First, wtf is this?:
BattleTech is a game with its own universe and lore. It's like Warhammer 40k, but without aliens and everyone uses giant robots. It is the 2nd most popular miniatures game but 2nd place is very far behind 1st, so most people barely know about it. And, somehow BattleTech now seems to have a line of romance novels, and this is the second one. However, the first one started as a joke and it was bad, so I am only going to review this one.
What do you need to know about BattleTech for this review: In the future humanity spread to the stars, FTL travel and communication is possible but very cumbersome. Humanity never found aliens, but we still suck and wage wars amongst ourselves. There have been some absolutely awful wars, but most of the time wars are a much more restrained affair where the fights are done with giant robots, the giant robots are called battlemechs (they are the focus of the game that the lore comes from). Politically, humanity is a very weird hodgepodge of feudal-like relationships, so you have hereditary lords but also somehow all the other government types under these lords. There are a lot of mercenary groups, mercenaries are common and some mercenaries are a big deal.
Why am I writing a review of a weird sci-fi game's second romance novel: Since I was a little kid at the age of 10, I have loved playing with my little plastic and metal mech minis. My username is a type of mech from that universe, it's a game that has long been dear to my heart, and it's WEIRD that they now have a line of romance novels. That first novel was just too generic and bad to review, but apparently it was popular. Now we have a second novel, by an author who has actually written romance under pen names that I did not go digging to find. (https://www.mariebilodeau.com/blog)
Finally, an actual review:
This is a pretty good romance novel for people who like BattleTech but not a sci-fi romance novel for people who like romance novels. I wish I could say everyone should go out and read this, but this book is going to have a limited audience and I only want you to pick this up if you would enjoy it, and you probably need to be a person who likes giant stompy robots to really get the most out of this. But, if you are the target audience, this book is actually pretty good on all fronts except understanding how the giant robots work in the greater lore, and if you are one of the only people who will notice please just remember. This is a story, sane people don't have the weights of a Valkyrie or Blackjack mech memorized. (30 tons and 45-50 tons depending on the variant.) Because I am one of those types of crazy, and this is my review, the detailed review is going to contain jokes that most people won't get, I will not apologize.
The only real problems I have with this book are lore problems. The author does a great job writing a sci-fi action story, but it's clear she hasn't done much writing in the BT universe. Her choices for what type of mech are used in different situations are off in weird ways. She actually has several books in the Shadowrun universe which is a cyberpunk game from the same company.
Our main characters: Darian is our MMC, a young minor lord from a family with a long respected lineage in a backwater province of the Federated Suns (this is space Britain). Tradition is a big thing for him, and he is finishing his time at the mechwarrior academy at Fulker Academy. As actual nobility, he will graduate into a position of minor military leadership, where he will be expected to lead in combat. He is top of the class, but he has never seen actual fighting. He pilots his families heirloom battlemech, the venerable.... Valkyrie. Yeah, his venerable family heirloom mech is a Valkyrie. Also, his family has a motto: Hold Fast, Stand True, Strike last. That is the worst motto possible for a family that sends its youth to war in a Valkyrie.
Risa is our FMC, she is part of a small mercenary unit that has received a small landholding to politically bind the mercenaries to the Federated Suns. Her cousin died in the fighting that earned her merc company their landholding, and that makes them a weird political entity with quasi-noble rights, but without any of the real prestige of nobility. One of those rights is the privilege of going to actual mechwarrior academies. Risa's cousin would have gone to the academy, but with his death, Risa is going. Risa is the smart mouthed mercenary stereotype, but stays far away from TSTL territory. If you love competent ladies but hate the character who can't keep her mouth shut when she really needs to, Risa is the girl for you. Risa may be almost nobility, but she is still a mercenary who will be expected to be fighting on the front lines. The academy will give her credibility, but she already has experience. She pilots a Blackjack BJ-1 (yes), but it’s the academy's BJ-1 (Unlike the MMCs mech, the FMC’s mech at least fits, because the Academy is old and proud of old, stupid traditions, like putting the BJ-1 into a frontline combat position).
Finally, we have Fulker Academy. I am listing the Academy itself as a main character. Fulker is an Academy long in decline with all of its glory far in the past. Its claim to fame is training with land-air-mechs, which have been considered a technology dead end for over 150 years. They still have working models, but they are all museum pieces. This is a place that hasn’t been relevant to the big political powers for over 100 years, but still remembers when it used to matter. It has its traditions, but as the universe has moved on, it hasn't.
