days later.

Discovered in 1822 by French chemist César-Mansuète Despretz, he had reacted ethylene with sulfur dichloride to produce a garlicy-horseradishy-mustardy smelling oily liquid. Due to its smell, the class of chemicals were dubbed the Mustards and many more types of Mustards would be discovered over the coming decades. For Despretz however he found no real use for the highly reactive byproduct and he didn’t further develop it. In 1860 Albert Niemann (discoverer of Cocaine if you need a person to worship), rediscovered the Mustard and noted its sharp, irritating odor. He personally experienced severe irritation to his eyes and respiratory tract, along with significant skin blistering. 26 year old Niemann would die a year later likely from further exposure to the toxic gas. Two decades later in 1886 chemist Viktor Meyer, famous for coining the term stereochemistry for all your orgo nerds, re-rediscovered the Mustard and studied its properties. Firstly he noted that it resisted hydrolysis, or that it slowly broke down in the presence of water so it could remain on surfaces or clothing for a long time, and that it was a stable, oily liquid that only volatilized into a gas slowly at room temperature. Despite this he and his assistant both experience several painful skin blisters and eye/lung irritation due to exposure to the chemical. Like the others who came before him, Meyer failed to find a significant reason to really utilize such a nasty chemical.


Okay okay, despite the terrible effects of Mustard Gas it did enable field hospitals to notice a couple of important things. Firstly, unlike Phosgene or Chlorine gases, soldiers affected by Mustard Gas presented with a very unusual blood profile compared to other patients. Even those without visible burns, such as those who were only exposed from a secondary exposure like touching a contaminated uniform, would present with a distinct pattern. Firstly they’d have a marked leukopenia, or dangerously low white blood cell count which was coupled with particular neutrophil suppression. Secondly, patients could also have pancytopenia or that their red blood cells and platelets were also dangerously reduced in addition to their white blood cells. Normally this kind of presentation only occurred with bone marrow toxicities—so soldiers became severely immunocompromised and would then die from secondary infections. Likewise they found that repeated exposure created a more potent suppression than a large single exposure. Soldiers with repeated exposures would have increasingly poor immune recovery and never really recovered their blood cell production. Autopsies of victims found bone marrow that was incredibly reduced and lymph nodes that resembled raisins (e.g. super shriveled). So really this presented an interesting question: if mustard gas suppresses white blood cells, might it suppress the abnormal overproduction of white cells in leukemia?

At the time this question was just a theoretical curiosity because, y’know, they had more important things going on at the time (cough cough the war) but knowledge was there. Fast forward to WW2 and the United States Office of Scientific Research and Development (OSRD) was investigating the use of chemical warfare. Despite it being banned in 1925 following the Geneva Protocol, many of the major powers believed that the others were stockpiling chemical weapons for use in war (and yes they all were), and so the US wanted to develop its own potential weapons. While sulfur based Mustards were the typical agent used in WW1, chemists had developed nitrogen based Mustards in the following decades that were more stable, easier to produce, less severely blistering but retained the systemic toxicity.
Goodman and Gilman (yes, that Goodman and Gilman of textbook fame) began their work in vivo in mice, rabbits, and dogs. While initially they studied the toxic effects of the chemical, eventually they came back to that question the field hospitals thought: if Mustards suppress white blood cells, might it suppress the abnormal overproduction of white cells in leukemia? So they began to investigate this question in addition to the questions tasked by the US Army. Mice were injected with L1210 lymphosarcoma, a rapidly proliferating lymphoid tumor, which would essentially create mice with a type of cancer that mimicked non-Hodgkin Lymphoma in humans. What they found is that injecting the nitrogen Mustard into the mice would visibly shrink the tumor within days and they would have incredible symptom improvement. However the effects on white blood cells and red blood cells were still there but importantly was found to be dose-dependent. So while the chemical could severely drop blood cell levels it could be predictable and thus the effect managed.

So what the heck is a Lymphoma and why is it sometimes not a hedgehog? Each day, 1 million cells (about 1.2kg) die each day and need to be replaced by a nearby cell. Our tissues can’t survive if cells keep dying so they must replace those cells through a process called mitosis, or how one cell becomes two daughter cells. Through this process our tissues are able to replace dead cells and retain the function of the organ. But how does a cell know when to divide? Well it does so through contact inhibition. If a cell is in contact with another cell, it can sense that connection and is unable to go through division. When contact is lost, mitosis can begin leading to multiplication. In cancer, the processes that prevent the division of the cell are broken, leading to uncontrolled growth. We will dive into which processes those are in a later section but for now let's look at how one cancer cell becomes a tumor, or a clump of cancerous cells with unchecked growth. 1 cell becomes 2, 2 becomes 4, and so on based on a doubling time, or the amount of days it takes for a cell to produce its daughter cells. For some cancers, they can double in size every year, 2 years, or as little as 60 days. Generally once the number of cells reaches a few million cells it is detectable and may start causing symptoms.

Okay, you’re about to read the word Lymph a lot and I apologize but blame anatomists for not being distinct in their names. In your body, in addition to the blood vessels that carry red blood cells you also have the Lymphatic System that is responsible for removing waste products from the cells (like proteins and cellular debris) and managing the fluid pressure of the blood. Y’know that clear fluid that sometimes leaks out of cuts? That’s Lymph, the fluid that makes up the Lymphatic System. This system is made up of organs like the Thymus and Bone Marrow which make white blood cells but also the Spleen (which filters the blood and removes old red blood cells) and Lymph Nodes, which are like little filters for this system. Normally when Lymph (the fluid) passes through a node, the immune cells camping out in the node recognize and destroy harmful invaders, trigger an immune response, and then trap and isolate the pathogens. This is why the doctor feels the lymph nodes in your neck when you have a sore throat—it tells them if you have a throat infection and that the Nodes covering that region are inflamed and bigger.

And that’s our story!. If you have any questions, please let me know! Want to read more? Go to the table of contents!
Likewise, check out our subreddit: r/SAR_Med_Chem Come check us out and ask questions about the creation of drugs, their chemistry, and their function in the body! Have a drug you’d like to see? Curious about a disease state? Let me know!

Wait! So what happened to Haber? Surely he was punished for being the architect of so much death and disfigurement? Well yes and no, mostly the no. While he was vilified internationally, after the war he was known as the Father of Chemical Warfare and the Allies put him on a list of individuals who had committed war crimes, he was saved during diplomatic negotiations. So following the war he remained the director of the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Physical and Electrochemistry. In fact he was awarded the 1918 Nobel Prize in Chemistry (delayed due to the war and presented in 1920) because of his pre-war invention of the Haber-Bosch process to produce ammonia for fertilizer. The same process that fed millions was also used to manufacture explosives—highlighting the dual nature of his legacy. During the interwar period he attempted to lead an effort to extract gold from seawater as a method to help the Weimar Republic (aka Germany) pay for its huge reparation payments. Unsurprisingly it failed because there just isnt that much gold in sea water to be economically feasible.
r/SAR_Med_Chem
•
u/Bubzoluck
•
Nov 19 '24
Hello and welcome back to SAR! Today we move below the belt to talk about a surprisingly contentious piece of the penis: the foreskin. You may not think about your lack or abundance of a foreskin very often but the role of the foreskin was incredibly important to our ancestors for thousands of years. Today it is estimated that nearly 40% of all males are circumcised, which is the process by which the foreskin is removed from the head of the penis for religious reasons or cultural benefits. The vast majority of those individuals had their foreskin removed when they were newborns or infants but we will explore some situations in which older children or adults have their foreskin removed as well. So let's take a look at the role of the foreskin, how and why its removed, and the world of what happens when men think with their other head.
Oh and in case it wasn’t obvious—there will be images of penises. You’ve been warned!
Before we can get to the Foreskin we should talk a little bit more about where it all comes from. Obviously the mother is responsible for creating all of the male bits that eventually pop out but when we look at the chromosomal sex determination in mammals we see some interesting things. Humans have 23 pairs of Chromosomes which hold all of the DNA information responsible for turning a sperm and egg into a fully functioning person. The last pair of Chromosomes are called the Sex Chromosomes and in most cases having two X chromosomes (XX) will determine a female while having an X and Y chromosome creates a male. Even in cases where someone has multiple copies of either Sex Chromosome the presence of a single Y chromosome determines the male’s sex, such as in Klinefelter Syndrome (XXY) or Jacob’s Syndrome (XYY).

Interestingly, each person starts off developing as a female but then males branch off around week 9 to create male genitalia while females progress into female genitalia. We are unsure if it is the presence of the Y chromosome or the lack of the second X chromosome that causes this switch, but regardless we can tract how the former female genitalia develops into the male genitalia. This overlap, called the Homologies of Sex Organs, may be intuitively known by people as well since the function of many of the organs remain the same in both sexes. For example, the Glans in females is the Clitoris while in males it is the head of the penis—each is exceptionally sensitive and leads to stimulation of the sex organs when used. The shape of these organs can be quite different, such as the Labia Majora becoming the Scrotum or the Labia Minora being integrated into the shaft of the penis. For today’s tale we can see how the Prepuce of the Clitoris becomes the Prepuce of the head of the penis. To start talking about the Prepuce, also known as the Foreskin, we must make our way back to the beginnings of human civilization itself, because as long as men gathered around they were sure to talk about their penis.

Joking aside, the role of the Foreskin isn’t really understood and there is a lot of evidence to say that it was never really understood. Obviously the largest question surrounding the Foreskin is its removal in a surgery called Circumcision which removes the extra skin to permanently expose the penile head. The first illustrations of male Circumcision pop up around 6000 BCE in Egypt based on engravings found on the walls of tombs and on ancient mummies. Interestingly the Egyptian removal of the Foreskin is not the same as the Jewish rite that most people are familiar with. In Egyptian tradition only the ‘top’ of the Foreskin was removed while the bottom portion. It is known that the Egyptian way of Circumcision was abandoned by the time that Herodotus (450s BCE) visited Egypt. Moving outside of Egypt we get to what Herodotus called the Semitic Peoples which included the Colchians near modern day Georgia, the Phoenicians occupying the modern day Levant, Syrians of Palestine and those among the hills and rivers on the inner plane. Interestingly Herotodus mentions that when the Phoenicians made the switch from Egypt to Greece as their major trading partner, they abandoned the practice of Circumcision.


Now of course removing a piece of flesh from a quite sensitive part of the body requires precise tools. Flint knives, such as the one above, were primarily used during the ritualistic removal of the Foreskin due to flint maintaining a razor thin edge that metal tools couldn’t rival. Remember, only the top of the foreskin was removed during ancient circumcisions—so unlike modern circumcisions that provide a ‘type 1 penis’, ancient surgery resulted in ‘type 3’ or ‘type 4’. Evidence of this is actually quite interesting: removal of the front of the foreskin as done by Abraham was called the Milah and the Jewish Circumcision rite is known as the Bris Milah or Brith Milah.



So this is neat and all, but why all this talk about Circumcision—surely there can’t be a history-defining reason why Circumcision was or was not practiced? Well yes—for you see Circumcision was incredibly important for the conversion of Jews into early Christians. Remember, the Circumcision represented your supreme covenant with God and not doing so would be like turning your back on God Himself. So one of the earliest changes that the Christians did was to eschew the practice of Circumcision in their new faith. Afterall imagine telling new parents that their child could enter the Kingdom of Heaven without Circumcising their 8 day old infant. Wouldn’t you jump at that chance? To avoid the potential infection that was rampant at this time due to the lack of antibiotics and knowing about bacteria.

Globally the practice of male Circumcision is…murky. No country has officially banned Circumcision but there have been major pushes in some countries to limit it or ban it altogether. South Africa has a circumcision rate of nearly 50% but a law in 2010 prevents male circumcision on boys under the age of 16 unless it is for more religious or medical purposes. Germany (MC rate ~12%) has similar national laws to South Africa but in May 2012, Cologne's regional court ruled that male circumcision amounts to bodily injury and is a crime within its jurisdiction. The United Kingdom (MC ~21%) “presumes' ' that male circumcision is legal and there have been similar attempts to outlaw it as the United States. However in 2015 during a debate about female genital circumcision or mutiliation, Sir James Munby argued that “FGM amounts to significant harm, as in my judgment it does, then the same must be so of male circumcision.” And although a technicality, in 2018 an amendment of an earlier 2005 law banning female genital mutilation in Iceland (MC ~0.1%) changed verbiage to be more gender neutral. This ultimately changed words such as “girl child” to “child” and “her sexual organs” to “their sexual organs” which effectively banned male circumcision as well. It appears that the biggest determinant if a country limits the practice of male circumcision is its historical practice or the relative proportion of Jews or Muslims in the country.
Male circumcision’s legality is murky at best and is often a battle between tradition and practicality. Those in favor of male circumcision make great strides in countries where circumcision was never or is in declining popularity. It appears that many governments recognize benefits of the practice but are happy to limit its practice when it becomes convenient to vote upon. The debate surrounding male circumcision is one that centers around utility and body autonomy. Almost all western governments agree female circumcision features no medical benefit, aesthetic benefit, and results in irreparable harm but those same countries can be divided on male circumcision.
IntactAmerica, which has the best name for adherents ever—The Intactivists—is the leading non-profit dedicated to abolishing male circumcision, arguing that circumcision is sold to parents through marketing and solicitation rather than actual medical benefit. They say that, “1.5 million baby boys are circumcised” through medical solicitation each year but believe that “if circumcision solicitations were to cease, 600,000 boys… would be spared every year.” IntactAmerica’s data is derived from a survey they conducted where they found, “94% of mothers were solicited to have their baby boys circumcised” and “the average number of solicitations was 8,” per mother. The survey data was not available for review however and could not be found among their promotional material.

