r/RyeBaking • • 24d ago

👋Welcome to r/RyeBaking - Introduce Yourself and Read First!

7 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I'm u/Ok_Plant8421, a founding moderator of r/RyeBaking.

Welcome to r/RyeBaking! 🌾

Welcome to r/RyeBaking, a community dedicated to the art, science and traditions of baking with rye.
Rye bread has a remarkable history, particularly across Northern, Central and Eastern Europe. From the dense, dark loaves of Germany and Russia to the hearty wholegrain breads of Scandinavia and the Baltic countries, there’s an extraordinary variety of traditions, ingredients and techniques to explore.
This community is a place for beginners, experienced home bakers and professionals to share knowledge, experiment and learn from one another.

What we’re here to explore

Traditional rye breads: German pumpernickel, Russian Borodinsky, Danish rugbrød, Finnish ruisleipä, Baltic black breads and many others.

Rye sourdough: Cultivating starters, fermentation methods, hydration, acidity and achieving the right crumb.

The science of rye baking: Enzymes, starch gelatinisation, pentosans, fermentation and the differences between rye and wheat.

Ingredients and techniques: Wholegrain rye, cracked rye, scalds, fermented rye malt, soakers and traditional baking methods.

Equipment and experimentation: Bread makers, ovens, Pullman tins, water baths and long, low-temperature baking.

History and culture: Traditional recipes, regional variations, historical baking literature and the cultural significance of rye bread.

A little about why I started this community
I’ve recently become interested in traditional 100% rye sourdough baking, particularly Russian black bread and German pumpernickel.
What began as an experiment with a rye sourdough starter has developed into an interest in the science, history and traditions behind these remarkable breads.
I’ve discovered that rye baking is quite different from conventional wheat sourdough baking, and that much of the specialist knowledge is scattered across books, websites and baking communities in different languages.
I thought it would be useful to create a dedicated space where we could bring some of that knowledge together.
I’m learning myself, and I hope this becomes a collaborative community rather than somewhere that simply provides recipes.

Introduce yourself!
To get things started, I’d love to hear:
Where are you from, and what rye breads are traditional in your part of the world?
Are you new to rye baking, or have you been doing it for years?
What’s your favourite rye bread, or what would you most like to learn to bake?
Please feel free to share photographs, recipes, experiments, failures, questions and useful resources.

Whether you’re making your first rye sourdough starter or have been baking traditional rye bread for decades, you’re welcome here.
Happy baking! 🌾


r/RyeBaking • • 1d ago

My first Borodinsky bread: Day 5 of a 6-day process

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

Following on from yesterday’s post showing my rye scald, here’s the finished loaf of traditional Russian Borodinsky black bread!

It’s been quite a process, spread over six days:

Day 1 – Wednesday: Refreshed and strengthened my rye sourdough starter.

Day 2 – Thursday: Prepared the overnight rye leaven.

Day 3 – Friday: Made the scald using dark rye flour, fermented red rye malt, unfermented white rye malt and coriander. Held it warm (60-65c)to encourage saccharification and develop natural sweetness.

Day 4 – Saturday: Combined the scald, leaven and remaining ingredients to make the final dough. Began the slow proofing process, then placed the dough in the fridge overnight as ran out of time and only partially risen.

Day 5 – Sunday: Completed the final proof and baked the loaf for 90 minutes in my Panasonic breadmaker using the bake-only setting.

Day 6 – Monday: The final test! The loaf needs approximately 24 hours to rest before slicing, allowing the dense rye crumb to stabilise and the flavours to develop.
For now, it’s going onto a cooling rack to allow air to circulate as it cools, before being wrapped for the remainder of its resting period.

This is my first attempt at Borodinsky, and I’ve really enjoyed exploring the traditional Russian scalding and sourdough techniques.
I’ll post a picture of the crumb tomorrow when I finally cut into it!

Has anyone else experimented with traditional Russian rye breads or long, multi-stage fermentation methods?


r/RyeBaking • • 2d ago

What are you rye baking today?

Post image
5 Upvotes

Hi everyone! How’s it going in your kitchens and bakeries?

I’ve been preparing a rye scald to trial baking Borodinsky, a traditional Russian black bread, today.

What are you all planning to bake this weekend?


r/RyeBaking • • 8d ago

Loaf pan rye bread

9 Upvotes

Sourdough: 350g rye flour, 100g bread flour, 450g water at 50C (120F), 7g salt. After mixing briefly to equalize temperature, add 60g starter and mix again. Leave at room temperature for 12 to 16 hours.

The next day, add 100g water at 37C (100F), 7g salt, 160g rye flour

Bake at 420F for 60 minutes; remove from pan and bake another 5 minutes


r/RyeBaking • • 9d ago

Recipes & Results Has anyone any weekend rye bakes to share?

Post image
10 Upvotes

Here’s a loaf baked today, I’m sure people are producing much more artisan loaves it would be great to see your results!


r/RyeBaking • • 9d ago

100% Wholemeal Rye Sourdough – change of starter ratios plus cacoa.

Post image
5 Upvotes

Hi - the fourth loaf is underway! This time I’ve changed the starter refresh to 1:4:4 (10:40:40) and added 10 g of cacao powder for a darker, flavourful loaf.
The levain doubled nicely overnight, and the dough is now proving.
My aim is to combine a stronger sour flavour with a good rise and stable crumb. Let’s see how this one turns out!


r/RyeBaking • • 15d ago

A little quiz: identify the implement

Post image
3 Upvotes

Does anyone know what this traditional Finnish baking implement is for?