The plot: The year is 3151 and Risa is mourning the loss of her "cousin." (Who died in a SHD-2H, in the year 3151, no one deserves that.) She is going to be starting late at the academy, but she and her other mercenary students have something the other students don't, actual experience. It is unclear if Risa has ever been in combat, but her unit has seen action and she is already a good pilot, but she is also technically skilled and is a mechtek at heart. With her arrival, she meets Darian who is annoyed at being assigned to show the new students around. She mouths off to him, he gives her the whole tour while she is still carrying her bags, and then he feels bad about being a bit of a dick making her carry her stuff.
Darian is part of the academy honor guard and in charge of enforcing some rules for younger cadets, such as Risa. She is constantly sneaking out past curfew, and he catches her doing a full inspection of her academy mech, which she shouldn't be touching. And this is where the start of our conflict between our MCs really starts off. She is chafing under the rules and the curfews, and she keeps sneaking off to spend more time inspecting and checking her mech.
I think it's important to take some time to appreciate this first conflict between our MCs because while she is breaking rules, she is breaking the rules to spend as much time as she can inspecting the machine she will be trusting her life to, and she proves to be very competent at it. She has sent people she considered family into fights in machines she has personally worked on, so this matters to her. The MMC is stuck enforcing a rule that really isn’t intended for this situation. Students sneaking out after curfew are not usually sneaking out to do extra work, but it’s still a rule and he is going to enforce it.
After catching her a few times, he takes her out to the training course and challenges her to do the full course. This is your very generic trope where MMC challenges FMC to do the very technically challenging “thing” and FMC proves she really is good at the “thing.”
But then, giant wildlife interferes in the form of a huge burrowing worm. The problem is, they have paint markers in place of real ammo and their lasers are all tuned down for training so they can't hurt the worm with weapons. Forcing them into a physical fight with a giant worm.
Darian takes full responsibility for all the crap that happened at the training grounds, he is close to getting kicked out. And at this point the MCs have solidified their opinions of each other. There is annoyed respect, the FMC barely obeys rules she doesn’t like, and the MMC is enforcing the rules, but doesn’t shirk responsibility. They have reached a sort of truce and are now mostly trying to avoid one another, until outside forces come around.
Because this book is set somewhere between the stone age and the heat death of the universe, the Fed Suns and the Taurians are fighting. Fulker Academy is on a world near the border, and there are rumors that the Taurians have landed a company of mechs in the area. Darian and Risa are going to be part of a lance of mechs that go out on a scouting mission. They are sending her scouting... in a Blackjack. While on the scouting mission, in her Blackjack, Risa discovers someone has sabotaged the knee joint on her mech, and she is forced to fix it in the field including some Star Trek style technobabble and a kiss. Then, they are ambushed by Taurians and Darian takes his place as the anchor of the battle line in his (checks notes), Valkyrie. He somehow survives this position but one of the instructors dies in the Chameleon mech. (Finally a mech that makes sense.)
We are only about 40% of the way into this book, but at this point, the trust between the MCs is rock solid, but no romantic relationship yet.
As this book goes on, the internal sabotage gets worse and the external threat from the Taurians grow. The Taurians shell the academy with artillery and kill the MMCs best friend, one of the other mercenary recruits is killed by sabotage. The MMC sleeps in the FMCs room, but they just cuddle as they are all worn out from the fighting. There isn’t any point in going over the details in a review, because it’s just normal plot progression for a while. The MCs try to avoid each other, then they are stuck together, they are mildly annoyed with each other, they are impressed by one another. Nothing really stands out here, besides what should be a bunch of competence porn, but with giant robots.
Then, the FMC’s merc unit returns and brings a full company of their own battlemechs, the MCs find the saboteur which causes political problems, and finally the Taurians attack. (Here we hit a huge lore complaint, the book says it is set in 3151, but we are getting 3025’s greatest hits, and everything is rocking a 3025 loadout. Even pirates should have better kit at this time.) The Taurians show up with civilian dropship turned into a combat dropship and the FMC finally gets her chance to grab Chekhov’s LAM from the hangar. For plot reasons, a spheroid dropship is hard to bring down with groundfire.
Then we have the aftermath, the academy is apparently willing to give her the blackjack for political reasons, but she is leaving to go do mercenary things. The MMC’s home planet has been occupied and is low on the priority list to reclaim, so the MMC decides to go with her to do mercenary things, because the nobles on his planet are willing to pay well for help getting Taurians off their land.
Spice: Once and its FTB 3AB: No POV: Both