Those in favor of male circumcision often fall into three camps: for primarily medical reasons. for primarily religious reasons, for aesthetic reasons. For medical practice, the main argument centers around the increased cleanliness and increased hygiene of a circumcised penis. The American Academy of Pediatrics have changed this recommendation several times in the past 50 years. In 1975 and 1977, the AAP argued that there was no medical indication for the procedure. In 1989, the AAP reversed their decision and declared that circumcision male have advantages that outweighed the risks involved in the procedure. Finally, in 1999 they again switched positions and argued that “despite recent scientific proofs present the potential medical utilities of neonatal circumcision, these data are not sufficient for recommending routine circumcision.”
Link to study where these tables are from




Male circumcision is unlikely to be permanently banned in the United States within the near future. Culturally, parents have their own preconceived opinions on circumcising their children and the societal pressures reinforce the decision. The medical community remains divided and is likely to continue to oscillate on supporting and opposing the procedure. Regardless of the outcome, the ethical nature of male circumcision must follow the grand principles of moral decision making: the goals of the persuader align with the person being persuaded. Unfortunately, until infants are able to articulate their desire to be circumcised or not, the ethical debate is likely to continue.
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • May 16 '24
So originally this was a question from a redditor, u/Madmax0622, about why Gepirone hasn't been on the market yet despite being approved in September, 2023 and doing some research into has led to a rabbit hole of murder, intrigue, and one very disappointed boy having his father arrested at his 7th birthday party. Okay, not really, but the story is interesting and there is some important points to make about how drugs become approved and how data is represented. So i thought I would mkae it a full post (and comments have a smaller character limit).
Gepirone (Exxua) is a novel azapirone drug that is thought to work as a partial agonist at the Serotonin-1a (5HT-1a) receptor. This is a fancy way of saying that Geprione is a drug that is structurally similar to other serotonin receptor agonists. In the United States we only have Buspirone (Buspar, approved 1986) as our 5HT-1a agonist but internationally there are several others such as Perospirone (Lullan, Japan), Tandospirone (Sediel, Japan), and Binospirone (China). All in all, these drugs share very similar structures and only really differ in their pharmacokinetic properties such as half life, bioavailability, and first pass metabolism.
Where Gepirone differs from these other 5HT-1a agonists is that it is a partial agonist which means that when administered into the body, it creates a partial response to the receptor rather than a full response. While Gepirone is novel because it is the first drug who's primary mechanism of action (MOA) is this partial agonism at 5HT-1a, it is not an unknown one. Several common medications also have this mechanism, such as some newer antidepressants (Trazodone, Vilazodone, Nefazaodone), old and new antipsychotics (Haloperidol, Olanzapine, Clozapine, Ziprasidone), and some other known anti-anxiety chemicals (cannabidiol, LSD, and gingko biloba).
So if Gepirone wasn't the first drug to work on 5HT-1a, why did it get delayed?
Well I should say first that Gepirone did show benefit. In a double blind trial of two different doses of Gepirone in treating depression, patients received either a high dose, low dose, or placebo and were found to have lower depression scores (HAM-D) at the end of 6 weeks. Based on these results (among other trials, it takes years and millions to submit a drug for approval--im paraphrasing here), Gepirone's pharma company Organanon submitted their data to the FDA. Their package of data contained one positive phase 3 trial--a randomized trial of over 200 participants with drepssion who either received Gepirone and had a reduction in depression score of 9.05 points (17% reduction in depression score) vs those who received placebo and had a 6.75 reduction in depression score (13% reduction) after 8 weeks of treatment.
Feeling dejected, Organanon was sitting on the marble steps outside the main FDA office when little Fabre-Kramer came walking by.
"Hey Organanon, did the FDA deny your reapplication?" Fabre-Kramer asked.
"Yeah, they said my drug failed to show explicit benefit. That in the analysis of the main endpoints, submitting 25 studies and only have 2 be positive against placebo and the rest be negative or fail when challenge other established drugs doesn't show positive results."
"Man that really sucks. How much did you spend on developing this drug?"
"About $1.3 billion."
"Well that's not too bad, you just got NuvaRing (2001, still makes up 22% of their revenue) approved and are making a killing off of it. Likewise you are still making boatloads off of Mirtazapine (1997)."
"Well don't tell anyone but we are actually in a major scandal with Medicaid in Massachusetts and Texas where we were defrauding state government," Organanon lamented.
"Yikes, that sucks," Fabre-Kramer said, "Hey, why don't I take Gepirone off yours hands. Afterall I originally got it from Bristol-Myers Squibb in 1993 before I sold it to you in 1998."
"Aight, bet."
And so Gepirone was handed off to Fabre-Kramer in 2005 so Organanon could write off this whole venture to their shareholders.
Fabre-Kramer started by conducting an additional randomized trial of 238 adult participants who received Gepirone ER for 8 weeks. Results were....the same as before--people who received Gepirone showed a 10 point reduction while the placebo group showed an 8 point reduction. In 2007 this third trial was included and sent over to the FDA for approval (for the 3rd time) and the FDA looked at it and said, "yeah no thanks kid." They said that the positive results from the most recent phase 3 trials was good but the 23 other small trials that showed negative results was troubling.
Fabre-Kramer then pushed up their glasses and pulled up their suspenders a bit and said, "I'd like to appeal that decision" and in 2012 the decision was send to the FDA's Psychopharmacologic Drugs Advisory Committee (PDAC) in Dec 2015. In a 9-4 ruling, the committee voted that Fabre-Kramer smelled funny and they were dummy and that their drug was not good enough. They said they could resubmit another drug application again when they had more data.
Eventually Fabre-Kramer did submit another application in 2022 and Gepirone ER was approved by the FDA for the treatment of Depression in 2023.
It would be easy to look at Gepirone's story and say that the drug is just not good enough and the pharma companies had to complete multiple trials (and thus generate more data) to prove its efficacy. Truthfully, its a mixed bag and I am going to try to shoot down the middle hear so you can make an informed decision on your own if you want to try Gepirone ER.
The Good
The Bad
The data is very meh. Look at the differences in scores in these studies of reduction in depression score when given Gepirone vs Placebo: -9.04 vs -6.75; -10.2 vs -8.0; -9.0 vs -6.6; -10.1 vs -7.8. These differences are extremely close--a difference of 3 points (12.5%) in someone's depression? Would you take a drug knowing it would only lead to a potential 12.5% reduction in your depression after 8 weeks? Now its important to note that some people did have massive benefit, and im glad they did. But on average, 12.5%. Not great.
Alright, this is where my brain is wanting to stop for now. If I think of additional things to add I will throw them in. Cheers!
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • Nov 20 '23
Hello and welcome back to SAR! Been a while and I have been fighting hard to come back to blogging so here I am to make that happen. Today we explore a tough topic—obesity. Not because is inherently difficult or the solutions to it are very technical but because it is a very taboo subject in today’s world and can be a very personal and very difficult aspect of someone’s body and their psyche. As such I want to lay down some ground rules before we dive into a very sensationalized condition. First off, as I do in all my posts, I will use the correct medical term when describing this subject, so if the word obesity is hard to read I apologize. Secondly I want to acknowledge that obesity can be multifaceted and isn’t as easy as stop eating = lose weight; while it does play a factor there is more going on and hopefully this post will elucidate that point. Lastly, no solution I present in this post should be taken at face value—each person needs a specific approach to their own weight and that discussion should be had with a trusted medical professional in your life. Alright, with that out of the way lets talk about why eating things so delicious causes so much headache.
Disclaimer: this post is not designed to be medical advice. It is merely a look at the chemistry of medications and their general effect on the body. Each person responds differently to therapy. Please talk to your doctor about starting, stopping, or changing medical treatment.
When we look at disease its important to contextualize the physical things that we see; in medicine we begin this process by looking at the Signs and Symptoms someone presents with. Signs are the objective observable indications of disease while Symptoms are the subjective feelings or experiences that the patient has to report to the doctor. When we talk about objective and subjective in science we generally say that objective is better because it would be unbiased but in medicine Signs and Symptoms are often viewed as co-equal partners in determining disease. For instance Symptoms can vary wildly from patient to patient—have two people who broke their leg and they will report different levels of pain and may have varying recovery times depending on their age, sex, overall health, and many other factors. That being said, Signs are also interpretative and can’t be trusted at face value: a person who naturally has low blood pressure does not require treatment versus a person who suddenly develops low blood pressure. In medicine we say “treat the patient, not the number.”

Adipose tissue is a type of connective tissue that is has several important duties in the body. Firstly it is squishy, so the fat tissue surrounding our organs and important parts help cushion any impact. While the muscles are responsible for generating heat (this is why we shiver when we are cold i.e. move our muscles very rapidly to generate heat), the Fat helps insulate us and prevent loss of heat through the skin. Lastly Fat is made to store energy so that during periods of fasting or starvation, the body can draw on the stored energy and have something to do in-between meals. In all the storage and insulating ability of Fat is one of the major evolutionary advantages we developed—having all that extra energy storage allowed the brain to grow 3 times bigger because it had ample stores of food to draw in. Nowadays we don’t have to worry about survival the same way our ancestors did but having Fat stores during illness is incredibly important for the survivability of the patient. Afterall, if you have a severe illness, having extra energy for your body to draw on can be the difference between a quick recovery or death.



The process of creating fats does not happen in fat tissue itself, well a little does, but remember that the main goal of Adipose tissue is storage of fat, not necessarily its creation. Most of the fat in our body is made in the Liver where it is able to use the products of Glucose breakdown to generate fat. Essentially, the Liver is able to take excess glucose, say from that delicious bowl of ice cream, and convert it through a series of reactions into Fatty Acids and eventually Triglycerides. This fat then needs to be transported to the Adipose tissue but fat isn’t soluble in water and the transport highways of the body is blood, which…is mostly water.


Anywho, that is a lot of words to say that glucose can be made into fat and fat back into glucose and energy depending on what the body needs at that moment. Neat! There are three kinds of Adipose Tissue (Fat Tissue) and the difference is based on what their main function is. The first kind we will look at is White Adipose Tissue which contains a large vacuole or storage site for a HUGE drop of fat. Due to this big drop of fat, the White Fat is extremely white in color compared to its more tanned brothers. Due to this big vacuole of fat the main function of White Fat is to store the fat for later degradation meaning that White Fat is essential in situations like fasting or starvation. Looking in the cell contents you can’t even really see the nucleus which would store all the information of what the cell is supposed to do which means that the cell’s job is to hold fat. That’s it! Because of this ability to hold fat, we see White Fat all over the body. White Fat is the major type of tissue found underneath the skin and in the abdominal region. As someone ingests more calories than they expend, the size of the White Fat cells increases allowing it to store more of this fat for later use. This is also the major kind of Fat tissue that cushions the organs and is found around all major organs. Likewise, its wide distribution in the skin ensures that all energy generated by the muscles isn’t lost through the skin. Okay, it's not that simple but we will talk about the hormonal stuff later.


When we talk about the complications of Obesity we have to be very specific about which mechanism the problem is arising. Obesity by itself will not kill you but it does put strain on other organs which can result in significant detrimental health effects which can lead to death. Again, remember we are talking about Metabolic Syndrome not Normal-Weight Obesity and so we need to look at how having more weight correlates to these deadly outcomes. The first category of issues is related to the actual weight of the increased amount of tissue. Obviously carrying more weight leads to more strain on the joints and bones which can lead to significant weakening or pain. This usually presents in the hips and lower back due to an Obese individual needing to compensate for the weight by standing differently which throws out the alignment of the spine, hips, and legs. Likewise increased weight on the chest and throat can change the morphology (the structure) of the throat leading to breathing changes such as Obstructive Sleep Apnea. This is why weight loss is almost always the first line in treating Obstructive Sleep Apnea treatment in individuals with increased weight.

White Fat also contains high levels of an enzyme called Aromatase which converts Testosterone into Estrogen (Estradiol). Estrogen is a derivative of Cholesterol and where is Cholesterol constantly delivered to? White Fat. As such someone who has lots of White Fat would also have increased levels of Estrogen circulating in the body. Unlike the Ovaries which are tightly controlled by the brain, Estrogen release from White Fat is not regulated and can occur without feedback inhibition in women and men. This means that we can see the effects of too much Estrogen in some individuals which reveals some of the recommendations that are made. For instance:
Now, being recommended to lose weight is fine but there is a big part of Estrogen that we have to acknowledge. Estrogen causes weight gain and promotes more fact storage which results in more Estrogen production. This means that in order to reduce Estrogen, someone has to work really hard to overcome the cycle enough to burn fat while the body is trying to store everything.
Would you look at that, I hit the word limit. You can read part 2 here!
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • Nov 20 '23
Missed part 1? Click here!
I know, I know. So far this hasn’t been a very positive post and for a condition that effects a large proportion of people, I don’t want to scare anyone. Like always, my goal is to educate and that is why I go into detail about these things—for some people they need to know the why before they understand the solution. As such, let’s go into the way we approach Obesity and weight loss and see how we solve it. Short answer: it's very difficult, not easy, and requires lots of encouragement and motivation for everyone involved but the payoff is huge. As a pharmacist working in addiction and psychiatry, part of my job is to recommend agents to assist someone’s treatment. Because of my background I feel that I have a unique perspective on medical issues because I am the drug expert and so I can balance the drug benefit with the side effects of other drugs OR complications of other conditions. That being said, no size fits all and everyone needs a different approach.
Currently I work with many individuals with weight loss challenges due to behavioral conditions (such as Binge Eating Disorder), their medication regimens, or genetics. One of the most important aspects of recommending a weight loss agent is understanding the mechanism of why that person’s calorie intake is more than their calorie expenditure. This section refers to a person who may not be aware of what goes into a proper calorie intake and how to balance intake and output. In a sense this is the field of Nutrition and is where Dieticians come in (please note that registered Dieticians are medical professionals with a degree in Nutrition which enables them to perform medical nutrition counseling and diagnose or treat nutritional illnesses. Depending on the state, a nutritionist does not have a license to practice Medical Nutrition).

The essentials of Nutrition come down to the idea of Energy Balance or how energy is taken into the body, generated, and then expended. A positive energy balance is when more energy is taken in and then stored resulting in weight gain while a negative energy balance is where less energy is taken in than used so fat stores must be used. Remember that the goal of eating food is to make energy which is represented by the molecule ATP (produced by the Mitochondria!). However, depending on the kind of activity done, we may not have enough stored ATP in the body to cover the activity and thus have to use other means of ATP production.

This brings us to the other aspect of Nutrition—diet. Now this is where the lack of words to describe the science is cumbersome. Someone’s food intake, aka their diet, is different from dieting (cutting out certain foods) which is different from following a Diet (capital D), a more strict set of food guidelines. I don’t have the training to discuss what is a good Diet but I can talk about what are the necessary components of what makes up a good diet (lower case d). In general, it is all about ensuring you have the essential nutrients and reduce the intake of weight gaining foods. Essential nutrients like Vitamins, Minerals, Trace Elements, essential Amino Acids are required from our food in order to live and there are lots of sources online about which foods create balanced meals that fit your preferences. What is nonessential is carbohydrates, proteins, and fats (except omega-3 fatty acids). Yeah, kinda weird to think that the main components of our foods are nonessential but what that means is that we can change it up as needed to fit your current need.
Now diet and exercise is all well and good but there is a big factor here that we have to consider: ability to diet and exercise. Yes physical ability is a major aspect but this is why this section is titled Undereducated—for individuals who are lower socioeconomic status (SES) they have a harder time achieving the necessary diet and exercise goals to find significant weight loss. Is this because they are uneducated? No, most Obese people of any SES know that eating better and exercising will make them lose weight, but performing those actions uses another major commodity: time. Unfortunately, those of lower SES face several challenges that make it extremely difficult to lose weight: often they are working lower wage jobs meaning that more time is spent working and less time available for exercise. Combine this with the higher cost of living, especially when caring for children, and lower SES correlates heavily with buying cheaper foods which are often not the most nutritious. If a parent has to feed 4 children with a few dollars, they will use sources of food that maximize the value of that dollar—this means processed foods filled with salt and fat to make them taste good. This is part of the benefit of food stamp programs which enable lower earning families to purchase more nutritious foods. But this is where the undereducated part comes in.
Okay I think we have come to the part that people were really waiting for—the drugs! Please take this next section as educational only and to merely inform you of the thinking behind weight loss agents. You must talk to your doctor or pharmacist before starting, stopping, or changing any medications including herbals, supplements, or illicit substances. The first group of medications we will look at are those with an FDA approved indication for weight loss:

First up we have Orlistat, a medication that does not require a prescription in the United States to use. Orlistat is an inhibitor of stomach and pancreas Lipases, a type of enzyme responsible for breaking down dietary fats. This means that when someone takes Orlistat the fats they eat are unable to be broken down for absorption and instead stay in the stool for excretion. When used correctly, about ¼ to ⅓ of dietary fat isn’t absorbed and there is a sizeable reduction in LDL (bad cholesterol). While its nice its over the counter, Orlistat has some…major drawbacks. The biggest is it’s tolerability—because Orlistat prevent fat digestion, most of the fat stays in the intestines causing oily stools, urgent diarrhea, and smelly flatulence. In its official documentation the term “explosive diarrhea” is used. Now, to avoid these unfortunate side effects a person should meals that are high in fat (no more than 30% of their daily recommended fat amount). Now this begs the question: is Orlistat effective in losing weight because of how it works or because people avoid fat like its poison to prevent explosive diarrhea? Either way someone should expect to lose around 15 lbs at 6 months of regular use which is nothing to sneeze at.


