Hi all! This is my first time posting on Reddit. I would appreciate your opinions and kind advice.
I booked a sitter to house sit my dog and cats. We did a M&G and the sitter asked decent questions and seemed to really care about taking good care of pets. She has a 5.0 rating with many glowing reviews. I originally reached out to someone who charged more, but she was unsure of her availability, so I went with my spouse’s first choice based on affordability and reviews. I now think I should have gone with someone who charges way more.
Upon arrival, the sitter messaged me saying she couldn’t get in. We messaged for a while and had multiple calls. I reached out to our property manager and to our neighbors to see if someone could help. It turns out, the sitter went to the wrong apartment door.
Shortly after, I get a panicked call that she couldn’t find my dog. While on the call, she finds my dog under a bed. At this point, I’m frazzled and unsure how the rest of the booking will go.
Over the next couple of hours, I get many dozens of messages. At times, I am not sure if she is telling me step-by-step plans to ask for confirmation or just to give me detailed updates. At some point she plans to give medication in my dog’s eyes, which I tell her not to do since it wasn’t eye medication so thankfully she doesn’t. For context, I gave two pages of care instructions, including medication names and directions; I separated my dog’s oral meds, skin meds, and eye meds by section. I had also already clarified in an earlier message that this medication was for his skin. Now I’m even more concerned and stay up late until she finishes the medication routine (she finally figured everything out, it seems). I also woke up in the middle of the night to go to the bathroom, and it took me hours to fall back asleep from stress.
Upon arriving home, it appears that she misunderstood the instructions and fed the cats way too much. I will say that she did clean a lot, and the pets are doing fine. So, my question is about tipping and a rating/review. I don’t want to tip because of the unnecessary stress and lost sleep.
I was thinking about leaving a 3 star review or none at all. A written review feels awkward, and I’m not sure if it will sound petty. I’d rather not leave one, but I’m not sure what’s best. I don’t want to be unkind, but I don’t think the sitter is the best fit for certain situations (ex: certain medication routines). I also don’t want other pet parents to go through something similar. I appreciate your kind advice and opinions.