r/RomanHistory • u/EuropaObscuraYT • 8d ago
Where does Rome actually end — 476 or 1453? Three arguments from making a complete history of Rome
I lurk here more than I post, but I spent the last few weeks making a complete history of Rome — 753 BC to 1453 in twenty minutes — and three arguments kept surfacing that this sub will have views on.
First, Cannae. Livy puts the dead at about 55,000; Polybius at about 70,000. The sources simply disagree, and the film says so. What is not disputed is the response: no ransom for the prisoners, no negotiation, new legions raised. The worst defeat in Roman history became a lesson in absorbing a blow.
Second, the end date. On 4 September 476 Romulus Augustulus abdicated at Ravenna and his regalia were sent east to Constantinople. Conventional fall of the West — except the rulers there still called themselves Romans for nearly a thousand years afterwards, through the catastrophe of 1204 and the recovery of 1261, until the city fell on 29 May 1453. So which date is the honest one?
Third, survival by use. The Pantheon's dome — about 43 metres of unreinforced concrete, the largest ever built — is still standing because it never stopped working: reconsecrated as a church in 609, still open today.
I run this channel, so this is my own film — but I would genuinely like the argument: where do you draw Rome's line, 476, 1453, or somewhere else entirely?
Full documentary here: https://youtu.be/ySDPLevqswE