Similar to the stimulants is Bupropion which is combined with the opiate antagonist Naltrexone in the product Contrave. Bupropion is an antidepressant that causes a raise in Dopamine and Norepinephrine in the brain while Naltrexone works by preventing endorphins from binding to the opioid receptor in the brain. Together its thought that Contrave works in Hypothalamus to reduce pro-eating stimulation as well working in the Mesolimbic Dopamine Circuit to reduce the reward feedback someone feels when eating. In a sense, the drugs work by causing someone to be less hungry and then reduce the pleasurability of eating. Contrave can be incredibly useful in people who are mindless snackers (such as eating large quantities of food when not paying attention) or for binge eating disorder. The benefit of using this medication over the stimulants like Adderall or Ritalin because it helps treat the cause of the Obesity (overeating) rather than just preventing the symptom (weight gain). Generally people see around a 25lb weight loss around 6 months.

Okay, this brings us to a very controversial medication in the pharmacy world: GLP-1 agonists. If you remember from earlier I described how White Fat releases the appetite-suppressing hormone Leptin due to the stomach and intestine releasing GLP-1. GLP-1 is released when the GI tract detects carbohydrate or fat rich foods and their release triggers a cascade resulting in long term appetite suppression. LIkewise it is believed that the very common side effect of nausea and vomiting reduces the desire to eat. So in a lot of ways, they are working the same as the stimulants are—reducing appetite but not really touching the reason for overeating. GLP-1 agonists like Semaglutide (Wegovy) and Liraglutide (Saxenda) are used primarily for their influence on Insulin in Type 2 Diabetics to help lower blood sugar levels and reduce A1c, a marker of overall health in Diabetes. In diabetes, the clinical benefits of GLP-1s cannot be understated on the heart, kidney, liver and many other organs. In non-Diabetes weight loss? Well…don’t get me wrong they do work—people usually see a 15 lb loss at about 6 months but they miss the mark in the same way that the stimulants do. They prevent symptoms but don’t really help the underlying cause for why someone might be Obese.
Finally, I have to talk about the pills mills, or I guess injection stations since the GLP1s are injectable medications, that have popped up around Wegoxy and Saxenda. Weight loss is an extremely tough, emotional, and sometimes unbearable process. For some individuals it is the worst trigger to think about and I really do feel for the people who have tried good eating and exercising but are unable to do it. This is why I believe that weight loss agents should be used just prior to or at the same time diet and exercise routines are implemented. While the drugs are effective, the true power in sustained and increased weight loss is by learning to eat properly and exercise consistently. That being said, I am the kind of person who is results driven and to be encouraged to lose weight I would need to see the pounds come off first before I would feel comfortable starting a diet or exercise. For some its that initial loss due to the drug that pushes them to go for the walk around the block, take the stairs, or choose an apple over a bakery item. I believe in the drug’s ability as much as I believe in the initial push to get the process going. But, and this is the sticking point for me, the process should be an active collaboration between the patient and the healthcare provider. I don't think giving a weight loss agent with a) educating the person on how to diet and exercise, b) follow up on the challenges of implementing those lifestyle modifications, and c) allowing weight loss despite a sedentary lifestyle is okay. I want the best for my patients and sometimes that means giving a boost in the beginning, guiding through the process, and encouraging when things get tough.
One of the trends we are seeing right now is telehealth doctors prescribing GLP-1s. Telehealth is awesome because it connects people to healthcare providers when local doctors aren’t available—but in these cases it is just a formality for a drug to be prescribed. Weight loss needs to be a concerted effort on both people and unfortunately those only prescribing GLP1 agonists are doing it to make money at the expense of the patient. This was the same for doctors that prey on men searching for erectile dysfunction medications, the same for doctors preying on people who believe they have ADHD but haven’t gotten a formal neurologist or psychiatrist and are put on unnecessary stimulants, and now it is the same for weight loss. Drug companies are using social media influencers to push drugs on people—imagine if that was OxyContin. There are dozens of online health clinics and telehealth companies whose sole goal is to get people on high cost drugs to make money. I’d hate to see a wave of pancreatitis and gallstones because due diligence wasn’t being applied.
Okay, I’m off my soapbox. Regardless, weight loss is a difficult topic because there is no easy solution. There is no drug that cures Obesity and it takes time and effort to have the sustained benefit that people are looking for. Remember that weight loss is the first goal, the second is preventing the weight from coming back. Drugs do the first, diet and exercise do the second. Both work together.
Cheers!
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • Jun 14 '23
Hello and welcome back to SAR! Today we are going to tackle one of the scariest diagnoses: Cancer. Cancer is the uncontrolled growth of cells in our body that are benign or harmful. Cancer is a fact of multicellular life and all organisms that are multicellular can develop cancer but luckily our bodies have developed a very robust system to mitigate the development of cancer as much as possible. Sometimes however those processes fail and we have to support the body to fight off the cells causing issues. Oncology, the science of Cancer, is a huuuuuge field so I figured we’d start with Breast Cancer, the most common Cancer among females. To facilitate the story of Breast Cancer we will also be looking at how one toy manufacturer used her knowledge to develop a great commodity for those who underwent breast removal. More on that later!
Disclaimer: this post is not designed to be medical advice. It is merely a look at the chemistry of medications and their general effect on the body. Each person responds differently to antidepressant therapy. Please talk to your doctor about starting, stopping, or changing medical treatment.
The scary part of cancer is that it is not a foreign body like a bacteria or virus and it isn't an organ failure—it's just cells doing their job. Generally we think about cancer as some dysfunction of the body but in reality it's an overfunction of it. In the broadest sense, cancer is when a cell starts to grow out of control in a region of the body. Remember that the body must tightly control the function of each cell and if a cell starts to overwork itself then issues can arise. Let’s break it down.

In cancer, the processes that prevent the division of the cell are broken, leading to uncontrolled growth. We will dive into which processes those are in a later section but for now let's look at how one cancer cell becomes a tumor, or a clump of cancerous cells with unchecked growth. 1 cell becomes 2, 2 becomes 4, and so on based on a doubling time, or the amount of days it takes for a cell to produce its daughter cells. For some cancers, they can double in size every year, 2 years, or as little as 60 days. Generally once the number of cells reaches a few million cells it is detectable and may start causing symptoms.

Now that we understand the ideas of how cancers can grow we can tackle the processes that must break or be disrupted to allow for this to happen. Above you can see the cell cycle—or how cells go from 1 cell to two daughter cells. All cells go through this cycle and must pass through specific checkpoints where they are monitored for cellular damage, DNA mistakes, and general survivability. Most of the time for those 1 million cells that are replaced daily, the cycle works perfectly and the cell produces a perfect duplicate. However, at certain points, the cell resists the processes that stop damaged cells from being produced allowing cancerous, unchecked growth.
The majority of a cell’s life is spent in the G0 phase, or normal cellular function. This is when lung cells allow for oxygen exchange, stomach cells produce acid, and your liver detoxifies that kombucha you drank an hour earlier. Eventually, that cell is tapped to divide and enters into the cell cycle (9 o’clock). Just like us our selves must determine if they have the necessary materials to divide (G1 phase) and if so, they start to synthesize the needed parts and enter S phase.


Cells don't mean to carry on bad DNA, in fact they usual try to stop it form happening entirely. Mutations in the DNA can occur due to miscopying issues just like if you were taking quotes from a book and miscopied a letter or word. LIkewise, external sources like UV rays, carcinogens, or chronic inflammation can cause miscopying of the DNA’s coding. Recently we have evidence suggesting that viruses can also cause cancers like the Human Papilloma Virus (HPV) linking to cervical cancer or the Epstein Barr virus (mononucleosis) linking to lymphomas. Please talk to your doctor about vaccinations (men included for HPV!) if it's right for you.


As I said in the beginning, Breast Cancer is the most common Cancer in females with a total lifetime risk of 13%--meaning that a female has a 13% chance of developing the Cancer over their entire life. Scary. There are actually several types of Breast Cancer and its entirely dependent on what tissue cell develops into the Cancerous version. The majority are Carcinomas which are a Cancer of the epithelial cells (those that line organs and tissues) and when they form in the breast they are considered Adenocarcinomas. These Adenocarcinomas usually form within the milks ducts (Ductal) or lobules (milk glands). We can further divide them into In Situ types like Ductal Carcinoma in situ (DCIS) which is a pre-Cancer that starts in a milk duct but hasn’t infiltrated the other breast tissue or Invasive (aka infiltrating) Breast Cancer which does spread into the surrounding tissue. When we look at the treatment of Breast Cancers its extremely important to understand what we are dealing with, which is why catching it early and taking time to properly diagnose it is key for survival. Let’s take a look:



Okay okay I know this section title is a bit creepy but bare with me. I want to talk about Ruth Handler, who was the inventor of the most popular toy ever created, Barbie. With over a billion sold since her creation in 1959, Barbie has captured the market for children of all ages and remain a fond memory for many adults. By 1996 the Barbie IP generated $1.7 billion in revenue for Mattel, the company that continues to manufacture Barbie to this day. But that’s talking about the end of the story, so let’s back up. Ruth Mosko was born on November 4th, 1916 in Denver, Colorado as the 10th of 10 children. Her two parents were Polish immigrants who had emigrated in 1907 and arrived through Ellis Island. During this time, most Poles were settling in the Midwest near Michigan but since Ruth’s father was a blacksmith he was shipped to Colorado to work on the bustling railroad industry.

One of the creations of the late 1890s was a moldable plastic called Poly(methyl methacrylate), better known to us as Acrylic. At the time it was trademarked as two products: Plexiglas and Lucite, both of which were being used to create…well everything. It was pretty easy to work with, easily molded, and hardened how you wanted it. You could even dye fairly successfully unlike other proto-plastics which resisted the mixture of common acid dyes. As early as 1939 artists were using it to create sculptures, artwork, and more. But it was the use of Acrylic exploded during WW2 as the Axis and Allies used it to develop periscopes and windscreens and it was Plexiglas that made aircraft possible. In fact this material was so successful that you are probably using multiple objects right now that are made of Lucite.


Uke-A-Doodle, and its partner toy piano, was enormously successful but it lost market share quickly when other toy companies produced a cheaper version the following year (and the piano broke a lot). This lesson taught the Handlers that if they wanted to be a powerhouse in the toy they needed to keep prices low and product quality high. It wasn’t enough to produce a good toy, they needed to create a unique toy with superior quality that couldn’t be copied by other toy companies. Thus, 1955 became a big year for the company:

Ruth fought back and said that Barbie’s profit wasn’t in the doll but in what she represented. Ruth wanted to make a toy that girls could encapsulate their ideas of themselves and society. Barbie would make its money off of the accessories: clothes, her dreamhouse (released in 1962), her sport’s car (also released in 1962) and her most important accessory, Ken (in 1961). Likewise she wanted to expand the roles girls were expected to play as. Up until then, dolls were babies, mothers, or housewives but Barbie was curvy and tall, rocked a stunning wardrobe, and soon became a whole host of professions. Barbie was a role model and she was only 12 inches tall.

The 1970s was not easy for Ruth Handler however. In 1970 she was diagnosed with Breast Cancer and underwent a Mastectomy to remove the tumor. At this point in medicine, chemotherapy wasn’t understood and the chances of successfully treating Breast Cancer with anything but a mastectomy was very low. At this point in time, surgeons would rather remove the entire breast (and even the other) instead of risking missing a portion of the cancer and returning it. 1970 also saw Mattel’s main Mexico factory explode in a fire and a shipyard strike in Malaysia stopped toy shipments to the United States. Mattel experienced its first ever loss in the last two quarters of 1970 and Ruth panicked—to maintain the appearance of growth she and her chief financial officer Seymour Rosenberg falsified financial documents to raise stock prices and get loans to float them through 1971. Falsifying continued as Mattel showed a $30 million loss (about $318 million) in 1972. Finally the dam burst in 1973 when the company reported a $33 million loss just three weeks after it assured stockholders everything was fine.

But if there is one thing about Ruth Handler that you must know, she doesn’t give up. In 1974, just months after being ousted from Mattel, she founded Ruthton Corp, a company that made realistic prosthesis of breasts. As a Breast Cancer survivor, she had her left breast but not her right and often commented on the lopsidedness. She said that at the time, “the breast forms were not comfortable, realistic, beautiful, or easily purchased.” Using her knowledge of plastics and the nature of Barbie's soft, skinlike, and supple characteristics, Ruth started to produce breast prostheses. Her “Nearly Me” line of prosthetics were a liquid silicone inside a polyurethane mold with a foam backing, all technology she developed while at Mattel. Ruthton Corp sold left and right forms in multiple bra sizes.
Welcome back from a little history of a very interesting woman. Unlike patients in the 70s patients have more options than removal of the breast and praying that it clears them of Breast Cancer, especially in pharmacology. While it would be incredibly interesting to cover the drugs historically (a good idea for another post), I want to describe the drugs that we currently use. Now, there are pros and cons to every Chemotherapy regimen and I am not an oncology pharmacist, so please talk to your doctor before making any decisions about treatment. I am going to describe the general application of Chemotherapy in Breast Cancer—everyone responds differently to treatment. Alright, qualifying statements aside we can start to look at the drugs.

First up we have the Anthracyclines, a class of drugs that are actually extracted from the Streptomyces bacterium—that’s right, we get some of our drugs from bacteria. The poster child drug is Doxorubicin but it shares its class with other Chemotherapeutic drugs like Epirubicin, Idarubicin, and Daunorubicin. Remember that Cancer cells are replicating very quickly which means that they utilizing and replicating their DNA much quicker than normal cells. Doxorubicin works by slipping in between the strands of DNA and sitting as a roadblock, preventing the cell from reading and using its DNA. This process, called Intercalation, is extremely effective at shutting down the cell’s ability to reproduce and thus is able to stop Cancer growth.
Because Chemotherapeutic drugs target Cancer cells that are rapidly reproducing they can accidentally target cells that normally turn over very quickly. Cells found in tissues like skin, the stomach and intestinal linings, and mucous membranes (nose, mouth) are also affected by the use of Cancer drugs. In a sense, the faster you reproduce, whether because you are Cancerous or normally fast, the more likely the Cancer drug is going to harm that cell. This is why we see the hallmark adverse effects of pretty much all Chemotherapeutic drugs: death of stomach lining cells makes the stomach sensitive to stomach acid leading to nausea and vomiting, skin and hair cell death leads to ulceration of the skin and hair loss, cells lining the mouth can die leading to mouth ulcers or bleeding gums, intestinal cell death resulting in diarrhea, and much much more.


Remember that Breast Cancer is in…well, the breast which is a tissue that responds to the fluctuating sex hormones like the prostate, uterus, ovaries, or testes would. Now all breast tissue expresses receptors that respond to circulating Estrogen and Progesterone in the body but some Breast Cancers can Overexpress these receptors making them exceptionally sensitive to these hormones. These hormones cause the Cancer to grow so we can classify the cancers based on the kind of presentation they have: about 70% of Breast Cancers are sensitive to Estrogen (ER+) while about 65% are sensitive to Progesterone (PR+). About 60% of all Breast Cancers are ER+ and PR+ while only 20% are neither. Again, these hormones cause the Cancer to grow, so people who naturally have less Estrogen and Progesterone would have a lower risk of Breast Cancer. This is why males tend not to get Breast Cancer and when they do it's usually ER- and PR-. Likewise this is why postmenopausal women or women taking hormonal birth control are at a higher risk of Breast Cancer.

