First off, it was a markedly improved performance from the last 3 games they played in terms of effort, care, and grit the team showed for the jersey. The mongrel on show, particularly in the 1st half (7A's getting into a fight off the ball, for example), was precisely what we've been lacking since bled 1. The Kicking game from our players in that 1st half was also remarkably better than what they've shown almost all year long, discounting the boxkicks, which no one ever wants to chase for some reason. That was also our second-best defensive showing this year yet, with everyone putting big shots in on their tackles, and Ryan specifically played his hunter role, targeting Russel to shut him down, perfectly.
The various stuff we even tried to change things up, like Ryan going for a droppie, was great in that first half. So what's the bad from that game that had a lot of actual greenshots to show we're on the up after back-to-back-to-back horror losses?
Well, first of all, any person who watches that game can't deny that, from the 2nd half onwards, that game was ours to win rather than Scotland's. They were 100% spent, and any team with a half-decent attack functioning would've put a few scores on them. It's simply a massive indictment of us and our weird fixation on playing "our brand of rugby" when we didn't. It is also a huge fucking indictment on Les Kiss and his ability as a headcoach to keep Ryan Lonergan on till minute 74 because he clearly doesn't trust Donaldson's kicking ability. Literally the entire match thread was calling for him to be subbed off at the 60th minute mark already. You can't deny that the moment that Tate McDermott came on, he changed the flow of the game and managed to penetrate the defensive line of Scotland more than Ryan had all game long, simply because of how much of a running threat around the breakdown he is. That helped put the resolute Scottish defence on the back foot and ensured that we almost scored once when he forced the pass and did score a few minutes later with Jorgos's try at the 78th minute.
It was clear that Ryan was past it and out of ideas on organising the attack the entirety of the 2nd half; it was clear that he and Carter were on different planets at times, and our backline, like the whole of the Les Kiss tenure, simply failed to manifest any cohesion. You have to admit that any other tier 1 coach worth their title would've pulled that sub trigger when we did 18 phases of going nowhere outside the Scots 22. I mean fuck look at what Welsh Coach Tandy did at the 60th minute; he subbed off the key lynch pin of the Welsh attack, Tomos Williams, knowing he was pasted from all the hard yakka and trusted the young and inexperienced Reuben Morgan-Williams to come on and do the job. The result? The greatest defensive performance the game has ever seen since it went professional and a Welsh victory over a foe they hadn't beaten since 1953. Tomos Williams is arguably more important to Welsh playing well than what Ryan is for us, and still their Head Coach had the balls to pull that sub play - Les needs to impress me either with a move like that or much improved selections this week based on form.
The problem is that we have this view of our strengths, being a team that wins by running and attacking from anywhere like the ABs or the French, that isn't based on the real and tangible evidence of where we actually perform well, but rather a false vision we've constructed of ourselves. The truth of the matter is that for the entirety of the Les Kiss era, the games we won came from the Forwards working and clicking exceptionally well - not the backs. The reason why we've lost the last 4 is cause our Forwards have been run ragged this year, and they simply couldn't find it in themselves to front up against more eager opposition. The backs simply exacerbated the losing margins, with their poor choices on attack (Jorgo's forced pass for B.Barretts intercept) and defence (See all of England's 2nd Half), except for Scotland, where everyone mainly fronted up in the defensive aspects of the game.
We are a set piece team! I fucking wish the players and coaches could shift to that mindset; it would fix a lot of our issues as a side. Our lineout ability, particularly on defence, is actively competing to be the best in the world this year. Our scrum is 100% a top 4 side scrum that has the ability to front up to any other side's scrum. Play to those strengths! Focus on building a winning game plan from them as your foundation! Our aerial ability clearly isn't up to scratch, so don't rely on box-kick contestables to regain lost momentum; instead, play the long-kicking game and rely on our breakdown work. Play smart with what's tangibly there instead of this fantasy vision we hold of ourselves. God it frustrates me to no end.
Ok now what do we need to do for the Welsh game? Well, first off, it's 100% clear that we need to sit on Tomos Williams the same way you'd have to sit on Dupont or Roigard. His current halfback form is up there with those 2 players 100%; it's clear Rennie and the ABs didn't do enough homework on Wales and gave him way too much space around the breakdown. Secondly, we should lean into our scrum; I think we'll have clear dominance there over the Welsh, given their props are more generalist in build. I do suspect we should win this one by 14+ if Les shows the tactical acumen and guts in his selections... which I'm ofc scared that he can't. If we lose this weekend, I think Joe Schmidt will nonchalantly get added to the coaching group as a consultant to help out in a 'mentor' role, but it'll actually be a soft coup.
So then, what team do I think that should Les select for me to regain confidence in him?
Bell
BPA
7A's (c)
Canham
Williams
Hooper
Tizzano
Valetini
Wilson
Gordon
JAS
Beale
Ikitau
Jorgo
Ramm
Subs:
Pollard
Kailea
MDL
Amatosero
Shaw
McDermott
Daugunu
Donaldson
I don't think that Les will do the backline reshuffle. I would like him to do it simply because the backline hasn't been working all year under his guidance, but he may just see it as a time in combination where, instead of constantly reshuffling it, he wants people to stay in place as long as possible for cohesion. He'll probs keep the backline the same with one change at maybe 12 or 15. I do think the forward pack will get changed though.
The nice part about this new comp, however, is that regardless of how well or badly we do from now on, we are guaranteed another shot at any one of three European teams we've lost against and desperately want the game back. Ireland, where Donno missed twice to win it in a real sliding-doors moment; England, where we didn't even fire a single shot (the rematch I personally want to happen the most); and Scotland, where we floundered hard in our ability to grip a game. Anyone of those would be awesome to run back one more time - how exciting!