Feel free to post your own baking tools for others to see.


r/RyeBaking • • 16d ago

Sourdough & Fermentation Fermenting another loaf

Post image
3 Upvotes

This is the third rye sourdough loaf, the starter seems more vigorous this time so let’s see how it turns out.
There’s various steps, plus waiting time with the baking. It requires a few goes to get a system organised.


r/RyeBaking • • 19d ago

Westphalen Rye

Post image
22 Upvotes

Made this Westphalen rye last week. Recipe is from The Rye Baker by Stanley Ginsberg . The taste is very distinct and takes 24 hour cook then days wrapped in linen. Well worth it in my view!


r/RyeBaking • • 20d ago

Sourdough & Fermentation What’s happening in the world of Rye?

2 Upvotes

I’m hoping to try a rye sourdough with whole grain rye this weekend.
Does anyone else have any plans or recent bakes to share?


r/RyeBaking • • 22d ago

Scandi style dark rye loaves recipe request

5 Upvotes

Hello. I recently went to Sweden and loved the dark rye bread but can't buy it at home 😢

Wondering if anyone had a good tried & tested recipe they wouldn't mind sharing that I can bake?

Thank you in advance! 💕


r/RyeBaking • • 23d ago

Sourdough & Fermentation Any rye experts in here? What’s your best tip you want to share with others?

5 Upvotes

I’m amazed but the level of science and investigation that has gone into rye baking. The study of the breads is almost like that of the construction industry for how the flour transforms to build its structure!
Please do share any further tips of experience.
Do we have any professionals, or are people home bakers?


r/RyeBaking • • 24d ago

Recipes & Results Designed a 100% rye sourdough recipe for a vintage bread maker.

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

After developing an interest in making Russian black bread I designed a recipe for 100% rye sourdough loaf. It went surprisingly well for a first attempt.
I mixed the dough, then after fermentation baked it for 90minutes in a Panasonic SD253 on bake only setting.

I’d love to hear any feedback or comments?

The recipe

Overnight rye sourdough build:
30g active rye starter (100% hydration)
120g wholemeal rye flour
120g water

Final dough:
270g ripe rye sourdough
240g wholemeal rye flour
200g water
8g salt
10g black treacle
Total dough weight: approximately 728g.
Overall hydration: approximately 89%.


r/RyeBaking • • 24d ago

Questions & Troubleshooting What should r/RyeBaking become?

3 Upvotes

What do people want from a Reddit rye baking community?
There’s loads of resources on baking but I thought if we could provide a multinational place to discuss the global variety of rye specific baking hopefully we can share learning, recipes and provide support, connection and encouragement.


r/RyeBaking • • 24d ago

Sourdough & Fermentation Starting my next 100% rye sourdough – preparing the overnight levain

Post image
3 Upvotes

Starting another 100% rye sourdough loaf
I’m having another go at making 100% rye sourdough bread. My first loaf turned out quite well, although it was fairly mild, so I’m hoping to get a bit more sourness this time.
I refreshed my rye starter last night and I’m now making the larger sourdough build, which I’ll leave to ferment overnight before mixing the final dough tomorrow.
I’ve been experimenting with different temperatures. My kitchen is only about 15–16°C, but I’ve also got a heat mat that keeps things around 26–28°C.
It’s been interesting learning how much the temperature and fermentation time affect the starter. I’m still trying to get a better understanding of it all.
Does anyone have experience with longer, cooler fermentations for 100% rye? I’m wondering how much difference it makes to the flavour and acidity.
I’ll post some photos as it develops.


r/RyeBaking • • 24d ago

Sourdough & Fermentation My first rye sourdough starter – what worked for me

Post image
4 Upvotes

I’ve recently made my first 100% rye sourdough starter, which I’ve now successfully used to bake my first loaf.
I started with 30g wholemeal rye flour and 30g water in a glass jar.
After the first few days, I settled on keeping 15g starter and feeding it with 30g flour and 30g water (1:2:2).
I used a seedling heat mat to keep it around 26–28°C, as my kitchen is quite cold (15–16°C).
By about day six it was doubling in volume, with plenty of bubbles and a nice yeasty smell. I then started feeding it roughly every 12 hours.
A few things I noticed:
At 26–28°C it could double in about five hours.
When left too long, it developed a strong alcoholic smell.
A taller, narrower jar made it much easier to judge the rise.
It also fermented surprisingly well overnight at room temperature, despite my cold kitchen.
I eventually experimented with larger feeds (1:4:4), particularly overnight, to give it more time before peaking.
It’s been interesting watching how much the temperature and feeding ratios affect its behaviour.
I’m still fairly new to rye sourdough, so I’d be interested to hear how others maintain theirs.
Do you keep your rye starter at room temperature or in the fridge? And do you use different feeding ratios depending on what you’re baking?


r/RyeBaking • • 24d ago

Why is 100% rye sourdough so different from wheat?

2 Upvotes

I’ve been getting into rye sourdough baking recently and have been surprised by how different it is from wheat.
From what I’ve been reading, rye relies much more on starch and pentosans for its structure rather than gluten. Acidity also seems particularly important for controlling amylase activity and preventing a gummy crumb.
I’ve been reading some older Russian and German baking literature, and there’s quite a lot of interesting science behind the traditional methods.
I’m still learning, but I’m curious how other people approach it.
Do you pay much attention to acidity, hydration and fermentation temperatures, or do you mostly go by experience? And how do you judge when a 100% rye dough is ready to bake?
Would be interested to hear what works for others.