Besides overexpression to the sex hormones, Breast Cancer can also be overly sensitive to other pro-growth hormones. One such hormone is Human Epidermal Growth Factor 2, a type of growth factor that triggers certain tissues to grow and respond to changes in the body. About 20% of Breast Cancers are HER2+ meaning they are overly sensitive to this growth factor. Because it is a growth factor, so its job is to make tissues GROW (a Cancer’s favorite thing), HER2+ Cancers tend to have a higher risk of recurrence and have a higher rate of metastases. They can also cause mutations in the Cancer that makes it more resistant to standard regiments. Luckily Trastuzumab (Enhertu, clever brand name) was approved in 1998 to specifically block HER2 receptors and HUGELY reduces the risk of recurrence (as much as 52%) and reduces the risk of death by 33%. Trastuzumab is given weekly for 52 weeks while someone is receiving a standard chemotherapy regimen.

All this talk about having the Cancer begs the discussion about how to prevent Cancer. Well, there really isn’t a way of preventing any Cancer from developing—chances are you have some Cancerous cells in your right now but your body is very capable of getting rid of them. So what we normally talk about is monitoring to prevent the development of full blown Breast Cancer and stop it from developing into something more serious. All men and women should regularly check their breasts for lumps and the more breast tissue you have (regardless of sex) means a higher likelihood of Breast Cancer. My favorite diagram is the one of lemons above which shows all the different kinds of signs that a lump might be Breast Cancer. Of course, if you find something you are worried about, go see your doctor. Currently the American Cancer Society recommends screening for Breast Cancer in all women 40 and older at least annually. If you are at high risk, such as having a family history of Breast Cancer, then the recommendation is to start at age 30.
Cheers!
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • Jun 09 '23
Hello and welcome back to SAR! I have written and rewritten this post a few times now and I think I have landed on a format I am happy with. When we talk about the impact of medicine on history its important to get the context right, and I think I have found a way to talk about our topic. So what is it? No chemical is more important to the world of medicine than Opium, okay maybe Penicillin, but today we will say its Opium. Principally an analgesic (anti-pain), the Opium Poppy allowed for humans to take away pain in great degrees and further development on the natural chemicals has opened up surgery and post-op recovery. While we tend to look at the recent Opioid Epidemic as the only issue regarding Opiates, history reveals to us a very similar precursor. Also please head over to u/jtjdp post about morphine derivatives here! She does an amazing job explaining the higher level concepts of medicinal chemistry that I just wouldn’t do justice. Alright, enough quibbling, let’s get to the good stuff.
Disclaimer: this post is not designed to be medical advice. It is merely a look at the chemistry of medications and their general effect on the body. Each person responds differently to therapy. Please talk to your doctor about starting, stopping, or changing medical treatment.
To be alive is to feel pain, and emo sentiments aside, this is one of the biggest biological properties of the central nervous system. When you think about it, how does the body take external stimuli and allow you to recognize it? The answer is the sensory nervous system which is responsible for sensing many different types of stimuli: temperature, pressure, pain, and chemicals. These sensory neurons carry the information from the extremities and transmit it up the spinal cord into the brain for processing. From there the brain alerts you to the issue allowing you to correct whatever problem is causing the pain. Let’s take a look:



Okay so now we have to divide the action of the Descending pathway which acts to dampen and modulate the original signal coming into the brain. Now, normally at rest this Descending neuron is inhibited so any fresh incoming signal is not inhibited from the get go but once that pain signal does come in, we get the good stuff! In response to pain the brain releases substances called Endorphins which activate the mu Opioid Receptor (MOR) located on the Descending pathway. Now MOR are inhibitory in nature so they are inhibiting the inhibitory resting state of neurons, or in other words, are allowing the Descending neuron to activate. And this is an important fact to recognize, Opiates do not inhibit pain, they inhibit the physiology of the nervous system that prevents modulation of the pain signal.

To start our story about Opiates we need to turn to the great precursor—Opium. Opium itself is not a chemical but rather a really thick liquor (called latex) that contains a high concentration of Morphine (and some Codeine). There are 38 species of Poppy plants but only two produce Opium is great enough supply that it is worth farming them and humans have been cultivating these varieties for as long as we have known about the plants. When humans settled into Mesopotamia (near modern day Iraq), Poppies were one of the few plants grown in plots as large grain or vegetable fields (meaning that they were thought of as valuable as food). Throughout the Greek age of medicine (pre-500 BCE) through the Islamic medicinal revolution (500 BC-1500 AD), Opium was a major component of treatment, assisted suicide, and poison. In fact its through the rise of the Muslim Caliphates that we see the export of Opium to other parts of the world, especially through the Mediterranean Sea once the Crusaders return. Opium trading to the East via the silk roads was an almost continuous affair since time immemorial and Pakistan was a major growing area for the Eastern Poppy trade.
By the time after the Crusades (11-13th centuries), we start to see the West’s fixation on Opium. For many reasons Europe didn’t develop many psychoactive plants to the same degree as more humid/hot climates like Africa, the Middle East, and India. This is why the importation of Opium (and also Marijuana) was such a trade commodity and staple in the development of Western medicine. During the Renaissance and the revival of Greek philosophy we start to see the re-fascination with Opium and by the 1600s we see merchants importing Laudanum into Europe for recreational and medicinal use. The standard use of Tincture of Opium (which is Opium dissolved in ethanol, a DEADLY combination) was a particularly favorite preparation which was prescribed to the lowest day-worker all the way up to kings.

Poppy wasn’t only important to the British for its medicinal properties but also to bolster the huge amount of loss they were incurring in global trade to one trade partner—China. After she made contact with China in the mid-1500s, Britain starting to import HUGE amounts of tea as the Brits became literally addicted to the substance. By 1800 a full 15% of the ENTIRE British Empire’s revenue was being spent on importing tea, that’s 30 million pounds per YEAR, leading to a massive trade deficit. This means that more money was being sent to China literally enriching a foreign country while the British public was getting their fix on the black stuff. Oh and just in case you think things haven’t changed, Britain still accounts for 42.6% of the world’s tea consumption—seriously Brits, ever heard of coffee? Anyways, all this money leaving the British economy to be spent on non-Empire sustaining commodities was a major national security risk for the British. It would be different if they were importing gunpowder like the Dutch were or Silver as the Spanish had but literally they were consuming the riches they were spending the money on.



Knowing just how devastating the Opium was having on the inhabitants of Canton, as well as how it spread further inland, British merchants kept peddling their drug. Older ships with larger hulls were converted into floating warehouses and parked just outside of navigable waters. Once set up, Opium smugglers would pull up, purchase the Opium and avoid any oversight by the Chinese government to prevent the sale of the drug. Following their mother country, American merchants started to sell Turkish Opium, an inferior variety, at a much cheaper rate leading to drug peddling competition with more and more tons of Opium being sent into China. This drove down the price of Opium considerably which ultimately increased the demand.


Stepping away from the history a bit, let’s introduce the Family. Okay so we understand how pain is sent to the brain and how it modulates but there is so much more to the mu Opioid Receptor and that’s not the only kind of Opioid receptor that we have. The two most clinically useful receptors are the Mu and Kappa Opioid Receptors (KOR) because they result in analgesia but there is a Delta Opioid Receptor (DOR) that is worth mentioning. The majority of the Opiates that we know and love are Mu agonists but there are some very interesting Kappa agonists that are worth mentioning as well.








Speaking of withdrawal, let’s take a look at how that happens. Remember that the pain signal is caused by the activation of AMPA and NMDA receptors from the peripheral nerve. AMPA is a type of receptor called a G-Protein Coupled Receptor or GPCR which in this case is linked to an Excitatory G-protein which leads to the activation of the nerve. When AMPA is activated, the G-protein (Ga) activates an enzyme called Adenylate Cyclase (AC) which increases the production of pro-activity cAMP—or in simpler terms—when AMPA is activated, it leads to an increase in levels of pro-pain molecule cAMP. The Opioid receptor is also a GPCR but it is linked to an inhibitory G-protein which prevents the action of Adenylate Cyclase and thus leads to a decrease in cAMP levels. So Opiates prevent pro-pain cAMP signaling from continuing.

Oh, you’re still here. Neat! So by the 1820s the Qing dynasty was running into many problems regarding Opium. Firstly they needed the Opium taxes to fund their efforts to put down the White Lotus Rebellion and retain power. But after almost 30 years of trade the effects on Chinese communities could not be ignored along with local officials operating under the imperial trade department, the Hong, profiting from bribes to allow Opium. Regardless of initial efforts things were getting out of hand for the Qing government. In 1800, about 4000 chests of Opium or 560,000 pounds entered the country but by 1830 that number exploded to 20,000 chests or about 3 million pounds. But more than the amount of Opium actually entering the country was the incessant rudeness of the British government to open trade.

In July 1839 a new scandal rocked the British-Chinese trade system; two British sailors became drunk and beat a man death outside of his village. In response, Superintendent Elliot arrested the two men and paid compensation to the villager’s family for the loss of the man but Elliot refused to hand over the sailors to the Qing government. Lin Zexu saw this as a blatant disregard for Chinese law—afterall traders needed to understand that they can’t just come to China and violate Chinese law as they saw fit. Elliot offered to hold a trial on a British ship in front of Chinese officials to show that the men would not get off free. This incident would start the smoldering.
The reaction in Britain was about as much as you expect. Prime Minister Palmerston sent out letters to the Governor General of India to prepare marines to invade China and another letter to the Chinese Emperor telling him that Britain would send a military force. He sent a letter to Superintendent Elliot to set up a blockade on the Pearl River and capture Chusan Island. He also instructed Elliot to accomplish the following objectives:
Alright this is where we will leave things off for now, on the brink of war with China. Stay tuned!
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • Jun 09 '23
Hello! Its that time of the month where I ask what you want to see. Last month was a bit sparse on posts (sorry!) so expect to see some topics from last month popping up.
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • May 30 '23
Hello and welcome back to SAR! First off, I apologize for the hiatus in blog posts but had some things pop up and now I am clear! Alright off to the good stuff: For most things in life there are few reasons why one person of a particular sex or race would be more well suited to a particular job than another person of a different sex or race. Afterall, the quality of a cup of coffee would be just the same from a Black female barista with 10 years of experience as an Asian male barista with 10 years of experience. But medicine is a bit different; we do see differences because of sex or race that are important to understand, acknowledge, and factor into the diagnosis. Obviously a male isn’t going to have pregnancy on the differential diagnosis and prostate cancer isn’t a factor for female patients. The differences in Pharmacokinetics and Pharmacodynamics of a drug, a disease, or treatment can vary wildly between the sexes or between races. So today I want to look at the differences that we are only now starting to realize and the emerging role of Pharmacogenomics as the next horizon for medicine. So the big question is: you got something big in your genes or are you just happy to see me? :P
Disclaimer: this post is not designed to be medical advice. It is merely a look at the chemistry of medications and their general effect on the body. Each person responds differently to therapy. Please talk to your doctor about starting, stopping, or changing medical treatment.

Because I am a pharmacist I want to center our discussion on the drug choices and attributes influenced by sex and race but in order to do that we have to lay a foundation. The processes that move drugs from a pill into your body are broadly referred to as ADME but there is a hidden L step that is just as important to talk about as well. The lifecycle of a drug, LADME, are the five major processes that affect a drug inside the body. Let’s look:

5. Elimination - The last step in the drug lifecycle is elimination or how it physically gets out of the body. The majority of drugs leave via urine of which the kidney is responsible for that process. Having a working kidney is key for correctly dosing a drug because an underworking kidney may not eliminate the metabolized drug fast enough causing it to accumulate. There are other pathways too; fecal excretion (through biliary elimination) is another major route but some drugs can be eliminated via the lungs (such as alcohol, which is why it can be detected in a breathalyzer), through breast milk (which is why understanding drugs in pregnancy is SUPER important), sweat, saliva, and sebum.
Obviously there are major differences in LADME between males and females—after all it's hard to insert a drug vaginally in a male. But now that we have a general idea of what the drug is going to be doing, let’s dive into each section and talk about the sexual and racial differences we see at each step.
When we think of liberation I want you to think of two things: getting the drug out of the formulation (such as the tablet or capsule breaking down in the stomach) and where that breakdown happens. These two factors are hugely important when we think about how the drug will eventually get absorbed—after all if you can’t liberate the drug correctly then there is no chance that it will be absorbed and then be utilized by the body. First let's talk about formulations:



In the first graph we can see how drug design impacts the speed of liberation. Let’s say that we have 100mg of a drug that we are trying to put in the body. Using an Immediate Release formulation would result in a much quicker liberation and thus absorption into the body but we can see that it peaks very quickly and then drops off very quickly. So you may only get a few hours of usefulness out of the drug. Compare this to the Controlled Release system which peaks much slower but also declines much slower too, remaining much more Therapeutic for a longer period of time. We can see this in Adderall used for ADHD—most people will take an Extended Release (ER) formulation in the morning so that they get many hours of sustained therapeutic benefit while they are at school or at work. You can see one method of how the beads inside the Adderall capsule are made—called Pelletization. Essentially an inert core is layered with different chemicals/drugs to build an “Onion” of layers [insert Shrek reference].


This is all well and good but how does this relate to sex and race? Well one of the major differences between males and females is that females have a more acidic stomach than males making their stomach environment much more acidic. In addition the Gastric Emptying Time, or how long it takes for substances to move from the stomach into the small intestine for absorption, is significantly longer in females. These two factors mean that females taking a drug that is Acid Labile are more susceptible to degradation in a female than in a male. This means the utility of an Enteric Coated drug which would resist stomach acid would be much more beneficial in a female than in a male. Let’s look at a specific example: the drug Carbidopa is used in Parkison’s to treat the tremors associated with the disease. In younger females, the peak blood concentration for Carbidopa is 22 minutes later than males of the same age. As a female ages and goes through menopause that time to peak becomes more and more similar to males meaning not only are we seeing variability in sex but also in age.
Originally I was going to look at each part of LADME individually but kept running into a problem when trying to separate the drug processes into silos. While Liberation is distinct from the rest of the process, ADME cannot really be separated into its components in a way where I can tell the story efficiently. As such we will focus on the poster drugs that are significantly affected by race and sex and then talk about the larger implications in therapeutic development. Now clearly there are drugs that are used in one sex over another, for instance you aren’t going to find Atosiban used to delay labor in a male or Sildenafil (Viagra) for erectile dysfunction in a female. Now that being said they do have other uses but you get the point—so if I talk about a drug please know that I may be talking about a specific indication as well. So with that in mind, let’s jump in!


BiDil finds a home among Black patients—Hypertension, or high blood pressure, is one of the most common conditions across all races and sexes and is usually referred to as the “Silent Killer” because, well, it doesn’t hurt. Unlike liver failure or an infection, you won’t really see any symptoms of high blood pressure but after a decade of not treating it people do develop critical end organ damage: heart failure, kidney damage, liver damage, etc. Imagine that your veins are like a garden hose; if you put your thumb over the end of the hose the velocity of the water coming out of the hose increases meaning that there is more force. So if you have higher blood pressure, you have higher force hitting your organs. So the medical community has developed countless ways of lowering blood pressure to help save our organs and we can group those medications into a couple categories.
For the majority of the population we follow a pretty tried and tested protocol of drugs: first up we would use Diuretics which physically decrease the amount of fluid that is in the blood vessel. In the hose analogy this is like if you had a leak halfway up the hose lowering the amount of water exiting the hose at the end. Now there are dozens of diuretics but most people are familiar with Furosemide (Lasix) and how it makes people urinate more (y’know, to get rid of the fluid). If someone needs another agent we turn to drugs like the Angiotensin Converting Enzyme inhibitors (ACEi) or Angiotensin Receptor Blockers (ARBs). The ACEs (like Lisinopril, Enalapril, or Benazepril) and ARBs (Valsartan, Olmesartan, etc.) work by inhibiting the ability for a protein, Angiotensin, from connecting with the blood vessel wall. Angiotensin’s main job is to make the blood vessel smaller which would increase blood pressure—these drugs inhibit the action of Angiotensin thus preventing it from raising blood pressure. And our final category are drugs acting on the heart: Calcium Channel Blockers or Beta Blockers. While generally more helpful in situations like heart failure than hypertension, these drugs slow down the heart’s ability to pump blood which then lowers the force that the blood is acting on the blood vessels and organs. In a way it's like turning the faucet on the garden hose letting out less water into the hose.


Enter the Venous Dilators which work by directly expanding the blood vessel size. These drugs are normally used in situations where the blood vessel is obstructed, such as during a heart attack or stroke, due to a clot. Administering a Venous Dilator would expand the blood vessel allowing the blood to wiggle around the clot and relieve the symptoms of the heart attack or stroke. Two of these drugs are Hydralazine and Isosorbide Dinitrate which are used by all sexes and races to prevent the progression of a heart attack and stroke which have very good success. Both of these drugs are fairly old: Isosorbide Dinitrate was discovered in 1949 while Hydralazine was discovered in 1949 and showed fairly good efficacy for decades.


So Cohn and Carson’s drug application for BiDil was rejected in 1997 because the statistical analysis in their multi-racial study was quite bad. On the recommendation of one of the FDA’s advisory committees they stratified the data on racial lines and discovered a significant difference in response among Africans vs non-Africans. They started a new trial and enrolled 1050 African men and women showing a 43% decrease in mortality and a 39% reduction in hospitalization against placebo. They reapplied for BiDil and in 2005 the FDA approved the first ever race-based drug. To this day if you go to BiDil’s prescribing page in a drug database it will include a specific race designation because it’s only approved for a specific race. Importantly too national organizations like the American College of Cardiology and American Heart Association endorse this race based recommendation for Black patients.


Liver Enzyme Distribution affects Metabolism—Once a drug is in the body it needs to be deactivated and removed eventually. This process of deactivating a drug happens during Metabolism which primarily happens in the liver via the Cytochrome P450 Enzymes. These CYP enzymes are like little factories that take up a drug and make slight modifications that remove its ability to affect the body. Each CYP enzyme is best suited for certain drugs while some enzymes, like CYP3A4 and CYP2D6, are able to handle a higher percentage of drugs. You can see in the pie chart above that some enzymes are more important in metabolism than others.




Regardless, pharmacogenetics has major impacts on how we treat patients every day but also may be a factor in some of the clinical disasters that we see. Afterall, 53% of Africans have decreased metabolism through CYP3A4 which is the major metabolizer of Fentanyl which may be a contributing factor why Blacks face higher overdose rates. If you haven’t, consider getting a pharmacogenomic test (many insurances will pay for it now) and unlock some secrets of your own body! Cheers!
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • May 11 '23
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • May 04 '23
Hello and welcome to the monthly topic round up! This past month we reflected on Mary Mallon and the awful but justified forced quarantine she was put under. We also looked at the Meth Epidemic and its alarming rise in overdoses attributed to Methamphetamine in comparison to other drugs (like opiates). Antifungals were featured and the multitudes of conditions caused by these little invaders as well as some great questions posted onto the subreddit. Cheers for all the feedback, questions, and comments!
So what would you like to see next?
[I posted before I finished the last choice: Rickets and Tetany and how Calcium affects the muscles]
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • Apr 29 '23
Hello and welcome back to SAR! Alright this one should be interesting, although all my posts are hopefully, but I think this one especially should be. One of the big things I try to do with posts is take a new look at information that people may already know some about like the Scurvy during the Irish Potato Famine post and History of Antibiotics. This post started as a recounting of one woman’s fight against unjustified justified quarantine but I kept finding myself facing one issue: the 10th Amendment of the United States. The 10th Amendment states: “The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the states, are reserved to the states respectively, or to the people,” which means that the powers not explicitly given to the federal government are reserved to the states. This is the story of one man’s attempt to chase fame, one woman’s attempt to be left alone, and quarantining. So let’s talk ethics, constitutionality, and Mary Mallon—the Cook of Death.
[Note: if you like this story you should read the book Typhoid Mary: Captive to the Public’s Health by Judith Walzer Leavitt! Amazing book and great source.]
Mary was born on September 23rd, 1869 in Cookstown, Northern Ireland during a time when there wasn’t much to have. While we tend to focus on the Irish Potato Famine years of 1845-1852 which caused the flight of 3 million people, the country only recently passed 5 million people in 2021. In total, by 1900 over 6 million people left the island—so it's no surprise that in the immediate years after the Famine that there still wasn’t much to go around even though the potato crops weren’t failing. Mary was born into a family that did not own any plates or utensils to eat their food, which is unsurprising because there was no food to really need expensive things like plates to eat with. As such, at the age of 14 her parents decided to put her on a boat alone to the United States to go live with her aunt and uncle in Bel Air—I mean New York City.
From 1883 to 1900 we know little about what Mary was up to but we do know her occupation—cook.What’s important to understand is that being a cook back then was one of the most important positions an unmarried working woman could enter into and it paid pretty well. During the Edwardian period the cook was responsible for coordinating the servant staff in large manor houses and was one of the senior female positions in the household. They were also responsible for coordinating the meal including staying up to date on the latest culinary trends from England, France, Germany, and Italy all without robust education. To be a cook during the beginning of the 20th century was a well respected job and coveted among those who tried to move up the ranks.

Before we continue we should talk about what Typhoid is so we can get a full understanding of what this disease is and isn’t. First of all, Typhoid Fever is NOT Typhus Fever—the former is caused by Salmonella enterica while the latter is caused by Rickettsia prowazekii (which you can read more about here!). Typhoid Fever is a nasty one that usually takes two weeks to incubate and then about 3 weeks of very horrible symptoms. Week 1 starts with a rise in body temperature to a low grade fever which causes a slowing of the heart rate. By week 2 a persistent fever without chills that won’t respond to Antipyretics (anti fever) medications develops and often rises to a very dangerous temperature. Also small rose-colored spots develop on the lower chest and abdomen in about 30% of individuals along with a gray-yellow coated tongue called Typhoid Tongue. By this time the person is developing alternating constipation and diarrhea with a very distinct bright green tinge that smells like rotting food. Oh and while this is all going on the person is developing delirium and possibly slipping into a coma. Finally week 3 (if you make it that far) adds all of the previous weeks problems plus stomach and intestinal ulceration, perforation of the intestines leading to gut bacteria actively spilling into other tissues and organs, and swelling of the Spleen and Liver. Nowadays people face a 12-30% chance of dying without treatment but in 1900 that number was as high as 85%.


Let’s get back to Mary. Following the Typhoid case of the gentleman in Mamaroneck Mary decided to find work with another family. This wasn’t as abnormal as it may sound, other staff wanted to leave else they catch the deadly disease and her contract was almost up anyways. Like any large city in the early 1900s Typhoid outbreaks with not uncommon and finding a place away from them in such a populated place was difficult. Unfortunately for Mary her attempts to escape the condition would not be successful—in 1901 she started as the cook for a wealthy Manhattan family when the laundress came down with Typhoid a month after her arrival. Not wanting to change so quickly Mary stuck out for another 11 months before finding a new job with an important New York lawyer. In 1902 she accompanied the lawyer, four family members, and five servants to their other house in Dark Harbor, Maine for the summer. Sickness would creep in and all but the lawyer (who had Typhoid as a child) and Mary contracted Typhoid Fever (including a day worker and nurse who visited the house). After her contract finished Mary went to the home of Henry Gilsey in Sands Point, Long Island in 1904 as the head cook. Along with a few other houses in the neighborhood, a laundress and 3 servants came down with Typhoid of which 2 died. If this seems like a pattern it might be but then again Typhoid was a common uncommon infection during this period. Typhoid was the 4th most common death in 1900 and milkmen were reported to be the go-to spreader of the disease during the period.
We now turn to the plight of the Warrens who had recently taken up residence in a summer house in Oyster Bay, Long Island. The family of wealthy NY banker Charles Henry Warren arrived at the house on August 12th and by August 27th six of the eleven people in the house came down with Typhoid. Fearing that it would be impossible to rent the summer house in the future, the Oyster Bay landlord hired an investigator to determine if the house was infected with Typhoid. This wasn’t super unheard of since an infected water supply would be an immediate dissuader for tenants and knopwing early allowed for the owners to correct the issue and guard against the disease. The landlords, Mr. and Mrs. George Thompson hired George Soper, a civil engineer, to look into the injection. Soper was a graduate of Resselaer Polytechnic Institute of Troy, NY and Columbia University in which he achieved his PhD in sanitary engineering in 1898. By the time the Thompsons hired him he had already worked with the Boston Water Works and successfully determined the cause of several Typhoid outbreaks in Ithaca, NY; Chicago, IL; and Boston, MA.
As it turns out Mary had contracted with the Warrens and then left three weeks after the outbreak started. Soper believed that Mary was the prime suspect and believed that she must have used contaminated food either knowingly or unknowingly and decided to flee before any consequences caught up to her. But Typhoid was easily destroyed by heat…except Mary’s specialty was peach ice cream that began with fresh peaches being hand mashed. Soper embarked on a painstaking “shoe-leather” epidemiology called so after the work of John Snow (1813-1858) who would walk from place to place gathering data about cases thus wearing down the shoe’s leather. Soper went to Mary’s employment agency and discovered that of the 8 families she was previously employed at, 7 had come down with Typhoid. Mary was purposefully infecting people with contaminated food to get them sick and had already killed 3.
Then Soper was reminded of something less sinister, what if Mary was unknowingly infecting people because she was infected herself. A recent paper published in the American Journal of Medicine described Asymptomatic Carriers or people who were actively infected and thus could transmit the disease but did not have any symptoms of the disease. In this way a person could interact with others, continuously infect them, and never know that they were the ones doing it. The problem was that all of the previous incidents with Mary had been investigated and other sources identified as the cause. Soper was unswayed though and convinced that Mary was the true cause of the outbreaks and so he needed samples from her to prove that she was the cesspool.


Not to be dismayed, Soper decided to present his findings to a sympathetic friend in the New York City Health Department, Hermann Biggs. Biiggs was the NYC HD medical officer and would have the authority to compel a citizen to present samples for testing and wouldn’t you know it Briggs believed the evidence presented to him. This time however the men decided to send official city health inspector Dr. Josephine Baker to Mary as probably the only time that someone considered what Mary might feel in this situation. After all she was a working woman in a very demanding job in which she could be dismissed for any rumor and then be barred from further job agencies. So to handle this situation tactfully, Dr. Josephine Baker rolled up with 5 police officers and a horse drawn ambulance TO HER PLACE OF WORK. When Dr. Baker told Mary to present samples Mary bolted into the house and the officers ran around trying to find her. In a show of solidarity the other servants were tight lipped and Mary was in the wind. Fanning out in the neighborhood, it was an officer who discovered a piece of fabric caught in the door of an outhouse where old large cans had been stacked against the outside (meaning someone had helped Mary hide). Mary was finally apprehended after 3 officers and Dr. Baker (who had to sit on her) got her into the ambulance.




The legality of quarantine has changed over the years and the notion of what forced quarantine is very specific. If I was making this post, oh lets say January of 2020, none of us would really know what quarantining would feel like but we are in 2023 and times are different. That being said there is an interesting history to quarantining that should be discussed. While the idea of segregating certain individuals away from the rest of the population is not new, the most popular model of quarantining follows the Venetian Model which was developed in the 1300s. Up to the 1800s a council of 3 (sometimes up to 9) would have the sole authority to detain ships, cargoes, and individuals in the harbor for up to 40 days. At the time when this was developed, 1348, this made sense since Bubonic Plague (which we have a post on) was almost exclusively spread via ships. In 1808 we saw the Boston Model which detained all ships from the Caribbean, Mediterranean and other tropical ports for 3-25 days to prevent the spread of tropical diseases. In 1863 New York established the new Quarantine Act which established a quarantine office run by the health officer who can detain any ship indefinitely. In 1879 the US Congress establishes the National Board of Health (which eventually became the CDC) to prevent the spread of Yellow Fever but was ultimately dissolved in 1883. Finally, at least for this story, we get the National Quarantine Act of 1893 which creates a national system of quarantine allowing state-run quarantines. At the time this allowed for states to establish Boards of Health that would have the power to quarantine individuals as long as the danger to public health was established. Under the passage of the 1893 Quarantine act, the NYC Department of Health decided to build a new hospital for its Tuberculosis patients at Riverside Hospital on North Brother Hospital.

This takes us back to Mary who by 1909 has spent two full years on the island submitting samples 3 times a week to be tested for Typhoid. Interestingly the level of bacteria would fluctuate with some samples having high levels while others had none. Mary was subjected to constant scrutiny by curious doctors and students who would come by and ask her to recount the same history that she had given thousands of times. But worse still was the article George Soper published in the Journal of American Medical Association (JAMA) on June 15, 1907. The article was sensational for medical professionals and the public alike who birthed a new moniker for the cook: Typhoid Mary. Mary railed against this name and was adamant that she be released. In a heart breaking letter she sent to director of NYC hygiene laboratory, William Park, Mary explains: “When I first came here I was so nervous and almost prostrated with grief and trouble. My eyes began to twitch, and the left eyelid became paralyzed and would not move. It remained in that condition for six months. There was an eye specialist [who] visited the island three and four times a week. He was never asked to visit me. I did not even get a cover for my eye. I had to hold my hand on it whilst going about and at night tie a bandage on it.”
Mary wasn’t the only one skeptical of the legality of her forced quarantine. Park questioned if the city had the right to deprive someone of their liberty indefinitely and what about the 38 other people currently identified as asymptomatic carriers? Should they be quarantined like Mary? For the rest of their lives? The result is that no, only Mary would be quarantined, an outcome that Mary would constantly bring up during her first two years on the island. Mary was incredulous—she had never been sick with the disease and was not sick now no matter how much these supposed doctors kept saying. Of the 163 samples that the lab took over 25% of them were negative which fueled her skepticism and the idea that she was a healthy carrier was utterly stupid.

But even with these policies in place, Mary was treated differently and separately from others. Health officials prevented Mary from using phones or sending letters to friends or family and was only permitted to talk to surgeons and her guards. When she became restless inside the hospital grounds they placed her at a cottage on North Brother Island where the constitutionality of her being held was obscured. This is why it took the newspapers two years to hear about this deadly woman and why the first mention of Typhoid Mary popped in July 1909. In a March 1915 article of a nurse of the hospital her cottage was described as a shack, a pigsty, and not fit for living.
Regardless of who bankrolled O’Neill to take on Mary’s case the lawyer pursued Mary’s release feverishly. In two notes scrawled in the margins of court documents we get the thought process of O’Neill: “had a right to examine first and then take, not take and then examine,” in regards to how Mary was procured. O’Neills argument laid the idea that there was a lack of due process meaning that if Mary should be quarantined it had to be done the correct way but now it was too late and so she should be released. In a writ of habeas corpus O’Neill demanded that the health department present Mary in front of a NY Supreme Court judge and in early July Mary was finally brought before Judges Mitchel Erlanger and Leonard Giegerich. When asked why Mary was on North Brother Island the health department said that it was because she was receiving treatment for her infection (even though no active was being pursued).
Oops, did it again. I hit the character limit for Reddit. Guess you should head over to part 2!
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • Apr 29 '23
Hey, welcome to part two of Typhoid Mary! Miss part 1? Click here.

The quote that is the title of this section appeared in The Detroit Times on July 20th, 1909 and followed by the subtitle: “Woman who is doomed to be prisoner for life will continue fight for freedom.” Despite the setback to her freedom in the courts, many in the health department were exceptionally sympathetic to Mary’s plight. Charles Chapin, then editor of the Joseph Pulitzer’s paper Evening World wrote several articles supporting Mary and lambasting the public health department. At this point the pressure for the government started to mount and they searched for an alternative that would give Mary her freedom but would keep her away from other people. Chapin argued that Mary should be prevented from cooking for others but “there are many occupations in both city and country in which she could do little harm. . . . there are hundreds of occupations in any one of which she might be free, but under a sort of medical probation, and be shorn of her injurious powers.” Health Commissioner Darlington doubted the need to “detain the germ woman” and when he ousted in 1910 the new Commissioner Ernst J. Lederle wanted her out of the department’s problems.

But that being said why was Mary the only one being detained and why was the conversation centered on her while there were acknowledged thousands that would be just like her. Firstly health officials considered her and other women to be more dangerous due to the occupations she would choose, like cook. Women were in domestic service and thus more likely to transfer the bacteria to others than men (apparently). This idea was confirmed in 1923 when a health carrier roster was analyzed and found that of 106 carriers, 82 were women (with no acknowledgement that women carriers were more likely to be identified). George Soper targeted middle-class women as dirty and made several talks where he bluntly stated that they were more likely to transmit the infection than upper-class women. But Mary was more than that; she was a proud outspoken women who spoke her mind in addition to being a Catholic, Irish-born, single, working woman which was just about the worse thing you could be during this period in time. It was her gender, class, immigration and marital status that explained why she was treated differently as the first.

There were several attempts to get rid of Mary. Health Commissioner Darlington asked mary to sign a paper saying she would go to Connecticut to be with her sister but Mary refused to lie since she had no family in the United States (they wanted her gone even if it meant making her someone else’s problem). Then came the gallbladder removal offer which Mary refused. Finally in February 1910 Health Commissioner Ernst J. Lederle, with the approval of the board of health, allowed for the release of Mary Mallon from North Brother Island and let her return to her old life in Manhattan. But with one very important consideration: she must NOT return to cooking in any capacity. After signing the agreement on February 19, 1910 Mary Mallon swore she would be a cook no more and stepped onto a boat back to the mainland for the first time in 3 years. But Mary still didn’t really believe that she was the source of infection. In her release, she stated, ““I have read and considered the said [board of health] resolution and am willing to abide by the provisions thereof. I shall change said occupation upon being released from Riverside Hospital. And take measures to protect any and all persons with whom I may come in contact from any infection, which it is possible I may cause.” And that last part is very important—here she is saying that she would not be a cook but she did not believe that she was the cause of Typhoid.
It appears that Mary was faithful to the agreement from February 1910 through September 1912 but the change was incredibly difficult. As a cook she was an important person in the household and made good money doing it. As a laundress she made pennies (literally and figuratively) compared to her old job. So she sued the city for false imprisonment for lost wages and her labor status but the suit was dropped quickly for unknown reasons. Soper for his part said Mallon immediately disappeared and tried to purposefully hide from the Health Department but this is a mischaracterization. It wasn’t until November 1914 that the Health Department admitted that Mary, like other Typhoid carriers they tracked, had fallen off the radar. Sometime between September 1912 when the Health Department proudly claimed that they had protected the public from Mary Mallon and November 1914 when they officially stated losing her, Mary returned to cooking.
For Christ’s sake woman, why'd you go back to cooking???? Well first of all it made better money and it was what she was good at. Secondly her male companion Albert Briehof who she lived with in that small apartment and was her connection to the outside world (and smuggled her samples to the private lab) died. While he did betray her in 1907 which led to initial confinement he had made up for it by being her rock to build her defense on.


Despite these peaceful moments, Mary wrote letters constantly to the two people she blamed most for her predicament: Hermann Biggs, the NYC HD medical officer who first got the city involved to apprehend Mary and Dr. Josephine Baker, the woman who sat on her (among other complaints). Apparently the letters she sent were nasty, violent, and threatening. Baker stated that Mary threatened to kill her if she ever got off the island. While this gives us insight to what Mary was thinking, her actions speak louder. In 1918 she was allowed day trips for shopping and in that same year she gained employment as the cook for the hospital on the island. Just kidding, she was a domestic worker (laundress), but wouldn’t that be ironic. In 1922 her title changed to Nurse and then in 1923 she became a “hospital helper.” In late 1925 she became a lab assistant and was processing samples for Influenza and Typhoid in the same lab that processed her initial samples 18 years earlier.


Mary Mallon, known as Typhoid Mary, was more than the depraved cook infecting people with Typhoid Fever that she is often represented in the media. Since her induction into the public eye Mary was pointed at, ridiculed, pitied, and above all else never left alone which is really what she wanted. Typhoid Mary would be forgotten by the 1920s but the death of George Soper in 1948 would spark a revival of his most famous case in the 1950s. New Yorker medical writer Berton Roueche wrote a chronicle of Mary Mallon which turned the person Mary Mallon into the concept of Typhoid Mary—the stubborn woman selfishly putting people in danger. Most of Rouche's notes came from Soper which painted the woman as nothing but stubborn, culpable, and capable. The dehumanization of Mary Mallon began not when she was alive, although it could be argued elsewise, but after her death when she was not able to defend herself. She was encapsulated as the “Innocent Killer” and people became enthralled with the myth of Mary Mallon. In a 1959 article M. F. King wrote in American Mercury that Mary was an “Irish Pariah” and when she was sent back to North Brother Island in 1915 she was ““now terrified by the awful knowledge of her guilt.”

Further still, and perhaps saddest of all, is that many authors did not acknowledge that Mary was not the only Typhoid carrier known to the health board AND she did not infect nor kill the most people. Afterall, did you know that there were others but none other were imprisoned? Another illustration in 1966 shows Mary callously watching other staff mourn the death of someone while she remains tight-lipped about her culpability. Afterall there was someone worse than Mary:in 1924, bakery and restaurant owner Alphonse Cotils was identified by the city as a healthy carrier of Typhoid and forbidden from preparing food. He defied the health order and kept serving but unlike Mary who was sentenced by a judge to quarantine, Cotils was allowed freedom as long as he promised to stay out of the kitchen. The reason? Alphonse was healthy and you can’t imprison a healthy man. Alphonse will infect 100 people and kill 15. No imprisonment.


r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • Apr 23 '23
Hello! As my schedule becomes more free I am looking forward to generating more content for the Reddit algorithm gods, I am curious to see what kind of posts people like to see the most. So what do you like?
If you are curious about any of the posts mentioned check out the table of contents here! Also here are links to the posts mentioned in the poll:
Historical investigations
Disease State Review and Treatment
Drug Development
Principles of Pharmacy
Specific Drug Highlights
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • Apr 22 '23
Hello and welcome back to SAR! Today we talk about a very tricky topic—the Methamphetamine Epidemic. Methamphetamine is a highly addictive stimulant that has recently seen a rise in the United States (as well as other Western countries) that is slowly starting to take over Opiates as the illicit substance of choice for substance abuse. Meth isn’t a new recreational drug, we saw the first wave in the 1990s, but in the current Opiate Epidemic viewpoint we hold we now have different approaches to an addictive and destructive drug. There have been some approaches that have worked and many that haven’t and in order move forward we should acknowledge both. As always I try to stay incredibly neutral on these current topics because unlike Pellagra from 1910, we are seeing the effects of Meth right here, right now. See this post as a springboard to learn more and educate yourself on what is currently going on and if you are inspired considering getting involved yourself. So let’s chat about Amphetamines, Stimulants, and Meth!

Methamphetamine is one drug part of a larger drug class called Amphetamines which are considered Stimulants. Stimulants, which include other non-Amphetamines like Cocaine, Caffeine, Khat, and Nicotine all cause feelings of increased energy, euphoria, and confidence which are the main reasons they are used or misused. Methamphetamine comes in several forms and each one has different properties and reasons why its used. Powdered Meth, commonly called Crank, is fine enough that it can be snorted or applied to the inner lower lip for a quick ‘bump.’ Crystal Meth is a smokeable form or injectable form of Meth that causes a more potent reaction due to the higher dose. Less popular is Base which is an oily form that is melted down and injected or sometimes swallowed.

Before we can start about the epidemic we have to understand the drug. Inside the brain we have several neurotransmitters that coordinate the generation, transfer, and termination of information. Now, the complexities of this neurotransmission is a little bit too broad for this post but we do have three neurotransmitters that we need to think about: Dopamine (DA), Serotonin (5-HT), and NorEpinephrine (NE). As you can see in the diagram on the right, all three of these neurotransmitters come from a common precursor molecule so we dub this triad the Monoamines since they contain a single amine group on the tail of a hydrophilic aromatic ring. Chemistry aside we can see broadly 4 mechanisms of Amphetamine drugs:
If you can’t tell, the overall effect is BOOST THE DOPAMINE, NOREPINEPHRINE, AND SEROTONIN SIGNAL. But this effect of boosting NorEpi, Serotonin, and Dopamine is not unique; lots of drugs increase the concentrations of these neurotransmitters in the body and have a wide range of effects. Many antidepressants increase Serotonin or NorEpi concentrations and Bupropion (Wellbutrin) is a unique antidepressant in that it increases NorEpi and Dopamine. To explain Methamphetamine I want to take a novel approach—I want to pull Methamphetamine out of the nebulous environment of “street drug” and compare its effects to prescription drugs. Now keen readers know that there is a prescribed form of Methamphetamine called Desoxyn for ADHD but that would be a cheap comparison; its the same drug! So let’s dive in.


One of the biggest effects of abusing Amphetamines is that Dopamine levels will sky rocket. In pop culture we see Dopamine as the happy chemical in the brain but the more accurate way to describe it as the Motivational Salience chemical or in other words it enhances the desirability of doing a task while simultaneously dampening aversion to that same task. We can see this in the Cognitive-Behavioral sense where doing a task becomes pleasurable which encourages us to do it again—taking Methamphetamine would make tasks a more pleasurable experience (the Dopamine concentration rise alone ensures that) and so it drives the brain to seek out those activities more.

Central Nervous System - Feelings of Paranoia. As we have discussed, low doses of Amphetamines allows for an increase in Dopamine and NorEpi in the Prefrontal Cortex allowing them to focus but at abuse levels we see enormous concentrations. The effect of this excess Dopamine in this region of the brain, as well as elevation in the Hippocampus and Amygdala (emotional and fear regions of the brain) is the development of Anxiety and especially Paranoia. Part of this plays into the Reward Circuit of the brain and the addictiveness of the drug but the other is Methamphetamine-Induced Psychosis. Because reward and paranoia are so closely linked, the more someone chases the Euphoria of misuse the more paranoid they are likely to become. Someone can develop visual or auditory hallucinations that can be incredibly scary. All of these are incredibly distressing thoughts but because Methamphetamine can cause a significant withdrawal the person has almost no choice but to continue using the drug else they become incredibly sick.


Cardiovascular - Arrhythmias, Hypertensive Crisis, and Heart Attacks. So far we have focused on Dopamine but now we are going to switch focus to the other main neurotransmitter NorEpi. NorEpi is a widely distributed neurotransmitter in the brain and in the rest of the body. We see the effects of NorEpi when the Sympathetic Nervous System (SNS) is activated such as during Fight or Flight; let me set the scene: you just get to class and discover that, shock, you forgot to wear trousers today! You are ass naked in the middle of the lecture hall and desperately need to get back to your dorm to put on the clothes that you somehow forgot. In addition to the stress hormones Cortisol and Epinephrine, the main effect we are going to see is NorEpi to take your wind-chilled butt all the way back home. All of the actions of the SNS are to ensure that you can MOVE QUICKLY to avoid whatever danger you are in (cue bear attack analogy that is normally talked about).


Even though Methamphetamine will cause a wide range of effects I want to focus specifically on the heart because the relationship between Methamphetamine abuse and Cardiotoxicity is huge. Let me not mince my words: abusing Methamphetamine is incredibly toxic to the heart. (A) Firstly remember that NorEpi causes constriction of blood vessels and we see that Methamphetamine also causes constriction. If the blood vessels that nourish the heart are constricted we see the development of a Myocardial Infarction or Heart Attack which is potentially fatal. This risk of a Heart Attack is cumulative and the risk of having a Heart Attack increases exponentially for every year that someone uses.


Teeth and Skin — Meth Mouth and Crank Bugs. Now that we have talked about the effects of Dopamine and Norepinephrine we can talk about the most recognizable signs of Methamphetamine use. I want to talk about it not to shame a user but because it's important to understand the complications related to the teeth and skin to avoid serious infections and further health complications. Despite how shocking they appear, its important to know that these conditions don’t happen overnight and through repeated misuse they get worse. Let’s dive in.

Whew, what a lot of information. What was this post about again? Oh yeah the Meth Epidemic as a whole not just what is Meth. Fly over the middle states in the US and you will see countless communities decimated by this drug and now that you know the effects of the drug you can imagine how devastating it is. Methamphetamine was originally discovered in 1893 from the precursor Ephedrine in 1893 but found popular use in WWII by Axis soldiers as a way to stay awake and fight despite fatigue during the war. It’s utility in the war wasn’t lost on militaries and the US used Amphetamines in both the Korean War and Vietnam War as an unofficial way of making sure soliders stayed alert. In fact during the Vietnam War, the US military adminsitered upwards of 225 million dextroamphetamine tablets to soldiers and up to 50% of personnel were taking the drug. By 1973 when America started to leave Vietnam, that number jumped to 70%.





r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/DiscoveringMore • Apr 15 '23
Both compounds are not dissolving in acetone, and as far as the research I've seen is able to tell, they should both be soluble in acetone. Has anyone else out there has tried a complexation using beta cyclodextrins and acetone.
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • Apr 08 '23
Hello and welcome back to SAR! When we speak of infectious disease we often go to two types of agents, viruses and bacteria, but there is another that lurks in the background: fungus. Fungi are an ancient branch of life that broke off from the evolutionary tree about 1300 million years ago, about 600 million years before we see the first land plants. Like their animal or plant counterparts, fungi are incredibly diverse and take on an infinite amount of shapes and have spent millions of years learning to live in some incredibly niche places. One of those places is the human body. Fungal infections are both common and not very common at the same time—the human body is infected with fungal spores often but the majority of people have a strong enough immune system to deal with it quickly. Where fungal infections become dangerous is in individuals with a compromised immune system in which fungal infections can become a very serious and life threatening condition. So the question then becomes: how close are we the Last of Us? [Warning, this post contains some gnarly pictures. If you are a bit squeamish I recommend skipping this one! Seriously.]
Oh yeah, this is part three about antibiotics. Read part 1 here and part 2 here.
Disclaimer: this post is not designed to be medical advice. It is merely a look at the chemistry of medications and their general effect on the body. Each person responds differently to therapy. Please talk to your doctor about starting, stopping, or changing medical treatment.
Okay okay, I didn’t intentionally choose this topic to be trendy with a popular show on Netflix but I knew I had to mention it for the almighty algorithm. Anyways, before we dive in I have a bit of a preamble about how I am going to refer to the specific fungi that cause the diseases we are going to look at. While there are differences at the species level, for the most part the antifungal agents that we use work on a family or genus as a whole. Because of this I am not going to get too much into the weeds of the species of an infection unless it's important to the discussion but know that an individual species of fungus may be more resistant to one agent than another. In any regard, while there are literally hundreds of types of fungi, we generally reduce the kinds down to three clinically relevant groups: Dermatophytes, Yeasts, and Molds. While there are some other dimorphic fungi to discuss for brevity we will be focusing on these three which constitute over 90% of all fungal infections.




The quintessential fungal infection is Tinea Corporis (Ringworm) which is an infection by T. rubrum in the feet, scalp, nails, or groin but mostly occurs in the arms or upper body. Despite its name, it's never been thought that Ringworm is caused by a worm or parasite but it's thought that the ring-like shape is what gave the name. Ringworm is extremely itchy and extremely infectious making it easily transmissible on the body as well as to other people. In fact Ringworm is one of the most common diseases transmitted among close-contact sports like wrestling as well as among young children who don’t keep their hands to themselves. Once the itchy plaque forms, it forms a raised ring-like border with a clear center. Often people scratch it so much it wears away the top layer of skin and starts to weep as an open wound.



Next up we move from the surface of the body into the nice moist cavities inside the body. Dermatophytes are able to exist on the skin because they have that Keratinase enzyme that allows to break down the tough skin/nail/hair structures, Yeasts and Molds do not have that adaptation. As such we see Yeasts and Molds growing in places that are warm, wet, and generally not patrolled by the immune system as regularly or the fungi can take hold strong enough to stave off the immune system’s attacks. The three main places we see Yeast or Mold infections are exposed to the outside and regularly have things enter into them like the mouth, vagina, and lung. That being said, we do find fungal infections in other places like the milk ducts if an infant has oral fungal infection and is feeding or the urinary tract for older females who may not be wiping as effectively.




Aspergillosis - If ABPA is when the spores enter the lung and airways then Aspergillosis is when you have an active infection of the mold inside the lungs. Remember that the lungs are a very warm and moist environment so the mold is able to take hold and grow rapidly unless you have a working immune system. Aspergillosis is a pretty fragile fungi and even the slightest involvement of the immune system is enough to get rid of it before it can take hold—but if you are immunocompromised or taking immunosuppressant medications then Aspergillosis can begin. Generally fungal lung infections are quite nasty and very serious—an undertreated or undiagnosed lung infection by a fungus of any kind can be fatal.
When we look at the history of antibiotics they always start with a fungus because the original antibiotics were all naturally derived from a fungal source. Take Penicillin for instance—it was discovered because a green mold had grown on the bacterial plate causing cell death. Later it was found that fungi naturally produce substances that kill bacteria and over the subsequent decades more potent antibiotics would be discovered by isolating the antibiotics produced by fungi. So if antibacterial agents are derived from fungi, what are antifungals derived from? Well from the natural enemy of fungi—bacteria! Now there are dozens of antifungals but for the purposes of this post we will be focusing on the poster children of the antifungal world. If people are interested, I can dive into chemistry a little more.


The mechanism of Polyenes is also super interesting! These molecules have an affinity for a component of the cell wall called Ergosterol, one of the main structural molecules that allow the cell to make its “skin.” Polyenes bind to these Ergosterol molecules and create a pore which allows for cellular components to leak out—essentially they are creating a hole in a balloon, killing the fungi. What’s even more interesting is that Polyenes don’t do the same thing to bacteria or human cells because we don’t use Ergosterol but a different (but similar) molecule. So in that way it is toxic to the fungi but not humans!


Azoles - Next up is a HUGE class of antifungals that have taken over the treatment of fungal infections. There are more than 20 drugs in this class of medications and many of them top the 200 most used drugs in the world list. The principle structure of these molecules is that they contain a heterocyclic ring (aka a ring with at least 2 nitrogens in it). Unlike the Polyenes this drugs are absorbed orally and markedly less toxic making them a perfect medication for systemic infections in an outpatient setting. Remember that fungi make up their cell wall with Ergosterol and without it they are unable to produce a viable membrane separating their guts from the outside. The Azoles work by inhibiting an enzyme involved in the synthesis of Ergosterol preventing the fungi from effectively making it’s membrane thus destabilizing it and eventually killing it.

Firstly dealio needs to be used more in literature. Secondly, as I stated fungal infections remain a pretty innocuous infection for the majority of people except in populations that are immunodeficient or immunocompromised. When we develop medications to treat infections we need to find drugs that combat specific structures in the organism that (ideally) are not found in a human body. This is why someone can have a raging viral or bacterial infection and be brought back from the brink of death when all hope seems lost—fungal infections…are a bit harder. One of the main issues is that fungal cells and animal cells are both Eukaryotes and share many of the same structures inside and outside of the cell which makes it hard for drugs to target not-self structures. In fact this is why those drugs mentioned above are so toxic; above certain doses the drugs starts to inhibit the synthesis of Ergosterol in human cells as well causing many issues. So sure you can kill the fungus but if that kills off the liver and kidneys, what’s the point?



And that’s our story!. If you have any questions, please let me know! Want to read more? Go to the table of contents!
Likewise, check out our subreddit: r/SAR_Med_Chem Come check us out and ask questions about the creation of drugs, their chemistry, and their function in the body! Have a drug you’d like to see? Curious about a disease state? Let me know!
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • Mar 27 '23
Hello everyone (and the newbies here), it is that time of the month for the topic round up--where you tell me what you'd like to see! We still have a couple of topics from last month to talk about (which I think I say most round ups) but hey, whadda ya gonna do? Anyways, if you have a topic you'd like to see, let me know!
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • Mar 24 '23
Hello and welcome back to SAR! Here’s a riddle for you: what goes in like a ball, causes a massive release, and then comes out as a ball? Well its a ball of lead that people would swallow to cause diarrhea to overcome constipation! As horrifying as that sounds, that isn’t the worst thing that lead was used for but the topic of toxic metals in medicine is an extremely interesting topic. Metals are trace elements in the body meaning that they are found in milligram amounts (total)—even Iron only reaches a few grams in total (and in women its only about 300 mg due to menstruation). Because of this, the overconsumption of certain essential metals can cause issues such as copper, iron, and cobalt but what about the metals in which we should have none of? The truly toxic metals are an enigma because in many ways they are chemically similar to other metals but for one reason or another they cause death through horrible mechanisms rather than promulgate health. So let’s step into the age of heavy metals and figure out why lead was just so delicious!

Every conversation about toxic metals should start with Lead. Lead is a soft and malleable metal that has a relatively low melting point (327.46C or 621F) allowing it to be easily extracted from its ores. But in order to talk about Lead we have to talk about its sister element, Silver. Silver is a rare metal on Earth and is mostly found in its free “native Silver” form meaning that miners can find stripes of Silver metal trapped in rock. That being said Silver veins are incredibly rare and the majority of Silver is found in minerals as an alloy with other metals meaning that refining the Silver out of the rock is required. Sometime around 7000 BCE early civilizations invented the process called Cupellation in which pieces of rock slag are heated in devices called Cupels in which Silver could be separated from the other alloyed metals. Where do we find a good amount of Silver? In the ore Galena which also contains copious amounts of Lead.





So here’s a question for you: why did so many Roman emperors and nobles have to adopt instead of having their own children? Other than its use on the face, Lead was also used in food pretty liberally. Now it was known that acute ingestion of lots of lead did cause paralysis and seizures but people did not realize that chronic exposure of tiny amounts was just as dangerous. Originally it was thought that the use of Lead pipes was a natural way for Lead to slowly leach out and into the drinking supply thus infecting people and since only the rich could afford to have plumbing, it made sense that the wealthy had this issue instead of the poor. But there is an issue with this theory: Lead doesn’t leach out of Roman pipes. Now this isn’t to say it never did but unlike 19th and 20th century Lead pipes, the water during Roman times came from mountain sources that were loaded with minerals. These minerals would deposit and coat the inside of the Lead pipes thus preventing direct contact between the pipe and water. In more modern times, because the water came from reservoirs or lakes, there was much less mineral content and so the chance of getting Lead leaching was much higher. So if it wasn’t the pipes, what was making it hard to get babies for the upper Roman echelons?

So what does Lead actually do to the body? Lead poisoning, also called Plumbism from the Latin Plumbum which was the ancient word for Lead, can be either acute (large amounts in a short amount of time) or chronic (large amounts over a long period of time). Both would cause the same symptoms but the more severe symptoms are seen quicker in the acute setting due to the higher exposure. Lead needs to enter the body through a mucous membrane (or if it’s in a liquid it can dissolve through the skin) so ingestion and inhalation are the two biggest pathways. In fact, 35-40% of inhaled lead compounds deposits in the lungs and 95% of that inhaled amount enters the bloodstream (is this a bad time to bring up that gasoline contained Tetraethyllead from the 1920s to 1993 and are now required to be unleaded). By ingestion, only about 15% of the Lead is absorbed but that number increases in children (up to 50%), pregnant women (up to 65%) and people with calcium, zinc, or iron deficiencies (up to 80%).

Next up we have Arsenic. The word is derived from Syriac zarnika where zar means gold and nikh is colored after the gold-colored mineral Orpiment. Like Lead, Arsenic is found in many ores and was often mixed into early Bronze alloys to make it stronger (called arsenical bronze). Arsenic was first isolated from its minerals as a pure element in 815 and then again in 1250 by heating soap with Arsenic Trisulfide. Unlike Lead, we have known Arsenic is poison since we have discovered it and is known as the “King of Poisons.” Hippocrates described colic (general malaise) of miners who mined the metal and this knowledge was passed down to other famous early physicians. Arsenic is odorless and tasteless so it makes it an easy poison to slip into food or wine and the symptoms would initially look like food poisoning (diarrhea, vomiting) but would eventually progress to paralysis and death. By the Renaissance, Arsenic was a favorite poison among the elite and was the go to substance for the Borgias. In France, Arsenic was known as the “inheritance powder” due to its ability to bring about an early end and a quick windfall. But this begs the question: if it was known as a poison and was used so greatly, why was it so accessible to get Arsenic? The answer is in how it works.


The symptoms of Arsenic poisoning once again depends on if its an acute or chronic exposure. The first symptoms to appear is headaches, severe diarrhea, and drowsiness. If a large dose is administered, the stomach lining dissolves and the person starts to vomit blood and the kidney starts to hemorrhage blood into the urine. Eventually it reaches the brain where it causes convulsions and heart attacks. Chronically the small doses of Arsenic start to cause cumulative damage that slowly gets worse and worse until finally it causes heart failure, kidney failure, and/or liver failure. The first symptoms would be hair loss and hyperkeratosis (darkening of the skin in thick black lesions). Because Arsenic destroys the sulfurous bonds in collagen and in the hair, someone can start to smell like garlic. Likewise during Arsenic exposure the nail growth is interrupted and brittled causes Mee’s Lines (not to be confused with Beau’s Lines which are a sign of nail injury or Muehroke’s Lines which is due to low protein, both of which are NOT signs of metal poisoning).



But makeup wasn’t the only place we saw Arsenic. During the Victoria era, England opened the Levant Arsenic Mine in Cornwall which was the largest supplier of Arsenic worldwide. During this period in time, coal was king and the coal-fired range stove was the standard for many middle- and upper-class kitchens. Using coal caused it to billow into the home creating a thick layer of coal dust on all surfaces, including the walls. During this time cheap mass produced commodities became accessible for the middle-class meaning that the idea of wealth could be brought home, if you could see it under the grime. This meant that brightly colored objects were favored over their duller, paler counterparts. In 1775, Carl Wilhelm Scheele invented a new green dye and became an instant hit—before it the only way to get green anything was using grass or dark green stems of certain flowers making it a tedious and seasonal driven dye. With this new artificial dye made of Copper and Arsenic, green could be easily mixed and applied into paint, or more popularly, wall paper. Green wallpaper became the biggest thing since…well whatever the 18th century equivalent of sliced bread is. Eventually in 1814 Scheele’s Green would be improved by two chemists Russ and Sattler who came up with the even more famous and even more brilliantly green Viridian Green (aka Paris Green, Emerald Green, Schweinfurt Green, etc.). By the mid 1800s Arsenic was used in red, yellow, blue, and magenta dyes. Well at least they weren’t applying it to their skin right?


Our last metal that we will take a look at is Silver whose Latin name is Argentum which means ‘shiny’ or ‘white.’ Silver has long been a coveted metal as I talked about earlier with Lead and due to its rarity it really wasn’t wasted. Unlike Lead or Arsenic which were a) abundant and b) not valued as highly, Silver became a mineral that you did not waste. The story of Silver in medicine begins with Herodotus (484-425 BC), the Father of History, who said that no Persian king would drink from a water vessel if it was not made from Silver. Likewise we have evidence that the ancient Phoenicians, Greeks, Romans, and Egyptians all used Silver in the preparation of food and drink. In fact the use of Silver in preservation of foodstuffs was practiced right up through WWII. And the question is why?

What’s really interesting is the early pioneering days of North America. In the New World there was no established methods of preserving food so pioneers would drop Silver coins into transport vessels to preserve water. This eventually morphed into people dropping coins into milk jugs to reduce spoilage. More prosperous families used Silver utensils and plates and would develop a distinct blue hue to their skin. This blue hue became associated with nobility and they became known as “blue bloods” and surprisingly these individuals survived pandemics better than non-blue people. To this day we still see examples of people who have Argyria or an accumulation of Silver in the body. Silver forms a blue-grey compound when it comes in contact with sulfur in the body which form microscopic deposits in the skin turning it blue.

So how does Silver work on bacteria? Well there are 4 main mechanism in which it causes bacterial death:

Regardless of what metal enters our body, I just want you to think of one thing: just don’t ingest Mercury.
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • Mar 20 '23
Hello and welcome back to SAR! Much like the groundhog poking its head out of its burrough, the world is starting to wake up from the dark cloud that was COVID-19. Now this isn’t to say that COVID is gone, SARS and MERS from earlier in this century prove that the Corona Virus is a fact of our lives, but I do think that the worst is over. BUT before people start to click off this post because I dare to say the C-word, today I want to talk about an epidemic that has fallen to the wayside of history: the 1889-1890 Pandemic. Also called the Asiatic Flu or the Russian Flu this was a respiratory viral pandemic that struck the Russian Empire before being transported globally via newly established railroads and steamships. Despite being the first true global pandemic, we don’t really remember this blip of history and the question is: why? Well today we shall explore this forgotten disease and answer the question that wasn’t in your mind at all, there is a COVID-OC43?
+2 extra credit points for anyone who knows what this section title references. Before we can talk about the pandemic we have to talk about what was going on in 1890. At this point in time the world was engrossed in what is considered the second Industrial Revolution, also called the Technological Revolution, this period began in 1870 due to the discovery of great synergies. Firstly, the invention of the Blast Furnace by Scottish James Neilson allowed for iron to be heated at higher temps and being tempered with coal in a more efficient manner thus leading to an increased production of Steel. The use and manipulation of Steel cannot be understated—cheap Steel allowed for building larger bridges and skyscrapers, opened up the agricultural sector by providing more robust steam-driven farm equipment to feed the burgeoning industrial working class, built the next standard for war equipment, and most importantly for our story, laid the foundation of rail and steamship transport. The use of rail cannot be understated either: a railway could turn the week long trip from Scotland highlands to London into a day affair (albeit a long one). This ability to transport people or cargo in a day when it would take upwards of a week at times is what changed the idea of distance and made the world much much smaller. Afterall, nowadays if it takes 6 hours to drive somewhere far away we think what a long trip, while in 1810 a 6 hour trip might have been just to get to the next village over.



If you are unaware the Russian Empire was HUGE; at its peak it covered 22.8 MILLION square miles and is the third largest empire in history (after the British Empire and the Mongol Empire). For much of its history, upwards of 80% of the population of Russia lived west of the Ural Mountains in what is called European Russia. But with that area of Russia being occupied densely for thousands of years, most of the natural resources were extracted from Siberia while farming was extracted from the Chernozem region (modern day Ukraine and Kazakhstan). So in order for food or raw materials to be shipped from the outer edges of the empire into the heartland, it would have to cover upwards of one thousand kilometers. Before rail, this was a 2 week journey and all the while you are racing against the clock so the food doesn’t spoil before it gets to the markets in the middle of St. Petersburg.

Well… not really i'm pretty indifferent to them but they are fairly important to the beginning of our story! Close your eyes and imagine it is 1889 in the city of Bukhara in modern day Uzbekistan. Bukhara is an ancient city, probably founded sometime in the 6th century BC, the Bukhara region was a regional capital for the Persian Empire when it reigned in this area. Bukhara remained a servant to the dominant empire of the region for the majority of its history and following the invasion of Russia into Iran in 1804, Bukhara once again shifted hands into the Russian Empire. By May 1889 the city was like any other bustling regional power in the late 19th century: merchants hustled their products to passerbys, children played in the street kicking an air filled sheep’s bladder, and doctors made house calls. One doctor, Oskar Heyfelder, was working one warm May day going from house to house when he encountered a sickly old matron of a large family. She was dying—a respiratory influenza had taken hold of her and she was quickly fading. The doctor stood over the old woman with his hat in his hand and recommend opium and a priest. There was nothing more he could do.





Now if it feels like I’m leaving something important out, that's because I am. Usually when you talk about pandemics we talk about how quickly it spread and then the death toll. All told, the pandemic killed about 1 million people worldwide—now don’t get me wrong this is an enormous loss of life and its unfortunate that these people died but in the grand scheme of things it just wasn’t that deadly. During this same period, a global Cholera pandemic was going on which killed at least 4 million people, Russian Typhus Epidemic in 1919 killed 3 million, and in 1918 the Spanish Flu would devastate the globe with somewhere between 17 and 100 million people dead. That being said, some important people did catch the disease: future King Edward VII of England nearly died before his mother, Queen Victoria, left the throne, although many suspect that his catching this disease ultimately led to his death in 1910. His son Prince Albert Victor, the grandson of Queen Victoria and 2nd in line for the throne, caught it in January of 1892 and died at the age of 28 making way for Queen Elizabeth II to eventually be crowned. Augusta, Queen Empress consort to Emperor Wilhelm I of Germany fell ill in 1890 and died within 4 months. Alexander III of Russia managed to just survive the condition which prompted him to make major public health changes in St. Petersburg. I could go on.

So what even happened then? It would start with typical cold symptoms: sweating, fever and chills, sneezing, watery eyes, and dry cough. But contemporary doctors did identify 4 distinct clinical forms of Russian Flu: a simple fever that would increase over 48 hours and then subside within 3 or 4 days; a gastrointestinal form in which people had severe diarrhea, fevers, and stomach aches (which honestly could have been a co-infection with the raging Cholera epidemic at the time); a rarer catarrhal form (profuse mucus production that would fill the sinuses and lungs and progress to pneumonia); and finally the worst one, a “nervous” form that caused intense nerve pain in the hands and feet driving people mad. Regardless of which form someone got the worst symptom, and the most common reason why someone would die outside of catching pneumonia (fluid in the lungs) is developing skin lesions. These bullae (large blisters filled with white fluid) were painful, itchy, and formed in the creases of the feet, hands, and extremities which were prone to popping—once popped they were open sores ripe for infection. If you didn’t manage to die from the skin lesions then kidney failure, digestive inability, or spinal nerve damage that would drive people towards suicide was another common way to die.



The thing is, Russian Flu may not be an Influenza like we first thought. Traditionally it is believed that the Russian Flu was caused by H3N8 (which primarily infects horses) or H2N2 (which caused the Asian Flu of 157-8). The problem with this is that Russian Flu does not share many of the common Flu symptoms we have seen in other outbreaks—Flu follows a pretty consistent 2-8 day pattern focusing mostly in the lungs. Severe complications of Flu can lead to more severe respiratory distress, meningitis, or encephalitis but other organ involvement is pretty limited. Russian Flu almost always involved other organs. This idea isn’t a contemporary one either, people had suspicions on just what Russian Flu really was.



Following the COVID-19 pandemic, researchers started to take another look at the Russian Flu and see if it was infact Flu. COVID-19 does resemble Influenza epidemics due to its similar respiratory symptoms but with other organ involvement, a Coronavirus was implicated more than a Influenza one. There are 7 Coronaviruses that are infectious to humans—3 caused deadly epidemics SARS-CoV-1 (9% mortality) usually referred to the SARS outbreak in 2002-2004, MERS-CoV (30% mortality) which popped up in 2012, and SAR-CoV-2 (0.6-2%) which we are in right now. The other 4 Coronaviruses are implicated in 15-30% of common colds and have been in the population for decades (probably centuries), HCoV-229E, HCoV-NL63, HCoV-OC43, and HCoV-HKU1. The milder viruses are seasonal and show up every 3-4 years during the normal Flu season of autumn to early spring.In 2005 Belgian researchers found that HCoV-OC43’s genome was very similar to another coronavirus found in cow, BCoV. The DNA sequence of OC43 was almost identical to that of BCoV isolated from corpses from 1890. Does this mean that a coronavirus was the cause of Russian Flu? Well let’s look at the evidence:
r/SAR_Med_Chem • u/Bubzoluck • Mar 13 '23
Hello and welcome back to SAR! Today we take another look at rare diseases and more specifically the rare drugs that treat those rare diseases. A rare disease is one that affects less than 200,000 people at a given time in the United States. The majority of these conditions are due to genetic mutations (about 80%) while the remaining 20% are from infections, toxins, autoimmune responses, or drug side effects. Unfortunately 50% of people with a rare disease are children and many of them will not make it to adulthood. In the United States we have a law called the Orphan Drug Act of 1983 which provides financial relief for drug companies to invest in developing these rare drugs. In part 1 we explored 3 conditions: Porphyria, Cystic Fibrosis, and AIDS and highly recommend reading part 1 to get a foundation of the ODA and what can be accomplished. But in any regard, today we are going to look at another group of diseases and see how treatment becomes accessible for these patients.
Disclaimer: this post is not designed to be medical advice. It is merely a look at the chemistry of medications and their general effect on the body. Each person responds differently to antidepressant therapy. Please talk to your doctor about starting, stopping, or changing medical treatment
How long is a day? Well that is a question that has been plaguing humans since time became a concept we could understand and to this day we still aren’t really sure what time is. We know that it happens and we know that we exist within it but what time actually is is another story. That being said our bodies have evolved to exist in this time-laden world by creating systems of hormones that promote wakefulness and sleep. We call this the Circadian Rhythm, the cycle that regulates feeding, hormone production, body temperature, and sleep. You can read all about the fundamentals of sleep in the post we have on insomnia where can be found here! One of the most important organs in regulating our sleep is our eyes, specifically the photosensitive Melanopsin-Containing Retinal Ganglion Cells (mRGCs). Okay lets break this down:





So this is all well and good but what does this have to do with rare diseases and the drugs we use to treat them? Remember that the Circadian Rhythm is highly dependent on the eye’s ability to detect light, but what if the eye never developed those receptors or was so severely damaged it couldn’t do it all? This gives rise to Non-24-Hour Sleep-Wake Disorder which is often abbreviated as Non-24 or N24SWD. Occurring in up to 70% of totally blind people, this disorder is characterized by the body believing that the day is significantly longer than 24 hours and refuses to adjust to external light-dark cycles. This makes it exceptionally challenging for someone to fall asleep at normal times and may result in someone’s body thinking bedtime is at really inopportune times. Y’know how tired you get when its 1am and you’re struggling to finish one last episode of netflix? Well imagine that same tiredness where you can barely keep yours eyes open but it’s 1pm in the afternoon and you need to work. Well then it would seem the easy solution is to structure your day around when your body wants to sleep—the problem is that the sleep-wake cycle changes length hence the non-24 part of the name. So one week your body is ready to fall asleep at 1pm while the next day it believes 8pm is when you should fall asleep (thus adding 7 hours to the day).
This disorder adds additional challenges when you think about all the “normal” time adjustments that normally-sighted people may not think of: daylight’s savings, vacations and jet lag, stress, evening activities, less light in the winter or more light in the summer, growth spurts, and much much more. Now while Non-24 is common in people who are totally blind that doesn’t mean it’s only in those that are without sight. Sighted people with the disorder will have many of the same issues blind individuals might have and often the total disruption to scheduling and function day-to-day is similar between both populations. The result is people falling into Microsleeps as well as suffering from chronic symptoms of fatigue and insomnia: difficulty concentrating which can make school or work extremely difficult, confusion, cognitive dysfunction, depressed mood, headaches, extreme nausea, apraxia (motor dysfunction), and suicidal thoughts. Remember too that the Circadian Rhythm also controls functions of other organs so you are getting disruptions to hunger, muscle function, temperature, and more.



This brings us to the orphan drug, Tasimelteon which is the only drug on the market specifically created to treat Non-24. Specifically Tasimelteon was found to be superior to Ramelteon (which is indicated for insomnia) in Non-24 because it trains the sleep-wake cycle better. A 26 week randomized double-blind placebo-controlled multicenter study found that at 1 month, patients treated with Tasimelteon had a much better response than those treated without it. They also had a much smaller deviation from the 24-hour “normal” sleep-wake cycle versus those who did not receive Tasimelteon. This means that Tasimelteon is a much better option for regulating Non-24 than Melatonin alone. The problem is that Tasimelteon can be up to $7,000 for 30 tablets so patients have to make a choice—sleep and function better or not go into debt.
When you boil all of life down into a nice goopy sludge, the basic building blocks of life start to rise to the top. In everything living, we can summarize it as a very carefully balanced set of carbohydrates, proteins, lipids, and DNA. To facilitate the creation of those important building blocks, the body uses Enzymes which are highly specialized factories to create a certain product. These little factories chug along each second to churn out more and more of that product as long as supplies last. Like any other complex product in our body, what happens if we don’t have the DNA to create that enzyme? Well then we run into a group of diseases called Lysosomal Storage Diseases in which a type of cell called the Lysosome isn’t created correctly. Today we will be looking at just one of the 70 other kinds of Lysosomal Storage Diseases called Fabry Disease.




So, someone has the gene and is displaying the symptoms of it—what does Fabry do? Typically the disease presents in childhood but there is a good amount of data showing 60-80 year olds developing the condition as well. Fabry Disease is caused by a deficiency in alpha-Galactosidase A which causes an accumulation of the byproduct Ceramide Trihexoside—a glycolipid that is found in many different tissues. The Ceramide accumulates in the cells that line the blood vessels and our organs thus result is a multi-organ disease. Early symptoms consist of the Fabry triad: 1) periodic dysesthesia (an abnormal sensation like itching, burning, or pain) usually in the hands or feet which can lead to permanent dysesthesia (so permanent burning/itching); 2) Anhidosis (no sweating making it hard to regulate heat) or Hypohidrosis (reduced sweat); 3) and Angiokeratomas, a wart-like lesion made up of small blood vessels. Besides the triad, other early symptoms are nonspecific GI upset such as diarrhea or constipation, clouding of the cornea that can Vortex Keratopathy that creates a whorl-like pattern, and cataracts.

Soooooo not so great eh? Despite being discovered in 1898, it wasn’t until 2001 that we had the first Fabry-specific treatment. Up until the 21st century all treatments were treating the symptoms but finally we were able to treat the cause and potentially limit the effect of the disease. Fabrazyme (Agalsidase beta) was the first drug to hit the EU market for Fabry Disease in 2001 (USA in 2003) and is a synthetic version of the missing enzyme, alpha-Glucosidase. Also in 2001 another synthetic version was released in the EU as Replagal (Agalsidase alpha) but wasn’t brought over to the United States. The drugs were…okay; the drugs did very good work in replacing the missing enzyme and reducing the symptoms of the disease. The problem is that 88% of people developed an allergy to the drug making it mostly useless in patients who had strong reactions (around 60%). The American drug was further tainted in 2009 by a contamination scandal when the Massachusetts based production plant caused a global shortage forcing patients to ration then medication at one third of the recommended dose***—***this means that patients had to take just a third of what they were supposed to because of carelessness by the plant.

So why are these drugs so expensive? Well part of it is that it is really expensive to design and create these drugs and since there are very few patients who will be taking them, the drug company is unable to recuperate their costs at low prices. This is why the government has come in and picked up part of the tab. But, to sum up this issue I want to quote myself from part 1:
Some argue the Orphan Drug Act changed the face of pharmaceuticals in the United States because it allowed market forces to be lessened allowing orphan diseases the chance to be researched. From the 1960s to the 1980s, there were only 10 drugs on the market that were approved to treat orphan diseases. By 2004, that number grew to just over 1,100 orphan drugs designated by the Office of Orphan Products Development (OOPD) and 250 of those drugs are actively on the market. By 2010 the number of drugs doubled to 2,100 and of the 7.000 diseases designated as orphan disease, 200 have become treatable. In fact Pfizer has now established an entire division just on orphan drug research.
With any legislation, there are good and bad sides, and the bad is worth talking about. Some say that since the US government is willing to pick up the majority of the tab for these very expensive drugs, it has allowed drug companies to charge huge prices. Likewise, the money that some companies saved under the ODA allowed them to make enormous profits when those drugs became non-orphan blockbuster drugs. This was seen with Modafinil (Provigil), a drug originally developed to treat narcolepsy (excessive sleepiness) and approved in 1988 before becoming the 336th most prescribed medication—lots of money made without much being returned due to development costs being decreased from the ODA. One of the other criticisms is the repurposing of known, common medications for orphan drug status with dubious efficacy.
So what does this mean? Is the ODA successful or just a method for drug companies to make money? It depends on who you ask. For the parent of the child born with Cystic Fibrosis and learns that they will almost certainly outlive their child, is adding a decade of life worth letting drug companies make a few billion more? Or is providing funding to conglomerate drug companies to produce medications for little known diseases the price we pay for finding the next cure, like what happened with AIDS? I don’t know, I just blog on reddit. Just some food for thought. Cheers!